The history of cold hardiness research in terrestrial arthropods

R.A.F. Reaumur in 1736 was the first entomologist to observe that some insects can tolerate freezing, while others cannot. The first reviews on insect cold hardiness were published by P. Bachmetjew who also discovered supercooling in insects. Authors like W. Robinson realised that piercing the cuticle changed the supercooling capacity and N.M. Payne pointed out that there are great seasonal variations in insect cold hardiness. In the early literature, references were frequently made to plant cold hardiness, in which theories on tolerance to freezing were more elaborated. A modern approach to the studies of insect cold hardiness was initiated by R.W. Salt. The number of reports increased enormously in the 1960's and 1970's. During the last 20 to 30 years new insight has appeared from studies on ice nucleators, antifreeze proteins, ice-nucleating bacteria, desiccation and biochemistry of cryoprotectants.     

Chill tolerance in the tropical beetle Stenotarsus rotundus

The tropical beetle Stenotarsus rotundus (Endomychidae) survived chilling at mildly low temperatures (above +5 degree C). With upper limit of cold injury zone (ULCIZ, the highest temperature that causes cold injury) well above freezing point, the supercooling ability (mean supercooling point - SCP; -11 degree C) has no cryoprotective importance. Mortality increases rapidly between -9 and +5 degree C, dependent on accumulated dose of chilling (sum of injurious temperatures - SIT; 2 degree-days below ULCIZ). The cold hardiness traits found in this species are by-products of deep diapause, and may serve as pre-adaptation for expansion into cooler regions.     

Insect cold hardiness: a Canadian perspective

The cold climates and diverse environments of Canada have allowed key studies of insect cold hardiness that developed and widened the understanding of this subject. For example, freezing tolerance, chilling tolerance, freezing resistance, supercooling, cryoprotectants and other features can be combined in many different ways, reflecting a wide range of adaptations. Many other factors interact with and influence cold hardiness, such as habitats and their selection, and water and energy balances. These findings suggest several topics that would be especially fruitful for further study in northern Canada.     

The tolerance of the field slug Deroceras reticulatum to freezing temperatures

Cold hardiness of ectotherms has been widely studied in arthropods, but there is a more limited literature on the survival of molluscs at low temperatures. A number of intertidal species have been examined in detail, but terrestrial molluscs have largely been overlooked until recently. This paper reports results of laboratory experiments to evaluate the cold hardiness of the terrestrial slug, Deroceras reticulatum. The mean supercooling point (SCP) rose from -4.2 degree C in summer to -3.6 degree C in winter. The SCP that caused 50 percent mortality (LSCP50) remained constant at -4.7 to -4.8 degree C in both seasons, but slugs were able to survive the frozen state for longer in winter (LD50 of 31.8 minutes compared with 17.0 minutes in summer). Slug survival at freezing temperatures was prolonged to at least five hours when placed on a moist, absorbent substrate. D. reticulatum exhibits partial freeze tolerance, with an increased survival in winter. The results are discussed in relation to the natural environment of slugs.     

Cold resistance in the lesser mealworm Alphitobius diaperinus (Panzer) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae)

We have investigated cold resistance, measured by the supercooling point (SCP) temperature, in life stages of the lesser mealworm, Alphitobius diaperinus (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae), collected in Brittany poultry houses. Mean SCP values drastically increased during the insect ontogeny: egg (-26.1 C), first instar larvae (-21.6 C), last instar larvae (-15.5 C), pupae (-11.6 C), teneral adults (-12.0 C) and mature adults (-13.1 C). Nymphal metamorphosis and adult maturation did not promote substantial decrease of freezing resistance. The SCP values reflect the physiological states of the developmental stages especially the absence of ice nucleating agents: (i) lower SCP values in egg and unfed newly-emerged larvae I (i.e. -25.1 C), (ii) higher SCP values in fed larvae (i.e. -14.7 C), pupae and adults most likely due to the presence of ice nucleation sites in the gut. A tropical species, A. diaperinus, seems not to use its potential cold hardiness even in winter to remain in this warm habitat in temperate regions.     

Survival at low temperatures in insects: what is the ecological significance of the supercooling point?

