Chemical oxidation of a redox-active, ferrocene-containing cationic lipid: Influence on interactions with DNA and characterization in the context of cell transfection

We report an approach to the chemical oxidation of a ferrocene-containing cationic lipid [bis(11-ferrocenylundecyl)dimethylammonium bromide, BFDMA] that provides redox-based control over the delivery of DNA to cells. We demonstrate that BFDMA can be oxidized rapidly and quantitatively by treatment with Fe(III)sulfate. This chemical approach, while offering practical advantages compared to electrochemical methods used in past studies, was found to yield BFDMA/DNA lipoplexes that behave differently in the context of cell transfection from lipoplexes formed using electrochemically oxidized BFDMA. Specifically, while lipoplexes of the latter do not transfect cells efficiently, lipoplexes of chemically oxidized BFDMA promoted high levels of transgene expression (similar to levels promoted by reduced BFDMA). Characterization by SANS and cryo-TEM revealed lipoplexes of chemically and electrochemically oxidized BFDMA to both have amorphous nanostructures, but these lipoplexes differed significantly in size and zeta potential. Our results suggest that differences in zeta potential arise from the presence of residual Fe²⁺ and Fe³⁺ ions in samples of chemically oxidized BFDMA. Addition of the iron chelating agent EDTA to solutions of chemically oxidized BFDMA produced samples functionally similar to electrochemically oxidized BFDMA. These EDTA-treated samples could also be chemically reduced by treatment with ascorbic acid to produce samples of reduced BFDMA that do promote transfection. Our results demonstrate that entirely chemical approaches to oxidation and reduction can be used to achieve redox-based ‘on/off’ control of cell transfection similar to that achieved using electrochemical methods.     

Nanostructure of complexes between cationic lipids and an oppositely charged polyelectrolyte

The morphology of aqueous solutions of polyelectrolytes and oppositely charged lipids is the subject of extensive colloid science research, because of their application in industry and medicine, the latter especially for gene therapy. In this work, we show that complexes of two different cationic lipids with the polyelectrolyte sodium poly(acrylic acid), PAA, share similar morphology with the complexes of those lipids with nucleic acids, implying a broader and universal packing phenomenon. We characterized by direct-imaging cryogenic-temperature transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM), dynamic light scattering (DLS), and zeta (ζ)-potential two cationic lipids, 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane (DOTAP) and bis(11-ferrocenylundecyl) dimethylammonium bromide (BFDMA), which are used in gene transfection, at equivalent lipid/polyelectrolyte charge ratio. Our results revealed that, for both types of complexes, onion-like multilamellar nanostructures formed, which exhibited similar morphology as in complexes of DNA or oligonucleotides (lipoplexes), based on the same lipids. Our findings suggest that the onion-like packing may be energetically favorable for a wide range of polyelectrolyte-liposome systems, from oligonucleotides and DNA to PAA.     

Characterization of the nanostructure of complexes formed by a redox-active cationic lipid and DNA

We report characterization of the nanostructures of complexes formed between the redox-active lipid bis(n-ferrocenylundecyl)dimethylammonium bromide (BFDMA) and DNA using small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) and cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). A particular focus was directed to the influence of lipid oxidation state (where reduced BFDMA has a net charge of +1 and oxidized BFDMA has a charge of +3) on the nanostructures of the solution aggregates formed. Complexes were characterized over a range of charge ratios of reduced BFDMA to DNA (1.1:1, 2.75:1, and 4:1) in solutions of 1 mM Li2SO4. For these complexes, a single peak in the SANS data at 1.2 nm(-1) indicated that a nanostructure with a periodicity of 5.2 nm was present, similar to that observed with complexes of the classical lipids DODAB/DOPE and DNA (multilamellar spacing of 7.0 nm). The absence of additional Bragg peaks in all the SANS data indicated that the periodicity did not extend over large distances. Both inverse Fourier transform analysis and form factor fitting suggested formation of a multilamellar vesicle. These results were confirmed by cryo-TEM images in which multilamellar complexes with diameters between 50 and 150 nm were observed with no more than seven lamellae per aggregate. In contrast to complexes of reduced BFDMA and DNA, Bragg peaks were absent in SANS spectra of complexes formed by oxidized BFDMA and DNA at all charge ratios investigated. The low-q behavior of the SANS data obtained using oxidized BFDMA and DNA complexes suggested that large, loose aggregates were formed, consistent with complementary cryo-TEM images showing predominantly loose disordered aggregates. Some highly ordered spongelike and cubic phase nanostructures were also detected in cryo-TEM images. We conclude that control of BFDMA oxidation state can be used to manipulate the nanostructures of lipid-DNA complexes formed using BFDMA.     

