Staining and quantification of proteins separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.

The present review concentrates on techniques for the staining and quantification of proteins separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Staining with organic dyes has been used for approximately thirty years; the silver staining technique was introduced in 1979. The problems of silver staining are presented separately because the mechanism of this staining is in principle different from staining with organic dyes. Less attention has been devoted to quantification of two-dimensional gels, because this autoradiography is preferred because of its high sensitivity and fewer problems with accurate quantification in contrast to silver staining.     

Improved detection of lymphocyte membrane proteins in purified form and as a crude mixture using native and denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis by optimisation of coomassie brilliant blue and silver staining.

Optimised silver staining protocols were devised for the detection of membrane proteins in purified form and as a crude mixture. These were adduced in both sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) and native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and consisted of ethanol-acetic acid-formaldehyde fixation, Coomassie Brilliant Blue prestaining, Rapidfix pretreatment, formaldehyde enhancement and finally ammoniacal silver staining. With these modifications, numerous staining problems of membrane proteins were overcome. These included reduction in background staining, enhanced detection sensitivity in native gels, elimination of negative staining and the avoidance of metallic silver deposition on the gel surface. In overcoming these problems, some factors determining the colour and stainability of membrane proteins in their native state were determined. Both the anionic Coomassie Brilliant Blue dye and SDS detergent improved the sensitivity of silver staining in native gels, and ammoniacal silver was more sensitive than neutral silver, suggesting silver staining to be a charge dependent process.     

Selective proteome-wide detection of hydrophobic integral membrane proteins using a novel fluorescence-based staining technology

Integral proteins containing two or more alpha-helical membrane-spanning domains are underrepresented in two-dimensional gels. While sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gels separate these proteins, staining profiles are usually dominated by high-abundance hydrophilic proteins in the specimen. A fluorescence-based stain is presented that selectively highlights integral proteins containing two or more alpha-helical transmembrane domains but does not detect lipoproteins or proteins with hydrophobic pockets, such as albumin. The stain detects as little as 5-10 ng of bacteriorhodopsin, a seven-helix transmembrane protein. Stained proteins are detected using a laser scanner or charge-coupled device (CCD) camera imaging system. Fluorescence intensity of stained bands is linear with protein quantity over at least two orders of magnitude. After visualizing transmembraneous proteins, the total protein profile may be revealed using a general protein stain. Analysis of the multisubunit protein F1F0 ATP synthase revealed selective staining of the a and c subunits, polypeptides known to possess 5 and 2 transmembrane domains, respectively.     

Sensitive silver staining of protein in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels using an azo dye, calconcarboxylic acid, as a silver-ion sensitizer

A highly sensitive silver staining method for detecting proteins in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) was developed. It is based on the silver nitrate staining method but also employs an azo dye, calconcarboxylic acid (NN), as a silver-ion sensitizer. It increases silver binding on protein bands or spots by the formation of a silver-dye complex and also increases the reducing power of silver ions to metallic silver by NN itself with formaldehyde. After a 2 h gel fixing step, the protocol including sensitization, silver-ion impregnation, and reduction steps can be completed in 1 h. The sensitivity is superior to that of silver stain with glutardialdehyde as a silver-ion sensitizer. The detection limit of NN-silver stain is 0.05-0.2 ng protein. Considering the high sensitivity without using glutardialdehyde, the NN-silver stain would be useful for routine silver staining of proteins.     

Improved silver staining procedure for fast staining in PhastSystem Development Unit. I. Staining of sodium dodecyl sulfate gels

A new modification of silver staining of proteins in sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gels is adapted to automated staining in PhastSystem Development Unit. The use of a reduction step, after fixation, with thiosulfate in alcoholic sodium acetate buffer results in a considerable increase in sensitivity without the need for a recycling step. The detection limit is tenfold lower than in the silver staining procedure recommended so far for PhastSystem and corresponds to 0.05-0.1 ng protein per band. Total staining time with the new procedure is 75 min.     

