PHOTOMORPHOGENIC RESPONSES TO UV RADIATION III: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF UVB EFFECTS ON ANTHOCYANIN and FLAVONOID ACCUMULATION IN WILD-TYPE and aurea MUTANT OF TOMATO (Lycopersicon esculentum MILL.)

The UV-mediated induction of anthocyanin and UV-absorbing compounds was characterized in etiolated hypocotyls of wild-type and aurea (au) mutant tomato seedlings. Ultraviolet radiation induced significant increases of anthocyanin and UV-absorbing compounds in hypocotyls of die au mutant and of its isogenic wild-type, but the differences in the time courses of UV-induced pigment accumulation indicate mat different photoregulatory mechanisms are involved for each of these two groups of pigments. It appears mat prolonged presence of adequate levels of UVB (290–320nm) energy and consequently the action of a specific UVB photoreceptor are indispensable for the photoinduction of anthocyanin accumulation in UV-irradiated hypocotyl of the au mutant that is missing the labile phytochrome pool. The large difference found between the wild-type and the au mutant strongly indicate the involvement of labile phytochrome as the primary functional photoreceptor for the photoinduction of anthocyanin accumulation in wild-type tomato hypocotyls. The UVB photoreceptor could at least partly replace the action of labile phytochrome (as far as anthocyanin accumulation is concerned) when the functional phytochrome pool is missing as in the au mutant. The general picture of UV-mediated induction of total UV-absorbing compounds shows only a macroscopic difference between wild-type and die au mutant of tomato: the higher initial level (in darkness) of these compounds in die wild-type in contrast to the au mutant. Although there is UV-induced accumulation of UV-absorbing compounds in bom genotypes, the levels in the au mutant never reach mat of the wild-type under the same UV exposure. A UVB photosensor may play a more important role in the photoinduction of UV-absorbing compounds. Indeed, in the absence of labile phytochrome, i.e. in the au mutant, a UVB-absorbing photoreceptor alone is able to establish high responsiveness for the UV-induced flavonoid accumulation.     

ACTION SPECTRA FOR INHIBITION OF HYPOCOTYL GROWTH OF WILD-TYPE PLANTS AND OF THE hy2 LONG-HYPOCOTYL MUTANT OF Arabidopsis thaliana L.

Abstract— An analysis was made by action spectroscopy, using the Okazaki Large Spectrograph, of the inhibition of hypocotyl elongation of wild-type plants and the hy2 mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana. Two day old etiolated seedlings were irradiated for 8 h with monochromatic light and left in the dark for 16 h before measurement of hypocotyl length. Spectrophotometric measurement showed that levels of phytochrome in the etiolated tissue of the hy2 mutant were less than 9% of those in the wild type. The action spectra of the wild type looked like those of high irradiance response and showed peaks at 375, 450, 625 and 725 nm, whereas the action spectra of hy2 showed only the peaks at 375 and 450 nm. Monochromatic light of wavelengths longer than 500 nm had no significant inhibitory effects on hy2 plants. Blue and UV-A light were about five times more effective in the wild type than in hy2 plants. Severe inhibitory effects were observed with UV-B light. It is concluded that inhibition of the growth of the hypocotyl involves combined actions of phytochrome and a putative blue/UV-A photoreceptor(s).     

DYES AND DYE MIXTURES USEFUL FOR GENERATION OF UV IN A FLASHLAMP DRIVEN TUNABLE DYE LASER

Abstract— We have used a flashlamp driven tunable dye laser combined with angle tuned frequency doubling crystals for producing UV-B radiation for action spectra studies of various organisms. Optimum UV-B power generation is needed to provide biologically effective doses at wavelengths greater than 300 nm. Optimizing power will also serve to lengthen the lifetime of dyes and other laser components at shorter wavelengths where UV-B output is more than adequate. While much information is available on dyes and dye performance from manufacturers, little information is available on the use of dyes and dye mixtures for providing the continuous high power spectrum of wavelengths necessary for biological UV action spectroscopy. We have examined a number of dyes and dye mixtures for optimal laser performance at wavelengths from 260 to 330 nm. The dyes and dye mixtures discussed here provide adequate power output in the UV-B wavelength range and have allowed us to perform numerous UV-B action spectra studies using the tunable dye laser.     

