Capillary electrophoresis using copolymers of different composition as physical coatings: a comparative study

In this work, a comparative study on the use of different polymers as physically adsorbed coatings for CE is presented. It is demonstrated that the use of ad hoc synthesized polymers as coatings allows tailoring the EOF in CE increasing the flexibility of this analytical technique. Namely, different polymers were synthesized at our laboratory using different percentages of ethylpyrrolidine methacrylate (EpyM) and N,N-dimethylacrylamide (DMA). Thus, by modifying the percentage of EpyM and DMA monomers it is possible to manipulate the positive charge of the copolymer, varying the global electrical charge on the capillary wall and with that the EOF. These coated capillaries are obtained by simply flushing a given EpyM-DMA aqueous solution into bare silica capillaries. It is shown that by using these coated capillaries at adequate pHs, faster or more resolved CE separations can be achieved depending on the requirements of each analysis. Moreover, it is demonstrated that these coated capillaries reduce the electrostatic adsorption of basic proteins onto the capillary wall. Furthermore, EpyM-DMA coatings allow the reproducible chiral separation of enantiomers through the partial filling technique (PFT). The EpyM-DMA coated capillaries are demonstrated to provide reproducible EOF values independently of the pH and polymer composition with%RSD values lower than 2% for the same day. It is also demonstrated that the coating procedure is reproducible between capillaries. The compatibility of this coating protocol with CE in microchips is discussed.     

New physically adsorbed polymer coating for reproducible separations of basic and acidic proteins by capillary electrophoresis

In this work, a new physically adsorbed coating for capillary electrophoresis (CE) is presented. The coating is based on a N,N-dimethylacrylamide-ethylpyrrolidine methacrylate (DMA-EPyM) copolymer synthesized in our laboratory. The capillary coating is simple and easy to obtain as only requires flushing the capillary with a polymer aqueous solution for 2 min. It is shown that by using these coated capillaries the electrostatic adsorption of a group of basic proteins onto the capillary wall is significantly reduced allowing their analysis by CE. Moreover, the DMA-EPyM coating provides reproducible separations of the basic proteins with RSD values for migration times lower than 0.75% for the same day (n = 5) and lower than 3.90% for three different days (n = 15). Interestingly, the electrical charge of the coated capillary wall can be modulated by varying the pH of the running buffer which makes possible the analysis of basic and acidic proteins in the same capillary. The usefulness of this coating is further demonstrated via the reproducible separation of whey (i.e. acidic) proteins from raw milk. The coating protocol should be compatible with both CE in microchips and CE-MS of different types of proteins.     

Estimation of the amount of β2-glycoprotein I adsorbed at the inner surface of fused silica capillaries after acidic, neutral and alkaline pretreatment

Sample adsorption to the inner surface of fused silica capillaries is a common problem in CE when analyzing macromolecules and is harmful to the analysis. We previously utilized the pH hysteresis effect of fused silica to facilitate electrophoresis of the strongly adsorbing protein β(2) gpI in plain-fused silica capillaries at neutral pH. In the present paper, the effect of different pretreatments of the capillary on the adsorption of the β(2) -glycoprotein I has been investigated using electroosmosis markers, SDS mobilization, and imaging based on indirect immunofluorescence microscopy for direct visualization. The amount of β(2) gpI adsorbed on the surface was probed using all these independent techniques after electrophoresis at neutral pH on capillaries pretreated with HCl, background electrolyte (BGE), and NaOH. BGE pretreatment was included as a positive control. We found that 80% or more of the starting material was adsorbed to the inner surface of the silica capillaries during electrophoresis after pretreatment with only BGE or with NaOH, but after acidic pretreatment the loss was consistently less than 20%. NaOH most efficiently removes adsorbed protein between runs. A theoretical calculation of the pH change of the BGE showed that electrolysis affects the pH more than the deprotonation of silanols during electrophoresis. We conclude that acidic pretreatment of fused silica capillaries diminishes adsorption of β(2) gpI by decreasing charge-dependent wall adsorption.     