Many freezing-intolerant insects may die during long or even brief exposures to temperatures above their supercooling point (SCP). Consequently, the real ecological value of the SCP remains ambiguous, particularly for tropical species that never experienced cold exposures. The bimodal distribution of SCP is discussed in the light of sexual dimorphism. The importance of sex in insect cold hardiness has been regularly neglected and although we admit that in some species sex may be uneasy to determine, it should be taken into account in further studies. We suggest that supercooling ability may be, at least partially, a result of adaptations to other functions unrelated to cold, including the desiccation resistance. The potential causes of insect death at low temperatures during survival experiments have also been examined. Prolonged exposures at lethal low temperatures can produce deleterious effects (including death) even if the insect does not freeze; during long-term exposure to low temperatures the organisms may finally die from the exhaustion of energy reserves.     

Refining the risk of freezing mortality for antarctic terrestrial microarthropods

In studies of three common, freezing susceptible, Antarctic microarthropods, the springtail Cryptopygus antarcticus and the mites Alaskozetes antarcticus and Halozetes belgicae, we report (i) the consequences on cold tolerance of cooling in contact with water, and (ii) the risk of freezing when held at temperatures above the typical freezing point (measured using standard techniques) for up to 12 h. The springtail showed no change in SCP distribution when in contact with freezing water while, in contrast, the mites showed clear shifts towards decreased cold tolerance, in addition to death of c. 33% of individuals during the freezing of the water. The springtail showed a bimodal SCP distribution, with the population divided into "high"(typically -8 to -12 degree C) and "low" (typically below -20 degree C) groups. Some animals held at temperatures above these values froze, over a timescale between minutes and several hours. These results highlight the danger of equating standard cold tolerance measures with mortality risk under more realistic water and thermal regimes.     

Are mummy characteristics reliable indicators of diapause and cold tolerance in the parasitoid wasp Aphidius rhopalosiphi (Braconidae, aphidiinae) ?

Many insect species have evolved different overwintering survival strategies such as cold tolerance or diapause. This study investigated the relationship between Aphidius rhopalosiphi mummy colour and cold tolerance and diapause. Mummy colour was insufficient to discriminate diapausing from non-diapausing individuals. This phenotypic character seems to reflect environmental conditions rather than direct developmental time and cocoon thickness (identification criteria of diapause). There is, however, a relationship between cold tolerance and mummy colour. Dark mummies exhibited significantly higher water content, survival at low temperature and lower supercooling point values than pale mummies. Mummy colour in Aphidius rhopalosiphi seems to be a phenotypic indicator of the cold tolerance.     

Relationships between cold hardiness, and ice nucleating activity, glycerol and protein contents in the hemolymph of caterpillars, Aporia crataegi L

Insects in Siberia must tolerate some of the coldest conditions on earth. The relationship between hemolymph ice nucleating activity, glycerol and total protein concentrations, and cold hardiness was explored in Aporia crataegi L. (Lepidoptera: Pieridae). Cold-hardened overwintering caterpillars were collected at a time of year when temperatures are regularly below -50 degree C, and warm-acclimated at +22 degree C, to see how changes in the physical and chemical properties of the hemolymph influence their cold hardiness potential. Warm acclimation led to a decrease in glycerol and proteins content in the hemolymph, which was associated with the decrease in ice nucleating activity and dramatic loss of cold hardiness potential of the caterpillars. It is suggested that one of the effects of cryoprotection in the freeze tolerant insects, caused by glycerol, might be associated with its ability to form larger aggregates of ice nucleating polypeptides that initiate the ice nucleation at high subzero temperatures. Such ice nucleating structures seem to ensure a high probability of ice nucleation at relatively high temperatures, which may contribute to the extraordinary cold hardiness of A. crataegi caterpillars, which may tolerate temperatures below -85 degree С.     

Increased dietary cholesterol enhances cold tolerance in Drosophila melanogaster

For many years, non-freezing cold shock injury has been associated with damage to the cell membrane. In this study, we enhanced membrane cholesterol levels of Drosophila melanogaster by raising larvae on a cholesterol-augmented diet. Diet augmentation significantly increased the amount of cholesterol in the cell membranes of the adult flies (1.57+/-0.17 nmol per mg vs. 0.93+/-0.11 nmol per mg). Flies on the cholesterol-augmented diet exhibited a greater intrinsic cold tolerance: this group had a higher survival rate after a 2-h cold shock of -5 degree C than did the control group (71.0+/-6.6 percent vs 36.0+/-8.1 percent). Cholesterol-augmented flies also had a significantly greater capacity to rapidly cold-harden to -7 degree C (36.7+/-4.4 percent) compared to flies on a control diet (20.0+/-2.9 percent). These results suggest a mechanistic link between protection from chilling or cold shock injury and modifications to the cellular membrane.     

