Use of parallel synthesis to probe structure-activity relationships among 12-helical beta-peptides: evidence of a limit on antimicrobial activity

We report structure-activity trends among helix-forming beta-amino acid oligomers that are intended to mimic alpha-helical host-defense peptides. Parallel synthesis of two small, focused beta-peptide libraries allowed us to identify relatively short (11-residue) beta-peptides that display antimicrobial activity. These beta-peptides exhibit selectivity for bacteria relative to human red blood cells. A large hydrophobic helical surface is necessary for antimicrobial activity. Longer analogues (16 residues) of the most active library members were prepared and evaluated. Some of these longer beta-peptides showed very good antimicrobial activity, but none was more active than a previously reported beta-peptide [Porter, E. A.; Wang, X.; Lee, H.-S.; Weisblum, B.; Gellman, S. H. Nature 2000, 404, 565]. The extensive literature on alpha-helical host-defense peptides and related alpha-peptides indicates that such molecules are seldom active at concentrations below 1 microg/mL, and our results suggest that amphiphilic helical beta-peptides are subject to a comparable limit.     

Structure-activity studies of 14-helical antimicrobial beta-peptides: probing the relationship between conformational stability and antimicrobial potency

Antimicrobial alpha-helical alpha-peptides are part of the host-defense mechanism of multicellular organisms and could find therapeutic use against bacteria that are resistant to conventional antibiotics. Recent work from Hamuro et al. has shown that oligomers of beta-amino acids ("beta-peptides") that can adopt an amphiphilic helix defined by 14-membered ring hydrogen bonds ("14-helix") are active against Escherichia coli [Hamuro, Y.; Schneider, J. P.; DeGrado, W. F. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 12200-12201]. We have created two series of cationic 9- and 10-residue amphiphilic beta-peptides to probe the effect of 14-helix stability on antimicrobial and hemolytic activity. 14-Helix stability within these series is modulated by varying the proportions of rigid trans-2-aminocyclohexanecarboxylic acid (ACHC) residues and flexible acyclic residues. We have previously shown that a high proportion of ACHC residues in short beta-peptides encourages 14-helical structure in aqueous solution [Appella, D. H.; Barchi, J. J.; Durell, S. R.; Gellman, S. H. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 2309-2310]. Circular dichroism of the beta-peptides described here reveals a broad range of 14-helix population in aqueous buffer, but this variation in helical propensity does not lead to significant changes in antibiotic activity against a set of four bacteria. Several of the 9-mers display antibiotic activity comparable to that of a synthetic magainin derivative. Among these 9-mers, hemolytic activity increases slightly with increasing 14-helical propensity, but all of the 9-mers are less hemolytic than the magainin derivative. Previous studies with conventional peptides (alpha-amino acid residues) have provided conflicting evidence on the relationship between helical propensity and antimicrobial activity. This uncertainty has arisen because alpha-helix stability can be varied to only a limited extent among linear alpha-peptides without modifying parameters important for antimicrobial activity (e.g., net charge or hydrophobicity); a much greater range of helical stability is accessible with beta-peptides. For example, it is very rare for a linear alpha-peptide to display significant alpha-helix formation in aqueous solution and manifest antibacterial activity, while the linear beta-peptides described here range from fully unfolded to very highly folded in aqueous solution. This study shows that beta-peptides can be unique tools for analyzing relationships between conformational stability and biological activity.     

Unexpected relationships between structure and function in alpha,beta-peptides: antimicrobial foldamers with heterogeneous backbones

We describe our first effort to design antimicrobial alpha/beta-peptides based upon their helical folding behavior. alpha/beta-Peptide 3 (above), designed as a scrambled negative control, exhibited the most favorable activity profile, combining high antimicrobial activity with low hemolytic activity. This finding suggests that design principles focused primarily on structures that adopt globally amphiphilic structures may exclude productive possibilities from evaluation.     

