Entropy and enthalpy of polyelectrolyte complexation: Langevin dynamics simulations

We report a systematic study by Langevin dynamics simulation on the energetics of complexation between two oppositely charged polyelectrolytes of same charge density in dilute solutions of a good solvent with counterions and salt ions explicitly included. The enthalpy of polyelectrolyte complexation is quantified by comparisons of the Coulomb energy before and after complexation. The entropy of polyelectrolyte complexation is determined directly from simulations and compared with that from a mean-field lattice model explicitly accounting for counterion adsorption. At weak Coulomb interaction strengths, e.g., in solvents of high dielectric constant or with weakly charged polyelectrolytes, complexation is driven by a negative enthalpy due to electrostatic attraction between two oppositely charged chains, with counterion release entropy playing only a subsidiary role. In the strong interaction regime, complexation is driven by a large counterion release entropy and opposed by a positive enthalpy change. The addition of salt reduces the enthalpy of polyelectrolyte complexation by screening electrostatic interaction at all Coulomb interaction strengths. The counterion release entropy also decreases in the presence of salt, but the reduction only becomes significant at higher Coulomb interaction strengths. More significantly, in the range of Coulomb interaction strengths appropriate for highly charged polymers in aqueous solutions, complexation enthalpy depends weakly on salt concentration and counterion release entropy exhibits a large variation as a function of salt concentration. Our study quantitatively establishes that polyelectrolyte complexation in highly charged Coulomb systems is of entropic origin.     

Simulation of nonlinear shear rheology of dilute salt-free polyelectrolyte solutions

Brownian dynamics simulations are used to conduct a systematic analysis of the nonlinear shear rheology of dilute polyelectrolyte solutions, exploring its relationship to shear rate, Bjerrum length, and concentration. A simple coarse-grained bead-spring chain model that incorporates explicit counterions is used. It is found that the polyelectrolyte chains exhibit a shear thinning behavior at high shear rate (as characterized by bead Peclet number Pe) that is independent of the electrostatic strength due to the stripping of ions from close proximity to the chain caused by the flow. In contrast, at low values of Pe, the viscosity increases monotonically with increasing Bjerrum length over the range studied here, in contrast to the nonmonotonic trend displayed by the chain size. Furthermore, at fixed Bjerrum length, the reduced viscosity increases monotonically with concentration. The mechanism underlying these observations is essentially the primary electroviscous effect; the ion cloud surrounding a polyelectrolyte chain deforms in flow, causing a significant increase in viscosity as concentration increases. Finally, the authors have also considered the role of hydrodynamic interactions in these simulations, finding that for low concentration studies in shear flow, these do not qualitatively affect the results.     

Simulation Study of the Conformational Properties of Diblock Polyelectrolytes in Salt Solutions

Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations are performed to understand the behavior of diblock polyelectrolytes in solutions of divalent salt by studying the conformations of chains over a wide range of salt concentrations. The polymer molecules are modeled as bead spring chains with different charged fractions and the counterions and salt ions are incorporated explicitly. Upon addition of a divalent salt, the salt cations replace the monovalent counterions, and the condensation of divalent salt cations onto the polyelectrolyte increases, and the chains favor to collapse. The condensation of ions changes with the salt concentration and depends on the charged fraction. Also, the degree of collapse at a given salt concentration changes with the increasing valency of the counterion due to the bridging effect. As a quantitative measure of the distribution of counterions around the polyelectrolyte chain, we study the radial distribution function between monomers on different polyelectrolytes and the counterions inside the counterion worm surrounding a polymer chain at different concentrations of the divalent salt. Our simulation results show a strong dependence of salt concentration on the conformational properties of diblock copolymers and indicate that it can tune the self-assembly behaviors of such charged polyelectrolyte block copolymers.     

