A DANREF certified reference plastic for measurement of overall migration into the food simulant olive oil by single sided testing

A reference material for the determination of overall migration from a plastic coextrudate into the fatty food simulant olive oil was produced and certified in an interlaboratory study. The analyses were carried out according to the ENV 1186 standard from the European Committee for Standardization (CEN) [1, 2, 3] with exposure of the coextrudate to olive oil for 10 days at 40?°C. After an initial preliminary interlaboratory study eight laboratories participated in the certification round, and two different methods were used to obtain single sided exposure of the plastic to the oil. The certified value was determined as the mean of laboratory mean values. No outliers were found. A reference value of 8.6 mg/dm²± 1.4 mg/dm² (± half width of the 95% confidence interval) was obtained which is within the range relevant for the regulatory limit (10 mg/ dm²), making this reference material suitable for laboratories measuring according to the EU overall migration limit [4]. The material has been found stable over 45 months.     

Validation of accuracy by interlaboratory programme

A statistical design is proposed for assessing the accuracy of an analytical method by its application to a certified reference material in an interlaboratory programme. The validation of accuracy is based on the difference between the certified value and the overall mean of the test programme and is linked to the concept that below a certain limit this difference has no practical significance. It is shown that a certified reference material cannot be used to detect bias in a method if the bias is smaller than the confidence interval of the certified value.     

Development of reference materials for paralytic shellfish poisoning toxins

A project was undertaken to develop mussel reference materials that were certified for their mass fractions of saxitoxin and decarbamoyl-saxitoxin. Fifteen laboratories from various European countries participated. Three of these had major responsibility for substantial parts of the work and overall coordination of the project. The project involved 4 main activities: (1) procurement and characterization of calibrants; (2) improvement of analytical methodology; (3) preparation of reference materials, including homogeneity and stability studies; (4) 2 interlaboratory studies and a certification exercise. The joint activities resulted in 3 homogeneous and stable reference materials: 2 lyophilized mussel materials with and without naturally incurred paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) toxins, and a saxitoxin enrichment solution. The reference materials were certified with respect to their saxitoxin and decarbamoyl-saxitoxin content. The lyophilized mussel material with PSP toxins (CRM 542) contained <0.07 mg saxitoxin x 2HCl/kg and 1.59 +/- 0.20 mg decarbamoyl-saxitoxin x 2HCl/kg. The lyophilized mussel material without PSP toxins (CRM 543) contained <0.07 mg saxitoxin x 2HCl/kg and <0.04 mg decarbamoyl-saxitoxin x 2HCl/kg. The certified value of the saxitoxin mass fraction in the saxitoxin enrichment solution (CRM 663) was 9.8 +/- 1.2 microg/g.     

Virginia Tobacco Leaves (CTA-VTL-2) – new Polish CRM for inorganic trace analysis including microanalysis

Preparation and certification of a new Polish reference material (CTA-VTL-2) for inorganic trace analysis including microanalysis is described. Virginia Tobacco Leaves of Bulgarian origin were hand picked, dried, comminuted and sieved at conditions preventing contamination of the material with metals. Ca. 13 kg of the material with particle size φ≤ 80 μm was prepared. Certification was based on world-wide interlaboratory comparison in which 60 laboratories from 18 countries participated. Data evaluation was done using an approach which includes rejection of outliers by concurrent use of four different outlier tests followed by calculation of overall means, confidence intervals etc. Several criteria were employed to qualify or disqualify the obtained overall mean as a certified or information value, respectively. 33 elements were certified and information values were established for 10 others. Particle size distribution of CTA-VTL-2 was investigated microscopically. The modal particle diameter was in the range of 15–35 μm. Extensive homogeneity checking by neutron activation analysis revealed that the material is sufficiently homogeneous for mg sample sizes.     