Recovery of intact proteins from silver stained gels

Silver stained proteins of a wide molecular weight (MW) range (20-116 kDa) were successfully recovered by both electroblot and electroelution. The recovery was demonstrated for nanogram loads of proteins separated by SDS-PAGE and visualized by silver staining methods compatible and incompatible with mass spectrometry (MS). It was shown that the alcohol/acid and glutaraldehyde fixation steps present in a number of staining procedures did not prevent recovery of intact proteins from gels. It was found that the recovery of intact proteins from silver stained gels was substantially increased upon pre-equilibration in a buffer containing the reducing agent, dithiothreitol (DTT). The effect of destaining on the recovery of silver stained proteins was also investigated. Comparable recovery of intact proteins within a wide MW range from silver stained gels with and without destaining step was demonstrated. Recovery of model proteins from gels visualized using silver staining method compatible with MS showed 52 to 76% yield of that from the unstained gel, depending upon method of the transfer. Comparison of the recovery of intact proteins from gels visualized using other staining procedures was also made. The above findings have implications as to the supposed irreversible nature of protein "fixation" inside polyacrylamide matrix, and confirm lack of binding of proteins in the gel to metal silver deposited on its surface. This method has the potential to be suitable for direct characterization of proteins by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) without additional purification steps.     

Fluorescence detection of proteins in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels using environmentally benign, nonfixative, saline solution

SYPRO Tangerine stain is an environmentally benign alternative to conventional protein stains that does not require solvents such as methanol or acetic acid for effective protein visualization. Instead, proteins can be stained in a wide range of buffers, including phosphate-buffered saline or simply 150 mM NaCl using an easy, one-step procedure that does not require destaining. Stained proteins can be excited by ultraviolet light of about 300 nm or with visible light of about 490 nm. The fluorescence emission maximum of the dye is approximately 640 nm. Noncovalent binding of SYPRO Tangerine dye is mediated by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and to a lesser extent by hydrophobic amino acid residues in proteins. This is in stark contrast to acidic silver nitrate staining, which interacts predominantly with lysine residues or Coomassie Blue R, which in turn interacts primarily with arginine and lysine residues. The sensitivity of SYPRO Tangerine stain is similar to that of the SYPRO Red and SYPRO Orange stains - about 4-10 ng per protein band. This detection sensitivity is comparable to colloidal Coomassie blue staining and rapid silver staining procedures. Since proteins stained with SYPRO Tangerine dye are not fixed, they can easily be eluted from gels or utilized in zymographic assays, provided that SDS does not inactivate the protein of interest. This is demonstrated with in-gel detection of rabbit liver esterase activity using alpha-naphthyl acetate and Fast Blue BB dye as well as Escherichia coli beta-glucuronidase activity using ELF-97 beta-D-glucuronide. The dye is also suitable for staining proteins in gels prior to their transfer to membranes by electroblotting. Gentle staining conditions are expected to improve protein recovery after electroelution and to reduce the potential for artifactual protein modifications such as the alkylation of lysine and esterification of glutamate residues, which complicate interpretation of peptide fragment profiles generated by mass spectrometry.     

Counterion-dye staining for DNA in electrophoresed gels using indoine blue and methyl orange

In this study, we describe a sensitive staining method for DNA in agarose and polyacrylamide gels using organic visible dyes, indoine blue (IB) and methyl orange (MO). The counterion-dye staining method uses two oppositely charged dyes to form a hydrophobic ion pair complex in the staining solution. A decrease in the number of free forms of dyes in staining solution can enhance the selectivity of binding between the dye and DNA, and can reduce nonspecific background staining. As a result, the sensitivity of counterion-dye staining was significantly improved compared with other dye-based staining. This method uses a staining solution consisting of 0.008% IB, 0.002% MO, 10% ethanol and 0.2 M sodium acetate at pH 4.7, and can detect 5 ng of lambda DNA/HindIII within 60 min in agarose gels and 10 ng of PhiX174 DNA/HaeIII within 20 min in polyacrylamide gels.     

Quantitative evaluation of proteins in one- and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels using a fluorescent stain

