High affinity, paralog-specific recognition of the Mena EVH1 domain by a miniature protein

Many protein domains involved in cell signaling contain or interact with proline-rich sequences, and the design of molecules that perturb signaling pathways represents a foremost goal of chemical biology. Previously we described a protein design strategy in which the well-folded alpha-helix in avian pancreatic polypeptide (aPP) presents short alpha-helical recognition epitopes. The miniature proteins designed in this way recognize even shallow protein clefts with high affinity and specificity. Here we show that the well-folded type-II polyproline helix in aPP can present the short PPII-helical recognition epitope within the ActA protein of Listeria monocytogenes. Like miniature proteins that use an alpha-helix for protein recognition, the miniature protein designed in this way displays high affinity for a natural ActA target, the EVH1 domain Mena1-112, and achieves the elusive goal of paralog specificity, discriminating well between EVH1 domains Mena1-112, VASP1-115, and Evl1-112. Most importantly, the miniature protein competed with ActA in Xenopus laevis egg cytoplasmic extracts, decreasing actin-dependent motility of L. monocytogenes and causing extreme speed variations and discontinuous tail formation. Our results suggest that miniature proteins based on aPP may represent an excellent framework for the design of ligands that differentiate the roles of EVH1 domains in vitro and in vivo.     

Paralog-selective ligands for bcl-2 proteins

There is considerable current interest in molecules that bind intra- or extracellular protein surfaces and inhibit protein-protein interactions. Previously we have reported that miniature proteins based on pancreatic-fold polypeptides can recognize even shallow alpha-helix binding clefts with high affinity and selectivity against unrelated proteins. One such miniature protein, PPBH3-1, binds the anti-apoptotic protein paralogs Bcl-2 and Bcl-XL with nanomolar affinity and a DeltaDeltaG = 1.2 kcal.mol-1 preference for Bcl-XL. Here we describe the directed evolution of PPBH3-1 into two new miniature proteins, PPBH3-5 and PPBH3-6, whose paralog specificity is reversed relative to PPBH3-1. PPBH3-5 and PPBH3-6 bind Bcl-2 with nanomolar affinity and a DeltaDeltaG = 0.9-1.3 kcal.mol-1 preference for Bcl-2 over Bcl-XL. Experiments with Bcl-XL variants suggest that PPBH3-5 and PPBH3-6 achieve high paralog specificity by exploiting subtle structural or electrostatic differences in the Bcl-2 and Bcl-XL molecular landscapes. PPBH3-5 and PPBH3-6 may have unique applications as early examples of nonnatural ligands that interact selectively with Bcl-2 proteins.     

Optimization of functionalized polymer layers for specific targeting of mobile receptors on cell surfaces

The reversible binding between a planar polymer layer functionalized by ligands and a planar cell surface containing different densities of mobile receptors has been studied by Monte Carlo simulations. Using the acceptance-ratio method, the distance-dependent profiles for the average number of ligands bound to receptors, the total free energy for the polymer layer-cell surface interaction and the interaction force were obtained. Four main design parameters for the polymer layer were considered: the degree of functionalization, chain degree of polymerization, polymer grafting density and the binding energy for the ligand-receptor interaction. We found that an increase in the degree of functionalization or in the absolute energy of ligand-receptor binding results in a larger number of ligands bound to the receptors, lower free energy, and stronger attractive force. Polymer layers composed of shorter chains were found to exhibit a deeper and narrower free energy profile and a larger attractive force, while longer tethers can interact with the cell surface at a larger and broader range of separation distances, in agreement with experimental observations. Our simulation results show that the increase in polymer grafting density from the mushroom to brush regime enhances the ligand availability and results in a stronger attractive force, increases the maximum binding distance, but exhibits a shallower free energy minimum due to the smaller tolerance to compression for polymer layers with high grafting density. We used two measures of the polymer layer binding affinity to the cell surface: the free energy minimum, related to the equilibrium binding constant and the fraction of bound ligands. We found that the polymer layers with a smaller chain length and grafting density, larger degree of functionalization, and larger absolute binding energy exhibit both a larger equilibrium binding constant to the cell surface and a larger average number of bound ligands, except for high binding energies when the maximum level of binding is reached independently of polymer length and grafting density. We showed that high binding specificity can be achieved by the polymer layers with intermediate ligand-receptor binding energies or an intermediate number of ligands, as a larger binding energy or number of ligands ensures a high binding affinity but lacks specificity while a smaller binding energy or number of ligands provides inadequate affinity. We found that the results for polymer layers with different properties follow a similar pattern when both high binding affinity to cells with high receptor density and high binding specificity are considered. As a result, the optimal design of the polymer layers can be achieved by using several different strategies, which are discussed.     

