Lipophilicity of Some Preservatives Estimated by RP-TLC Using Stationary Phases with Different Polarity

Lipophilcity of some preservatives was determined by reversed phase high performance thin layer chromatography (RP-HPTLC) using methanol–water mixtures in different volume proportions as mobile phase on three stationary phases of different polarity: RP-18F_254s, RP-18WF_254s and CNF_254s plates. The R _M values decreased linearly with increasing methanol concentration in the mobile phase in all cases. The regression determination coefficients obtained for all stationary phases were excellent (higher than 0.98 in most cases). The chromatographic behavior of the preservatives on the RP-HPTLC plates used in this study is similar and in a very good agreement with their polarity. Good chromatographic regularities found for retention factors and by applying principal component analysis for all three types of stationary phases indicate that the same lipophilic interactions are dominants in all cases. The relationships between different RP-HPTLC retention parameters (R _M0 , b, scores of R _F -PC1/R _F and scores of R _M -PC1/R _M ) and various calculated log P values of the same preservatives show highly significant correlations for all types of stationary phases.     

Lipophilicity data for some preservatives estimated by reversed-phase liquid chromatography and different computation methods

The chromatographic behavior of some preservatives was performed by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography on C18 (LiChroCART, Purosphere RP-18e), C8 (Zorbax, Eclipse XDB-C8), CN100 (Säulentechnik, Lichrosphere) and NH₂ (Supelcosil LC-NH₂) columns. The lipophilicity estimated for the first time on the first three columns are comparable and very well correlated. The mobile phase was a mixture of methanol–water (0.1% formic acid) in different volume proportions from 40% to 60% (v/v) for RP-C18, RP-C8 and RP-CN100 column (exception for parabens on RP-C8 column—the methanol concentrations being from 55% to 65%) and from 30% to 50% (v/v) for RP-NH₂. Highly significant correlations were obtained between different experimental indices of lipophilicity (log k_w, S, φ₀, mean of k and log k, and scores of k and log k corresponding to the first principal component) and computed log P values, and C8 column seems to be more suited for estimating the lipophilicity of the investigated compounds. These direct correlations offer a very good opportunity to derive powerful predictive models via Collander-type equations. The reliability of scores values as lipophilic indices is shown by their high correlation with the log K_ow obtained using classical “shake-flask” technique, log k_w and also some of the computed log P values. In addition, the results obtained applying PCA to the retention data may be used in interpreting the molecular mechanism of interactions between eluents and stationary phases with different polarity and to explain the chromatographic behavior of compounds. Finally, the “congeneric lipophilicity chart” described by the scores corresponding to the first principal component has the effect of separating compounds from each other more effectively from congeneric ((dis)similarity) point of view. The parabens and tert-butylhydroquinone appeared to be the most lipophilic preservatives.     

A Comparative Study of the Lipophilicity of Metformin and Phenformin

The results presented in this paper confirm the beneficial role of an easy-to-use and low-cost thin-layer chromatography (TLC) technique for describing the retention behavior and the experimental lipophilicity parameter of two biguanide derivatives, metformin and phenformin, in both normal-phase (NP) and reversed-phase (RP) TLC systems. The retention parameters (R_F, R_M) obtained under different chromatographic conditions, i.e., various stationary and mobile phases in the NP-TLC and RP-TLC systems, were used to determine the lipophilicity parameter (R_MW) of metformin and phenformin. This study confirms the poor lipophilicity of both metformin and phenformin. It can be stated that the optimization of chromatographic conditions, i.e., the kind of stationary phase and the composition of mobile phase, was needed to obtain the reliable value of the chromatographic lipophilicity parameter (R_MW) in this study. The fewer differences in the R_MW values of both biguanide derivatives were ensured by the RP-TLC system composed of RP2, RP18, and RP18W plates and the mixture composed of methanol, propan-1-ol, and acetonitrile as an organic modifier compared to the NP-TLC analysis. The new calculation procedures for logP of drugs based on topological indices ⁰χ^ν, ⁰χ, ¹χ^ν, M, and M^ν may be a certain alternative to other algorithms as well as the TLC procedure performed under optimized chromatographic conditions. The knowledge of different lipophilicity parameters of the studied biguanides can be useful in the future design of novel and more therapeutically effective metformin and phenformin formulations for antidiabetic and possible anticancer treatment. Moreover, the topological indices presented in this work may be further used in the QSAR study of the examined biguanides.     