Explicit ions condensation around strongly charged polyelectrolytes and spherical macroions: the influence of salt concentration and chain linear charge density. Monte Carlo simulations

The condensation of monovalent counterions and trivalent salt particles around strong rigid and flexible polyelectrolyte chains as well as spherical macroions is investigated by Monte Carlo simulations. The results are compared with the condensation theory proposed by Manning. Considering flexible polyelectrolyte chains, the presence of trivalent salt is found to play an important role by promoting chain collapse. The attraction of counterions and salt particles near the polyelectrolyte chains is found to be strongly dependent on the chain linear charge density with a more important condensation at high values. When trivalent salt is added in a solution containing monovalent salt, the trivalent cations progressively replace the monovalent counterions. Ion condensation around flexible chains is also found to be more efficient compared with rigid rods due to monomer rearrangement around counterions and salt cations. In the case of spherical macroions, it is found that a fraction of their bare charge is neutralized by counterions and salt cations. The decrease of the Debye length, and thus the increase of salt concentration, promotes the attraction of counterions and salt particles at the macroion surface. Excluded volume effects are also found to significantly influence the condensation process, which is found to be more important by decreasing the ion size.     

Chain stiffness, salt valency, and concentration influences on titration curves of polyelectrolytes: Monte Carlo simulations

Monte Carlo simulations have been used to study two different models of a weak linear polyelectrolyte surrounded by explicit counterions and salt particles: (i) a rigid rod and (ii) a flexible chain. We focused on the influence of the pH, chain stiffness, salt concentration, and valency on the polyelectrolyte titration process and conformational properties. It is shown that chain acid-base properties and conformational properties are strongly modified when multivalent salt concentration variation ranges below the charge equivalence. Increasing chain stiffness allows to minimize intramolecular electrostatic monomer interactions hence improving the deprotonation process. The presence of di and trivalent salt cations clearly promotes the chain degree of ionization but has only a limited effect at very low salt concentration ranges. Moreover, folded structures of fully charged chains are only observed when multivalent salt at a concentration equal or above charge equivalence is considered. Long-range electrostatic potential is found to influence the distribution of charges along and around the polyelectrolyte backbones hence resulting in a higher degree of ionization and a lower attraction of counterions and salt particles at the chain extremities.     

Dynamic exchange of counterions of polystyrene sulfonate

Adopting a cationic fluorescent molecule, rhodamine 6G, as the probe of the counterions of the model anionic polyelectrolyte (sodium polystyrene sulfonate, PSSNa), the diffusion of the counterion probes inside the solution of PSSNa was studied by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Two species of the counterion probes with different diffusion coefficient were discovered--the freely diffusing probes and the probes bound to the PSS(-) chains. The concentration fraction of these two species was found to change with the concentration and molecular weight of PSSNa. The results show that the counterion binding to the PSS(-) chain is enhanced with the increase of polymer concentration, attributed to the result of the lowered translational entropic penalty at higher polymer concentrations. The counterion binding is also enhanced with the increase of molecular weight, and the origin was attributed to the chain end effect to the counterion distribution. The results indicate the dynamic exchange process between the free counterions and the bound ones, which is further evidenced by the replacement of the bound probes by the elevated salt levels in the solution.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of end‐grafted polymers with charged side chains

We report molecular dynamics simulations on bottle‐brush polyelectrolytes end‐grafted to a planar surface. For each bottle‐brush polyelectrolyte, flexible charged side chains are anchored to one neutral main chain. The effects of the counterion valence and the grafting density on the density profiles and the structural characteristics of the brush were studied in this work. It is found that the electrostatic repulsion between charged monomers in the side chains leads an extended conformation of the brush in a solution containing monovalent counterions, while strong electrostatic binding of multivalent counterions to the side chains has a significant contribution to the collapse of the brush. For the trivalent case, the distribution of end monomers in the main chains becomes broader upon decreasing the grafting density, as compared with the monovalent case. However, the position of the distribution for the monovalent case is relatively insensitive to the change of the grafting density. Additionally, with increased counterion valence, enhanced electrostatic correlation between counterions and charged side chains also weakens the diffusive ability of counterions. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys, 2011     

Molecular dynamics simulation of discontinuous volume phase transitions in highly-charged crosslinked polyelectrolyte networks with explicit counterions in good solvent