Rapid cold hardening in young hoppers of the migratory locust Locusta migratoria L. (Orthoptera: Acridiidae)

This paper describes a rapid cold hardening process for first instar hoppers of the migratory locust Locusta migratoria L. First instar hoppers of this species are often subjected to subzero temperatures or frosts in early April or May after their emergence from the soil. The mean supercooling point of hoppers is -13.0 +/- 1.4 degrees C; the fact that none could survive this temperature suggests they are freezing intolerant. When young hoppers were transferred directly from 30 degrees C to -7 degrees C for 2 h, there was only 35.8% survival. However, exposure to 0 degrees C for 2 h prior to transfer to -7 degrees C increased the apparent survival to 75%. A similar rapid cold hardening response can also be induced by gradual cooling at rates of between 0.05 and 0.1 degreess C min(-1). Rapid cold hardening also elevates the Ltime50 of first instar hoppers at -7 degrees C by approximately 3 fold, and reduces the lethal temperature from -10 degrees C to -12 degrees C. However, the protection from cold shock gained through rapid cold hardening was transient and easily lost within 2 h of hoppers being returned to 30 degrees C. The rapid cold hardening response is possibly advantageous to first instar hoppers that are often exposed to large temperature fluctuations in spring or early summer.     

Survival of freezing by free-living Antarctic soil nematodes

Free-living microbivorous nematodes become numerically dominant in Antarctic terrestrial faunas as environmental conditions become more severe, while also reaching very high levels of abundance in moist, vegetated habitats. Nematodes have little resistance to freezing via exogenous ice nucleation, such as would occur as their microhabitat freezes. We report the results of experiments testing the ability of seven maritime Antarctic nematode taxa to survive freezing in small water droplets at high sub-zero temperatures. Isolated individuals of these species possessed supercooling characteristics similar to those previously reported (supercooling points -6 to -25 degree C). When frozen in water at -3 to -6 degree C, most showed high (> 70%) survival both (i) after rapid cooling (1 degree C/min) to c. -60 degree C followed by immediate rewarming, and (ii) when held for 7-12 h at either -10 or -30 degree C, although the proportions surviving varied between species. We propose that the ability to survive freezing while fully hydrated at high sub-zero temperatures is one of the most important aspects of these species' survival tactics.     

Cryo-scanning electron microscopic study on freezing behavior of xylem ray parenchyma cells in hardwood species