A TLC Study of the lipophilicity of thirty-two acetylcholinesterase inhibitors — 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroacridine and 2,3-dihydro-1H-cyclopenta[b]quinoline derivatives

The lipophilicity of thirty-two novel acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibitors — 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroacridine and 2,3-dihydro-1H-cyclopenta[b]quinoline derivatives was studied by thin layer chromatography. The analyzed compounds were chromatographed on RP-18, RP-8, RP-2, CN and NH₂ stationary phases with dioxane — citric buffer pH 3.0 binary mobile phases containing different proportions of dioxane. R_M values for pure water were extrapolated from the linear Soczewiński-Wachtmeister equation and six compounds with known literature log P values were used as reference calibration data set for computation of experimental log P values. The obtained results were compared with computationally calculated partition coefficients values (AlogPs, AClogP, AlogP, MlogP, KOWWIN, XlogP2, XlogP3) by PCA and significant differences between them were observed.     

The lipophilicity of parabens estimated on reverse phases chemically bonded and oil‐impregnated plates and calculated using different computation methods

The chromatographic behaviour of the parabens has been investigated on RP‐18F_254S, RP‐18WF_254S, CNF_254S, Diol F_254s and silica gel 60F₂₅₄ plates impregnated with different oils (paraffin, olive, sunflower and corn) using methanol–water mixtures in different volume proportions as mobile phases, the regression determination coefficients being excellent (higher than 0.98 for the majority of compounds). Moreover, highly significant correlations were obtained between different experimental indices of lipophilicity (R_M0, b and scores corresponding to the first principal component (PC1)) and computed log P values. All types of stationary phases investigated appear to be highly suited for estimating the lipophilicity of the parabens.     

Comprehensive evaluation of lipophilicity of biogenic amines and related compounds using different chemically bonded phases and various descriptors

The retention behavior for a series of biogenic amines and related sympathomimetic drugs has been investigated in reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography using RP-2, RP-8, RP-18W, and Diol stationary phase and mixtures of phosphate buffer (pH = 7.10) and methanol in different proportions as mobile phases. Several methodologies like arithmetic mean of experimental retention values, extrapolation to zero methanol concentration procedure and principal component analysis were applied to retention data values (R(M)) in order to determine relevant parameters (mean of R(M) - mR(M), R(M0), and scores corresponding to the first principal component - PC1/R(M) respectively) encoding information on the lipophilic behavior of compounds. High similarities in lipophilicity behavior of investigated amines were highlighted by mR(M) and PC1/R(M) lipophilicity indices for all of the studied stationary phases. The experimental results were compared with some computed lipophilicity parameters expressed as distribution coefficients at working pH (logD), partition coefficients (logP(N), logP(I), and diff(logP(N-I))) concerning both neutral and fully protonated species and difference between both species, and also with various lipophilicity values (logP) generated by different commonly used software. Significant correlations were observed between the experimental lipophilicity indices mR(M) respectively PC1/R(M) and diff(logP(N-I) ) values in all cases.     

Relationships between LC retention, octanol-water partition coefficient, and fungistatic properties of 2-(2,4-dihydroxyphenyl)benzothiazoles

The retention behavior of newly synthesized compounds with antimycotic activity from the 2-(2,4-dihydroxyphenyl)benzothiazole group by high-performance liquid chromatography has been investigated. RP-18 stationary phase and methanol-acetate buffer aqueous mobile phases at pH 4 and 7.4 have been used. In the case of the mobile phase at pH 7.4, higher concentrations of water can be applied than at pH 4. The studied compounds showed regular retention behavior, their log k values decreasing linearly with an increasing concentration of methanol in the mobile phase. On the basis of these relationships, the lipophilicity (log kw), specific hydrophobic surface area (S), and isocratic chromatographic hydrophobicity index (psi0) were determined. Similar log kw values and sensitivity to changes in the structure of compounds studied for both mobile phases have been found. Moderate correlations between the chromatographic parameters and the calculated octanol-water log P values were found. Finally, the lipophilicity parameters were compared with the fungistatic properties of compounds expressed by log MIC (minimum inhibitory concentration) values to find quantitative structure activity relationship equations.     