The volumetric properties of highly-charged defect-free polyelectrolyte networks with tetrafunctional crosslinks are studied through molecular dynamics simulations in the canonical ensemble. The network backbone monomers, which are monovalent, and the counterions, which are mono-, di-, or trivalent, are modeled explicitly in the simulations, but the solvent is treated implicitly as a dielectric medium of good solvation quality. The osmotic pressure of the network-solvent system is found to depend greatly on the strength of electrostatic interactions. Discontinuous volume phase transitions are observed when the electrostatic interactions are strong, and the onset of these transitions shifts to higher solvent dielectricity as the counterion valency increases. The roles of the various virial contributions to the osmotic pressure are examined. The network elasticity entropy is found to behave nearly classically. As the network contracts and collapses with increasing strength of electrostatic interactions, the loss of counterion entropy leads to increased counterion osmotic pressure contributions via two mechanisms. The reduction in available configurational space increases the counterion translational entropy contribution to the ideal part of the osmotic pressure, and the greater number of counterion-monomer contacts formed due to counterion condensation and confinement increases the counterion excluded-volume entropy contribution to the excess part of the osmotic pressure. These observations contrast the decrease in the single ideal-gas-like counterion translational entropy contribution to the osmotic pressure predicted by the counterion condensation-charge renormalization theory. An accompanying decrease in the total electrostatic energy balances the loss of counterion excluded-volume entropy as the polyelectrolyte networks collapse in low-dielectric solvents. This interplay between the electrostatic energy and the counterion excluded-volume entropy appears to be responsible for the discontinuous volume phase transitions that are observed in polyelectrolyte networks. The structure of the polyelectrolyte network is also found to be affine in the swollen state, with constituent chains nearly fully extended, and nonaffine in the collapsed state, with the chains adopting a Gaussian conformation.     

Interactions among spherical poly(acrylic acid) brushes: Observation by rheology and small angle X‐ray scattering

Interactions among annealed spherical polyelectrolyte brushes (SPB) in concentrated aqueous dispersion under the effect of concentration, pH, and salt concentration are investigated by means of rheology, and small angle X‐ray scattering (SAXS). SPB consist of a solid polystyrene (PS) core and linear poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) chains densely grafted onto the core by one end. Rheological investigation demonstrates that the viscosity, the storage modulus G′ and the loss modulus G″ of SPB dispersion increase significantly upon increasing the SPB concentration and pH value which reflects the enhanced interactions among SPB. At high pH, a further increase in pH from 8 to 13 has almost no impact on the rheological properties and SAXS curves, while a “Uniform Shell Model” can fit the SAXS data very well probably due to the uniform filling of polyelectrolyte chains among SPB. When increasing the salt concentration from 10^?5 to 10^?3 M, the so‐called “polyelectrolyte peak” appears at middle to high q range in SAXS curves which means the overlapped polyelectrolyte chains are associated under the bridging effect of counterions, which disappears at higher salt concentration due to the screening effect of further added salts. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part B: Polym. Phys. 2016 , 54, 405–413     

Molecular dynamics simulations of grafted polyelectrolytes on two apposing walls

Molecular dynamics simulations of polyelectrolytes grafted to two apposing surfaces were performed. Bead-spring polymer models are used to treat flexible chains [e.g., sodium poly(styrene sulfonate)] and stiff chains (double-stranded DNA). The counterions are explicitly treated. The effect of the surface density of the grafted polymer, the chain length, and the gap width on the structure and the pressure were studied. Results are compared to experimental measurements and to simulations of polyelectrolyte brushes on a single surface. The density profiles exhibit a maximum not found in single surface data. The maximum is due to the brushes shrinking to avoid interpenetration.     