Kinetics of Stem Elongation in Light-Grown Tomato Plants. Responses to Different Photosynthetically Active Radiation Levels by Wild-Type and aurea Mutant Plants

Abstract— In this research, we measured the short- and long-term, stem elongation responses of wild-type and aurea(au) mutant tomato plants to different photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) levels by using linear voltage transducers. Stem elongation was continuously measured in green tomato plants over 2.75 days, under 12 h light/12 h dark photoperiods or in darkness after a 6 h irradiation period. There is no significant difference in stem elongation between wild-type plants pregrown at either LOO or 400 μmol m^?2 s^?1 and then exposed to 12 h photoperiods. However, in the au mutant there is a very large difference between plants pregrown under 100 or 400 umol m ^?2 s^?1 and then exposed either to 12 h photoperiods or to continuous darkness. Total stem elongation of the wild type appears to be maximal at 100 umol m^?2 s^?1, while that of the au mutant appears to be maximal with PAR 400 umol m^?2 s^?1. Wild-type plants displayed PAR-dependent (in the range 100-800 umol m^?2 s^?1) inhibition of growth both during the day and during the night. In contrast, the au mutant showed a fluence-rate-dependent promotion of growth during the dark periods in the range of 10-400 umol m^?2 s^?1. Large, fast and opposite changes in stem elongation rate at the light/dark and dark/light transitions were present in both genotypes. Internode elongation rate in the first half of the night was always modest in wild-type tomato, whereas it increased rapidly in the au mutant. Stem elongation rate of wild type starts to increase after about 6 h in darkness, showing the typical time course of escape from Pfr-mediated inhibition of elongation by an end-of-day response. The role of phytochrome level and type in sensing light quantity is discussed.     

PHOTOBIOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF A SPORE GERMINATION MUTANT dkgl WITH REVERSED PHOTOREGULATION IN THE FERN Ceratopteris richardii

Abstract— This paper describes the mutant dkgl in the fern Ceratopteris richardii, which shows rapid germination in darkness but is markedly inhibited by white light. Action spectra plotted at 10 nm intervals from 400 to 800 nm are presented for germination responses of wild-type and mutant spores to photon flux densities of 0.004, 0.04 and 0.4 jtmol/mVs. The action spectra for wild-type spores exhibit a sharp phytochrome-mediated peak at 660 nm, a broad peak from 670 to 740 nm resulting from an apparent high irradiance response and no germination below 560 nm. In the corresponding action spectra for mutant spores, the blue region displays rather complex fine structure with prominent minima at 450 and 470 nm, which suggests that cryptochrome is unaltered in these spores. The region from 550 to 640 nm shows the greatest inhibition of spore germination, but this region exhibits no obvious fine structure, which argues rather strongly against the possibility of a unique photoreceptor being active in mutant spores. The mutant spectra resemble the wild-type spectra in the region from 650 to 800 nm, and thus phytochrome seems normal in the mutant spores. The dkgl mutation appears to act late in the phytochrome transduction pathway where a hypothetical coupling protein may regulate the light-sensitive step in spore germination.     

SPECTRAL DEPENDENCE OF SOME UV-B AND UV-C RESPONSES OF Tetrahymena pyriformis IRRADIATED WITH DYE LASER GENERATED UV

Abstract— We have generated UV-B and UV-C radiations using a flashlamp driven tunable dye laser combined with frequency doubling crystals. Using this novel UV source, we have investigated lethality and its modification by growth phase, photoreactivation and caffeine in Tetrahymena pyriformis at 254 nm and from 260–315 nm in 5 nm steps. From the observed responses we have constructed action spectra for lethality, with or without caffeine (a repair inhibitor) and under conditions of photoreactivation. We have also estimated quantum efficiencies for these responses. Our observations suggest that complex changes in response occur at several wavelengths over the UV-C and UV-B regions.     