Nonionic side chains modulate the affinity and specificity of binding between functionalized polyamines and structured RNA

This Communication introduces side-chain-bearing polyamines as molecules for selective recognition of folded RNA structures. The complex folded structures associated with RNA create binding pockets for proteins, and also binding sites for small molecules. Developing organic molecules that can bind RNA with high affinity and specificity is a challenge that must be overcome for RNA to be considered a viable drug target. In this work, six polyamines with different side chains were synthesized to test for effects on binding affinity and specificity to TAR RNA and RRE RNA of HIV. Binding interactions between polyamines and RNAs were examined using two footprinting assays, based on terbium-induced cleavage and magnesium-catalyzed cleavage at higher pH. The binding constants and the binding specificity were highly dependent on the side chains of the polyamines, demonstrating that this class of molecules is a very promising starting point for development of highly selective RNA-binding ligands.     

Immobilized peptides as high-affinity capture agents for self-associating proteins

There is currently great interest in the fabrication of protein-detecting arrays comprised of large numbers of immobilized protein capture agents. While most efforts in this arena have focused on the use of biomolecules such as antibodies and nucleic acid aptamers as capture agents, synthetic species have many potential advantages. However, synthetic molecules isolated from combinatorial libraries generally do not bind target proteins with the high affinity necessary for array applications. Here, we demonstrate that simple linear peptides bind dimeric proteins tenaciously when immobilized, although they exhibit only modest affinity in solution. These data show that high-affinity bidentate capture agents for dimeric proteins can be created by simply immobilizing modest-affinity ligands on a surface at high density, bypassing the requirement for careful optimization of linker length and geometry that is normally required to create a high-affinity solution bidentate ligand.     

Chimeric (alpha/beta + alpha)-peptide ligands for the BH3-recognition cleft of Bcl-XL: critical role of the molecular scaffold in protein surface recognition

Molecules that bind to specific surface sites on proteins are of great interest from both fundamental and practical perspectives. We are exploring a ligand development strategy that is based on oligomers with discrete folding propensities ("foldamers"); we target a specific cleft on the cancer-associated protein Bcl-xL because this system is well characterized structurally. In vivo, this cleft binds to alpha-helical segments (BH3 domains) of other proteins. We evaluated several types of helical foldamer, built entirely from beta-amino acid residues or from mixtures of alpha- and beta-amino acid residues, and ultimately identified foldamers in the latter class that bind very tightly to Bcl-xL. Our results suggest that combining different types of foldamer backbones will be an effective and general strategy for creating high-affinity and specific ligands for protein surface sites.     

DNA and RNA aptamers: from tools for basic research towards therapeutic applications

The systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) is a combinatorial oligonucleotide library-based in vitro selection approach in which DNA or RNA molecules are selected by their ability to bind their targets with high affinity and specificity, comparable to those of antibodies. Nucleic acids with high affinity for their targets have been selected against a wide variety of compounds, from small molecules, such as ATP, to membrane proteins and even whole organisms. Recently, the use of the SELEX technique was extended to isolate oligonucleotide ligands, also known as aptamers, for a wide range of proteins of importance for therapy and diagnostics, such as growth factors and cell surface antigens. The number of aptamers generated as inhibitors of various target proteins has increased following automatization of the SELEX process. Their diagnostic and therapeutic efficacy can be enhanced by introducing chemical modifications into the oligonucleotides to provide resistance against enzymatic degradation in body fluids. Several aptamers are currently being tested in preclinical and clinical trials, and aptamers are in the process of becoming a new class of therapeutic agents. Recently, the anti-VEGF aptamer pegaptanib received FDA approval for treatment of human ocular vascular disease.     

Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry as a tool for determination of drug binding sites to human serum albumin by noncovalent interaction

Most proteins in blood plasma bind ligands. Human serum albumin (HSA) is the main transport protein with a very high capacity for binding of endogenous and exogenous compounds in plasma. Many pharmacokinetic properties of a drug depend on the level of binding to plasma proteins. This work reports studies of noncovalent interactions by means of nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry (nanoESI-MS) for determination of the specific binding of selected drug candidates to HSA. Warfarin, iopanoic acid and digitoxin were chosen as site-specific probes that bind to the main sites of HSA. Two drug candidates and two known binders to HSA were analyzed using a competitive approach. The drugs were incubated with the target protein followed by addition of site-specific probes, one at a time. The drug candidates showed predominant affinity to site I (warfarin site). Naproxen and glyburide showed affinity to both sites I and II. The advantages of nanoESI-MS for these studies are the sensitivity, the absence of labeled molecules and the short method development time.     

In vitro evolution of ligands to the membrane protein caveolin

Membrane proteins comprise a third of the human genome, yet present challenging targets for reverse chemical genetics. For example, although implicated in numerous diseases including multiple myeloma, the membrane protein caveolin-1 appears to offer a poor target for the discovery of synthetic ligands due to its largely unknown structure and insolubility. To break this impasse and identify new classes of caveolae controlling lead compounds, we applied phage-based, reverse chemical genetics for the discovery of caveolin-1 ligands derived from the anti-HIV therapeutic T20. Substitution of homologous residues into the T20 sequence used a process analogous to medicinal chemistry for the affinity maturation to bind caveolin. The resultant caveolin-1 ligands bound with >1000-fold higher affinity than wild-type T20. Two types of ELISAs and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) measurements demonstrated high affinity binding to caveolin by the T20 variants with K(d) values in the 150 nM range. Microscopy experiments with the highest affinity caveolin ligands confirmed colocalization of the ligands with endogenous caveolin in NIH 3T3 cells. The results establish the foundation for targeting caveolin and caveolae formation in living cells.     

全细胞的核酸适配体筛选的研究进展

核酸适配体(aptamer)是从人工合成的随机单链DNA(ssDNA)或RNA文库中筛选得到的,能够高亲和力、高特异性地与靶标结合的ssDNA或RNA。核酸适配体的靶标范围广,可包括小分子、蛋白质、细胞、微生物等多种靶标。其中以细胞为靶标的适配体在生物感应、分子成像、医学诊断、药物传输和疾病治疗等领域有很大的应用潜能。但全细胞的核酸适配体筛选过程复杂,筛选难度大,筛选的适配体性能不佳是导致目前可用的适配体非常有限的主要原因。由于细胞表面蛋白质在提取纯化过程中分子结构和形态会发生改变,故以膜表面蛋白质为靶标筛选的适配体很难应用于识别整体细胞。以全细胞为靶标的核酸适配体筛选则不需要准确了解细胞表面的分子结构,筛选过程中可保持细胞的天然状态,以全细胞为靶标筛选出的核酸适配体有望直接用于全细胞识别。本文总结了2008~2015年全细胞的核酸适配体筛选的研究进展,介绍了靶细胞的分类、核酸库的设计、筛选条件和方法以及核酸适配体的亲和力表征方法等。并列出全细胞靶标的核酸适配体序列。     

Application of affinity selection-mass spectrometry assays to purification and affinity-based screening of the chemokine receptor CXCR4

Affinity selection-mass spectrometry (AS-MS) is a sensitive technology for identifying small molecules that bind to target proteins, and assays enabled by AS-MS can be used to delineate relative binding affinities of ligands for proteins. 'Indirect' AS-MS assays employ size-exclusion techniques to separate target-ligand complexes from unbound ligands, and target-associated ligands are then specifically detected by liquid chromatography mass spectrometry. We report how indirect AS-MS binding assays with known reference control compounds were used as guideposts for development of an optimized purification method for CXCR4, a G-protein coupled chemokine receptor, for which we sought novel antagonists. The CXCR4 purification method that was developed was amenable to scale-up and enabled the screening of purified recombinant human CXCR4 against a large combinatorial library of small molecules by high throughput indirect AS-MS. The screen resulted in the discovery of new ligands that competed off binding of reference compounds to CXCR4 in AS-MS binding assays and that antagonized SDF1α-triggered responses and CXCR4-mediated HIV1 viral uptake in cell-based assays. This report provides a methodological paradigm whereby indirect AS-MS-based ligand binding assays may be used to guide optimal integral membrane protein purification methods that enable downstream affinity selection-based applications such as high throughput AS-MS screens.     