"Like-charge attraction" between anionic polyelectrolytes: molecular dynamics simulations

"Like-charge attraction" is a phenomenon found in many biological systems containing DNA or proteins, as well as in polyelectrolyte systems of industrial importance. "Like-charge attraction" between polyanions is observed in the presence of mobile multivalent cations. At a certain limiting concentration of cations, the negatively charged macroions cease to repel each other and even an attractive force between the anions is found. With classical molecular dynamics simulations it is possible to elucidate the processes that govern the attractive behavior with atomistic resolution. As an industrially relevant example we study the interaction of negatively charged carboxylate groups of sodium polyacrylate molecules with divalent cationic Ca2+ counterions. Here we show that Ca2+ ions initially associate with single chains of polyacrylates and strongly influence sodium ion distribution; shielded polyanions approach each other and eventually "stick" together (precipitate), contrary to the assumption that precipitation is initially induced by intermolecular Ca2+ bridging.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of polyelectrolyte-polyampholyte complexes. Effect of solvent quality and salt concentration

Complexation between polyelectrolyte and polyampholyte chains in poor solvent conditions for the polyelectrolyte backbone has been studied by molecular dynamics simulations. In a poor solvent a polyelectrolyte forms a necklace-like structure consisting of polymeric globules (beads) connected by strings of monomers. The simulation results can be explained by assuming the existence of two different mechanisms leading to the necklace formation. In the case of weak electrostatic interactions, the necklace formation is driven by optimization of short-range monomer-monomer attraction and electrostatic repulsion between charged monomers on the polymer backbone. In the case of strong electrostatic interactions, the necklace structure appears as a result of counterion condensation. While the short-range attractions between monomers are still important, the correlation-induced attraction between condensed counterions and charged monomers and electrostatic repulsion between uncompensated charges provide significant contribution to optimization of the necklace structure. Upon forming a complex with both random and diblock polyampholytes, a polyelectrolyte chain changes its necklace conformation by forming one huge bead. The collapse of the polyelectrolyte chain occurs due to the neutralization of the polyelectrolyte charge by polyampholytes. In the case of the random polyampholyte, the more positively charged sections of the chain mix with negatively charged polyelectrolyte forming the globular bead while more negatively charged chain sections form loops surrounding the collapsed core of the aggregate. In the case of diblock polyampholyte, the positively charged block, a part of the negatively charged block, and a polyelectrolyte chain form a core of the aggregate with a substantial section of the negatively charged block sticking out from the collapsed core of the aggregate. In both cases the core of the aggregate has a layered structure that is characterized by the variations in the excess of concentration of monomers belonging to polyampholyte and polyelectrolyte chains throughout the core radius. These structures appear as a result of optimization of the net electrostatic energy of the complex and short-range attractive interactions between monomers of the polyelectrolyte chain.     

Associating polymers in a well-defined extensional flow field: Influence of solvent quality and polymer concentration

The conformational response of an associating-type random coil macromolecule in solution was investigated utilizing an opposing jet device. This device, capable of generating a well-defined elongational flow field, is quite useful for probing intra- and intermolecular interactions of lightly sulfonated polystyrene ionomers in both nonpolar and polar solvent systems. Below a critical concentration in nonpolar media, such ionomers qualitatively follow trends predicted by dilute solution theory, although intramolecular ionic associations markedly increase the critical elongational shear rate. With further increases in concentration, the extensional behavior is determined by the initial formation of relatively strong intermolecular associations. At even higher polymer concentrations, a third regime is observed where the conformational relaxation process becomes even more facile. On the contrary, in a polar solvent, the conformational relaxation process is markedly enhanced (i.e., critical elongational shear rate is reduced) due to the polyelectrolyte effect, i.e., dissociation of a significant level of the counterions. The effect of this dissociation process influences the relaxation process over the entire concentration region examined. These findings are compared directly with solution rheology, where in low polarity solvents the reduced viscosity is markedly diminished by ion pair-type interactions, and in more polar environments the reduced viscosity is enhanced due to the dissociation of the counterions from the vicinity of the chain backbone.     