Chromatographic Study of Novel Heteronuclear Complexes with Schiff Base as Main Ligand

The properties of 12 new heterodi- and heterotrinuclear complexes having general formulae [Cu₂Ln(L)₂(NO₃)(H₂O)₂](NO₃)₂·3H₂O [where Ln = Pr (1), Nd (2), Sm (3) and Eu (4)], and [CuLn(L)(NO₃)₂(H₂O)₃MeOH]NO₃·MeOH [where Ln = Gd (5), Tb (6), Dy (7), Ho (8), Ef (9), Tm (10), Yb (11) and Lu (12)], and their main ligand [L = C₁₉H₁₈N₂O₄Br₂ = N,N’-bis(5-bromo-3-methoxysalicylidene)propylene-1,3-diamine] have been characterized by chromatographic analyses. The parameter of relative lipophilicity (R _M0) of the tested compounds was determined experimentally by reversed-phase high-performance thin layer chromatography method with mixtures of methanol and water as a mobile phase. We also described interactions between chromatographed substances and various surfaces (silica—SiO₂ and modified by hydrocarbon chains—RP-2, RP-8, RP-18 phases). This study also investigates the effect of pH of the mobile phase on the retention on the polar stationary phase. Thin layer chromatography combined with magnetic and electric field has been proposed as a complementary method for the determination of physicochemical properties of the investigated compounds. The chromatograms in the field and outside of it were developed simultaneously in three identical chromatographic chambers. One of them was placed in external magnetic field of 0.4 T inductivity, and the second in external electrical field. In magnetic and electric fields, retention of some complexes changed, which indicated that the presence of these fields influenced physicochemical properties of the compounds and their interactions with the stationary phase.     

Lipophilicity determination of some nitrostyrene derivatives on RP-2, PR-8 and RP-18 layers

Summary The lipophilicity of 33 nitrostyrene derivatives was determined by reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography on RP-2, RP-8 and RP-18 layers using methanol as the organic phase. The R_M value of each compound linearly decreased with increasing concentration of the organic solvent. The retention strength of RP-2 layer was lower than that of RP-8 and RP-18 layers. Between the retention strength of RP-8 and RP-18 layers no significant difference was detected. Minor differences among the selectivities of the layers were also observed. The impact of the change of methanol concentration on the retention was higher on RP-2 than on RP-18 layers probably due to the sterically favourable interaction of methanol with the shorter alkyl groups on the silica surface.     

LC and Principal Component Analysis in the Lipophilicity Study of Seven Angiotensin II-AT1 Receptor Antagonists (Sartans)

Seven sartans have been chromatographed with acetonitrile-buffer and methanol–buffer in different proportions as mobile phases. The retention values, log k or R _M were extrapolated to zero organic modifier content to obtain the log k _w or R _MW values. Calibration equations were obtained for standards of known lipophilicity. A simple method employing a gradient procedure of 10–100% acetonitrile or methanol in 60 min and standards of the extreme lipophilicity was also elaborated. Chromatographic log P values were compared to those calculated by use of different software products. Finally, principal component analysis was performed to explore and visualize similarities and differences among the drugs and among the methods.     

Retention data from reverse‐phase high‐performance thin‐layer chromatography in characterization of some bis‐salicylic acid derivatives

The chromatographic behaviour of salicylic acid derivatives was investigated using reversed‐phase high performance thin‐layer chromatography (RP HPTLC) with methanol–water and dioxane–water binary mixtures as mobile phase in order to establish relationships between chromatographic data and selected physico‐chemical parameters that are related to ADME (absorption, distribution, metabolism and elimination). Some of the investigated compounds were screened for antioxidant activity. Examination of chromatographic behaviour revealed a linear correlation between R_M values and the volume fraction of mobile phase modifier. Obtained R_M⁰ values were correlated with lipophilicity, solubility, human intestinal absorption, plasma‐protein binding, and blood–brain barrier data. The comparison among chromatographic data obtained by two mobile phase was performed with a statistical technique, principle component analysis. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Dominant Factors Affecting the Chromatographic Behaviour of Bile Acids

With the aim of optimizing the chromatographic process by avoiding any preliminary derivatizing step, we examined the chromatographic behaviour of a selected set of unconjugated bile acids looking at the dominant factors that affect the performances of three different stationary phases: RP-8, RP-18 and RP-18 Base Deactivated (RP-18-BD). Accordingly to its structural peculiarity, the RP-18-BD column combined with a specific mobile phase has proved to be the most suitable one, in enhancing both separation factor α and resolution R _S within the selected set of analytes. Pronounced changes in the chromatographic profiles by only slightly changing the mobile phase composition (pH, buffer concentration, percentage and kind of organic modifier) prompted us to achieve satisfactory results in the separation and resolution of the selected set of bile acids.Presented at: CE in the Biotechnology & Pharmaceutical Industries: 7th symposium on the practical applications for the analysis of proteins, nucleotides and small molecules, Montreal, Canada, August 12–16, 2005.An erratum to this article can be found at     