Capillary electrophoresis of histone H1 variants at neutral pH in dynamically modified fused- silica tubing

Existing methods for the analysis of histone H1 by capillary electrophoresis (CE) employ acidic buffers (pH <3.0) to suppress silanol ionization and minimize the loss of these extremely basic proteins by adsorption to capillary walls. Here we describe the use of Polybrene (PB) as a dynamic modification reagent in a simple procedure that facilitates the analysis of chicken H1 at neutral pH. PB is adsorbed to the inner surfaces of capillaries to render them cationic prior to use and a low concentration of PB is included in the electrolyte to replenish the coating during use. Inclusion of ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) in the electrolyte results in the assembly of a dynamic cation-exchange layer upon the immobilized PB that influences the relative mobilities of H1 variants. The six nonallelic variants of H1 known in this species as well as certain allelic variants are resolved. Because the procedure is effective in preventing the adsorption of proteins as basic as H1 at neutral pH, this strategy should facilitate CE analyses of many basic proteins under conditions that maintain their native conformation.     

CE coupled to MALDI with novel covalently coated capillaries

CE offers the advantage of flexibility and method development options. It excels in the area of separation of ions, chiral, polar and biological compounds (especially proteins and peptides). Masking the active sites on the inner surface of a bare fused silica capillary wall is often necessary for CE separations of basic compounds, proteins and peptides. The use of capillary surface coating is one of the approaches to prevent the adsorption phenomena and improve the repeatability of migration times and peak areas of these analytes. In this study, new capillary coatings consisting of (i) derivatized polystyrene nanoparticles and (ii) derivatized fullerenes were investigated for the analysis of peptides and protein digest by CE. The coated capillaries showed excellent run‐to‐run and batch‐to‐batch reproducibility (RSD of migration time ≤0.5% for run‐to‐run and ≤9.5% for batch‐to‐batch experiments). Furthermore, the capillaries offer high stability from pH 2.0 to 10.0. The actual potential of the coated capillaries was tested by combining CE with MALDI‐MS for analysing complex samples, such as peptides, whereas the overall performance of the CE‐MALDI‐MS system was investigated by analysing a five‐protein digest mixture. Subsequently, the peak list (peptide mass fingerprint) generated from the mass spectra of each fraction was entered into the Swiss‐Prot database in order to search for matching tryptic fragments using the MASCOT software. The sequence coverage of analysed proteins was between 36 and 68%. The established technology benefits from the synergism of high separation efficiency and the structure selective identification via MS.     

Fast and easy coating for capillary electrophoresis based on a physically adsorbed cationic copolymer

In this work, a new copolymer synthesized in our laboratory is used as physically adsorbed coating for capillary electrophoresis (CE). The copolymer is composed of ethylpyrrolidine methacrylate (EPyM) and methylmethacrylate (MMA). The capillary coating is easily obtained by simply flushing into the tubing an EPyM/MMA solution. It is demonstrated that the composition of the EPyM/MMA copolymer together with the selection of the background electrolyte (BGE) and pH allow tailoring the direction and magnitude of the electroosmotic flow (EOF) in CE. It is also shown that the EOF obtained for the EPyM/MMA-coated capillaries was reproducible in all cases independently on pH or polymer composition. Thus, RSD values lower than 1.9% (n=5) for the same capillary and day were obtained for the migration time, while the repeatability interdays (n=5) was observed to provide RSD values lower than 0.5%. The stability of the coating procedure was also tested between capillaries (n=3) obtaining RSD values lower than 0.6%. It is demonstrated with several examples that the use of EPyM/MMA coatings in CE can drastically reduce the analysis time and/or to improve the resolution of the separations. It is shown that EPyM/MMA-coated capillaries allow the separation of basic proteins by reducing their adsorption onto the capillary wall. Also, EPyM/MMA-coated capillaries provide a faster separation of samples containing simultaneously positive and negative analytes. Moreover, it is demonstrated that the use of EPyM/MMA-coated capillaries can incorporate an additional chromatographic-like interaction with nucleosides that highly improves the separation of this group of solutes.     

