Heuristics with guaranteed performance bounds for a manufacturing system with product recovery

We consider a manufacturing system with product recovery. The system manufactures a new product as well as remanufactures the product from old, returned items. The items remanufactured with the returned products are as good as new and satisfy the same demand as the new item. The demand rate for the new item and the return rate for the old item are deterministic and constant. The relevant costs are the holding costs for the new item and the returned item, and the fixed setup costs for both manufacturing and remanufacturing. The objective is to determine the lot sizes and production schedule for manufacturing and remanufacturing so as to minimize the long-run average cost per unit time. We first develop a lower bound among all classes of policies for the problem. We then show that the optimal integer ratio policy for the problem obtains a solution whose cost is at most 1.5% more than the lower bound.     

Optimal acquisition and production policy in a hybrid manufacturing/remanufacturing system with core acquisition at different quality levels

We study the acquisition and production planning problem for a hybrid manufacturing/remanufacturing system with core acquisition at two (high and low) quality conditions. We model the problem as a stochastic dynamic programming, derive the optimal dynamic acquisition pricing and production policy, and analyze the influences of system parameters on the acquisition prices and production quantities. The production cost differences among remanufacturing high- and low-quality cores and manufacturing new products are found to be critical for the optimal production and acquisition pricing policy: the acquisition price of high-quality cores is increasing in manufacturing and remanufacturing cost differences, while the acquisition price of low-quality cores is decreasing in the remanufacturing cost difference between high- and low-quality cores and increasing in manufacturing and remanufacturing cost differences; the optimal remanufacturing/manufacturing policy follows a base-on-stock pattern, which is characterized by some crucial parameters dependent on these cost differences.     

Simple heuristics for push and pull remanufacturing policies

Inventory policies for joint remanufacturing and manufacturing have recently received much attention. Most efforts, though, were related to (optimal) policy structures and numerical optimization, rather than closed form expressions for calculating near optimal policy parameters. The focus of this paper is on the latter. We analyze an inventory system with unit product returns and demands where remanufacturing is the cheaper alternative for manufacturing. Manufacturing is also needed, however, since there are less returns than demands. The cost structure consists of setup costs, holding costs, and backorder costs. Manufacturing and remanufacturing orders have non-zero lead times. To control the system we use certain extensions of the familiar (s, Q) policy, called push and pull remanufacturing policies. For all policies we present simple, closed form formulae for approximating the optimal policy parameters under a cost minimization objective. In an extensive numerical study we show that the proposed formulae lead to near-optimal policy parameters.     

Dynamic pricing of remanufacturable products under demand substitution: a product life cycle model

We consider a manufacturer who sells both the new and remanufactured versions of a product over its life cycle. The manufacturer’s profit depends crucially on her ability to synchronize product returns with the sales of the remanufactured product. This gives rise to a challenging dynamic optimization problem where the size of both the market and the user pool are dynamic and their current values depend on the entire history. We provide an analytical characterization of the manufacturer’s optimal pricing, production, and inventory policies which lead to a practical threshold policy with a small optimality gap. In addition, our analysis offers a number of interesting insights. First, the timing of remanufacturing activity and its co-occurrence with new product manufacturing critically depends on remanufacturing cost benefits, attractiveness of the remanufactured product and product return rate. Second, there is a small upward jump in the price of the new product when remanufacturing is introduced. Third, the manufacturer keeps the new product longer on the market as the cost of remanufacturing decreases. Fourth, partially satisfying demand for the remanufactured item is never optimal, i.e., it is satisfied either fully or not at all. Finally, user pool and inventory of returned products are substitutes in ensuring the supply for future remanufacturing.     