A physicochemical characterization of the interaction between DC-Chol/DOPE cationic liposomes and DNA

A 1:1 mixture of the cationic lipid 3beta-[ N-( N', N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl]cholesterol hydrochloride (DC-Chol) and the zwitterionic lipid, 1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphoetanolamine (DOPE), has been used to compact calf-thymus DNA (CT-DNA) in aqueous buffered solution at 298.15 K. The formation process of this lipoplex has been analyzed by means of electrophoretic mobility, cryo-TEM, dynamic light scattering, and fluorescence spectroscopy techniques. The experimental results indicate that DC-Chol/DOPE liposomes are mostly spherical and unilamellar, with a mean diameter of around 99 +/- 10 nm and a bilayer with a thickness of 4.5 +/- 0.5 nm. In the presence of CT-DNA, DC-Chol/DOPE/CT-DNA lipoplexes are formed by means of a strong entropically driven surface electrostatic interaction, as confirmed by zeta potential and fluorescence results, as a consequence of which DNA is compacted and condensed at the surface of the cationic liposomes. The negative charges of DNA phosphate groups are neutralized by the positive charges of cationic liposomes at the isoneutrality L/ D ratio, ( L/ D) varphi around 4, obtained from electrophoretic, fluorescence, and DLS measurements. The decrease in the fluorescence emission intensity of ethidium bromide, EtBr, initially intercalated between DNA base pairs, as long as the association between the biopolymer and the cationic liposomes takes place has permitted one to confirm its electrostatic character as well as to evaluate the different microenvironments of varying polarity of DNA-double helix, liposomes, and/or lipoplexes. Electronic microscopy reveals a rich scenario of possible nanostructures and morphologies for the lipoplexes, from unilamellar DNA-coated liposomes to multilamellar lipoplexes passing through cluster-like structures and several intermediate morphologies.     

Interaction of lipoplexes with anionic lipids resulting in DNA release is a two-stage process

We propose a mechanism for DNA release from lipoplexes in cells that accounts for various observations of lipoplex-anionic lipid interactions. We examined the structural evolution of lipoplexes upon interaction with cellular lipids by synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD), and the extent of DNA release from lipoplexes was determined by gel electrophoresis. We find that the interaction of lipoplexes with anionic cellular lipids is a two-stage process. In the first step, anionic lipids laterally diffuse into the complex and neutralize the cationic lipids. As a result, the membrane charge density of lipoplexes decreases and interactions between cationic lipids and DNA become weaker, but DNA is extremely poorly released. Only after the cationic charge of lipoplex membranes is completely neutralized by anionic lipids does DNA starts to be released significantly.     

Effects of Headgroups and Serum on Gene Transfection of Alkaline Amino Acid Based Cationic Lipids

Three cationic lipids with lysylated(l), histidylated(2), and arginylated(3) headgroups and cholesterol hy-drophobic moiety were synthesized. The average sizes of liposomes and lipoplexes were around 100 and 160 nm, re-spectively. The gene transfection efficiency of the three lipoplexes loaded with pGL3 or pORF-LacZ was compared on 293T cells in the presence or the absence of serum. The transfection efficiency of the three lipoplexes in a se-rum-free medium was 2 to 3-fold higher than that of dioleoyl-trimethylammonium propane(DOTAP). In the presence of serum, however, most of the lipoplexes showed lower transfection activities; only lipoplex 3 retained its high transfection efficiency.     