Connections between structure and performance of four cationic copolymers used as physically adsorbed coatings in capillary electrophoresis

In this work, the properties of four cationic copolymers synthesized in our laboratory are studied as physically adsorbed coatings for capillary electrophoresis (CE). Namely, the four copolymers investigated were poly(N-ethyl morpholine methacrylamide-co-N,N-dimethylacrylamide), poly(N-ethyl pyrrolidine methacrylate-co-N,N-dimethylacrylamide), poly(N-ethyl morpholine methacrylate-co-N,N-dimethylacrylamide) and poly(N-ethyl pyrrolidine methacrylamide-co-N,N-dimethylacrylamide). Capillaries were easily coated using these four different macromolecules by simply flushing into the tubing an aqueous solution containing the copolymer. The stability and reproducibility of each coating were tested for the same day, different days and different capillaries. It is demonstrated that the use of these coatings in CE can drastically reduce the analysis time, improve the resolution of the separations or enhance the analysis repeatability at very acidic pH values compared to bare silica columns. As an example, the analysis of an organic acids test mixture revealed that the analysis time was reduced more than 6-times whereas the separation efficiency was significantly increased to nearly 10-times attaining values up to 595,000 plates/m using the coated capillaries. Moreover, it was shown that all the copolymers used as coatings for CE allowed the separation of basic proteins by reducing their adsorption onto the capillary wall. Links between their molecular structure, physicochemical properties and their performance as coatings in CE are discussed.     

Polymeric ionic liquid-coated capillary for capillary electrophoresis

A new application of the polymeric ionic liquid (PIL) in capillary electrophoresis is reported. Poly(1-vinyl-3-butylimidazolium bromide) was physically adsorbed on silica capillary as the simple and effective coating for capillary electrophoresis (CE) analysis, in which the PIL is not present in the background electrolyte. The electroosmotic flow (EOF) of the PIL-coated capillary as compared with that of the bare fused-silica capillary shows a different dependence on electrolyte pH values. The EOF is reversed over a wide pH range from 3.0 to 9.0 and shows good repeatability. It is also found that the coated capillary has a good tolerance to some organic solvents, 0.1 M NaOH and 0.1 M HCl. The PIL-coated capillary has been employed in different areas. Both the basic proteins and anionic analytes can be well separated by PIL-coated capillaries in a fast and easy way. The PIL-coated capillary is also able to separate organic acid additives in a grape juice. The results showed that this type of coating provides an alternative to the CE separation of anions and basic proteins.     

Effect of quasi‐interpenetrating network of polyacrylamide and poly(N,N‐dimethylacrylamide) on separation of dsDNA fragments and basic protein using CE

Quasi‐interpenetrating network (quasi‐IPN) of linear polyacrylamide (LPA) with low molecular mass and poly(N,N‐dimethylacrylamide) (PDMA), which is shown to uniquely combine the superior sieving ability of LPA with the coating ability of PDMA, has been synthesized for application in dsDNA and basic protein separation by CE. The performance of quasi‐IPN on dsDNA separation was determined by polymer concentration, electric field strength, LPA molecular masses and different acrylamide (AM) to N,N‐dimethylacrylamide (DMA) ratio. The results showed that all fragments in Φ×174/HaeIII digest were achieved with a 30 cm effective capillary length at –6 kV at an appropriate polymer solution concentration in bare silica capillaries. Furthermore, EOF measurement results showed that quasi‐IPN exhibited good capillary coating ability, via adsorption from aqueous solution, efficiently suppressing EOF. The effect of the buffer pH values on the separation of basic proteins was investigated in detail. The separation efficiencies and analysis reproducibility demonstrated the good potentiality of quasi‐IPN matrix for suppressing the adsorption of basic proteins onto the silica capillary wall. In addition, when quasi‐IPN was used both as sieving matrix and dynamic coating in bare silica capillaries, higher peak separation efficiencies, and better migration time reproducibility were obtained.     