On the optimal control of manufacturing and remanufacturing activities with a single shared server

We consider a single-product make-to-stock manufacturing–remanufacturing system. Returned products require remanufacturing before they can be sold. The manufacturing and remanufacturing operations are executed by the same single server, where switching from one activity to another does not involve time or cost and can be done at an arbitrary moment in time. Customer demand can be fulfilled by either newly manufactured or remanufactured products. The times for manufacturing and remanufacturing a product are exponentially distributed. Demand and used products arrive via mutually independent Poisson processes. Disposal of products is not allowed and all used products that are returned have to be accepted. Using Markov decision processes, we investigate the optimal manufacture–remanufacture policy that minimizes holding, backorder, manufacturing and remanufacturing costs per unit of time over an infinite horizon. For a subset of system parameter values we are able to completely characterize the optimal continuous-review dynamic preemptive policy. We provide an efficient algorithm based on quasi-birth–death processes to compute the optimal policy parameter values. For other sets of system parameter values, we present some structural properties and insights related to the optimal policy and the performance of some simple threshold policies.     

Simple expressions for finding recovery system inventory control parameter values

In recent years considerable effort has been devoted to the development of inventory control models for joint manufacturing and remanufacturing. Optimality of control policies is analyzed and algorithms for the determination of parameter values have been developed. However, there is still a lack of formulae or algorithms that allow for an easy computation of optimal or near optimal policy parameter values. This paper addresses the problem of computing the produce-up-to level S and the remanufacture-up-to level M in a periodic review inventory control model. We provide simple formulae for the policy parameter values, which can easily be implemented within spreadsheet applications. The approach is to derive news-vendor-type formulae that are based on underage and overage cost considerations. We propose different formulae depending on whether lead times for production and remanufacturing are identical or not. A numerical study shows that the obtained solutions provide relatively small cost deviations compared to the optimal solution within the investigated class of inventory control policies.     

The economics of a closed-loop supply chain with remanufacturing

This study deals with joint decisions on pricing and production lot-sizing in a closed-loop supply chain consisting of manufacturing and remanufacturing operations. This study emphasizes the economic analysis of this hybrid system with substitution between the new and the remanufactured versions of the same product. We develop analytical models under a newsvendor framework bearing the following questions in mind. Can a hybrid system operate cost-effectively? Can it outperform the manufacturing-only system? If yes, to what extent and under what conditions? If not, what are the key factors that cause underperformance? This study formulates a multi-variable optimization problem and performs mathematical and numerical analysis. Results show that the hybrid system does not outperform the manufacturing-only system under a generic setting, but achieves better performance under conditions with a higher degree of substitution and/or a lower remanufacturing cost. In this scenario, participating in remanufacturing is not only an issue of environmental responsibility, but a profit-boosting option.     

回收率依赖价格的再制造EPQ模型研究

研究了考虑回收率依赖于回收品价格,并带有废弃处理的制造和再制造混合系统的(1,R)和(M,1)EPQ模型.在模型中,采用新产品的制造和回收产品的再制造两种方式来满足客户的需要,回收产品部分用于再制造,其余作为废弃处理;总平均成本包括与回收产品、可销售产品有关的库存持有成本,与制造和再制造有关的生产成本和固定成本,与回收品及制造所需原材料的采购成本以及废弃处理成本.模型给出最优生产策略及总平均成本的表达式.算例验证了所建模型的计算方法,并分析了新引人决策变量p(回收产品单价占制造新产品所需原料价格的比例对总平均成本的变化率的影响.     

Optimal policy and holding cost stability regions in a periodic review inventory system with manufacturing and remanufacturing options

In this paper a periodic review inventory model with finite horizon and remanufacturing, manufacturing options is studied. It is assumed that demand and cost parameters are constant and a sufficiently large quantity of used products is available at the beginning of the horizon. The model is studied within the class of policies with given remanufacturing and manufacturing set up and the optimal policy is obtained within this class. The policy specifies the period of switching from remanufacturing to manufacturing (switching period), the periods where remanufacturing and manufacturing activities take place and the corresponding lot sizes. An explicit formula for the cost function and some of its properties are established. Based on these, an algorithm which partitions the set of holding cost parameters into subsets, computes the optimal policy and constructs its corresponding stability regions on every such subset is proposed.     