AMELIORATION OF UV-B DAMAGE UNDER HIGH IRRADIANCE. II: ROLE OF BLUE LIGHT PHOTORECEPTORS

Abstract Sensitivity of plants to UV-B radiation (280–315 nm) is often reduced at high background irradiance. Interpretation of plant responses to potential increases in solar UV-B requires improved understanding of interactions between UV-B and other environmental parameters. In this study, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR, 400–700 nm) was kept approximately constant (38 mol m-² per day) while the daily blue light fluence (BL, 400–500 nm) was varied between 0.23 and 2.68 mol m-². Two lines of cucumber (cvs Ashley and Poinsett) with differential sensitivity to UV-B were compared. At low BL, 3 days of UV-B treatment (21 kJ m-² biologically effective radiation per 10 h per day) caused severe inhibition of growth in a developing leaf in both cultivars. Growth effects were detectable sooner and were accompanied by chlorotic lesions in the sensitive cultivar (cv Poinsett). Supplemental BL progressively reduced symptoms, consistent with an important role for BL photoreceptor(s) in prevention or repair of UV-B damage. Ultraviolet-induced increases in UV-absorbing compounds on an area basis were significant within 24 h of the start of the treatment but were independent of BL fluence over the range tested, suggesting that bulk accumulation of screening pigments did not contribute to BL-dependent amelioration of UV damage. However, BL did stimulate net increases in extractable UV-absorbing compounds on a total leaf busis, while high-performance liquid chromatography analysis indicated that BL and UV-B acted synergistically to increase specific components. Thus, the data do not necessarily exclude UV-absorbing compounds from an important role in overall UV-B protection nor do they rule out some more specific function for these compounds (e.g. antioxidants). Finally, BL effects on UV-B alteration of leaf growth and accumulation of UV-absorbing compounds were not saturated under the conditions used here, suggesting that BL may contribute to interactions between UV-B and natural levels of background irradiance. Caution is urged in the interpretation of data on UV-B effects obtained under conditions of low BL irradiance.     

THE EFFECT OF PROLONGED LIGHT EXPOSURE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PHYTOCHROME IN ANTHOCYANIN SYNTHESIS IN TOMATO SEEDLINGS*

Abstract— The hypocotyl of the tomato ( Lycopersicon esculentum ) seedling synthesizes large amounts of anthocyanin if exposed to prolonged light. Single light pulses are totally ineffective. The involvement of phytochrome can be shown by light pulse treatments following a prolonged light exposure. It is predominantly the action of blue/UV light which leads to a high responsiveness of anthocyanin synthesis towards phytochrome. Moreover, the data suggest a phytochrome-independent action of blue/UV light, in particular of UV-B, on anthocyanin synthesis.     

DEVELOPMENT OF AN in vitro SYSTEM FOR THE ANALYSIS OF ULTRAVIOLET RADIATION-INDUCED SUPPRESSION OF NATURAL KILLER CELL ACTIVITY

Previous studies have shown that natural killer (NK) cell activity was suppressed in volunteer subjects exposed to ultraviolet radiation (UVR) from solarium lamps. The present studies were carried out to determine that spectrum of UVR responsible for suppression of NK activity and to develop in vitro methods to analyze the effectivenes of sunscreen agents in prevention of UVR-mediated suppression of NK activity and other aspects of immune function. UVR from a xenon are lamp source was used to irradiate peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in wells of tissue culture flasks, and transmission interference filters were used to eliminate UVR of particular wavelengths. The results indicated that UVR from this source inhibited NK activity of PBL in a dose-dependent manner with a 50% inhibitory dose of 5.5 mJ/cm² when unfiltered and 29.6 mJ/cm² when diluted through cellulose acetate, which gave a UV spectrum similar to that in solar radiation. Equivalent suppression of NK activity was mediated by UV-A (UVR > 315 nm) at dose levels of 4.2 J/cm², which was approximately 140 times greater than the amount of UV-B (UVR > 315 nm) needed to suppress NK activity. Similar dose-response curves were seen for inhibition of mitogenic responses to phytohemagglutinin except that the latter appeared less sensitive than NK to inhibition by UV-A. These studies suggest that whe the greater proportion of UV-A in solar radiation adn its greater penetration into skin is taken into account, UV-A may have equivalent or greater direct immunosuppressive effects than UV-B. The mechanisms of their immunosuppressive effects may, however, differ. The in vitro system described here would appear to provide a simple test system for further analysis of UVR-indued imunosuppression.     