Separation of Basic Proteins in Bare Fused-Silica Capillaries with Diethylentriamine Phosphate Buffer as the Background Electrolyte Solution

The effectiveness of diethylentriamine (DIEN) phosphate buffer at separating basic proteins in bare fused-silica capillaries at various pH values was examined. Such a buffer consists of an aqueous solution of DIEN titrated to the desired pH value with phosphoric acid. The study was conducted by investigating the effect of DIEN phosphate buffer on the electrophoretic mobility and efficiency of four basic proteins at various pH values within the ranges over which the phosphate salts of DIEN are effective at controlling the protonic equilibrium on the basis of the acidic pKa values of either diethylentriamine or phosphoric acid. The ranges were taken as one pH unit below and above the acidic pKa values of either DIEN or phosphoric acid. Electrophoretic separations of the four basic proteins performed at the selected pH values, ranging from pH 3.0 to pH 8.0, showed well-resolved efficient and symmetric peaks, demonstrating the capability of DIEN phosphate buffer at inhibiting untoward interactions of basic proteins with the active sites on the inner wall of bare fused-silica capillaries. Such effect is ascribed to the absorption of DIEN ions at the interface between the capillary wall and the electrolyte solution resulting in drastic variations of the positive charge density in the compact region of the electric double layer that, however, are is not suppressing completely the negative charges due to the ionization of silanol groups. Consequently, the net charge within the immobilized region of the electric double layer is negative as evidenced by the cathodic electroosmotic flow measured at any pH value within the range 3.0–8.0, indicative of negative zeta potential.     

Improvement of reproducibility and sensitivity of CE analysis by using the capillary coated dynamically with carboxymethyl chitosan

Analysis reproducibility and detection sensitivity of capillary electrophoresis (CE) are often questioned by applied scientists, which has hindered its application as a routine method. To address these issues, a simple, precise, and reproducible dynamic coating method was developed by applying carboxymethyl chitosan (CMC) dynamic coating on fused silica capillary. The proposed coating was accomplished by simply rinsing the capillary with CMC solution for 1 min in between runs, with no regeneration procedure or buffer additives needed. Electroosmotic flow could be well controlled by adjusting the pH of background electrolyte, and the adsorption of analytes onto the capillary inner wall was effectively eliminated. The main parameters of the coating condition were optimized, and extensive applications of these CMC-dynamically coated capillaries in CE separations were then firmly confirmed. By using proteins, aristolochic acids, and inorganic anions as model analytes, the coating showed a good stability, high reproducibility, as well as improved sensitivity. Baseline separations could be obtained with high efficiency. The reduced adsorption was impressively effective for basic proteins, with an average plate number of 90,000/m for each protein, apart from the good resolution on the chromatogram. A high sensitive detection of α-lactalbumin was achieved with a limit of detection (S/N = 3) of 3.5 nM, and the number of theoretical plates was as high as 1,200,000/m. In addition, the combination of the CMC coating with nonaqueous CE and CE-mass spectrometry proved to be practical. All results showed that the CMC-dynamically coated capillary has special properties and obvious superiority over the uncoated ones for CE analysis.     

Co‐electroosmotic capillary electrophoresis of basic proteins with 1‐alkyl‐3‐methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate ionic liquids as non‐covalent coating agents of the fused‐silica capillary and additives of the electrolyte solution

The paper reports the results of a study carried out to evaluate the use of three 1‐alkyl‐3‐methylimidazolium‐based ionic liquids as non‐covalent coating agents for bare fused‐silica capillaries and additives of the electrolyte solutions (BGE) for CE of basic proteins in the co‐EOF separation mode. The three ionic liquids are differentiated from each other by the length of the alkyl group on the imidazolium cation, consisting of either an ethyl, butyl or octyl substituent, whereas tetrafluoroborate is the common anionic component of the ionic liquids. Coating the capillary with the ionic liquid resulted in improved peak shape and protein separation, while the EOF was maintained cathodic. This indicates that each ionic liquid is effective at masking the protein interaction sites on the inner surface of the capillary, also when its adsorption onto the capillary wall has not completely neutralized all the negative charges arising from the ionization of the silanol groups and the ionic liquid is not incorporated into the BGE employed for separation. Using the coated capillaries with BGE containing the ionic liquid employed for the coating, at concentration low enough to maintaining the EOF cathodic, both peak shape and protein separation varied to different extents, based on the particular ionic liquid used and its concentration. Fast and efficient separation of the model basic protein mixture in co‐electroosmotic CE is obtained with the 1‐butyl‐3‐methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate coated capillary and 100 mM acetate buffer (pH 4.0) containing 4.4 mM 1‐butyl‐3‐methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate as the BGE.     

