The Mukaiyama Aldol Reaction: 40 Years of Continuous Development

A directed cross‐aldol reaction of silyl enol ethers with carbonyl compounds, such as aldehydes and ketones, promoted by a Lewis acid, a reaction which is now widely known as the Mukaiyama aldol reaction. It was first reported in 1973, and this year marks the 40th anniversary. The directed cross‐aldol reactions mediated by boron enolates and tin(II) enolates also emerged from the Mukaiyama laboratory. These directed cross‐aldol reactions have become invaluable tools for the construction of stereochemically complex molecules from two carbonyl compounds. This Minireview provides a succinct historical overview of their discoveries and the early stages of their development.     

The Impact of the Mukaiyama Aldol Reaction in Total Synthesis

Four decades since Mukaiyama’s first reports on the successful application of silicon and boron enolates in directed aldol reactions, the ability of this highly controlled carbon–carbon bond‐forming method to simultaneously define stereochemistry, introduce complexity, and construct the carbon skeleton with a characteristic 1,3‐oxygenation pattern has made it a powerful tool for natural product synthesis. This Minireview highlights a number of representative total syntheses that demonstrate the impact of the Mukaiyama aldol reaction and discusses the underlying mechanistic rationale that determines the stereochemical outcomes.     

Super Brønsted acid catalysis

Br?nsted acid catalysis has emerged as a new class of catalysis in modern organic synthesis. However, in order to make the utility of the Br?nsted acid catalysis as broad as the well-developed Lewis acid catalysis, it is desirable to develop Br?nsted acids demonstrating both high reactivities and selectivities. In this feature article, we will present our achievement in the design and development of strong Br?nsted acids and their application to organic reactions. Furthermore, we will describe the Tf(2)NH-catalyzed Mukaiyama aldol reaction of super silyl enol ethers. We also will highlight the differences in reactivity and chemo- and stereo-selectivity between Br?nsted and Lewis acid catalysis.     

Enantioselective total synthesis of convolutamydines B and E

[reaction: see text] The first enantioselective total synthesis of convolutamydines B and E has been achieved using our vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction. The synthesis features highly diastereoselective vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction with isatin instead of aldehydes to construct a chiral center of convolutamydines. Additionally, the absolute configuration of natural convolutamydine B has been determined as R by its CD spectrum.     

Study of the lanthanide-catalyzed, aqueous, asymmetric Mukaiyama aldol reaction

The development of efficient methods for the asymmetric Mukaiyama aldol reaction in aqueous solution has received great attention. We have developed a new series of chiral lanthanide-containing complexes that produce Mukaiyama aldol products with outstanding enantioselectivities. In this paper, we describe an optimized ligand synthesis, trends in stereoselectivity that result from changing lanthanide ions, and an exploration of substrate scope that includes aromatic and aliphatic aldehydes and silyl enol ethers derived from aromatic and aliphatic ketones.     

Bidentate Chiral Bis(imidazolium)‐Based Halogen‐Bond Donors: Synthesis and Applications in Enantioselective Recognition and Catalysis

Even though halogen bonding—the noncovalent interaction between electrophilic halogen substituents and Lewis bases—has now been established in molecular recognition and catalysis, its use in enantioselective processes is still very rarely explored. Herein, we present the synthesis of chiral bidentate halogen‐bond donors based on two iodoimidazolium units with rigidly attached chiral sidearms. With these Lewis acids, chiral recognition of a racemic diamine is achieved in NMR studies. DFT calculations support a 1:1 interaction of the halogen‐bond donor with both enantiomers and indicate that the chiral recognition is based on a different spatial orientation of the Lewis bases in the halogen‐bonded complexes. In addition, moderate enantioselectivity is achieved in a Mukaiyama aldol reaction with a preorganized variant of the chiral halogen‐bond donor. This represents the first case in which asymmetric induction was realized with a pure halogen‐bond donor lacking any additional active functional groups.     

Asymmetric vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction of aldehyde-derived dienolates

Unsaturated aldehydes are exquisite building blocks for further transformations in polyketide synthesis. Besides standard transformations that take advantage of the aldehyde functionality, the conjugate addition of hydrides followed by internal protonation allows access to alpha chiral aldehydes. Even though vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reactions have been used in natural product syntheses before, the first enantioselective Mukaiyama aldol reaction of aldehyde-derived dienolates is described.     

Hydrogen bond catalyzed enantioselective vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction

[chemical reaction: see text]. The concept of hydrogen bonding catalysis was extended to the vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction, which gives rapid access to polyketide derivatives. The reaction of the silyldienol ether shown and a range of aldehydes catalyzed by TADDOL proceeds regiospecifically to produce the addition products in good yields and enantiomeric excesses.     

