Minimax regret solution to multiobjective linear programming problems with interval objective functions coefficients

The current paper focuses on a multiobjective linear programming problem with interval objective functions coefficients. Taking into account the minimax regret criterion, an attempt is being made to propose a new solution i.e. minimax regret solution. With respect to its properties, a minimax regret solution is necessarily ideal when a necessarily ideal solution exists; otherwise it is still considered a possibly weak efficient solution. In order to obtain a minimax regret solution, an algorithm based on a relaxation procedure is suggested. A numerical example demonstrates the validity and strengths of the proposed algorithm. Finally, two special cases are investigated: the minimax regret solution for fixed objective functions coefficients as well as the minimax regret solution with a reference point. Some of the characteristic features of both cases are highlighted thereafter.     

Robust placement of sensors in dynamic water distribution systems

Designing a robust sensor network to detect accidental contaminants in water distribution systems is a challenge given the uncertain nature of the contamination events (what, how much, when, where and for how long) and the dynamic nature of water distribution systems (driven by the random consumption of consumers). We formulate a set of scenario-based minimax and minimax regret models in order to provide robust sensor-placement schemes that perform well under all realizable contamination scenarios, and thus protect water consumers. Single-and multi-objective versions of these models are then applied to a real water distribution system. A heuristic solution method is applied to solve the robust models. The concept of “sensitivity region” is used to visualize trade-offs between multiple objectives.     

Robust multi-market newsvendor models with interval demand data

We present a robust model for determining the optimal order quantity and market selection for short-life-cycle products in a single period, newsvendor setting. Due to limited information about demand distribution in particular for short-life-cycle products, stochastic modeling approaches may not be suitable. We propose the minimax regret multi-market newsvendor model, where the demands are only known to be bounded within some given interval. In the basic version of the problem, a linear time solution method is developed. For the capacitated case, we establish some structural results to reduce the problem size, and then propose an approximation solution algorithm based on integer programming. Finally, we compare the performance of the proposed minimax regret model against the typical average-case and worst-case models. Our test results demonstrate that the proposed minimax regret model outperformed the average-case and worst-case models in terms of risk-related criteria and mean profit, respectively.     

Existence and stability of minimax regret equilibria

In this paper, we study minimax regret equilibria. First, existence theorem of minimax regret equilibria is proved. Further, the generic stability of minimax regret equilibria is studied. We show that the set of minimax regret equilibria for most of problems (in sense of Baire category) is a singleton set.     

A multi-objective integrated facility location-hardening model: Analyzing the pre- and post-disruption tradeoff

Two methods of reducing the risk of disruptions to distribution systems are (1) strategically locating facilities to mitigate against disruptions and (2) hardening facilities. These two activities have been treated separately in most of the academic literature. This article integrates facility location and facility hardening decisions by studying the minimax facility location and hardening problem (MFLHP), which seeks to minimize the maximum distance from a demand point to its closest located facility after facility disruptions. The formulation assumes that the decision maker is risk averse and thus interested in mitigating against the facility disruption scenario with the largest consequence, an objective that is appropriate for modeling facility interdiction. By taking advantage of the MFLHP’s structure, a natural three-stage formulation is reformulated as a single-stage mixed-integer program (MIP). Rather than solving the MIP directly, the MFLHP can be decomposed into sub-problems and solved using a binary search algorithm. This binary search algorithm is the basis for a multi-objective algorithm, which computes the Pareto-efficient set for the pre- and post-disruption maximum distance. The multi-objective algorithm is illustrated in a numerical example, and experimental results are presented that analyze the tradeoff between objectives.     

Minimising the maximum relative regret for linear programmes with interval objective function coefficients

The minimax relative regret solution to a linear programme with interval objective function coefficients can be found using an algorithm that, at each iteration, solves a linear programme to generate a candidate solution and a mixed integer programme (MIP) to find the corresponding maximum regret. This paper first shows that there exists a regret-maximising solution in which all uncertain costs are at a bound, and then uses this to derive a MIP formulation that maximises the regret of a candidate solution. Computational experiments demonstrate that this approach is effective for problems with up to 50 uncertain objective function coefficients, significantly improving upon the existing enumerative method.     