Molecular dynamics and neutron scattering study of the dependence of polyelectrolyte dendrimer conformation on counterion behavior

Atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and contrast variation small angle neutron scattering (SANS) have been combined to investigate the Generation-5 polyelectrolyte polyamidoamine starburst dendrimer. This work reveals the dendrimer conformational dependence on counterion association at different levels of molecular charge. The accuracy of the simulations is verified through satisfactory comparison between modeled results, such as excess intra-dendrimer scattering length density distribution and hydration level, and their experimental counterparts. While the counterion distributions are not directly measureable with SANS, the spatial distribution of the counterions and their dendrimer association are extracted from the validated MD equilibrium trajectories. It is found that the conformation of the charged dendrimer is strongly dependent on the counterion association. Sensitivity of the distribution of counterions around charged amines to the counterion valency is qualitatively explained by adopting Langmuir adsorption theory. Moreover, via extending the concept of electrical double layer for compact charged colloids, we define an effective radius of a charged dendrimer including the spatial distribution of counterions in its vicinity. Within the same framework, the correlation between the strength of intra-dendrimer electrostatic repulsion and the counterion valency and dynamics is also addressed.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of dendritic polyelectrolytes with flexible spacers in salt free solution

We present the results of molecular dynamics simulations of dendritic polyelectrolytes in dilute salt-free solutions. The dendritic polyelectrolytes are modeled as an ensemble of regular-branched bead-spring chains of neutral and charged Lennard-Jones particles with explicit counterions. A wide range of molecular variables of the dendritic polyelectrolytes such as generation number, spacer length, and charge density were considered in the simulations. The effect of dendrimer size on relaxation time, the conformation of spacers, and the size dependence of the dendrimer on molecular variables are discussed and compared with a Flory type theory. The osmotic coefficients of the dilute dendritic polyelectrolyte solutions, as well as the profiles of monomers and counterions, are calculated directly from the simulations. Our simulation results show that the inner spacers of the dendrimers are extensively stretched, and the size dependence on the molecular weight deviates from the scaling prediction that assumes a Gaussian elasticity of the spacer.     

Molecular bottle brushes in a solution of semiflexible polyelectrolytes and block copolymers with an oppositely charged block: a molecular dynamics simulation

Using a coarse-grained model, we performed molecular dynamics simulations of the electrostatically driven self-assembly of strongly charged polyelectrolytes and diblock copolymers composed of oppositely charged and neutral blocks. Stoichiometric micelle-like complexes formed in a dilute solution represent cylindrical brushes whose conformation is determined by the linear charge density on the polyelectrolyte and by temperature. The core-shell morphology of the cylindrical brushes is proven. The core of these anisotropic micelles consists of an insoluble complex coacervate formed by the ionic chains and a shell made up of the neutral solvophilic blocks. As the concentration of macromolecules increases, the orientational ordering of ionic micelles takes place. The complexation can induce effective steric stiffening of the polyelectrolyte chains.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of polyelectrolyte adsorption

We have performed molecular dynamics simulations of polyelectrolyte adsorption at oppositely charged surfaces from dilute polyelectrolyte solutions. In our simulations, polyelectrolytes were modeled by chains of charged Lennard-Jones particles with explicit counterions. We have studied the effects of the surface charge density, surface charge distribution, solvent quality for the polymer backbone, strength of the short-range interactions between polymers and substrates on the polymer surface coverage, and the thickness of the adsorbed layer. The polymer surface coverage monotonically increases with increasing surface charge density for almost all studied systems except for the system of hydrophilic polyelectrolytes adsorbing at hydrophilic surfaces. In this case the polymer surface coverage saturates at high surface charge densities. This is due to additional monomer-monomer repulsion between adsorbed polymer chains, which becomes important in dense polymeric layers. These interactions also preclude surface overcharging by hydrophilic polyelectrolytes at high surface charge densities. The thickness of the adsorbed layer shows monotonic dependence on the surface charge density for the systems of hydrophobic polyelectrolytes for both hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces. Thickness is a decreasing function of the surface charge density in the case of hydrophilic surfaces while it increases with the surface charge density for hydrophobic substrates. Qualitatively different behavior is observed for the thickness of the adsorbed layer of hydrophilic polyelectrolytes at hydrophilic surfaces. In this case, thickness first decreases with increasing surface charge density, then it begins to increase.     