The characteristics of protein detection and quantitation with SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain in one- and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels were evaluated. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analyses of three different purified recombinant proteins showed that the limits of detection were comparable to the limits of detection with ammoniacal silver staining and were protein-specific, ranging from 0.5 to 5 ng. The linearity of the relationship between protein level and SYPRO Ruby staining intensity also depended on the individual protein, with observed linear dynamic ranges of 200-, 500-, and, 1000-fold for proteins analyzed by SDS-PAGE. SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain was also evaluated in two-dimensional electrophoretic (2-DE) analysis of Escherichia coli proteins. The experiment involved analysis of replicates of the same sample as well as dilution of the sample from 0.5 to 50 nug total protein across gels. In addition to validating the 2-DE system itself, the experiment was used to evaluate three different image analysis programs: Z3 (Compugen), Progenesis (Nonlinear Dynamics), and PDQuest (Bio-Rad). In each program, we analyzed the 2-DE images with respect to sensitivity and reproducibility of overall protein spot detection, as well as linearity of response for 20 representative proteins of different molecular weights and pI. Across all three programs, coefficients of variation (CV) in total number of spots detected among replicate gels ranged from 4 to 11%. For the 20 representative proteins, spot quantitation was also comparable with CVs for gel-to-gel reproducibility ranging from 3 to 33%. Using Progenesis and PDQuest, a 1000-fold linear dynamic range of SYPRO Ruby was demonstrated with a single known protein. These two programs were more suitable than Z3 for examining individual protein spot quantity across a series of gels and gave comparable results.     

Highly sensitive double-fluorescent dye staining on microchip electrophoresis for analysis of milk proteins

We demonstrated a highly sensitive double-fluorescent dye staining in microchip electrophoresis (ME) for analysis of milk proteins. The detection sensitivity of ME was very limited so far and needed improvement. Our staining method consisted of two steps. First, in sample preparation before electrophoresis, protein was covalently bound to an amine-reactive fluorescent dye, Cy5. Then, the Cy5-attached protein was denatured with SDS and was further stained, during electrophoresis, with Agilent fluorescent dye, which was noncovalently attached to hydrophobic regions of the SDS-protein complexes. This double-fluorescent staining enhanced fluorescent intensity and lowered the detection limit to 200 pg of protein. This provided higher sensitivity than silver- or SYPRO Ruby-staining methods, which have previously given the highest sensitivity in protein staining. In addition, we applied our staining method to analysis of milk proteins and achieved their successful detection, whereas it was difficult to analyze them by the unimproved method.     

Quantitative proteomics by fluorescent labeling of cysteine residues using a set of two cyanine‐based or three rhodamine‐based dyes

Despite all remarkable progress in gel‐based proteomics in recent years, there is still need to further improve quantification by decreasing the detection limits and increasing the dynamic range. These criteria are achieved best by fluorescent dyes that specifically stain the proteins either by adsorption after gel electrophoresis (in‐gel staining) or covalent coupling prior to gel electrophoresis (in‐solution staining). Here we report a multiplex analysis of protein samples using maleimide‐activated cyanine‐based (Cy3 and Cy5) and rhodamine‐based dyes (Dy505, Dy535, and Dy635) to permanently label all thiol‐groups of cysteine‐containing proteins. The detection limits in SDS‐PAGE were about 10 ng per band and even 2 ng for BSA due to its high content of cysteine residues. Thus only 5 μg protein of a mouse brain homogenate were analyzed by 2‐DE. Both cyanine‐ and rhodamine‐based dyes also stained proteins that did not contain cysteines, probably by reaction with amino groups. This side reactivity did not limit the method and might even extend its general use to proteins missing cysteine residues, but at a lower sensitivity. The dynamic range was more than two orders of magnitude in SDS‐PAGE and the Dy‐fluorophores did not alter the mobility of the tested proteins. Thus, a mixture of Dy505‐, Dy555‐, and Dy635‐labeled Escherichia coli lysates were separated by 2‐DE in a single gel and the three spot patterns relatively quantified.     

Microwave-assisted protein staining: mass spectrometry compatible methods for rapid protein visualisation

The effects of microwave irradiation on the staining of electrophoresed and electroblotted proteins have been assessed using currently available detection methods. Although the absorption of microwave radiation was found to be uneven, band intensity following microwave-assisted protein staining (MAPS) was comparable and in some cases exceeded the intensity of the bands visualised by the original staining methods. It was found that microwave treatment drastically reduced the duration of the staining protocols for visualisation of the proteins separated by both one- and two-dimensional electrophoresis. Application of MAPS methods did not affect peptide mass fingerprinting analysis by mass spectrometry and subsequent identification of the protein by database searching. The peptide mass maps corresponding to the proteins visualised using both the conventional and MAPS methods did not show significant difference in signal/noise ratio. Moreover, it appeared that microwave treatment of the gels resulted in the increased recovery of the peptides following in-gel trypsin digestion. Briefly, microwave-assisted protein staining methods were rapid, compatible with mass spectrometry and were equally effective on thin (0.75-mm) and thick (1.5-mm) gels (such as those used in 2D electrophoresis).     

