A fuzzy goal programming method with imprecise goal hierarchy

Two most widely used approaches to treating goals of different importance in goal programming (GP) are: (1) weighted GP, where importance of goals is modelled using weights, and (2) preemptive priority GP, where a goal hierarchy is specified implying infinite trade-offs among goals placed in different levels of importance. These approaches may be too restrictive in modelling of real life decision making problems. In this paper, a novel fuzzy goal programming method is proposed, where the hierarchical levels of the goals are imprecisely defined. The imprecise importance relations among the goals are modelled using fuzzy relations. An additive achievement function is defined, which takes into consideration both achievement degrees of the goals and degrees of satisfaction of the fuzzy importance relations. Examples are given to illustrate the proposed method.     

Solving multi-level multi-objective linear programming problems through fuzzy goal programming approach

In this paper, two new algorithms are presented to solve multi-level multi-objective linear programming (ML-MOLP) problems through the fuzzy goal programming (FGP) approach. The membership functions for the defined fuzzy goals of all objective functions at all levels are developed in the model formulation of the problem; so also are the membership functions for vectors of fuzzy goals of the decision variables, controlled by decision makers at the top levels. Then the fuzzy goal programming approach is used to achieve the highest degree of each of the membership goals by minimizing their deviational variables and thereby obtain the most satisfactory solution for all decision makers.     

The supplier selection problem of a manufacturing company using the weighted multi-choice goal programming and MINMAX multi-choice goal programming

This paper presents two methods of decision making, Weighted multi-choice goal programming (MCGP) and MINMAX MCGP. With the proposed Weighted MCGP method, decision makers can set different weights w_i for each goal with linguistic terms, such as high, average and low, which can be transformed into trapezoidal fuzzy numbers. Meanwhile, with the proposed MINMAX MCGP method, this study also let decision makers set the satisfaction membership function for each goal according to their preference in order to eliminate the effect of different scales in each goal.This paper also investigates the relationship between Weighted multi-choice goal programming and MINMAX multi-choice goal programming. According to the sensitivity analysis, decision makers can get the solution with the minimum aggregate deviation for all multiple goals from the Weighted multi-choice goal programming. Meanwhile, decision makers can get the solution with the most balanced solution between all multiple goals from the MINMAX multi-choice goal programming method. The weight variable is introduced to the above two methods to provide decision-makers with a mechanism to evaluate the discrepancy between the maximum aggregate achievement and the most balanced solution, enabling decision-makers to reach the preferable decision for their situation. A real-world problem of supplier selection by the purchasing and sales managers of a manufacturing company is used to illustrate the differing solutions given by the two models.     

Bilevel programming approach applied to the flow shop scheduling problem under fuzziness

This paper presents a fuzzy bilevel programming approach to solve the flow shop scheduling problem. The problem considered here differs from the standard form in that operators are assigned to the machines and imposing a hierarchy of two decision makers with fuzzy processing times. The shop owner considered higher level and assigns the jobs to the machines in order to minimize the flow time while the customer is the lower level and decides on a job schedule in order to minimize the makespan. In this paper, we use the concepts of tolerance membership function at each level to define a fuzzy decision model for generating optimal (satisfactory) solution for bilevel flow shop scheduling problem. A solution algorithm for solving this problem is given. Mathematics Subject Classification: 90C70, 90B36, 90C99     

Multi-choice goal programming with utility functions

Goal programming (GP) has been, and still is, the most widely used technique for solving multiple-criteria decision problems and multiple-objective decision problems by finding a set of satisfying solutions. However, the major limitation of goal programming is that can only use aspiration levels with scalar value for solving multiple objective problems. In order to solve this problem multi-choice goal programming (MCGP) was proposed by Chang (2007a). Following the idea of MCGP this study proposes a new concept of level achieving in the utility functions to replace the aspiration level with scalar value in classical GP and MCGP for multiple objective problems. According to this idea, it is possible to use the skill of MCGP with utility functions to solve multi-objective problems. The major contribution of using the utility functions of MCGP is that they can be used as measuring instruments to help decision makers make the best/appropriate policy corresponding to their goals with the highest level of utility achieved. In addition, the above properties can improve the practical utility of MCGP in solving more real-world decision/management problems.     