回收率依赖回收产品质量的再制造EOQ模型

研究回收率依赖回收产品质量情况下制造/再制造混合系统的EOQ模型.该模型假设顾客的需求可通过新产品的制造和回收产品的再制造两种方式满足,且这两种产品无质量差异;需求率是确定的、连续的;总成本包括制造和再制造的固定启动成本,可销售产品和回收品的库存成本,以及缺货成本.当假设缺货成本无限大时给出不允许缺货情况下的模型.给出算例验证模型的有效性.     

Examining the balance between efficiency and resilience in closed-loop supply chains

Central European Journal of Operations Research - We study a hybrid system where the demand of customers can be satisfied by both manufacturing new products and remanufacturing used products. To...     

Lot sizing for a single product recovery system with variable setup numbers

Inventory systems for joint remanufacturing and manufacturing have recently received considerable attention. In such systems, used products are collected from customers and are kept at the recoverable inventory warehouse for future remanufacturing. In this paper a production–remanufacturing inventory system is considered, where the demand can be satisfied by production and remanufacturing. The cost structure consists of the EOQ-type setup costs, holding costs and shortage costs. The model with no shortage case in serviceable inventory is first studied. The serviceable inventory shortage case is discussed next. Both models are considered for the case of variable setup numbers of equal sized batches for production and remanufacturing processes. For these two models sufficient conditions for the optimal type of policy, referring to the parameters of the models, are proposed.     

Robust optimal dynamic production/pricing policies in a closed-loop system

Hybrid manufacturing/remanufacturing systems play a key role in implementing closed-loop production systems which have been considered due to increasingly environmental concerns and latent profit of used products. Manufacturing and remanufacturing rates, selling price of new products, and acquisition price of used products are the most critical variables to optimize in such hybrid systems. In this paper, we develop a dynamic production/pricing problem, in which decisions should be made in each period confronting with uncertain demand and return. The manufacturer is able to control the demand and return by adjusting selling price and acquisition price respectively, also she can stock inventories of used and new products to deal with uncertainties. Modeling a nominal profit maximization problem, we go through robust optimization approach to reformulate it for the uncertain case. Final robust optimization model is obtained as a quadratic programming model over discrete periods which can be solved by optimization packages of QP. A numerical example is defined and sensitivity analysis is performed on both basic parameters and parameters associated with uncertainty to create managerial views.     

Approximability of nonlinear affine control systems

This paper focuses on a strong approximability property for nonlinear affine control systems. We consider control processes governed by ordinary differential equations (ODEs) and study an initial system and the associated generalized system. Our theoretical approach makes it possible to prove a strong approximability result for the above dynamical systems. The latter can be effectively applied to some classes of variable structure and hybrid control systems. In particular, this paper deals with applications of the strong approximability property obtained to the conventional sliding mode processes and to hybrid control systems with autonomous location transitions. We also take into consideration some optimal control problems for the above class of hybrid systems.     

Production planning for hybrid remanufacturing and manufacturing system with component recovery

In this paper, we address component recovery under the condition of limited resources from the OEM's (Original Equipment Manufacturer's) standpoint. We develop a linear programming model for a hybrid remanufacturing and manufacturing system for production planning problems with deterministic returns. In this paper, a data set from an OEM that both remanufactures and manufactures the products is used to demonstrate the performance of the proposed model. Subsequently, an analysis of the impact of the remanufactured product’s price and the quantity of returns on revenue and total cost will be discussed. We have found that uncertain factors of manufacturing influence the profit and uncertain factors of remanufacturing influence the production planning, such as the rate of the yield on component remanufacturing and the quantity of returns.     