Theory of counter-ion condensation on flexible polyelectrolytes: adsorption mechanism

A new model is presented for counterion distribution around flexible polyelectrolytes by considering (i) free energy of the polyelectrolyte chain, (ii) translational entropy of adsorbed counterions, (iii) adsorption energy, (iv) translational entropy of unadsorbed counterions, (v) fluctuations of dissociated ions, and (vi) correlation among ion-pairs formed by adsorbed counterions on the polymer. The effective charge and size of the polymer are calculated self-consistently. The degree of ionization f of the polymer decreases continuously with 1/epsilonT (epsilon and T are the dielectric constant of the solvent and temperature, respectively), depending sensitively on local dielectric heterogeneity. Further, f decreases with an increase in salt concentration, monomer concentration, or chain flexibility. The polymer size, accompanying the changes in f, depends nonmonotonically on 1/epsilonT. The predictions of the model are consistent with all trends observed previously in simulations and are distinctly different from the Manning argument for rodlike chains.     

On the interaction of bovine serum albumin with ionic surfactants: temperature induced EPR changes of a maleimide nitroxide reflect local protein dynamics and probe solvent accessibility

The interaction of bovine serum albumin (BSA) with the ionic surfactants sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS, anionic), cetyltrimethylammonium chloride (CTAC, cationic) and N-hexadecyl-N,N-dimethyl-3-ammonio-1-propanesulfonate (HPS, zwitterionic) was studied by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy of spin label covalently bound to the single free thiol group of the protein. EPR spectra simulation allows to monitor the protein dynamics at the labeling site and to estimate the changes in standard Gibbs free energy, enthalpy and entropy for transferring the nitroxide side chain from the more motionally restricted to the less restricted component. Whereas SDS and CTAC showed similar increases in the dynamics of the protein backbone for all measured concentrations, HPS presented a smaller effect at concentrations above 1.5mM. At 10mM of surfactants and 0.15 mM BSA, the standard Gibbs free energy change was consistent with protein backbone conformations more expanded and exposed to the solvent as compared to the native protein, but with a less pronounced effect for HPS. In the presence of the surfactants, the enthalpy change, related to the energy required to dissociate the nitroxide side chain from the protein, was greater, suggesting a lower water activity. The nitroxide side chain also detected a higher viscosity environment in the vicinity of the paramagnetic probe induced by the addition of the surfactants. The results suggest that the surfactant-BSA interaction, at higher surfactant concentration, is affected by the affinities of the surfactant to its own micelles and micelle-like aggregates. Complementary DLS data suggests that the temperature induced changes monitored by the nitroxide probe reflects local changes in the vicinity of the single thiol group of Cys-34 BSA residue.     

Counterion adsorption theory of dilute polyelectrolyte solutions: apparent molecular weight, second virial coefficient, and intermolecular structure factor

Polyelectrolyte chains are well known to be strongly correlated even in extremely dilute solutions in the absence of additional strong electrolytes. Such correlations result in severe difficulties in interpreting light scattering measurements in the determination of the molecular weight, radius of gyration, and the second virial coefficient of charged macromolecules at lower ionic strengths from added strong electrolytes. By accounting for charge-regularization of the polyelectrolyte by the counterions, we present a theory of the apparent molecular weight, second virial coefficient, and the intermolecular structure factor in dilute polyelectrolyte solutions in terms of concentrations of the polymer and the added strong electrolyte. The counterion adsorption of the polyelectrolyte chains to differing levels at different concentrations of the strong electrolyte can lead to even an order of magnitude discrepancy in the molecular weight inferred from light scattering measurements. Based on counterion-mediated charge regularization, the second virial coefficient of the polyelectrolyte and the interchain structure factor are derived self-consistently. The effect of the interchain correlations, dominating at lower salt concentrations, on the inference of the radius of gyration and on molecular weight is derived. Conditions for the onset of nonmonotonic scattering wave vector dependence of scattered intensity upon lowering the electrolyte concentration and interpretation of the apparent radius of gyration are derived in terms of the counterion adsorption mechanism.