Multiple criteria group decision-making with generalized interval-valued fuzzy numbers based on signed distances and incomplete weights

Decision-making information provided by decision makers is often imprecise or uncertain, due to lack of data, time pressure, or the decision makers’ limited attention and information-processing capabilities. Interval-valued fuzzy sets are associated with greater imprecision and more ambiguity than are ordinary fuzzy sets. For these reasons, this paper presents a signed distance-based method for handling fuzzy multiple-criteria group decision-making problems in which individual assessments are provided as generalized interval-valued trapezoidal fuzzy numbers, and the information about criterion weights are not precisely but partially known. First, concerning the relative importance of decision makers and the group consensus of fuzzy opinions, all individual decision opinions were aggregated into group opinions using a hybrid average with weighted averaging and signed distance-based ordered weighted averaging operations. Next, considering a decision situation with incomplete weight information of criteria, an integrated programming model was developed to estimate criterion weights and to order the priorities of various alternatives based on signed distances. In addition, several deviation variables were introduced to mitigate the effect of inconsistent evaluations on the importance of criteria. Finally, the feasibility of the proposed method is illustrated by a numerical example of a multi-criteria supplier selection problem. Furthermore, a comparative analysis with other methods was conducted to validate the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed methodology.     

Fuzzy goal programming approach to multilevel programming problems

The purpose of this paper is to propose a procedure for solving multilevel programming problems in a large hierarchical decentralized organization through linear fuzzy goal programming approach. Here, the tolerance membership functions for the fuzzily described objectives of all levels as well as the control vectors of the higher level decision makers are defined by determining individual optimal solution of each of the level decision makers. Since the objectives are potentially conflicting in nature, a possible relaxation of the higher level decision is considered for avoiding decision deadlock. Then fuzzy goal programming approach is used for achieving highest degree of each of the membership goals by minimizing negative deviational variables. Sensitivity analysis with variation of tolerance values on decision vectors is performed to present how the solution is sensitive to the change of tolerance values. The efficiency of our concept is ascertained by comparing results with other fuzzy programming approaches.     

A multi-objective joint replenishment inventory model of deteriorated items in a fuzzy environment

In this study, a fuzzy multi-objective joint replenishment inventory model of deteriorating items is developed. The model maximizes the profit and return on inventory investment (ROII) under fuzzy demand and shortage cost constraint. We propose a novel inverse weight fuzzy non-linear programming (IWFNLP) to formulate the fuzzy model. A soft computing, differential evolution (DE) with/without migration operation, is proposed to solve the problem. The performances of the proposed fuzzy method and the conventional fuzzy additive goal programming (FAGP) are compared. We show that the solution derived from the IWFNLP method satisfies the decision maker’s desirable achievement level of the profit objective, ROII objective and shortage cost constraint goal under the desirable possible level of fuzzy demand. It is an effective decision tool since it can really reflect the relative importance of each fuzzy component.     

An algorithm for systems welfare interactive goal programming modelling

Every human system is faced with the problem of choosing between alternative options, and methods of interactive programming have been suggested as the best way to lead decision makers reach decisions that are consistent with their preferences. However, even though a large number of interactive algorithms have been proposed for multiobjective decision making (MODM), there is yet no truly interactive goal programming (GP) algorithm, despite the preference of GP over other MODM methodologies. The current paper presents an algorithm for interactive GP modelling called SWIGP (systems welfare interactive GP) which ensures that the overall welfare of the system under consideration is adequately taken into account in the interactive process. To achieve this, this paper distinguishes between technical, allocative and economic efficiencies and combines an economic efficiency index with interactive GP process. Besides being of wide applicability, the algorithm exerts little cognitive burden on the decision maker (DM). Indeed, even if the DM is assumed to operate under conditions of complete ignorance, SWIGP provides the direction for searching the “best” compromise solution. Moreover, the algorithm converges very fast because of the economic efficiency index that complements the interactive process in aiding the DM arrive at a most preferred solution.     