Antifungal activity from 14-helical beta-peptides

We have discovered that short beta-peptides (9 or 10 residues) designed to adopt globally amphiphilic helical conformations display significant antifungal activity. The most promising beta-peptides cause little lysis of human red blood cells at concentrations that kill Candida albicans, a common human fungal pathogen. Since fungi are eukaryotes, discrimination between fungal and human cells is a significant finding. Our beta-peptides are active under assay conditions that mimic physiological ionic strength; in contrast, alpha-helix-forming host-defense alpha-peptides are inactive against C. albicans under these conditions.     

Mimicry of host-defense peptides by unnatural oligomers: antimicrobial beta-peptides

We have designed beta-amino acid oligomers that are helical, cationic, and amphiphilic with the intention of mimicking the biological activity of amphiphilic, cationic alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides found in nature (e.g., magainins). We have previously identified a 17-residue beta-peptide (called beta-17) with antibiotic activity similar to that of a magainin derivative against four bacterial species, including two clinical isolates that are resistant to common antibiotics. This beta-peptide displays very low hemolytic activity against human red blood cells, which indicates selectivity for bacterial cells over mammalian cells. Here we examine some of the factors important for activity in this class of beta-peptides. An amphiphilic helix is necessary, because a nonamphiphilic isomer proved to be inactive. The ratio of cationic to hydrophobic residues is also important. Active beta-peptides induce the leakage of beta-galactosidase from treated Bacillus subtilis cells, as do alpha-helical antibiotic peptides, and this similarity suggests that the beta-peptide mode of action involves disruption of microbial membranes. This class of beta-peptides is not degraded by proteases, which bodes well for biological applications.     

De novo design, synthesis, and characterization of antimicrobial beta-peptides

beta-Peptides are a class of polyamides that have been demonstrated to adopt a variety of helical conformations. Recently, a series of amphiphilic L(+2) helical beta-peptides were designed, which were intended to mimic the overall physicochemical properties of a class of membrane-active antimicrobial peptides, including magainin and cecropin. Although these peptides showed potent antimicrobial activity, they also showed significant activity against human erythrocytes. Operating under the assumption that their lack of specificity arose from excessive hydrophobicity, two additional beta-peptides H-(beta(3)-HAla-beta(3)-HLys-beta(3)-HVal)(n)-NH(2) (n = 4, 5) were designed and synthesized. Both have high antimicrobial activities, but very low hemolytic potencies. The peptides bind in an L(+2) conformation to phospholipid vesicles, inducing leakage of entrapped small molecules. The peptides have a low affinity for membranes consisting of neutral phosphatidylcholine lipids, but bind avidly to vesicles containing 10 mol % of acidic phosphatidylserine lipids. Differences in vesicle leakage kinetics for the two peptides suggest that chain length could affect their mechanisms of disrupting cell membranes. Thus, insights gained from the study of variants of natural alpha-peptides have provided a useful guide for the design of nonnatural antimicrobial beta-peptides.     

Environment-independent 14-helix formation in short beta-peptides: striking a balance between shape control and functional diversity

We report a significant and unanticipated advance in the study of beta-amino acid-based foldamers: a small proportion of highly preorganized residues can impart high stability to a specific helical secondary structure in water. Most of the residues in these beta-peptides (2 and 3) are intrinsically flexible. Flexible beta-amino acids can be readily and enantiospecifically prepared in functionally diverse forms, but preorganized residues with side chains are rare and challenging to synthesize. Our findings demonstrate that interspersing a few copies of an unfunctionalized but rigid residue among a larger number of flexible residues with diverse side chains is a viable strategy for creating beta-peptides that adopt the 14-helix conformation and therefore display side chains in a predictable spatial arrangement. These results are significant because they enhance the prospects of developing beta-peptides with useful activities.     