Enhanced transfection efficiency of multicomponent lipoplexes in the regime of optimal membrane charge density

Recently, membrane charge density of lipid membranes, sigma M, has been recognized as a universal parameter that controls the transfection efficiency of complexes made of binary cationic liposomes and DNA (binary lipoplexes). Three distinct regimes, most likely related to interactions between complexes and cells, have also been identified. The purpose of this work was to investigate the transfection efficiency behavior of multicomponent lipoplexes in the regime of optimal membrane charge density (1< sigma M < 2 x 10 (-2) e/A (2)) and compare their performance with that of binary lipoplexes usually employed for gene delivery purposes. We found remarkable differences in transfection efficiency due to lipid composition, with maximum in efficiency being obtained when multicomponent lipoplexes were used to transfect NIH 3T3 cells, while binary lipoplexes were definitely less efficient. These findings suggested that multicomponent systems are especially promising lipoplex candidates. With the aim of providing new insights into the mechanism of transfection, we investigated the structural evolution of lipoplexes when interacting with anionic (cellular) lipids by means of synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD), while the extent of DNA release upon interaction with anionic lipids was measured by electrophoresis on agarose gels. Interestingly, a clear trend was found that the transfection activity increased with the number of lipid components. These results highlight the compositional properties of carrier lipid/cellular lipid mixtures as decisive factors for transfection and suggest a strategy for the rational design of superior cationic lipid carriers.     

The analysis of serum effects on structure, size and toxicity of DDAB-DOPE and DC-Chol-DOPE lipoplexes contributes to explain their different transfection efficiency

The effect of serum on structural properties of dimethyl-dioctadecyl-ammonium bromide (DDAB)–1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) liposomes and DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes has been investigated by energy dispersive X-ray diffraction (EDXD) technique, at different cationic lipid/DNA weight ratios (ρ). The role of serum on the size of lipoplexes has also been studied by dynamic light scattering. Lipoplex transfection efficiency (TE) as a function of ρ, and lipoplex toxicity to C6 rat glioma cells have been evaluated in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) with and without serum. A multi-parametric analysis concerning the role of size, structure and cytotoxicity on transfection efficiency contributes to explain the experimental observation that 3β-[N-(N′,N′-dimethylaminoethane)carbamoyl]-cholesterol (DC-Chol)–DOPE/DNA transfect C6 cells better than DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes.     

The analysis of serum effects on structure,size and toxicity of DDAB–DOPE and DC-Chol–DOPE lipoplexes contributes to explain their different transfection efficiency

The effect of serum on structural properties of dimethyl-dioctadecyl-ammonium bromide (DDAB)–1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) liposomes and DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes has been investigated by energy dispersive X-ray diffraction (EDXD) technique, at different cationic lipid/DNA weight ratios (ρ). The role of serum on the size of lipoplexes has also been studied by dynamic light scattering. Lipoplex transfection efficiency (TE) as a function of ρ, and lipoplex toxicity to C6 rat glioma cells have been evaluated in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) with and without serum. A multi-parametric analysis concerning the role of size, structure and cytotoxicity on transfection efficiency contributes to explain the experimental observation that 3β-[N-(N′,N′-dimethylaminoethane)carbamoyl]-cholesterol (DC-Chol)–DOPE/DNA transfect C6 cells better than DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes.     

Correlation between structure and transfection efficiency: a study of DC-Chol--DOPE/DNA complexes

The supramolecular structural nature of some cationic liposomes-DNA complexes, currently used as vehicles in non-viral gene delivery, has been elucidated by recent X-ray diffraction experiments. The relationship between the chemico-physical properties of these self-assembled structures and their transfection efficiency is extensively studied. Here we report a first comprehensive structural study by using energy dispersive X-ray diffraction, of the complex DC-Chol--DOPE/DNA (3beta[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl]cholesterol dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine/DNA), which has been classified as one of the most effective in in-vivo experiments. Our results show that DC-Chol--DOPE/DNA lipoplexes have a columnar inverted hexagonal structure, which is not influenced by the cationic liposome/DNA charge ratio. The transfection efficiency of C6 rat glioma cells by DC-Chol--DOPE/DNA lipoplexes and the toxicity of lipoplexes to cells are dramatically affected by cationic liposome/DNA weight ratio.It seems therefore that the lipoplex structures have not any influence on transfection efficiency and toxicity in our experimental system.     