Evaluation of N-Substituted 2,4-Dihydroxyphenylthioamide Fungicide Lipophilicity Using the Chromatographic Techniques HPLC and HPTLC

2,4-Dihydroxyphenylthioamide derivatives modified on the N-aryl ring have substantial fungicidal activity. To determine their quantitative structure–activity relationships their lipophilicity was determined by use of the chromatographic methods column liquid chromatography and thin-layer chromatography. Methanol–water systems were used as mobile phases and the linear dependences of retention (R_M and log k) on volume fraction of organic modifier, φ, were determined. This enabled precise determination of lipophilicity (R_Mw and log k_w) by extrapolation. Correlations were found between quantities characterizing the lipophilicity of the compounds. Deviations enabled discovery of compound structural features which increase or reduce lipophilicity. When these data were correlated with biological activity against the phytopathogenic fungi Alternaria alternata and Botrytis cinerea parabolic dependences were obtained.     

Chromatographic properties ofs-triazines in the presence of soluble β-cyclodextrin polymer

The effect of a water-soluble β-cyclodextrin polymer on the lipophilicity and adsorption strength of 17 substituteds-triazine derivatives was studied by thin-layer chromatography. Beta-cyclodextrin polymer dissolved in the mobile phase modifies the chromatographic behaviour ofs-triazine derivatives and, consequently, higherR _f and lowerR _M values were observed. LiCl exerts an opposite influence, it decreases theR _f and increases theR _M values. The β-cyclodextrin polymer enhances the mobility of thes-triazine derivatives on silica gel and reduces their lipophilicity, thus promoting their penetration through the hydrophilic membranes of the target organism. The presence of LiCl decreases the stability of inclusion complexes. The first and second substituents on thes-triazine ring result in an increase of the inclusion complex stability but — due to steric hindrances — the third substituent decreases it.     

Preparation and evaluation of n-octadecylphosphonic acid-modified magnesia-zirconia stationary phases for reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Three n-octadecylphosphonic acid-modified magnesia-zirconia reversed stationary phases (C₁₈PZM) are prepared via the strong Lewis base interactions between organophosphonate and magnesia-zirconia composite. And two of them are end-capped by using trimethylchlorosilane as end-capping agent in different procedures. Stability studies at extreme high pH conditions (pH 9-12) show that both the non-endcapped and endcapped columns are quite stable at pH 12 mobile phase. The reversed-phase liquid chromatographic behavior of three C₁₈PZM stationary phases are comparatively investigated in detail using a variety of basic compounds as probes. The retention of basic compounds on the three phases is studied over a wide range of pHs. And the possible retention mechanisms of basic compounds on the three stationary phases are discussed. The results show that the basic solutes retain by a hydrophobic and cation-exchange interaction mixed mechanism on three stationary phases when they are operated in eluents at pH values near to the pK_a of the Brönsted conjugate acid form of the analyte, suggesting that inherent zirconol groups on ZM are not expected to interact with bases via cation-exchange interaction at lower pH. Nonetheless, the non-endcapped phase differs markedly from the edncapped ones in retention and selectivity of basic solutes using eluents at pH 4.1, implying a complex retention mechanism at this pH. The cation-exchange sites under such conditions are more likely due to the adsorbed Lewis base anionic buffer constituents (acetate) on accessible ZM surface sites than the chemisorbed phosphonate. Although the three phases exhibit very similar chromatographic behavior with eluents at pH 10.1, and show in general satisfactory separation of basic compounds and alkaloids studied, the performance for a specific analyte, however, differs largely from column to column.     

Unconventional TLC systems in lipophilicity determination: A review

ABSTRACT

This review focuses on four unusual thin-layer chromatography (TLC) approaches for the determination of lipophilicity: (1) the use of medium-polar stationary phases: CN, NH₂, and DIOL instead of RP plates, together with water-based mobile phase; (2) the use of silica gel in a typical normal-phase manner and treating extrapolated retention indices as the “reversed lipophilicity”; (3) the use of oil impregnated silica gel in the reversed-phase manner; and (4) the use of salting-out mobile phases. The chromatographic indices obtained in these systems are numerously reported as well correlated with lipophilicity and they are an interesting alternative to classical RP systems approaches.