Differential thermal analysis (DTA) has indicated that xylem ray parenchyma cells (XRPCs) of hardwood species adapt to freezing of apoplastic water either by deep supercooling or by extracellular freezing, depending upon the species. DTA studies indicated that moderately cold hardy hardwood species exhibiting deep supercooling in the XRPCs were limited in latitudinal distribution within the −40°C isotherm, while very hardy hardwood species exhibiting extracellular freezing could distribute in colder areas beyond the −40°C isotherm. Predictions based on the results of DTA, however, indicate that XRPCs exhibiting extracellular freezing may appear not only in very hardy woody species native to cold areas beyond the −40°C isotherm but also in less hardy hardwood species native to tropical and subtropical zones as well as in a small number of moderately hardy hardwood species native to warm temperate zones. Cryo-scanning electron microscopic (cryo-SEM) studies on the freezing behavior of XRPCs have revealed some errors in DTA. These errors are originated mainly due to the overlap between exotherms produced by freezing of water in apoplastic spaces (high temperature exotherms, HTEs) and exotherms produced by freezing of intracellular water of XRPCs by breakdown of deep supercooling (low temperature exotherms, LTEs), as well as to the shortage of LTEs produced by intracellular freezing of XRPCs. In addition, DTA results are significantly affected by cooling rates employed. Further, cryo-SEM observations, which revealed the true freezing behavior of XRPCs, changed the previous knowledge of freezing behavior of XRPCs that had been obtained by freeze-substitution and transmission electron microscopic studies. Cryo-SEM results, in association with results obtained from DTA that were reconfirmed or changed by observation using a cryo-SEM, revealed a clear tendency of the freezing behavior of XRPCs in hardwood species to change with changes in the temperature in the growing conditions, including both latitudinal and seasonal temperature changes. In latitudinal temperature changes, XRPCs in less hardy hardwood species native to tropical and subtropical zones exhibited deep supercooling to −10°C, XRPCs in moderately hardy hardwood species native to temperate zones exhibited a gradual increase in the supercooling ability to −40°C from warm toward cool temperate zones, and XRPCs in very hardy hardwood species native to boreal forests exhibited extracellular freezing via an intermediate form of freezing behavior between deep supercooling and extracellular freezing. In seasonal temperature changes, XRPCs in hardwood species native to temperate zones changed their supercooling ability from a relatively low degree in summer to a high degree in winter. XRPCs in hardwood species native to boreal forests changed their freezing behavior from deep supercooling to −10°C in summer to extracellular freezing in winter. These results indicate that the freezing behavior of XRPCs in hardwood species tends to shift gradually from supercooling of −10°C, to a gradual increase in the deep supercooling ability to −40°C or less, and finally to extracellular freezing as a result of cold acclimation in response to both latitudinal and seasonal temperature changes. It is thought that these temperature-dependent changes in the freezing behavior of XRPCs in hardwood species are mainly controlled by changes in cell wall properties, although no distinct changes were detected by electron microscopic observations in cell wall organization between hardwood species or between seasons. Evidence of temperature-dependent changes in the freezing behavior of XRPCs in hardwood species provided by the results of studies using a cryo-SEM has indicated the need for further investigation to clarify cold acclimation-induced cell wall changes at the sub-electron microscopic level in order to understand the mechanisms of freezing adaptation.     

Solute accumulation in heat seedlings during cold acclimation: contribution to increased freezing tolerance

Accumulation of sugars, amino acids and glycinebetaine in leaf tissues during cold acclimation was simultaneously monitored and compared in three wheat cultivars that have different freezing tolerance. Freezing tolerance was the decreasing order of cv. Norstar (NO) > cv. Chihokukomugi (CH) > or = cv. Haruyutaka (HA). During cold acclimation, there was a significant increase in osmotic concentration in the three cultivars. The increase was largely due to the increase in soluble sugars and the extent of the increase was the greatest in NO and the least in HA. While there was a considerable increase in glucose, fructose and sucrose during the first week of cold acclimation, the increase in raffinose occurred only after the second week. The total sugar content was the order of NO > CH > HA after 4 weeks of cold acclimation. Proline increased in all cultivars after 1 week of cold acclimation but a prolonged cold acclimation resulted in different profiles: no further increase occurred in HA while an additional increase occurred in other two cultivars. In all three cultivars, a noticeable increase of glycinebetaine occurred only after the second week of cold acclimation with the amount being the order of NO > CH > HA. It is concluded that a substantial part of the increase in osmotic concentration during cold acclimation was due to the increase in sugars, but the extent of the contribution of each compatible solute is cultivar-specific and can be associated with the degree of the maximum freezing tolerance attainable.     

Rapid cold hardening: a gut feeling

This study examined the rate of cold hardening of a field population of Antarctic springtails and the effect of eating food with particular levels of ice nucleating activity on the animal's whole body freezing point. The SCPs of samples of c. 20, freshly collected, Cryptopygus antarcticus were measured hourly over a 32 hour collection period using differential scanning calorimetry and related to habitat temperature. The mean SCP of the springtails increased from -24 to -10 degree C during which time the habitat temperature warmed slowly from -2.5 to +2.5 degree C. In laboratory experiments, previously starved, cold tolerant springtails were fed on selected species of algae with measured SCP's but there was no clear correlation between the SCP of food and that of the animals after feeding. Microscopic examination of faecal pellets and guts from springtails showed that algal cells were completely destroyed during digestion.     

Cold acclimation improves recovery of cryopreserved grass (Zoysia and Lolium sp.)