Mimicking helical antibacterial peptides with nonpeptidic folding oligomers

Unnatural oligomeric scaffolds designed to adopt defined secondary structures (e.g., helices), while retaining the chemical diversity of amino acid side chains, are of practical value to elaborate functional mimetics of bioactive alpha-polypeptides. Enantiopure N,N'-linked oligoureas as short as seven residues long have been previously shown to fold into a stable helical structure, stabilized by 12- and 14-membered H-bonded rings. We now report that eight-residue oligoureas designed to mimic globally amphiphilic alpha-helical host-defense peptides are effective against both gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria (including methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus [MRSA]) and exhibit selectivity for bacterial versus mammalian cells. Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy studies suggest enhanced helical propensity of oligoureas in the presence of phospholipid vesicles. The utility of this new class of nonpeptidic foldamers for biological applications is highlighted by high resistance to proteolytic degradation.     

Conformational ordering of apolar, chiral m-phenylene ethynylene oligomers

A series of m-phenylene ethynylene oligomers containing nonpolar, (S)-3,7-dimethyl-1-octanoxy side chains have been synthesized and studied. In apolar alkane solvents, oligomers of sufficient length (n > 10) were found to adopt a helical conformation with a large twist sense bias. In contrast, in chloroform the oligomers adopt a random coil conformation. Surprisingly, the strong twist sense bias was determined to be highly time dependent and is partially attributed to intermolecular aggregation.     

Beta-turn modified gramicidin S analogues containing arylated sugar amino acids display antimicrobial and hemolytic activity comparable to the natural product

This paper describes the design and synthesis of gramicidin S (GS) analogues 10a-c containing arylated sugar amino acids (SAAs) as a replacement of one of the two (D)Phe-Pro beta-turn regions. The cyclic, amphiphilic peptides adopt a beta-sheet conformation featuring an unusual reverse turn induced by the SAAs. The altered turn region induces a slight distortion of the antiparallel beta-sheet, as compared to GS; the overall geometry however closely resembles that of the nonarylated GS analogue 1. GS analogues 10a-c proved to be as active as the parent GS itself as antibacterial agents and are equally efficient in lysing red blood cells. These properties are in sharp contrast to the diminished biological activity displayed by 1. We conclude that the presence of aromaticity in the turn regions of GS derivatives is required for biological activity, whereas the native conformation of the beta-hairpin is not. Our findings may guide future research toward efficient and nonhemolytic GS analogues for combating bacterial infections.     

Lyotropic liquid crystals from designed helical beta-peptides

We demonstrate that 14-helical beta-peptides can self-assemble to form lyotropic liquid crystalline (LC) phases in water. beta-Peptides 1-4 were designed to form globally amphiphilic 14-helices of increasing length. Optical microscopy showed that several of these beta-peptides formed LC phases in aqueous solutions at concentrations as low as 2.5 wt % (15 mM). Liquid crystallinity appears to require the adoption of a globally amphiphilic conformation because a scrambled sequence, 5, does not display LC behavior. Thermal stability and reversibility of LC phase formation were assessed by variable temperature 2H NMR spectroscopy and optical microscopy. The LC phase formed by beta-peptide 3 at 10 wt % is disrupted above 40 degrees C in D2O and re-forms within minutes upon cooling. LC phase behavior for solutions of 3 is influenced by concentration and net charge. These studies demonstrate that highly folded 14-helical beta-peptides can produce LC phases at shorter lengths than do alpha-helical alpha-peptide mesogens and can provide a basis for tailoring properties of LC phases for future applications.     

Hydrazino peptides as foldamers: an extension of the beta-peptide concept.