不确定环境下制造再制造供应链定价与协调问题研究

研究模糊不确定环境下制造/再制造供应链系统的定价与协调问题。通过考虑制造产品与再制造产品的差异性,利用模糊理论和博弈论理论等知识,在集中式和分散式决策方式下,分别给出了制造/再制造商和零售商关于制造产品和再制造产品的最优价格决策,以及分散决策方式下的系统协调策略,并且利用数值算例对所得结果进行了分析。     

Joint control of production,remanufacturing, and disposal activities in a hybrid manufacturing–remanufacturing system

To generate insights into how production of new items and remanufacturing and disposal of returned products can be effectively coordinated, we develop a model of a hybrid manufacturing–remanufacturing system. Formulating the model as a Markov decision process, we investigate the structure of the optimal policy that jointly controls production, remanufacturing, and disposal decisions. Considering the average profit maximization criterion, we show that the joint optimal policy can be characterized by three monotone switching curves. Moreover, we show that there exist serviceable (i.e., as-new) and remanufacturing (i.e., returned) inventory thresholds beyond which production cannot be optimal but disposal is always optimal. We also identify conditions under which idling and disposal actions are always optimal when the system is empty. Using numerical comparisons between models with and without remanufacturing and disposal options, we generate insights into the benefit of utilizing these options. To effectively coordinate production, remanufacturing, and disposal activities, we propose a simple, implementable, and yet effective heuristic policy. Our extensive numerical results suggest that the proposed heuristic can greatly help firms to effectively coordinate their production, remanufacturing, and disposal activities and thereby reduce their operational costs.     

Simultaneous optimization of capacity and planned lead time in a two-stage production system with different customer due dates

We consider a two-stage make-to-order manufacturing system with random demands, processing times, and distributed customer due dates. The work to each stage is released based on a planned lead time. A general approach to minimize total inventory holding and customer order tardiness cost is presented to find the optimal manufacturing capacities and planned lead times for each manufacturing stage. Expressions are derived for work-in process inventories, finished-goods-inventory and expected backorders under the assumption of a series of M/M/1 queuing systems and exponentially distributed customer required lead times. We prove that the distribution of customer required lead time has no influence on the optimal planned lead times whenever capacity is predefined but it influences the optimal capacity to invest into. For the simultaneous optimization of capacity and planned lead times we present a numerical study that shows that only marginal cost decreases can be gained by setting a planned lead time for the upstream stage and that a considerable cost penalty is incurred if capacity and planned lead time optimization are performed sequentially.     

再制造能力有限的多产品混合系统库存决策

为确定各产品的制造与再制造策略,对再制造能力有限的多产品混合系统进行研究.在系统中,对多种产品进行制造和再制造.每种产品在顾客使用后都会以恒定速率返回,但因再制造能力有限,有些产品无法用于再制造而被处置.每种产品需求恒定且由服务性产品来满足,服务性产品由制造品和再制造品组成,不允许缺货.在一次制造准备和至少一次再制造准备策略下构建了库存决策模型,利用拉格朗日乘数法和贪婪算法分别确定了各产品的再制造顺序和再制造比率.并当再制造比率一定时,给出了再制造准备次数为正整数时各产品制造与再制造策略的求解程序,得到了各产品制造和再制造批量、再制造准备次数等求解公式.最后,应用算例对模型及求解方法进行了验证.     

Competition for cores in remanufacturing

We study competition between an original equipment manufacturer (OEM) and an independently operating remanufacturer (IO). Different from the existing literature, the OEM and IO compete not only for selling their products but also for collecting returned products (cores) through their acquisition prices. We consider a two-period model with manufacturing by the OEM in the first period, and manufacturing as well as remanufacturing in the second period. We find the optimal policies for both players by establishing a Nash equilibrium in the second period, and then determine the optimal manufacturing decision for the OEM in the first period. This leads to a number of managerial insights. One interesting result is that the acquisition price of the OEM only depends on its own cost structure, and not on the acquisition price of the IO. Further insights are obtained from a numerical investigation. We find that when the cost benefits of remanufacturing diminishes and the IO has more chance to collect the available cores, the OEM manufactures less in the first period as the market in the second period gets larger to protect its market share. Finally, we consider the case where consumers have lower willingness to pay for the remanufactured products and find that in that case remanufacturing becomes less profitable overall.