Stackelberg solutions for fuzzy random two-level linear programming through level sets and fractile criterion optimization

This paper considers Stackelberg solutions for two-level linear programming problems under fuzzy random environments. To deal with the formulated fuzzy random two-level linear programming problem, an α-stochastic two-level linear programming problem is defined through the introduction of α-level sets of fuzzy random variables. Taking into account vagueness of judgments of decision makers, fuzzy goals are introduced and the α-stochastic two-level linear programming problem is transformed into the problem to maximize the satisfaction degree for each fuzzy goal. Through fractile criterion optimization in stochastic programming, the transformed stochastic two-level programming problem can be reduced to a deterministic two-level programming problem. An extended concept of Stackelberg solution is introduced and a numerical example is provided to illustrate the proposed method.     

A practical prioritization by multi-level group decision support

Military capability is proposed to be defined according to the DYNPOT scoring method. Multiobjective resource allocation of shared resources by group decision-making can combine analytic and qualitative modeling. Recently it has been pointed out that the goal programming model is superior to other models though it remained to be answered how to take into account hierarchy of decision makers (and objectives) (Stummer and Vetschera in Cent Eur J Oper Res 11:3–260, 2003). In this article it is tried to present, that the quantitative model can be easily adapted to the qualitative STT/QFD model of objectives of top-level group of decision-makers. The subsequent phases of the qualitative and the analytic solution of a multiobjective cooperative resource allocation problem can be applied within the group decision-making framework of defence requirements capability-based planning.     

Aggregation of analytic hierarchy process models based on similarities in decision makers’ preferences

The analytic hierarchy process is widely used in both individual and group decision making environments. In this paper we investigate its applicability to model a specific class of decentralized decision problems where many decision makers take individual subjective decisions using locally available information. In such subjective decision making environments, it is neither possible nor appropriate to use group preference aggregation techniques to model the problem as a single group decision problem. An approach to identify homogeneous subgroups of decision makers based on similarities in preferences and to aggregate preferences within each subgroup is proposed. This approach is validated using employment preferences of 70 subjects modeled using the analytic hierarchy process.     

Weighting method for bi-level linear fractional programming problems

In this paper we consider the solution of a bi-level linear fractional programming problem (BLLFPP) by weighting method. A non-dominated solution set is obtained by this method. In this article decision makers (DMs) provide their preference bounds to the decision variables that is the upper and lower bounds to the decision variables they control. We convert the hierarchical system into scalar optimization problem (SOP) by finding proper weights using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) so that objective functions of both levels can be combined into one objective function. Here the relative weights represent the relative importance of the objective functions.     

Binary fuzzy goal programming

Goal programming is an important technique for solving many decision/management problems. Fuzzy goal programming involves applying the fuzzy set theory to goal programming, thus allowing the model to take into account the vague aspirations of a decision-maker. Using preference-based membership functions, we can define the fuzzy problem through natural language terms or vague phenomena. In fact, decision-making involves the achievement of fuzzy goals, some of them are met and some not because these goals are subject to the function of environment/resource constraints. Thus, binary fuzzy goal programming is employed where the problem cannot be solved by conventional goal programming approaches. This paper proposes a new idea of how to program the binary fuzzy goal programming model. The binary fuzzy goal programming model can then be solved using the integer programming method. Finally, an illustrative example is included to demonstrate the correctness and usefulness of the proposed model.     

带有限反馈下层的二层规划问题的部分合作模型

对下层最优反馈为离散有限多个的二层规划问题的部分合作模型进行探讨. 当下层的合作程度依赖于上层的决策变量时, 给出一个确定合作系数函数的一般方法, 进而得到一个新的部分合作模型. 在适当地假设下, 可保证所给的部分合作模型一定可以找到比悲观解要好的解, 并结合新的部分合作模型对原不适定问题进行分析, 得到了一些有益的结论. 最后以实际算例说明了所给部分合作模型的可行性.     