Replacing the C(beta) atoms in the beta-amino acid constituents of beta-peptides by nitrogen atoms leads to hydrazino peptides. A systematic conformation analysis of blocked hydrazino peptide oligomers of the general type I at the HF/6-31G, MP2/6-31G, and DFT/B3LYP/6-31G levels of ab initio MO theory and on the basis of molecular mechanics reveals a wide variety of secondary structures, as for instance various helices and sheet- and turnlike conformers. Some of them are closely related to secondary structure types found in beta-peptides; others represent novel types. Thus, a very stable, novel helix with 14-membered hydrogen-bonded pseudocycles, which occupies a conformation space different from that of helices with 14-membered rings found among the most stable conformers in beta-peptides, is indicated. The most important secondary structure elements are characterized by interactions between peptidic NH and CO groups. The additional hydrazino N(alpha)H group takes part in special structuring effects but is of lesser importance for secondary structure formation. The influence of environmental effects on the existence and stability of the various structure types is discussed. Due to the wide variety of structural possibilities, hydrazino peptides might be a useful tool for peptide and protein design.     

Cyclic beta-tetra- and pentapeptides: synthesis through on-resin cyclization and conformational studies by X-ray, NMR and CD spectroscopy and theoretical calculations

The solution-phase synthesis of the simplest cyclic beta-tetrapeptide, cyclo(beta-Ala)4 (4), as well as the solid-phase syntheses through side chain anchoring and on-resin cyclization of the cyclic beta3-tetrapeptide cyclo(-beta3hPhe-beta3hLeu-beta3hLys-beta3hGln-) (14) and the first cyclic beta3-pentapeptide cyclo(-beta3hVal-beta3hPhe-beta3hLeu-beta3hLys-beta3hLys-) (19) are reported. Extensive computational as well as spectroscopic studies, including X-ray and NMR spectroscopy, were undertaken to determine the preferred conformations of these unnatural oligomers in solution and in the solid state. cyclo(beta-Ala)4 (4) with no chiral side chains is shown to exist as a mixture of rapidly interchanging conformers in solution, whereas inclusion of chiral side chains in the cyclo-beta3-tetrapeptide causes stabilization of one dominating conformer. The cyclic beta3-pentapeptide on the other hand shows larger conformational freedom. The X-ray structure of achiral cyclo(beta-Ala)4 (4) displays a Ci-symmetrical 16-membered ring with adjacent C=O and N-H atoms pointing pair wise up and down with respect to the ring plane. CD spectroscopic examinations of all cyclic beta-peptides were undertaken and revealed results valuable as starting point for further structural investigations of these entities.     

On the influence of charged side chains on the folding-unfolding equilibrium of beta-peptides: a molecular dynamics simulation study

The influence of charged side chains on the folding-unfolding equilibrium of beta-peptides was investigated by means of molecular dynamics simulations. Four different peptides containing only negatively charged side chains, positively charged side chains, both types of charged side chains (with the ability to form stabilizing salt bridges) or no charged side chains were studied under various conditions (different simulation temperatures, starting structures and solvent environment). The NMR solution structure in methanol of one of the peptides (A) has already been published; the synthesis and NMR analysis of another peptide (B) is described here. The other peptides (C and D) studied herein have hitherto not been synthesized. All four peptides A-D are expected to adopt a left-handed 3(14)-helix in solution as well as in the simulations. The resulting ensembles of structures were analyzed in terms of conformational space sampled by the peptides, folding behavior, structural properties such as hydrogen bonding, side chain-side chain and side chain-backbone interactions and in terms of the level of agreement with the NMR data available for two of the peptides. It was found that the presence of charged side chains significantly slows down the folding process in methanol solution due to the stabilization of intermediate conformers with side chain-backbone interactions. In water, where the solvent competes with the solute-solute polar interactions, the folding process to the 3(14)-helix is faster in the simulations.     