Cold acclimation of Lolium L. and Zoysia Willd. Grass cultivars significantly increased regrowth of cryopreserved meristems. One wk of cold acclimation improved recovery following cryopreservation but extended acclimation (4-8 wk) resulted in the best regrowth. Cold acclimation also significantly increased the dehydration tolerance of both Zoysia and Lolium meristems. Lolium apices cold acclimated for 4 wk produced 60-100% regrowth following cryopreservation by slow freezing or encapsulation-dehydration. Cold-acclimated Zoysia had greater than 60% regrowth following encapsulation-dehydration when beads were dehydrated to less than 22% water content. Non-acclimated meristems of both genera had little or no regrowth. Thawed meristems grew quickly without callus formation and the plantlets produced were transplanted to pots in the greenhouse after 4 to 6 wk. Samples of each cultivar were stored in liquid nitrogen as part of the U.S. National Plant Germplasm System.     

基于LNG冷能的海水冷冻淡化机理研究

为利用液化天然气(LNG)的冷能实现海水冷冻淡化,研究了海水在超低温环境下的冷冻淡化机理,试验测试了海水在不同冷冻条件下的制冰淡化性能参数,分析了各因素对海水冷冻淡化过程的作用机理及性能影响,比较得出了该工艺系统的最优运行参数。该研究结果为基于LNG冷能的海水冷冻淡化系统工艺设计提供了重要的参考依据。     

Antifreeze glycoproteins from the antarctic fish Dissostichus mawsoni studied by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in combination with nanolitre osmometry

This study investigates in detail the freezing events during cooling of solutions of various size classes of antifreeze glycoproteins. Differential scanning calorimetry and nanolitre osmometry were used to observe ice growth at temperatures within the hysteresis gap between the melting point and non-equilibrium freezing point (hysteresis freezing point) of solutions of the various sized antifreeze glycoproteins (AFGPs). The ice growth within the hysteresis gap is presumably due to both the expression of primary or near primary prism planes and also some growth at the basal plane. The binding of the AFGPs to the ice causes a particular ice crystal morphology. With the smaller AFGPs, substantial microscopic ice growth was observed in the form of a hexagonal bipyramids within the hysteresis gap.     

壁面静止水滴冻结过程形状变化

低温表面上的液滴冻结时会形成具有尖顶的形状。针对这一现象开展了理论与实验研究,建立了新的动态曲形相界面模型用来模拟水滴冻结过程中的形状变化。模型考虑重力和成核再辉效应的影响,将冻结过程中的冰水相界面近似为球冠形曲面,并在三相点处引入动态生长角和直角关系。对壁面上20μL静止水滴进行了冻结实验,记录水滴三相点高度的演化过程,以此拟合得到了其随时间变化的关联式,基于该关联式求解理论模型,得到了水滴最终冻结形状。模拟结果与实验结果在水滴初始轮廓、成核再辉轮廓和最终冻结轮廓以及冻结时间上均吻合良好。曲面模型的计算结果表明,固液相界面上不同位置处的冻结速率不同;随着相界面向上推移,冻结速率逐渐减小。     

Cold tolerance of field-collected and laboratory reared larvae of Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Sesamia nonagrioides Lefébvre (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) is considered one of the most destructive pests of corn in the Mediterranean region. The purpose of the present study was to investigate some aspects of the cold tolerance of non-diapausing and diapausing laboratory reared larvae of S. nonagrioides, as well as of field-collected larvae, taking into consideration various parameters, such as supercooling ability, mean lethal temperature and accumulation of cryoprotectant substances, in relation to diapause. Our results provide evidence that S. nonagrioides has limited cold tolerance as it displays a low ability of supercooling. This is strongly supported by the fact that mortality of the individuals occurred after extended exposure to subzero temperatures, equivalent or slightly lower to their mean supercooling point. However, lethal temperatures of diapausing larvae were significantly lower in relation to that of non-diapausing larvae, indicating the existence of a direct link between diapause and cold tolerance. Regarding the role of cryoprotectant substances, accumulation of glycerol seems to be closely related to diapause, in contrast to accumulation of trehalose, which is more related to exposure to low temperatures slightly higher than 0 degree C. Finally, non-diapausing larvae of different instars displayed a similar ability of supercooling and tolerance to low temperatures as well as accumulation of cryoprotectant substances. The ecological significance of our findings on cold tolerance of this species is being discussed with particular reference to the microclimate observed in northern Greece.