Ferrocene-containing cationic lipids: influence of redox state on cell transfection

A ferrocene-containing, redox-active cationic lipid that can be transformed using electrochemical methods yields large differences in cell transfection depending on the oxidation state of the lipid. Expression of enhanced green fluorescent protein and firefly luciferase occurs at very high levels when DNA lipoplexes are formulated using the lipid in the reduced state. In contrast, transfection is negligible when oxidized lipid is used. These observations suggest the basis of a general method that could be used to transform inactive lipoplex formulations to an active form through the application of externally applied electrical potentials. The ability to activate lipoplexes toward transfection electrochemically and "on demand" could create new opportunities to deliver DNA in vitro and in vivo with both spatial and temporal control.     

Investigation of complexes formed by interaction of cationic gemini surfactants with deoxyribonucleic acid

Cationic gemini surfactants, N,N-bis(dimethylalkyl)-alpha,omega-alkanediammonium dibromide [C(m)H(2m+1)(CH(3))(2)N(+)(CH(2))(s)N(+)(CH(3))(2)C(m)H(2m+1) x 2 Br(-), or m-s-m], have proven to be effective synthetic vectors for gene delivery (transfection). Complexes (lipoplexes) of gemini compounds, where m = 12, s = 3, 12 and m = 18 : 1(oleyl), s = 2, 3, 6, with DNA have been investigated using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), dynamic light scattering (DLS), zeta potential, atomic force microscopy (AFM) and circular dichroism (CD) techniques. The results show that lipoplex properties depend on the structural properties of the gemini surfactants, the presence of the helper lipid dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE), and the titration sequence. ITC data show that the interaction between DNA and gemini surfactants is endothermic and the observed enthalpy vs. charge ratio profile depends upon the titration sequence. Isoelectric points (IP) of lipoplex formation were estimated from the zeta potential measurements and show good agreement with the reaction endpoints (RP) obtained from ITC. DLS data indicate that DNA is condensed in the lipoplex. AFM images suggest that the lipoplex morphology changes from isolated globular-like aggregated particles to larger-size aggregates with great diversity in morphology. This change is further accentuated by the presence of DOPE in the lipoplexes. The results are interpreted in terms of some current models of lipoplex formation.     

Cationic lipo-thiophosphoramidates for gene delivery: synthesis, physico-chemical characterization and gene transfection activity--comparison with lipo-phosphoramidates

The synthesis of cationic lipo-thiophosphoramidates, a new family of cationic lipids designed for gene delivery, is reported herein. This new class of lipids is less polar than its oxygenated equivalent the lipo-phosphoramidates. Fluorescence anisotropy and FRET were used to determine the fluidity and fusogenicity of the lipo-phosphoramidates 3a-b and lipo-thiophosphoramidates 7a-b. The determination of both the size and the zeta potential of the nano-objects (liposomes and lipoplexes) and the determination of the DNA binding ability of the liposomes have completed the physico-chemical characterizations of the cationic lipids studied. Finally, the cationic lipids 3a-b and 7a-c have been evaluated as synthetic vectors for gene transfection into a variety of mammalian cell lines. The lipo-thiophosphoramidate 7a proved to be an efficient and low toxicity synthetic vector even when used at low lipid to DNA charge ratios.     