Crystallographic characterization of helical secondary structures in alpha/beta-peptides with 1:1 residue alternation

Oligomers that contain both alpha- and beta-amino acid residues in a 1:1 alternating pattern have recently been shown by several groups to adopt helical secondary structures in solution. The beta-residue substitution pattern has a profound effect on the type of helix formed and the stability of the helical conformation. On the basis of two-dimensional NMR data, we have previously proposed that beta-residues with a five-membered ring constraint promote two different types of alpha/beta-peptide helix. The "11-helix" contains i, i+3 CO...H-N hydrogen bonds between backbone amide groups; these hydrogen bonds occur in 11-atom rings. The alpha/beta-peptide "14/15-helix" contains i, i+4 CO...H-N hydrogen bonds, which occur in alternating 14- and 15-atom rings. Here we provide crystallographic data for 14 alpha/beta-peptides that form the 11-helix and/or the 14/15-helix. These results were obtained for a series of oligomers containing beta-residues derived from ( S,S)- trans-2-aminocyclopentanecarboxylic acid (ACPC) and alpha-residues derived from alpha-aminoisobutyric acid (Aib) or l-alanine (Ala). The crystallized alpha/beta-peptides range in length from 4 to 10 residues. Nine of the alpha/beta-peptides display the 11-helix in the solid state, three display the 14/15-helix, and two display conformations that contain both i, i+3 and i, i+4 CO...H-N hydrogen bonds, but not bifurcated hydrogen bonds. Only 3 of the 14 crystal structures presented here have been previously described. These results suggest that longer alpha/beta-peptides prefer the 14/15-helix over the 11-helix, a conclusion that is consistent with previously reported NMR data obtained in solution.     

(alpha/beta+alpha)-peptide antagonists of BH3 domain/Bcl-x(L) recognition: toward general strategies for foldamer-based inhibition of protein-protein interactions

The development of molecules that bind to specific protein surface sites and inhibit protein-protein interactions is a fundamental challenge in molecular recognition. New strategies for approaching this challenge could have important long-term ramifications in biology and medicine. We are exploring the concept that unnatural oligomers with well-defined conformations ("foldamers") can mimic protein secondary structural elements and thereby block specific protein-protein interactions. Here, we describe the identification and analysis of helical peptide-based foldamers that bind to a specific cleft on the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-xL by mimicking an alpha-helical BH3 domain. Initial studies, employing a fluorescence polarization (FP) competition assay, revealed that among several alpha/beta- and beta-peptide foldamer backbones only alpha/beta-peptides intended to adopt 14/15-helical secondary structure display significant binding to Bcl-xL. The most tightly binding Bcl-xL ligands are chimeric oligomers in which an N-terminal alpha/beta-peptide segment is fused to a C-terminal alpha-peptide segment ((alpha/beta + alpha)-peptides)). Sequence-affinity relationships were probed via standard and nonstandard techniques (alanine scanning and hydrophile scanning, respectively), and the results allowed us to construct a computational model of the ligand/Bcl-xL complex. Analytical ultracentrifugation with a high-affinity (alpha/beta + alpha)-peptide established 1:1 ligand:Bcl-xL stoichiometry under FP assay conditions. Binding selectivity studies with the most potent (alpha/beta + alpha)-peptide, conducted via surface plasmon resonance measurements, revealed that this ligand binds tightly to Bcl-w as well as to Bcl-xL, while binding to Bcl-2 is somewhat weaker. No binding could be detected with Mcl-1. We show that our most potent (alpha/beta + alpha)-peptide can induce cytochrome C release from mitochondria, an early step in apoptosis, in cell lysates, and that this activity is dependent upon inhibition of protein-protein interactions involving Bcl-xL.     