A robust additive consistency-based method for decision making with triangular fuzzy reciprocal preference relations

To express uncertain information in decision making, triangular fuzzy reciprocal preference relations (TFRPRs) might be adopted by decision makers. Considering consistency of this type of preference relations, this paper defines a new additive consistency concept, which can be seen as an extension of that for reciprocal preference relations. Then, a simple method to calculate the triangular fuzzy priority weight vector is introduced. When TFRPRs are inconsistent, a linear goal programming framework to derive the completely additive consistent TFRPRs is provided. Meanwhile, an improved linear goal programming model is constructed to estimate the missing values in an incomplete TFRPR that can address the situation where ignored objects exist. After that, an algorithm for decision making with TFRPRs is presented. Finally, numerical examples and comparison analysis are offered.     

An intuitionistic fuzzy programming method for group decision making with interval-valued fuzzy preference relations

The paper develops a new intuitionistic fuzzy (IF) programming method to solve group decision making (GDM) problems with interval-valued fuzzy preference relations (IVFPRs). An IF programming problem is formulated to derive the priority weights of alternatives in the context of additive consistent IVFPR. In this problem, the additive consistent conditions are viewed as the IF constraints. Considering decision makers’ (DMs’) risk attitudes, three approaches, including the optimistic, pessimistic and neutral approaches, are proposed to solve the constructed IF programming problem. Subsequently, a new consensus index is defined to measure the similarity between DMs according to their individual IVFPRs. Thereby, DMs’ weights are objectively determined using the consensus index. Combining DMs’ weights with the IF program, a corresponding IF programming method is proposed for GDM with IVFPRs. An example of E-Commerce platform selection is analyzed to illustrate the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed method. Finally, the IF programming method is further extended to the multiplicative consistent IVFPR.     

Comment to “interactive fuzzy goal programming approach for bilevel programming problem” by S.R. Arora and R. Gupta

The fuzzy bilevel programming problem is solved in the paper [1] using an approach of fuzzy goal programming. Using a simple example we show that this will not lead to a satisfactory solution. Especially the fuzzy constraint that the upper level variable is near some desired one has no influence on the computed solution in the example. This constraint is used to model the hierarchy in the approach in [1]. At the end of the paper we suggest one straightforward possibility for modeling the fuzzy bilevel programming problem and converting it into a crisp substitute.     

A new multiple attribute group decision making method in intuitionistic fuzzy setting

The multiple attribute group decision making (MAGDM) problem with intuitionistic fuzzy information investigated in this paper is very useful for solving complicated decision problems under uncertain circumstances. Since experts have their own characteristics, they are familiar with some of the attributes, but not others, the weights of the decision makers to different attributes should be different. We derive the weights of the decision makers by aggregating the individual intuitionistic fuzzy decision matrices into a collective intuitionistic fuzzy decision matrix. The expert has a big weight if his evaluation value is close to the mean value and has a small weight if his evaluation value is far from the mean value. For the incomplete attribute weight information, we establish some optimization models to determine the attribute weights. Furthermore, we develop several algorithms for ranking alternatives under different situations, and then extend the developed models and algorithms to the MAGDM problem with interval-valued intuitionistic fuzzy information. Numerical results finally illustrate the practicality and efficiency of our new algorithms.     

An outranking-based general approach to solving group multi-objective optimization problems

This paper presents a general approach to solving multi-objective programming problems with multiple decision makers. The proposal is based on optimizing a bi-objective measure of “collective satisfaction”. Group satisfaction is understood as a reasonable balance between the strengths of an agreeing and an opposing coalition, considering also the number of decision makers not belonging to any of these coalitions. Accepting the vagueness of “collective satisfaction”, even the vagueness of “person satisfaction”, fuzzy outranking relations and other fuzzy logic models are used.