Total Synthesis,Stereochemical Reassignment,and Biological Evaluation of (−)‐Lyngbyaloside B

(?)‐Lyngbyaloside B is a 14‐membered macrolide glycoside isolated from the marine cyanobacterium Lyngbya sp. as a cytotoxic substance by Moore and co‐workers. The first total synthesis of (?)‐lyngbyaloside B and the reassignment of its stereostructure is described. The synthesis features an Abiko–Masamune aldol reaction, a vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction, and a macrocyclization involving an acyl ketene intermediate for the construction of the macrocyclic backbone, which contains an acylated tertiary alcohol. The antiproliferative activity of selected compounds against a small panel of human cancer cell lines is also reported.     

Total Synthesis,Stereochemical Reassignment,and Biological Evaluation of (−)‐Lyngbyaloside B

(−)‐Lyngbyaloside B is a 14‐membered macrolide glycoside isolated from the marine cyanobacterium Lyngbya sp. as a cytotoxic substance by Moore and co‐workers. The first total synthesis of (−)‐lyngbyaloside B and the reassignment of its stereostructure is described. The synthesis features an Abiko–Masamune aldol reaction, a vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol reaction, and a macrocyclization involving an acyl ketene intermediate for the construction of the macrocyclic backbone, which contains an acylated tertiary alcohol. The antiproliferative activity of selected compounds against a small panel of human cancer cell lines is also reported.     

Contemporaneous Dual Catalysis: Aldol Products from Non‐Carbonyl Substrates

The aldol reaction represents an important class of atom‐economic carbon–carbon bond‐forming reactions vital to modern organic synthesis. Despite the attention this reaction has received, issues related to chemo‐ and regioselectivity as well as reactivity of readily enolizable electrophiles remain. To help overcome these limitations, a new direct approach toward aldol products that does not rely upon carbonyl substrates is described. This approach employs room‐temperature contemporaneous lanthanum/vanadium dual catalysis, whereby a vanadium‐catalyzed 1,3‐transposition of allenols is coupled with a lanthanum‐catalyzed Meinwald rearrangement of epoxides in situ to directly form aldol products.     

Synthesis of Dendrimer-supported Chiral Bis(oxazoline) Ligands and Their Applications in Aldol Reaction via Aqueous Media

Chiral bis(oxazoline) ligands have been applied in many enatioselective reactions. Recently, studies of the immobilization of bis(oxazoline) on both soluble and insoluble supports have been of great interest. Among the different methods to anchor the homogeneous catalysts, a soluble, polymer-supported catalyst usually achieves higher stereoselectivity and activity because the catalysis can be separated and recycled via simple methods such as solvent precipitation. Dendrimers are highly branche…     

C2, Symmetric Dibenzosuberanes as Templates for the Chirality Determination of Helicenes and Their Applications as Optically Switchable Memory Device

We have recently developed a new type of chiral templates, dibenzosuberanes. Thess C₂, symmetric diaryl modifiers have been successfully applied to the synthesis of chiral triarylcarbenium ions. They can serve as catalysts in the asymmetric Mukaiyama aldol reactions with moderate enantioselectivities of up to 50% [1]. We have subsequently found that one major side reaction between the catalyst and the substrate-silyl ketene acetal which releases extra silyl-X species is responsible for the erosion of asymmetric induction. The dibenzosuberane scaffold was found essential to prevent this type of side reaction. For the selection of carbenium counter ions, we have resorted to the chloride in order to completely suppress the undesired silyl catalysis [2].     

Synthetic studies toward potent cytostatic macrolide rhizopodin: stereoselective synthesis of the C16-C28 fragment

A stereoselective synthesis of the C16-C28 fragment of cytostatic C₂-symmetric macrolide rhizopodin is described. Enantioselective addition of a chiral thiazolidinethione derived titanium enolate to acetal, Evans’ aldol reaction, Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons reaction, and Mukaiyama aldol reaction were applied as key steps.     

Current progress in the asymmetric aldol addition reaction

Control of stereochemistry during aldol addition reactions has attracted considerable interest over the years as the aldol reaction is one of the most fundamental tools for the construction of new carbon-carbon bonds. Several strategies have been implemented whereby eventually any single possible stereoisomeric aldol product can be accessed by choosing the appropriate procedure. With earlier methods, stoichiometric quantities of chiral reagents were required for efficient asymmetric induction, with the auxiliary most often attached covalently to the substrate carbonyl. Lewis acid catalyzed addition reactions of silyl enolates to aldehydes (Mukaiyama reaction) later opened the way for catalytic asymmetric induction. In the last few years, both chiral metal complexes and small chiral organic molecules have been found to catalyse the direct aldol addition of unmodified ketones to aldehydes with relatively high chemical and stereochemical efficiency. These techniques along with the more recent developments in the area are discussed in this tutorial review.     