Comparison of facially amphiphilic biaryl dendrimers with classical amphiphilic ones using protein surface recognition as the tool

Facially amphiphilic biaryl dendrimers are compared with the more classical benzyl ether amphiphilic dendrimers for molecular recognition, using protein binding as the probe. The protein used for the proposed study is chymotrypsin (ChT). A generation-dependent binding affinity was observed with the benzyl ether dendrimers, while the affinities were independent of generation in the case of the biaryl dendrimers. Similarly, although the ligands incorporated in both dendrons are the same, the biaryl dendrimers are able to bind more proteins compared to the benzyl ether dendrimers. For example, G3-dendron of biaryl dendrimer can bind six molecules of chymotrypsin, whereas G3-analogue of benzyl ether dendrimers can bind only three molecules of chymotrypsin. This result is consistent with our hypothesis that the internal layers of the facially amphiphilic biaryl dendrons are solvent-exposed and accessible for recognition. In addition, the systematic size differences in dendrons were also used to gain insights into the substrate selectivity that the enzyme gains upon binding to a ligand scaffold.     

蛋白质的核酸适配体筛选的研究进展

核酸适配体是通过指数富集系统配体进化(SELEX)筛选获得的,与靶标具有高亲和力和特异性结合的单链DNA或RNA。蛋白质是生命进程中的关键功能分子。近年来,以蛋白质为靶标的适配体筛选在蛋白质相关的基础及应用研究领域受到广泛关注。核酸适配体应用性能的优劣取决于其亲和力、特异性与稳定性。目前,适配体筛选方法的优化主要是提高筛选效率、提升适配体性能及降低筛选成本。适配体主要筛选步骤包括复合物分离、核酸库优化、次级库的富集、适配体序列分析以及亲和力表征等。迄今为止,以蛋白质-核酸复合物的分离为核心步骤的适配体筛选方法有20余种。本文归纳总结了2005年以来以蛋白质为靶标的适配体筛选技术,讨论了各方法的缺陷与局限。介绍了核酸库的设计优化方法、适配体的序列特征,以及常用的亲和力表征方法。     

Peptide‐Guided Assembly of Repeat Protein Fragments

Herein, we present the peptide‐guided assembly of complementary fragments of designed armadillo repeat proteins (dArmRPs) to create proteins that bind peptides not only with high affinity but also with good selectivity. We recently demonstrated that complementary N‐ and C‐terminal fragments of dArmRPs form high‐affinity complexes that resemble the structure of the full‐length protein, and that these complexes bind their target peptides. We now demonstrate that dArmRPs can be split such that the fragments assemble only in the presence of a templating peptide, and that fragment mixtures enrich the combination with the highest affinity for this peptide. The enriched fragment combination discriminates single amino acid variations in the target peptide with high specificity. Our results suggest novel opportunities for the generation of new peptide binders by selection from dArmRP fragment mixtures.     

High-affinity small molecule inhibitors of T cell costimulation: compounds for immunotherapy

Costimulatory molecules are important regulators of T cell activation and thus favored targets for therapeutic manipulation of immune responses. One of the key costimulatory receptors is CD80, which binds the T cell ligands, CD28, and CTLA-4. We describe a set of small compounds that bind with high specificity and low nanomolar affinity to CD80. The compounds have relatively slow off-rates and block both CD28 and CTLA-4 binding, implying that they occlude the shared ligand binding site. The compounds inhibit proinflammatory cytokine release in T cell assays with submicromolar potency, and as such, they represent promising leads for the development of novel therapeutics for immune-mediated inflammatory disease. Our results also suggest that other predominantly beta proteins, such as those that dominate the cell surface, may also be accessible as potentially therapeutic targets.     

Grafting miniature DNA binding proteins

Miniature proteins serve as leads for biological and medicinal applications by positioning all amino acids necessary for biomolecular recognition on a compact protein structure. Protein grafting was recently used to create miniature helical proteins with high DNA binding affinity and specificity.