Single-molecule force spectroscopy of β-peptides that display well-defined three-dimensional chemical patterns

Oligomers of β-amino acids ("β-peptides") can be designed to fold into stable helices that display side chains with a diverse range of chemical functionality in precise arrangements. We sought to determine whether the predictable, three-dimensional side-chain patterns generated by β-peptides could be used in combination with single-molecule force spectroscopy to quantify how changes in nanometer-scale chemical patterns affect intermolecular interactions. To this end, we synthesized β-peptides that were designed to be either globally amphiphilic (GA), i.e., display a global segregation of side chains bearing hydrophobic and cationic functional groups, or non-globally amphiphilic (iso-GA), i.e., display a more uniform distribution of hydrophobic and cationic functional groups in three-dimensions. Single-molecule force measurements of β-peptide interactions with hydrophobic surfaces through aqueous solution (triethanolamine buffer, pH 7.2) reveal that the GA and iso-GA isomers give rise to qualitatively different adhesion force histograms. The data are consistent with the display of a substantial nonpolar domain by the GA oligomer, which leads to strong hydrophobic interactions, and the absence of a comparable domain on the iso-GA oligomer. This interpretation is supported by force measurements in the presence of methanol, which is known to disrupt hydrophobic interactions. Our ability to associate changes in measured forces with changes in three-dimensional chemical nanopatterns projected from conformationally stable β-peptide helices highlights a contrast between this system and conventional peptides (α-amino acid residues): conventional peptides are more conformationally flexible, which leads to uncertainty in the three-dimensional nanoscopic chemical patterns that underlie measured forces. Overall, we conclude that β-peptide oligomers provide a versatile platform for quantifying intermolecular interactions that arise from specific functional group nanopatterns.     

alpha and piDL helical states of alternating poly(gamma-benzyl D-L-glutamate) in solution.

As in solid state, strictly alternating poly(gamma-benzyl D-L-glutamate) in solution can adopt two different helical conformations. Besides the alpha helix, a second helical conformation is found at higher temperatures in dioxane and chloroform, the properties of which correspond to that of the piDL4 helix. As the molecules have a finite length a screw sense is favored for both helical forms thus giving rise to optical activity allowing the study of the transconformation by optical rotatory dispersion and circular dichroism besides infrared and dielectric measurements. Thus, as the temperature is raised the equilibria right-left handed alpha helices and alpha-piDL helical forms can be followed. The favored screw senses are determined by the number of interacting side chains for the alpha helix and by the number of hydrogen bonds which are formed in the piDL helical conformation. The side chain-side chain interactions in the alpha helix are experimentally shown to be attractive.     

Formation of Periodic γ‐Turns in α/β‐Hybrid Peptides: DFT and NMR Experimental Evidence

Hybrid peptidic oligomers comprising natural and unnatural amino acid residues that can exhibit biomolecular folding and hydrogen‐bonding mimicry have attracted considerable interest in recent years. While a variety of hybrid peptidic helices have been reported in the literature, other secondary structural patterns such as γ‐turns and ribbons have not been well explored so far. The present work reports the design of novel periodic γ‐turns in the oligomers of 1:1 natural‐α/unnatural trans‐β‐norborenene (TNAA) amino acid residues. Through DFT, NMR, and MD studies, it is convincingly shown that, in the mixed conformational pool, the heterogeneous backbone of the hybrid peptides preferentially adopt periodic 8‐membered (pseudo γ‐turn)/7‐membered (inverse γ‐turn) hydrogen bonds in both polar and non‐polar solvent media. It is observed that the stereochemistry and local conformational preference of the β‐amino acid building blocks have a profound influence on accessing the specific secondary fold. These findings may be of significant relevance for the development of molecular scaffolds that facilitate desired positioning of functional side‐chains.     

Synthesis of 3-aryl pyrrolidines: A highlights

Pyrrolidine derivatives are very important families of heterocyclic compounds that show diverse biological activity. The substitution pattern and functionalization on these derivatives show different biological activities. Different substituted pyrrolidines shown to have different antibacterial effects. They are also used as scaffolds in the synthesis of unnatural oligomers which have various biological applications in the field of antidiabetic, anticancer, antimalarial, antiviral, antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial activities . Numerous groups have synthesized substituted pyrrolidines and they constructed the pyrrolidine ring by the formation of various different bonds from acyclic precursors. Some of the groups have synthesized that derivatives only by reduction.