Routine diagnosis with PhastSystem compared to conventional electrophoresis: automated sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, silver staining and western blotting of urinary proteins

The recent introduction of the PhastSystem, an automatic electrophoresis and staining system with precast gradient-gels, allows rapid and reproducible analysis of proteinuria in patients suffering from renal injury. A routine method for sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gradient gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and silver staining of unconcentrated urine specimens in the PhastSystem is described and compared to our conventional "macro"-method with self-cast SDS-polyacrylamide gradient gels. The method described for the PhastSystem using 0.3 microL sample volumes and an 8-25% polyacrylamide gradient gel leads to highly reproducible results within 1.5 h. Before electrophoresis urine specimens were neither concentrated nor dialyzed. Samples with a protein concentration exceeding 5 mg/mL had to be diluted 1:5 (v/v). Analysis and documentation of PhastGels appeared as easy as with our conventional SDS-PAGE. Protein bands could reliably be identified by Western blotting. Urine and serum proteins, separated in PhastGels, were electrophoretically transferred to nitrocellulose and detected with specific antibodies against human albumin, transferrin, alpha-1-antitrypsin and IgG. Comparison of several standard kits for molecular weight determination revealed considerable differences concerning the quality of protein separation patterns. Availability of precast gels and automatization of SDS-PAGE and staining allows easy standardization of urine SDS-PAGE among clinical routine laboratories.     

Postelectrophoretic staining of proteins separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis using SYPRO dyes

While the classical silver stain has been the method of choice for high sensitivity protein visualization on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-D PAGE), post-electrophoretic fluorescent staining with the SYPRO group of dyes has emerged to challenge silver staining for proteome analysis. The latter offers improved sensitivity, higher dynamic range and easy handling. However, most of the published data were derived from analysis of 1-D gel separations. In this work, we have focused on three commercially available fluorescent dyes, SYPRO Ruby, SYPRO Orange and SYPRO Red (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR, USA) and studied their sensitivity and dynamic range on 2-D PAGE. The use of a multiwavelength fluorescent scanner to image 2-D protein profiles visualized with fluorescent staining is discussed, and a detailed comparison with analysis by silver staining is also provided. These results demonstrate the advantages of using SYPRO dyes, which are in agreement with the literature based on 1-D gel electrophoresis, and give a more realistic understanding of the performance of these fluorescent dyes with 2-D PAGE.     

Fully reversible procedure for silver staining improves densitometry of complex mixtures of biopolymers resolved by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

Due to its high sensitivity, silver staining is a widely popular method for the revelation of biopolymers separated by both native and denaturing electrophoresis. A step-by-step method for the destaining and restaining of overdeveloped/overloaded silver-stained bands is described that is applicable to both proteins and nucleic acids. The procedure significantly improves densitometric analysis of gels that have been silver stained with either commercial kits or solutions made in-house. The method permits reproducible densitometry of silver-stained gels and allows quantification of both main and minor components in complex mixture of molecules resolved on the same gel slab. All steps may be interrupted and are readily reversible, allowing for facile densitometric analyses and photographic recording under optimized conditions. Furthermore, common artifacts such as differential staining of the two gel surfaces, localized uneven yellow-ochre background, and the presence of fold marks and fingerprints can be easily removed.     

Background-free,fast protein staining in sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel using counterion dyes,zincon and ethyl violet

A background-free, fast protein staining method in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis using an acidic dye, zincon (ZC) and a basic dye, ethyl violet (EV) is described. It is based on the counterion dye staining technique that employs two oppositely charged dyes to form an ion-pair complex in staining solution. The selective binding of free dye molecules to proteins in acidic solution produces bluish violet-colored bands. It is a rapid and end-point staining procedure, involving only fixing and staining steps that are completed in 1-1.5 h. The detection limit of this method is 8-15 ng of protein that is comparable to the sensitivity of the colloidal Coomassie Brilliant Blue G (CBBG) stain. Due to its sensitivity and speed, this stain may be more practical than any other dye-based stains for routine laboratory purposes.     