A well-defined diblock copolymer of poly-(ethylene oxide)-block-poly (4-vinylpyridine) for separation of basic proteins by capillary zone electrophoresis

A series of well-defined diblock copolymers, poly(ethylene oxide)-block-poly(4-vinylpyridine) (PEO-b-P4VP) used as physical coating of capillaries, were synthesized by atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). EOF measurement results showed that all synthesized PEO-b-P4VP diblock copolymer-coated capillaries in this report could suppress EOF effectively compared to the bare fused-silica capillaries, and efficient separations of basic proteins were achieved. The effects of the molecular weight of P4VP block in PEO-b-P4VP and buffer pH on the separation of basic proteins for CE were investigated in detail. Moreover, the relationships between morphologies of PEO-b-P4VP diblock copolymers in buffer, which were studied by transmission electron microscopy, and the separation efficiencies of basic protein with PEO-b-P4VP diblock copolymers coatings were discussed.     

Analysis of peptides and proteins by capillary electrophoresis/mass spectrometry using acidic buffers and coated capillaries.

The direct coupling of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and mass spectrometry, combined with ionspray ionization using a coaxial capillary arrangement, is described. The CE/mass spectrometer interface is shown to be effective for the analysis of native and tryptic peptides and of proteins of high molecular weight such as bovine serum apotransferrin (approximately 78 kDa). Adsorption of cationic analytes under acidic buffer conditions is minimized through the use of a non-covalent coated capillary possessing an overall positive charge. Since the direction of the electroosmotic flow is thus reversed, compared to that in conventional CE separation on uncoated capillaries, migration of cations is achieved by applying a negative voltage (typically -30 kV) at the injector end of the capillary. In addition to the inherent advantage of providing pre-formed cationic species for mass spectral detection, this arrangement permits analysis of proteins of high isoelectric points even at low pH. The ability to conduct electrophoresis of globular proteins under acidic conditions also provides a means of monitoring their conformational changes, as reflected both by the variation of migration times and by concurrent changes in the multiply charged ion envelopes.     

Preparation of linear polyacrylamide-coated capillaries: Study of the polymerization process and its effect on capillary electrophoresis performance

The effect of different parameters controlling the characteristics of linear polyacrylamide coatings deposited on the inner wall of fused-silica capillaries and their influence on capillary electrophoresis (CE) performance of these coated columns is investigated. To carry out this study, a reproducible procedure to obtain capillaries with similar extent of modification of the surface silanols with 7-oct-1-enyltrimethoxisilane was first approached. Next the polymer attachment to the silica wall, via covalent linkage to the silyl reagent grafted onto the silica, was investigated. In this way, by using columns with a similar silylation extent, differences in CE performance observed among capillaries coated under diverse conditions could be assigned to the characteristics of the polyacrylamide layer. It is demonstrated that the characteristics and reproducibility of these polymeric coatings depend on the adequate control of both the temperature of polymerization and the degassing of the polymerizing dissolutions used. More interestingly, it is also demonstrated that the quantities of monomer (acrylamide), initiator (ammonium persulfate) and activator (N,N,N′,N′-tetramethylethylenediamine), and the ratio among them used in the preparation of the coating polymer have a large influence on the performance of CE columns. The optimum conditions for preparing the polyacrylamide coatings are discussed. The applicability of these linear polyacrylamide-coated capillaries to the separation of basic and acidic proteins in free zone CE is demonstrated. Besides, the use of these coated columns in capillary gel electrophoresis for the separation of DNA fragments is shown.     

A fully automated linear polyacrylamide coating and regeneration method for capillary electrophoresis of proteins

Surface modification of the inner capillary wall in CE of proteins is frequently required to alter EOF and to prevent protein adsorption. Manual protocols for such coating techniques are cumbersome. In this paper, an automated covalent linear polyacrylamide coating and regeneration process is described to support long‐term stability of fused‐silica capillaries for protein analysis. The stability of the resulting capillary coatings was evaluated by a large number of separations using a three‐protein test mixture in pH 6 and 3 buffer systems. The results were compared to that obtained with the use of bare fused‐silica capillaries. If necessary, the fully automated capillary coating process was easily applied to regenerate the capillary to extend its useful life‐time.     