A multi-objective approach to simultaneous determination of spare part numbers and preventive replacement times

Different models have been proposed in the field of preventive maintenance planning for finding optimal age replacement policies. While previous studies have focused mainly on classical cost objectives, this paper presents a novel multi-objective model for preventive replacement of a part over a planning horizon. The proposed model considers different objectives and practical issues, such as corrective replacement and its consequences, residual lifetime objective, and kind of productivity index. Also, the model determines number of spare parts, required for replacement with the defected part, to be provided at the beginning of the planning horizon. The multi-objective model is applicable for machines or equipments which are repaired through replacing their defected part with new spare part.For solving the multi-objective model, regarding to ability of ε-constraint method to generate different pareto-optimal solutions, a procedure is developed based on this method. The procedure shows how the ε-constraint method can be used for finding preferred solution in situations where there is no access to decision maker. The model and solution procedure are illustrated by a numerical example.     

证券投资组合一种多目标优化模型及其算法

针对Young(1998)提出的证券投资组合极小极大(Minimax)模型,给出了一种有效算法;并在此基础上建立了一个多目标优化模型以及求解该问题的一个中心算法.最后通过算例分析,对两种模型及其算法进行了比较.     

Superiority–inferiority modeling coupled minimax-regret analysis for energy management systems

In this study, a superiority–inferiority-based minimax-regret analysis (SI-MRA) model is developed for supporting the energy management systems (EMS) planning under uncertainty. In SI-MRA model, techniques of fuzzy mathematical programming (FMP) with the superiority and inferiority measures and minimax regret analysis (MMR) are incorporated within a general framework. The SI-MRA improves upon conventional FMP methods by directly reflecting the relationships among fuzzy coefficients in both the objective function and constraints with a high computational efficiency. It can not only address uncertainties expressed as fuzzy sets in both of the objective function and system constraints but also can adopt a list of scenarios to reflect the uncertainties of random variables without making assumptions on their possibilistic distributions. The developed SI-MRA model is applied to a case study of long-term EMS planning, where fuzziness and randomness exist in the costs for electricity generation and demand. A number of scenarios associated with various alternatives and outcomes under different electricity demand levels are examined. The results can help decision makers identify an optimal strategy of planning electricity generation and capacity expansion based on a minimax regret level under uncertainty.     

A fuzzy multidimensional multiple-choice knapsack model for project portfolio selection using an evolutionary algorithm

Project portfolio selection problems are inherently complex problems with multiple and often conflicting objectives. Numerous analytical techniques ranging from simple weighted scoring to complex mathematical programming approaches have been proposed to solve these problems with precise data. However, the project data in real-world problems are often imprecise or ambiguous. We propose a fuzzy Multidimensional Multiple-choice Knapsack Problem (MMKP) formulation for project portfolio selection. The proposed model is composed of an Efficient Epsilon-Constraint (EEC) method and a customized multi-objective evolutionary algorithm. A Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model is used to prune the generated solutions into a limited and manageable set of implementable alternatives. Statistical analysis is performed to investigate the effectiveness of the proposed approach in comparison with the competing methods in the literature. A case study is presented to demonstrate the applicability of the proposed model and exhibit the efficacy of the procedures and algorithms.     

Multi-objective and prioritized berth allocation in container ports

This paper considers a berth allocation problem (BAP) which requires the determination of exact berthing times and positions of incoming ships in a container port. The problem is solved by optimizing the berth schedule so as to minimize concurrently the three objectives of makespan, waiting time, and degree of deviation from a predetermined priority schedule. These objectives represent the interests of both port and ship operators. Unlike most existing approaches in the literature which are single-objective-based, a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm (MOEA) that incorporates the concept of Pareto optimality is proposed for solving the multi-objective BAP. The MOEA is equipped with three primary features which are specifically designed to target the optimization of the three objectives. The features include a local search heuristic, a hybrid solution decoding scheme, and an optimal berth insertion procedure. The effects that each of these features has on the quality of berth schedules are studied.     

A maximum entropy approach to the newsvendor problem with partial information

In this paper, we consider the newsvendor model under partial information, i.e., where the demand distribution D is partly unknown. We focus on the classical case where the retailer only knows the expectation and variance of D. The standard approach is then to determine the order quantity using conservative rules such as minimax regret or Scarf’s rule. We compute instead the most likely demand distribution in the sense of maximum entropy. We then compare the performance of the maximum entropy approach with minimax regret and Scarf’s rule on large samples of randomly drawn demand distributions. We show that the average performance of the maximum entropy approach is considerably better than either alternative, and more surprisingly, that it is in most cases a better hedge against bad results.     

Using modified maximum regret for finding a necessarily efficient solution in an interval MOLP problem

The current research concerns multiobjective linear programming problems with interval objective functions coefficients. It is known that the most credible solutions to these problems are necessarily efficient ones. To solve the problems, this paper attempts to propose a new model with interesting properties by considering the minimax regret criterion. The most important property of the new model is attaining a necessarily efficient solution as an optimal one whenever the set of necessarily efficient solutions is nonempty. In order to obtain an optimal solution of the new model, an algorithm is suggested. To show the performance of the proposed algorithm, numerical examples are given. Finally, some special cases are considered and their characteristic features are highlighted.     