Use of an excess variance approach for the certification of reference materials by interlaboratory comparison

In the nuclear field, the accuracy and comparability of analytical results are crucial to insure correct accountancy, good process control and safe operational conditions. All of these require reliable measurements based on reference materials whose certified values must be obtained by robust metrological approaches according to the requirements of ISO guides 34 and 35. The data processing of the characterization step is one of the key steps of a reference material production process. Among several methods, the use of interlaboratory comparison results for reference material certification is very common. The DerSimonian and Laird excess variance approach, described and implemented in this paper, is a simple and efficient method for the data processing of interlaboratory comparison results for reference material certification. By taking into account not only the laboratory uncertainties but also the spread of the individual results into the calculation of the weighted mean, this approach minimizes the risk to get biased certified values in the case where one or several laboratories either underestimate their measurement uncertainties or do not identify all measurement biases. This statistical method has been applied to a new CETAMA plutonium reference material certified by interlaboratory comparison and has been compared to the classical weighted mean approach described in ISO Guide 35. This paper shows the benefits of using an “excess variance” approach for the certification of reference material by interlaboratory comparison.     

Preparation of a reference material “Creatinine in Human Urine”

Two batches of a reference material “Creatinine in Human Urine” have been prepared with creatinine concentrations at the physiological level, and used in interlaboratory comparisons in which up to 26 laboratories participated employing up to 4 independent methods. The 95% confidence intervals obtained for the certified creatinine concentrations are better than the “acceptable ranges” of commercially control samples available for clinical laboratories, the certified values being traceable to mean values of the commercial control samples. Thus, a suitable reference material has been prepared for the quality assurance of environmental and occupational health studies in which the concentration of a pollutant or its metabolites in human urine has to be related to the creatinine concentration.     

Development of a reference material for residues of chlorfluazuron and fluazuron in beef fat ACSL CRM 3

The certification by interlaboratory testing of a candidate reference material (ACSL CRM 3) for the concentration (mass fraction) of the pesticides chlorfluazuron (CFZ) and fluazuron (FZN) is described. The certification process was based on a two-stage nested design described in ISO Guide 35. Analysis of results reported by collaborating laboratories provided an assessment of the homogeneity of the RM. The certified values were chlorfluazuron -1.01 mg/kg and fluazuron -1.02 mg/kg. The upper and lower 95% confidence limits for CFZ and FZN were calculated to be: CFZ upper=1.05 mg/kg, lower=0.97 mg/kg; FZN upper=1.08 mg/kg, lower=0.95 mg/kg. A certificate was prepared according to guidelines set out in ISO Guide 31.     

Determination of niacin in infant formula by solid-phase extraction/liquid chromatography: peer-verified method performance-interlaboratory validation

This paper reports the results of the interlaboratory peer validation study of AOAC Peer-Verified Method (PVM) 1:2,000 for the determination of niacin in infant formula by solid-phase extraction/liquid chromatography. We have used a Data Quality Objectives (DQO) approach to address not only method variability and robustness but also accuracy of data through the use of an appropriate reference material in conjunction with the interlaboratory validation study. Our DQO included the following: (1) statistical agreement of analytical results and quantitative recovery between 2 collaborating laboratories; (2) the repeatability relative standard deviation (RSDr) values and the HORRAT (Horwitz ratio) obtained (1.07), which satisfied the criteria of the Horwitz "limits of acceptability" at the analyte level present; (3) validation of lack of interference; and (4) accuracy agreement within assigned values for a certified reference material. National Institute of Standards and Technology Standard Reference Material (NIST SRM) 1846 Infant Formula, with a certified value of 63.3 +/- 7.6 microg/g for niacin content, was used as a test material for collaborative study and accuracy assessment. Niacin values obtained by the originating laboratory were 59.7 +/- 4.0 microg/g (95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.4 microg/g with a relative standard deviation [RSD] of 6.7%) and by the peer laboratory were 56.6 +/- 6.6 microg/g (95% CI = 4.1 microg/g, with an RSD of 11.7%). Statistical evaluation using the means equivalence test showed that nicotinic acid values obtained by the peer laboratory were equivalent to those values obtained by the originating laboratory. Linear calibration curves and quantitative recovery were obtained. Integration of the PVM process with a readily available certified reference material gives the user confidence in the accuracy of the data generated by the method through traceability to the reference material used.     