Vesicles as pseudostationary phase for enantiomer separation by capillary electrophoresis

The suitability of noncovalently bilayer-coated capillaries for the analysis of proteins by capillary electrophoresis (CE) at medium pH was investigated. Fused-silica capillaries were coated simply by successively flushing with a polybrene (PB) and a poly(vinyl sulfonate) (PVS) solution. A protein test mixture was used to evaluate the performance of the coated capillaries. Comparisons with bare fused-silica capillaries were made. Several background electrolytes (BGEs) were tested in combination with the PB-PVS coating, showing that optimum performance was obtained for the proteins using high BGE concentrations. With a 300 mM Tris phosphate buffer (pH 7.0), good plate numbers (150,000-300,000), symmetrical peaks, and favorable migration-time repeatabilities (RSDs below 0.8%) were obtained for the proteins. Using bare fused-silica capillaries, the protein peaks were significantly broadened and the migration-time RSDs often exceeded 5%. It is concluded that the PB-PVS coating effectively minimizes adverse protein adsorption and provides a very stable electroosmotic flow (EOF). We also investigated the potential of a commercially available bilayer coating (CEofix) for protein analysis. It is demonstrated that with this coating, good plate numbers and peak symmetries for proteins can be achieved when the CEofix BGE ("accelerator") is replaced by a common BGE such as sodium or Tris phosphate. Apparently, the negatively charged polymer present in the "accelerator" interacts with the proteins causing band broadening. The utility of the bilayer coatings is further illustrated by the separation of proteins such as interferon-alpha 2b, myoglobin and carbonic anhydrase, by the analysis of a degraded insulin sample in time, and by the profiling of the glycoprotein ovalbumin. In addition, it is demonstrated that even in the presence of concentrations of human serum albumin in the sample of up to 60 mg/mL, the PB-PVS coating still provides reproducible protein separations of good performance.     

Capillary electrophoresis off-line matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation mass spectrometry of intact and digested proteins using cationic-coated capillaries

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) was coupled off-line with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOFMS) for the analysis of proteins and peptides. CE fractions were collected directly on a matrix-coated MALDI target, using a sheath-flow interface. Protein adsorption during CE separations was prevented by coating the capillaries with the physically adsorbed, cationic polymer PolyE-323. The CE/MALDI-MS system was used for the analysis of model proteins and peptides at physiological pH as well as analysis of proteins in tear fluid. Moreover, tryptic on-target digestion of the collected protein fractions, with subsequent MALDI-MS and MS/MS peptide analysis, was demonstrated.     

Investigation of the separability of thaumatin by capillary electrophoresis

The electrophoretic behaviour of the highly basic protein thaumatin was explored in strongly acid (pH 2) and mildly acid (pH 4.5) separation systems using both bare and coated fused silica capillaries. The separation selectivity for thaumatin I, thaumatin II, and for other sample constituents was insufficient for their baseline separation at pH 2 in an uncoated capillary because the separation efficiency was markedly lower than is common in the electrophoretic separations of proteins. A separation selectivity higher by up to one order of magnitude has been reached at pH 4.5. A pronounced asymmetry of zones, which impaired resolution at this pH, was effectively suppressed by coating of the capillary wall with a polymer. In fact, adsorption on the capillary coating always plays a contributory role whenever a good separation of thaumatin constituents is attained. This indicates that electrochromatographic separation systems based on capillaries coated with the layer of either cationic or hydrophilic uncharged polymer hold promise for the development of methods for thaumatin analysis.     

Isotachophoresis as an on-line concentration pretreatment technique in capillary electrophoresis

One of the major disadvantages of capillary electrophoresis (CE) is its limited loadability. Therefore, the on-line coupling of isotachophoresis (ITP) and CE was studied with regard to its potential for the improvement of the minimum concentration that can be measured by CE. Based on the concentrating and separating power of ITP, detection limits could be lowered by at least two orders of magnitude. Especially for biological samples containing proteins, it appeared that in non-treated capillaries the electromigration characteristics are hardly influenced when isotachophoretic pretreatment is applied. The potential of ITP-CE coupling is illustrated by the analysis of o-phthaldialdehyde and fluorescein isothiocyanate derivatives of a number of amino acids.