Correlation of the physicochemical properties of symmetric 1,3-dialkoylamidopropane-based cationic lipids containing single primary and tertiary amine polar head groups with in vitro transfection activity

The physicochemical properties of a novel series of symmetric 1,3-dialkylamidopropane-based cationic amphiphiles [M. Sheikh, J. Feig, B. Gee, S. Li, M. Savva, In vitro lipofection with novel series of symmetric 1,3-dialkoylamidopropane-based cationic surfactants containing single primary and tertiary amine polar head groups, Chem. Phys. Lipids 124 (2003) 49-61] were studied by several techniques, in an effort to correlate cationic lipid structure with transfection efficacy. It was found that only the unsubstituted amine and tertiary amine dioleoyl derivatives 1,3lmp5 and 1,3lmt5, respectively, mediated in vitro transfection activity in the absence of helper lipids. This activity pattern was consistent with ethidium bromide fluorescence quenching studies, which indicated that only these two derivatives bound to and efficiently condense plasmid DNA at physiological pH. Dynamic light scattering indicated that lipoplexes made by these two cationic lipids were relatively small particles below 1 microm, in sharp contrast to lipoplexes bigger than 3 microm composed of saturated cationic derivatives. Transmission electron microscopy studies clearly indicated that cationic lipid dispersions made by saturated derivatives form multilamellar tubules at physiological pH. Calorimetric studies showed that cationic amphiphiles with saturated acyl chains longer than 12 carbons exhibit solid-to-liquid crystalline phase transitions above 37 degrees C. In agreement with the microscopy and calorimetry studies, Langmuir film balance experiments indicated that saturated derivatives with hydrophobic chains longer that 12 carbons are not well hydrated and exist at a chain-ordered state at ambient temperature. Calculation of compressibility moduli from monolayer compression isotherms at 23 degrees C suggested that monolayers made by cationic lipids bearing saturated acyl chains are less compressible relative to those of the dioleoyl derivatives 1,3lmp5 and 1,3lmt5. In conclusion, high hydration, increased fluidity and high elasticity of cationic lipid assemblies in isolation, all correlate with high in vitro transfection activity.     

Structural stability against disintegration by anionic lipids rationalizes the efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes

Reported here is the correlation between the transfection efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes (lipoplexes) and the structural evolution that they undergo when interacting with anionic membrane lipids. Multicomponent lipoplexes, incorporating from three to six lipid species simultaneously, presented a much higher transfection efficiency than binary lipoplexes, which are more commonly used for gene-delivery purposes. The discovery that a high transfection efficiency can be achieved by employing multicomponent complexes at a lower-than-ever-before membrane charge density of lipoplexes was of primary significance. Synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD) experiments showed that anionic liposomes made of dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) disintegrated the lamellar phase of lipoplexes. DNA unbinding was measured by electrophoresis on agarose gels. Most importantly, structural changes induced by anionic lipids strictly depended on the lipid composition of lipoplexes. We found evidence of the existence of three different regimes of stability related to the interaction between complexes and anionic membranes. Both unstable (with low membrane charge density, sigmaM) and highly stable lipoplexes (with high sigmaM) exhibited low transfection efficiency whereas highly efficient multicomponent lipoplexes exhibited an "optimal stability". This intermediate regime reflects a compromise between two opposing constraints: protection of DNA in the cytosol and endosomal escape. Here we advance the concept that structural stability, upon interaction with cellular anionic lipids, is a key factor governing the transfection efficiency of lipoplexes. Possible molecular mechanisms underlying experimental observations are also discussed.     

Transfection mediated by gemini surfactants: engineered escape from the endosomal compartment

The structure of the lipoplex formed from DNA and the sugar-based cationic gemini surfactant 1, which exhibits excellent transfection efficiency, has been investigated in the pH range 8.8-3.0 utilizing small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). Uniquely, three well-defined morphologies of the lipoplex were observed upon gradual acidification: a lamellar phase, a condensed lamellar phase, and an inverted hexagonal (H(II)) columnar phase. Using molecular modeling, we link the observed lipoplex morphologies and physical behavior to specific structural features in the individual surfactant, illuminating key factors in future surfactant design, viz., a spacer of six methylene groups, the presence of two nitrogens that can be protonated in the physiological pH range, two unsaturated alkyl tails, and hydrophilic sugar headgroups. Assuming that the mechanism of transfection by synthetic cationic surfactants involves endocytosis, we contend that the efficacy of gemini surfactant 1 as a gene delivery vehicle can be explained by the unprecedented observation of a pH-induced formation of the inverted hexagonal phase of the lipoplex in the endosomal pH range. This change in morphology leads to destabilization of the endosome through fusion of the lipoplex with the endosomal wall, resulting in release of DNA into the cytoplasm.     