An interactive evolutionary multi-objective optimization algorithm with a limited number of decision maker calls

This paper presents a preference-based method to handle optimization problems with multiple objectives. With an increase in the number of objectives the computational cost in solving a multi-objective optimization problem rises exponentially, and it becomes increasingly difficult for evolutionary multi-objective techniques to produce the entire Pareto-optimal front. In this paper, an evolutionary multi-objective procedure is combined with preference information from the decision maker during the intermediate stages of the algorithm leading to the most preferred point. The proposed approach is different from the existing approaches, as it tries to find the most preferred point with a limited budget of decision maker calls. In this paper, we incorporate the idea into a progressively interactive technique based on polyhedral cones. The idea is also tested on another progressively interactive approach based on value functions. Results are provided on two to five-objective unconstrained as well as constrained test problems.     

A multi-item mixture inventory model involving random lead time and demand with budget constraint and surprise function

This study deals with a multi-item mixture inventory model in which both demand and lead time are random. A budget constraint is also added to this model. The optimization problem with budget constraint is then transformed into a multi-objective optimization problem with the help of fuzzy chance-constrained programming technique and surprise function. In our studies, we relax the assumption about the demand, lead time and demand during lead time that follows a known distribution and then apply the minimax distribution free procedure to solve the problem. We develop an algorithm procedure to find the optimal order quantity and optimal value of the safety factor. Finally, the model is illustrated by a numerical example.     

Efficient Location for a Semi-Obnoxious Facility

This paper deals with a location model for the placement of a semi-obnoxious facility in a continuous plane with the twin objectives of maximizing the distance to the nearest inhabitant and minimizing the sum of distances to all the users (or the distance to the farthest user) in a unified manner. For special cases, this formulation includes (1) elliptic maximin and rectangular minisum criteria problem, and (2) rectangular maximin and minimax criteria problem. Polynomial-time algorithms for finding the efficient set and the tradeoff curve are presented.     

基于弹性区带架构的多目标设施布局问题研究

为解决设施面积不等的连续型设施布局问题,建立了基于弹性区带架构布置形式,以物料搬运成本最小、邻近关系最大、距离要求满足度最大的多目标设施布局模型。模型中考虑了区域内的横向、纵向过道,对设施的长宽比进行了限制,使得结果更符合实际情况。为克服传统多目标单一化方法需要人为设置子目标函数权重、主观性过强的缺陷,采用基于带有精英保留策略的非支配排序遗传算法(NSGA Ⅱ)的多目标优化算法求解模型,设计了相应的编码方式、交叉算子、变异算子、罚函数。最后通过某物流园区的实例分析证明了模型与方法的有效性。     

考虑协同效应的突发事件救援人员分组方法

针对突发事件的应急救援人员分组问题,提出了一种考虑人员间协同效应的应急救援人员分组方法。首先,对突发事件应急救援人员分组问题进行了描述。然后,基于系统协同理论的思想,提出了救援小组的协同度模型,定量化的度量救援人员间的协同效应。进一步地,综合考虑救援人员的基础效能与协同效应,基于协同度模型给出了救援人员完成不同任务的实际效能的表达式。在此基础上,以最大化各救援小组的实际效能为目标,构建了突发事件应急救援人员分组的优化模型,并给出了将这一多目标0-1二次规划模型转换为单目标0-1线性规划模型的方法,进而可求解并确定救援人员的最优分组方案。最后,通过一个实例分析说明了本文所提出方法的可行性和有效性。     

A Branch and Bound algorithm for the minimax regret spanning arborescence

The paper considers the problem of finding a spanning arborescence on a directed network whose arc costs are partially known. It is assumed that each arc cost can take on values from a known interval defining a possible economic scenario. In this context, the problem of finding the spanning arborescence which better approaches to that of minimum overall cost under each possible scenario is studied. The minimax regret criterion is proposed in order to obtain such a robust solution of the problem. As it is shown, the bounds on the optimal value of the minimax regret optimization problem obtained in a previous paper, can be used here in a Branch and Bound algorithm in order to give an optimal solution. The computational behavior of the algorithm is tested through numerical experiments. This research has been supported by the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science and FEDER Grant No. MTM2006-04393 and by the European Alfa Project, “Engineering System for Preparing and Making Decisions Under Multiple Criteria”, II-0321-FA.