Total synthesis of leucascandrolide a: a new application of the Mukaiyama aldol-Prins reaction

A total synthesis of the marine natural product leucascandrolide A has been completed. The titanium tetrabromide-mediated Mukaiyama aldol-Prins (MAP) reaction with aldehydes developed in our group provided a highly convergent and stereoselective method for assembling the core of the molecule. A new class of MAP reactions with acetals is introduced, and mechanistic considerations for both MAP methods are described. The total synthesis was completed by coupling of the side chain through two avenues: a known Still-Gennari olefination and a new Z-selective aldol/dehydroselenation reaction. Both procedures were highly selective and provided the natural product.     

Synthesis of 8‐Desmethoxy Psymberin: A Putative Biosynthetic Intermediate Towards the Marine Polyketide Psymberin

The synthesis of a putative biosynthetic precursor of psymberin including a formal synthesis of the natural product is described. The key step towards the densely functionalized tetrahydropyran core was an enantioselective catalytic Mukaiyama aldol reaction using a titanium(IV)–BINOL catalyst system. syn‐Selective reduction followed by ozonolysis led to a rapid assembly of the tetrahydropyran ring. This flexible approach also allows the synthesis of similar fragments of other complex molecules such as bryostatins and pederins. The syn‐selective coupling between the tetrahydropyran and the aromatic aldehyde was achieved using a boron‐mediated aldol reaction which was followed by further transformations to complete the synthesis of the precursor as well as the formal synthesis of the natural product.     

Iron‐ and Bismuth‐Catalyzed Asymmetric Mukaiyama Aldol Reactions in Aqueous Media

We have developed asymmetric Mukaiyama aldol reactions of silicon enolates with aldehydes catalyzed by chiral Fe^II and Bi^III complexes. Although previous reactions often required relatively harsh conditions, such as strictly anhydrous conditions, very low temperatures (?78 °C), etc., the reactions reported herein proceeded in the presence of water at 0 °C. To find appropriate chiral water‐compatible Lewis acids for the Mukaiyama aldol reaction, many Lewis acids were screened in combination with chiral bipyridine L1 , which had previously been found to be a suitable chiral ligand in aqueous media. Three types of chiral catalysts that consisted of a Fe^II or Bi^III metal salt, a chiral ligand ( L1 ), and an additive have been discovered and a wide variety of substrates (silicon enolates and aldehydes) reacted to afford the desired aldol products in high yields with high diastereo‐ and enantioselectivities through an appropriate selection of one of the three catalytic systems. Mechanistic studies elucidated the coordination environments around the Fe^II and Bi^III centers and the effect of additives on the chiral catalysis. Notably, both Brønsted acids and bases worked as efficient additives in the Fe^II‐catalyzed reactions. The assumed catalytic cycle and transition states indicated important roles of water in these efficient asymmetric Mukaiyama aldol reactions in aqueous media with the broadly applicable and versatile catalytic systems.     

Total synthesis of the spirocyclic imine marine toxin (-)-gymnodimine and an unnatural C4-epimer

The first total synthesis of the marine toxin (-)-gymnodimine (1) has been accomplished in a convergent manner. A highly diastereo- and enantioselective exo-Diels-Alder reaction catalyzed by a bis-oxazoline Cu(II) catalyst enabled rapid assembly of the spirocyclic core of gymnodimine. The preparation of the tetrahydrofuran fragment utilized a chiral auxiliary based anti-aldol reaction. Two major fragments, spirolactam 56 and tetrahydrofuran 55, were then coupled through an efficient Nozaki-Hiyama-Kishi reaction. An unconventional, ambient temperature t-BuLi-initiated intramolecular Barbier reaction of alkyl iodide 64 was employed to form the macrocycle. A late stage vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol addition of a silyloxyfuran to a complex cyclohexanone 83 appended the butenolide, and a few additional steps provided (-)-gymnodimine (1). A diastereomer of the natural product was also synthesized, C4-epi-gymnodimine (90), derived from the vinylogous Mukaiyama aldol addition.     

Stereoselective synthesis of the monomeric unit of actin binding macrolide rhizopodin

An efficient, scalable, and stereocontrolled synthesis of the entire carbon framework of an actin binding dimeric macrolide rhizopodin has been accomplished in its protected form. The key features of our synthesis include a titanium catalyzed anti acetal aldol reaction, a substrate controlled diastereoslelective prenyl stannylation, a Mukaiyama aldol reaction, an indium mediated diastereoselective propargylation, and an advanced stage Stille coupling reaction.