Reference materials for PAHs in foodstuffs: Results of the certification exercise of two coconut oil reference materials

This certification exercise was the final stage of a stepwise interlaboratory study approach, organized within the SMT-program of the EC, for the development of certified reference materials (CRMs) for the determination of PAHs in foodstuffs. The certification exercise was carried out by thirteen European laboratories using a variety of extraction and clean-up procedures and different analytical procedures. Two different coconut oil materials were certified for their mass fractions of six selected PAHs. Received: 25 May 1997 / Revised: 5 September 1997 / Accepted: 28 September 1997     

Reference materials for PAHs in foodstuffs: Results of the certification exercise of two coconut oil reference materials

This certification exercise was the final stage of a stepwise interlaboratory study approach, organized within the SMT-program of the EC, for the development of certified reference materials (CRMs) for the determination of PAHs in foodstuffs. The certification exercise was carried out by thirteen European laboratories using a variety of extraction and clean-up procedures and different analytical procedures. Two different coconut oil materials were certified for their mass fractions of six selected PAHs.     

Migration Study of Polypropylene (PP) Oil Blends in Food Simulants

Migration study in aqueous and olive oil food simulants was carried out on PP and its blend with oil mixture. It was found that after 10 days at 44 °C PP with oil content up to 0.83% had overall migration into olive oil less than 10 mg/dm². However, under high temperature migration test (at 110–138 C for 4 hours), the overall migration into olive oil was large for both the virgin PP and all its blends. The overall migration in water, 10% ethanol, and 3% acetic acid was smaller than those in olive oil under both migration test conditions. DSC and density measurement showed that addition of oil in PP led to smaller spherulite size and increased degree of crystallinity in the pure PP part. Small decrease in tensile strength in the oil blends was also observed but there was no significant change in tensile strength after migration test.     

Determination of domoic acid toxins in shellfish by biosense ASP ELISA--a direct competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay: collaborative study

A collaborative study was conducted on the Biosense amnesic shellfish poisoning (ASP) enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the determination of domoic acid (DA) toxins in shellfish in order to obtain interlaboratory validation data for the method. In addition, a method comparison study was performed to evaluate the ASP ELISA as an alternative to the current liquid chromatography (LC) reference method for DA determination. The study material comprised 16 shellfish samples, including blue mussels, Pacific oysters, and king scallops, spiked with contaminated mussel homogenates to contain 0.1-20 mg DA/kg shellfish flesh. The shellfish samples were extracted with 50% aqueous methanol, and the supernatants were directly analyzed. Sixteen participating laboratories in 10 countries reported data from the ASP ELISA, and 4 of these laboratories also reported data from instrumental LC analysis. The participating laboratories achieved interlaboratory precision estimates for the 8 Youden paired shellfish samples in the range of 10-20% for RSD(r) (mean 14.8 +/- 4%), and 13-29% for RSDR (mean 22.7 +/- 6%). The precision estimates for the ELISA data did not show a strong dependence on the DA concentration in the study samples, and the overall precision achieved was within the acceptable range of the Horwitz guideline with HorRat values ranging from 1.1 to 2.4 (mean HorRat 1.7 +/- 0.5). The analysis of shellfish samples spiked with certified reference material (CRM)-ASP-MUS-b gave recoveries in the range of 88-122%, with an average recovery of 104 +/- 10%. The estimate on method accuracy was supported by a correlation slope of 1.015 (R2 = 0.992) for the determined versus the expected DA values. Furthermore, the correlation of the ASP ELISA results with those for the instrumental LC analyses of the same sample extracts gave a correlation slope of 1.29 (R2 = 0.984). This indicates some overestimation of DA levels in shellfish by the ELISA, but it is also a result of apparent low recoveries for the LC methods. This interlaboratory study demonstrates that the ASP ELISA is suitable for the routine determination and monitoring of DA toxins in shellfish, and that it offers a rapid and cost-effective methodology with high sample throughput.     

Development of the NIST Rocky Flats Soil Standard

The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Rocky Flats Soil-II Standard reference material (SRM) is being certified through a statistical analysis of results from an interlaboratory comparison of fourteen laboratories from four countries. Mean values were calculated as the most robust and reliable certified values for each of the radionuclides. Twenty two radionuclides and four isotopes ratios were evaluated based on reported data. This article describes the approach for establishing the certified values and uncertainties for the radionuclides in the Rocky Flats Soil II SRM.     