Effect of α-Ketoglutarate on Monoclonal Antibody Production of Hybridoma Cell Lines in Serum-Free and Serum-Containing Medium

Process development and optimization for increase population growth and protein productivity in mammalian cell culture have been studied for many years. In this study, the behavior of hybridoma cells was investigated using six-well micro-titer plate systems with a working volume of 4 ml. Mouse hybridoma cell lines D2 and 2C83G2 were seeded in serum-free and serum-containing media and cultured for 8 days. alpha-Ketoglutarate is an integral component of the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle and is produced from glutamine via glutamate. To study its effect on cell growth, metabolism, and monoclonal antibody (mAb) production, 2 mM alpha-ketoglutarate (pH 7.2) was added in both media at the beginning of the cultivation and in another set after 72 h. High cell density was observed in D2 cell culturing in serum-free medium, while 2C83G2 cell line showed high cell density in serum-containing medium. However, both cell lines cultured in serum-free medium gave viability above 70% when grown for 8 days. The supplement of 2 mM alpha-ketoglutarate supported cell growth and mAb production of both hybridoma cell lines in serum-free and serum-containing medium. The addition of alpha-ketoglutarate at the beginning of the batch cultivation gave better result in cell growth and mAb production as compared to alpha-ketoglutarate supplementation after 72 h. However, addition after 72 h was better than no addition at all. This indicates that alpha-ketoglutarate have a positive effect on production and release of antibody.     

Cryo-TEM studies of DNA and DNA–lipid structures

Studies published between 2001 and 2005 that utilise cryogenic transmission electron microscopy as a tool for investigating solutions containing DNA with or without amphiphiles present are reviewed. DNA or oligonucleotides form complexes with amphiphilic molecules such as lipids, so-called lipoplexes, and the structures and morphologies are excellent objects to study by cryogenic transmission electron microscopy. Recent studies show that this technique is an effective tool for identification of a range of structures such as unilamellar or multilamellar vesicles or dispersed liquid crystalline phases.     

Solid-phase synthesis of 89 polyamine-based cationic lipids for DNA delivery to mammalian cells

The ability of non-viral gene delivery systems to overcome extracellular and intracellular barriers is a critical issue for future clinical applications of gene therapy. In recent years much effort has been focused on the development of a variety of DNA carriers, and cationic liposomes have become the most common non-viral gene delivery system. Solid-phase synthesis was used to produce three libraries of polyamine-based cationic lipids with diverse hydrophobic tails. These were characterised, and structure-activity relationships were determined for DNA binding and transfection ability of these compounds when formulated as cationic liposomes. Two of the cationic lipids produced high-efficiency transfection of human cells. Surprisingly, these two compounds were from the library with two headgroups and one aliphatic tail, a compound class regarded as detergent-like and little investigated for transfection. These cationic lipids are promising reagents for gene delivery and illustrate the potential of solid-phase synthesis methods for lipoplex discovery.     

DNA–DNA electrostatic interactions within cationic lipid/DNA lamellar complexes

We present a simple theoretical analysis of the DNA–DNA electrostatic interactions within charge-neutral lamellar cationic lipid/DNA complexes (lipoplexes). Although always repulsive as a function of the DNA–DNA interaxial distance, the calculated electrostatic force shows a deep minimum for each value of lipid composition corresponding to an equilibrium distance of the system. The excellent agreement between the equilibrium distances predicted by the model and that experimentally observed in charge-neutral complexes as revealed by synchrotron X-ray diffraction, shows that the spatial dimensionality of both the lipids and the DNA may not be a crucial point to capture the essence of the DNA–DNA interactions within charge-neutral lipoplexes.