Novel procedure for the identification of proteins by mass fingerprinting combining two-dimensional electrophoresis with fluorescent SYPRO red staining

The fluorescent sensitive SYPRO Red dye was successfully employed to stain proteins in two-dimensional gels for protein identification by peptide mass fingerprinting. Proteins which are not chemically modified during the SYPRO Red staining process are well digested enzymatically in the gel and hence the resulting peptides can be efficiently eluted and analysed by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS). A SYPRO Red two-dimensional gel of a complex protein extract from Candida albicans was analysed by MALDI-TOF MS. The validity of SYPRO Red staining was demonstrated by identifying, via peptide mass fingerprinting, 10 different C. albicans proteins from a total of 31 selected protein spots. The peptide mass signal intensity, the number of matched peptides and the percentage of coverage of protein sequences from SYPRO Red-stained proteins were similar to or greater than those obtained in parallel with the modified silver protein gel staining. This work demonstrates that fluorescent SYPRO Red staining is compatible with the identification of proteins separated on polyacrylamide gel and that it can be used as an alternative to silver staining. As far as we know, this is the first report in which C. albicans proteins separated using 2-D gels have been identified by peptide mass fingerprinting. The improved technique described here should be very useful for carrying out proteomic studies.     

Green-light transilluminator for the detection without photodamage of proteins and DNA labeled with different fluorescent dyes

The excitation spectra of Nile red and SYPRO red, two currently used dyes for the fluorescent staining of protein bands in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gels, show an excitation peak in the UV region and another in the visible region (maximum at about 550 nm). Ethidium bromide and other intercalating dyes, e.g. propidium iodide, ethidium dimers, and benzoxazolium-4-quinolinium dimer-3 (YOYO), used for the fluorescent staining of DNA bands in agarose gels also show an excitation peak in the same region of the visible spectrum. We have designed and constructed a green-light transilluminator with an emission maximum at 542 nm. This visible transilluminator allows the detection of protein bands stained with Nile red and SYPRO red with the same sensitivity obtained with a 300 nm UV transilluminator. The green-light transilluminator also allows the detection of about 2 ng of DNA per band in gels stained with ethidium bromide and the other intercalating dyes indicated above. In contrast to the UV transilluminators, the green-light transilluminator does not produce photodamage of DNA even after long exposures (10 min). This makes this transilluminator very useful for preparative work. Furthermore, the green-light transilluminator does not require UV safety equipment and, consequently, it can be very convenient for teaching laboratories.     

Application of Neuhoff's optimized Coomassie brilliant blue G-250/ammonium sulfate/phosphoric acid protein staining to ultrathin polyacrylamide gels on polyester films

An optimized Coomassie staining procedure, utilizing Coomassie Brilliant Blue G-250 in phosphoric acid/ammonium sulfate, was applied to ultrathin-layer isoelectric focusing in 0.18 mm polyacrylamide gels, and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in 0.38 mm polyacrylamide gels, both backed to Gel-Fix polyester supporting films. After isoelectric focusing staining of gelatin and acidic proteins was better with the phosphoric acid/ammonium sulfate procedure than with conventional organic solvent methods. When applied to gels after sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis the sensitivity of the phosphoric acid/ammonium sulfate method was equal to that on conventional staining but lower than on silver staining.     

Ultrasensitive fluorescence protein detection in isoelectric focusing gels using a ruthenium metal chelate stain

SYPRO Ruby IEF Protein Gel Stain is an ultrasensitive, luminescent stain optimized for the analysis of protein in isoelectric focusing gels. Proteins are stained in a ruthenium-containing metal complex overnight and then rinsed in distilled water for 2 h. Stained proteins can be excited by ultraviolet light of about 302 nm (UV-B transilluminator) or with visible light of about 470 nm. Fluorescence emission of the dye is maximal at approximately 610 nm. The sensitivity of the SYPRO Ruby IEF protein gel stain is superior to colloidal Coomassie blue stain and the highest sensitivity silver staining procedures available. The SYPRO Ruby IEF protein gel stain is suitable for staining proteins in nondenaturing or denaturing carrier ampholyte isoelectric focusing and immobilized pH gradient gel electrophoresis. The stain is compatible with N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide or piperazine diacylamide cross-linked polyacrylamide gels as well as with agarose gels and high tensile strength Duracryl gels. The stain does not contain extraneous chemicals (formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, Tween-20) that frequently interfere with peptide identification in mass spectrometry. Successful identification of stained proteins by peptide mass profiling is demonstrated.