Development and certification of reference materials for residues of organochlorine and organophosphorus pesticides in beef fat ACSL CRM 1 and 2

Beef fat samples were prepared and tested as candidate reference materials for organochlorine and organophosphorus pesticides. The CRMs consisted of beef fat spiked with pesticide solutions. One sample (ACSL CRM 1) was prepared containing close to 0.2 mg/kg of each of the organochlorine pesticides dieldrin and heptachlor epoxide. A second sample (ACSL CRM 2) was prepared containing close to 0.8 mg/kg of each of the organophosphorus pesticides diazinon, chlorpyrifos and ethion. The spiking levels and homogeneity of the materials were verified. The coefficients of variation of 5 analyses carried out to test between-jar homogeneity for each reference material were dieldrin, 3.5%; heptachlor epoxide, 1.1%; diazinon, 2.1%; chlorpyrifos, 1.2% and ethion, 3.1%. No instability in any of these compounds was detected over a twelve month period. The candidate reference materials were found to be suitable for certification by interlaboratory testing. The certification process was based on a two-stage nested design described in ISO Guide 35. Analysis of results reported by collaborating laboratories provided an assessment of the homogeneity of the reference materials. The certified values together with their upper and lower 95% confidence limits are: ACSL CRM 1*Dieldrin*0.199 mg/kg **(0.188, **0.210 mg/kg) *Heptachlor epoxide*0.194 mg/kg **(0.176, **0.212 mg/kg) ACSL CRM 2*Diazinon*0.805 mg/kg **(0.755, **0.855 mg/kg) *Chlorpyrifos*0.790 mg/kg **(0.728, **0.852 mg/kg) *Ethion*0.813 mg/kg **(0.746, **0.879 mg/kg). A certificate for each material was prepared according to the guidelines set out in ISO Guide 31. Received: 25 April 1997 / Revised: 19 August 1997 / Accepted: 28 August 1997     

Development and certification of reference materials for residues of organochlorine and organophosphorus pesticides in beef fat ACSL CRM 1 and 2

Beef fat samples were prepared and tested as candidate reference materials for organochlorine and organophosphorus pesticides. The CRMs consisted of beef fat spiked with pesticide solutions. One sample (ACSL CRM 1) was prepared containing close to 0.2 mg/kg of each of the organochlorine pesticides dieldrin and heptachlor epoxide. A second sample (ACSL CRM 2) was prepared containing close to 0.8 mg/kg of each of the organophosphorus pesticides diazinon, chlorpyrifos and ethion. The spiking levels and homogeneity of the materials were verified. The coefficients of variation of 5 analyses carried out to test between-jar homogeneity for each reference material were dieldrin, 3.5%; heptachlor epoxide, 1.1%; diazinon, 2.1%; chlorpyrifos, 1.2% and ethion, 3.1%. No instability in any of these compounds was detected over a twelve month period. The candidate reference materials were found to be suitable for certification by interlaboratory testing. The certification process was based on a two-stage nested design described in ISO Guide 35. Analysis of results reported by collaborating laboratories provided an assessment of the homogeneity of the reference materials. The certified values together with their upper and lower 95% confidence limits are: ACSL CRM 1*Dieldrin*0.199 mg/kg **(0.188, **0.210 mg/kg) *Heptachlor epoxide*0.194 mg/kg **(0.176, **0.212 mg/kg) ACSL CRM 2*Diazinon*0.805 mg/kg **(0.755, **0.855 mg/kg) *Chlorpyrifos*0.790 mg/kg **(0.728, **0.852 mg/kg) *Ethion*0.813 mg/kg **(0.746, **0.879 mg/kg). A certificate for each material was prepared according to the guidelines set out in ISO Guide 31.     

The BIOREMA project—Part 2: International interlaboratory comparison for biodiesel test methods

The results of an interlaboratory comparison, using various measurement methods to carry out biodiesel testing, are presented and the findings are discussed. The interlaboratory comparison was organised within the framework of an EU-funded project called BIOREMA. A general overview of the project and results of an interlaboratory comparison on bioethanol are published as Part 1 and 2 of this series of papers. In the study presented here, reference values, provided by national metrology institutes and expert laboratories, were used for evaluating the results. Consensus values, derived from the results of all participants, were used to assess any bias between the results from the national metrology institutes and testing laboratories. The emphasis in this interlaboratory comparison was not the performance rating of the individual laboratories, but recognising and interpreting differences caused by the measurement methods applied. For most biodiesel parameters, a good agreement of measurement results was found among different methods, and between the consensus and reference values. The study material was a rapeseed oil fatty acid methyl ester, for which it was demonstrated that it is feasible to prepare and characterise reference materials for biodiesel with well-established reference values for many parameters.     

Mineral oil content in sediments and soils: comparability, traceability and a certified reference material for quality assurance

The performance of twelve laboratories with previously established proficiency in the determination of the mineral oil content in a fresh water sediment is described. The summation parameter total petrol hydrocarbon (TPH) is defined according to ISO 16703:2004 with regard to the sample preparation to be applied, the flame ionisation detection (FID) and the boiling range of C₁₀–C₄₀ to be integrated. Comprehensive tests of homogeneity and stability have been carried out on the candidate material using appropriate models. The outcome of the study served as the basis for the certification of the candidate reference material as ERM-CC015a. The certified mass fraction is 1,820±130mgkg⁻¹and traceability was established by using an appropriate calibration standard certified for the mass fraction of C₁₀–C₄₀. The interlaboratory scatter of measurement results in this exercise can largely be explained by the variability of the individual calibrations based on this common calibration standard.     

Creatinine determination in urine from the point of view of reference values

In this paper, the creation of a certified reference material for urinary creatinine is described. We used the Jaffe method and HPLC method for establishment of the certified value. Homogeneity tests are also described. We obtained material with sufficient homogeneity, stability, and with certified value (expanded uncertainty, k=2 for CI 95%) (7.77±0.27) mmol·L⁻¹. This material was consequently used for the interlaboratory comparison (EQA Czech Republic for clinical chemistry). Twenty-nine percent of the participants obtained measurement results within the interval of the certified value ± expanded uncertainty, while 85% of the participants obtained values inside the interval of the certified value ± target measurement uncertainty. Direct use of the certified reference materials for method evaluation in EQA programs means a significant advance for monitoring and documentation traceability of results in routine measurements.     

Characterization of a potato reference material for major, minor and trace elements

Summary A potato reference material (RM) was prepared for the analytical quality control program to be employed by the Sub-network on Trace Elements in Food of the FAO European Co-operative Network on Trace Elements. Approximately 50 kg of commercially available potato granules prepared from baked, mashed and roller-dried potatoes, containing 2.8% ash and 3 mg/kg added butylhydroxyanisole was purchased. The granules were carefully homogenised in large glass cylinders followed by division into 50 g portions into numbered acid-washed bottles. The bottled material was tested for homogeneity by taking ten bottles throughout the bottling line and determining by validated atomic absorption spectrometric methods 1.0 g samples for seven mineral elements. Homogeneity for Mg, Ca, Zn, Fe, Mo, Ni and Cd was better than 5%. An international network on experienced, high-quality reference laboratories was established to conduct an interlaboratory comparison study on the determination of 14 mineral elements in the RM. A total of seven methods based on independent analytical principles were employed by the reference laboratories. After excluding outlying analytical results, the criteria defined by the IAEA were used for classification of the overall medians obtained through the interlaboratory comparison study. The relative standard deviations for the 95% confidence limits of the medians were as follows: P=4.2%, K=0.7%, Na=4.7%, Ca=5.5%, Mg=2.4%, Fe=9.3%, Mn=4.0%, Zn=3.6%, Cu=4.7%, Mo=23%, Ni=22%, Cr=19%, Pb=11% and Cd=4.6%. With the exception of Cr, all of the recommended concentration values obtained for the above indicated elements fell into category A, i.e. values recommended with a high degree of confidence according to the classification criteria of the IAEA. The present RM is the only certified potato RM currently available for mineral elements.

---

Charakterisierung eines Kartoffel-Referenzmaterials für Haupt-, Neben- und Spurenelemente