COMPARISON OF UV ACTION SPECTRA FOR LETHALITY AND MUTATION IN Salmonella typhimurium USING A BROAD BAND SOURCE AND MONOCHROMATIC RADIATIONS

Abstract— The UV-B region (280–320 nm) is thought to be primarily responsible for the mutagenic, lethal, and carcinogenic effects of solar radiation. We have conducted UV-B action spectroscopy for mutagenesis and survival of Ames' Salmonella typhimurium strain TA98 ( uvrB , pKM101) using both monochromatic radiation from a dye laser and broader bandwidth radiation emitted from FS-20 sunlamps. A series of optical filters having different transmission cut-offs together with the sunlamp source provided bandwidths having successively less short wavelength components from which a "broad band" action spectrum was deduced. The two sets of action spectra differed both qualitatively and quantitatively: in comparison to the monochromatic action spectra, the "broad band" spectra showed up to a 200-fold reduced efficiency for both mutation induction and lethality by UV-B wavelengths. These results suggest a large protective effect of the background UV-A and/or visible radiations which were present during the broad spectrum irradiations and which are also present in solar radiation. Additional experiments show that to the extent tested this protective effect is not due to photo-reactivation or irradiance (dose rate) effects     

A NOVEL EFFECT OF UV-B IN A HIGHER PLANT (SORGHUM VULGARE)

Abstract— Two non-photosynthetic photoreceptors (phytochrome and the usual blue/UV light photoreceptor) were previously found to be involved in light-mediated anthocyanin synthesis in the mesocotyl of Sorghum seedlings (Drumm and Mohr, 1978). The decisive point is that phytochrome can act only after a blue/UV light effect has occurred. On the other hand, the expression of the blue/UV light effect is controlled by phytochrome ('obligatory sequential action'). A strong positive interaction between the blue/UV-A and the UV-B part of the spectrum was found, in addition to the above sequential action: an inductive effect of blue or UV-A light can only express itself fully if short wavelength UV (approximately 300–320nm. UV-B range) is also given, either after the blue/UV-A light or simultaneously. Since even small amounts of the UV-B are strongly effective it is probable that this effect plays a role under natural conditions and may not be considered as a mere laboratory artifact.     

MULTIPLICATIVE ACTION OF A UV-B PHOTORECEPTOR and PHYTOCHROME IN ANTHOCYANIN SYNTHESIS

Using 290-nm light, which excites only a UV-B photoreceptor, and 385- and 660-nm light, which activate only phytochrome, the fluence rate-response curves of monochromatic irradiations for anthocyanin synthesis in the first internodes of broom sorghum (Sorghum bicolor Moench, cv. Acme Broomcorn) were analyzed. Although the two photoreceptors absorbed light independently, they multiplicatively increased the action of each other. Accordingly, when the fluence rates of both wavelengths were changed together, the resulting slopes of the fluence rate-response curves of double-log plots were steep compared with the slopes obtained with the respective monochromatic irradiations. The slopes of fluence rate-response curves for monochromatic irradiations at 325 to 345 nm were steeper than those at other wavelengths. This difference was shown to be due to the multiplicative actions of both photoreceptors.     

ULTRAVIOLET RADIATION IN ANTARCTICA: INHIBITION OF PRIMARY PRODUCTION

With the seasonal formation of the ozone hole over Antarctica, there is much concern regarding the effects of increased solar UV-B radiation (280–320 nm) on the marine ecosystem in the Southern Ocean. In situ incubations of natural phytoplankton assemblages in antarctic waters indicate that under normal ozone conditions UV-B radiation is responsible for a loss of approximately 4.9% of primary production in the euphotic zone, whereas UV radiation with wavelengths between 320 and 360 nm causes a loss of approximately 6.2%. When combined with data on the action spectrum for photoinhibition by UV radiation, our data suggest that the enhanced fluence of UV-B radiation under a well-developed ozone hole (150 Dobson units) would decrease daily primary productivity by an additional amount of 3.8%. Calculations that take into consideration the extent and duration of low stratospheric ozone concentrations during September to November indicate that the decrease in total annual primary production in antarctic waters due to enhanced UV-B radiation would be 0.20%.     

PHYSIOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF A HIGH-PIGMENT MUTANT OF TOMATO

Abstract— A high-pigment (hp) mutant, which shows exaggerated phytochrome responses and three other genotypes of Lycopersicon esculenrum Mill. cv. Ailsa Craig: the aurea (au) mutant deficient in the bulk light-labile phytochrome (PI) pool, the au, hp double mutant, and their isogenic wild type, were used in this study. Measurements of phytochrome destruction in red light (R) revealed that the exaggerated responses of the hp mutant are not caused by a higher absolute phytochrome level or a reduced rate of phytochrome destruction. Fluence-response relationships for anthocyanin synthesis after a blue-light pretreatment were studied to test if the hp mutant conveys hypersensitivity to the far-red light (FR)-absorbing form of phytochrome (Pfr), i.e. the threshold of Pfr required to initiate the response is lower. The response range for the hp mutant and wild type was identical, although the former exhibited a 6-fold larger response. Moreover, the kinetics of anthocyanin accumulation in continuous R were similar in the wild-type and hp-mutant seedlings, despite the latter accumulating 9-fold more anthocyanin. Since the properties of phytochrome are the same, the hp mutation appears to affect the state of responsiveness amplification, i.e. the same amount of Pfr leads to a higher response in the hp mutant. We therefore propose that the hp mutation is associated with an amplification step in the phytochrome transduction chain. Escape experiments showed that the anthocyanin synthesis after different light pretreatments terminated with a R pulse was still 50% FR reversible after 4–6 h darkness, indicating that the Pfr pool regulating this response must be relatively stable. However, fluence-rate response relationships for anthocyanin synthesis and hypocotyl growth induced by a 24-h irradiation with 451, 539, 649, 693, 704 and 729 nm light showed no or a severely reduced response in the au and au, hp mutants, suggesting the importance of PI in these responses. We therefore propose that the capacity for anthocyanin synthesis (state of responsiveness amplification) could be established by PI, while the anthocyanin synthesis is actually photoregulated via a stable Pfr pool. The Hp gene product is proposed to be an inhibitor of the state of responsiveness amplification for responses controlled by this relatively stable Pfr species.     

Responses of a marine red tide alga Skeletonema costatum (Bacillariophyceae) to long-term UV radiation exposures

UV radiation (280–400 nm) is known to affect phytoplankton in negative, neutral and positive ways depending on the species or levels of irradiation energy. However, little has been documented on how photosynthetic physiology and growth of red tide alga respond to UVR in a long-term period. We exposed the cells of the marine red tide diatom Skeletonema costatum for 6 days to simulated solar radiations with UV-A (320–400 nm) or UV-A + UV-B (295–400 nm) and examined their changes in photosynthesis and growth. Presence of UV-B continuously reduced the effective photosynthetic quantum yield of PSII, and resulted in complete growth inhibition and death of cells. When UV-B or UV-B + UV-A was screened off, the growth rate decreased initially but regained thereafter. UV-absorbing compounds and carotenoids increased in response to the exposures with UVR. However, mechanisms for photoprotection associated with the increased carotenoids or UV-absorbing compounds were not adequate under the continuous exposure to a constant level of UV-B (0.09 W m^?2, DNA-weighted). In contrast, under solar radiation screened off UV-B, the photoprotection was first accomplished by an initial increase of carotenoids and a later increase in UV-absorbing compounds. The overall response of this red tide alga to prolonged UV exposures indicates that S. costatum is a UV-B-sensitive species and increased UV-B irradiance would influence the formation of its blooms.     

ACTION SPECTRUM FOR ENHANCEMENT OF PHOTOTROPISM BY Arabidopsis thaliana SEEDLINGS

Fluence-response relationships have been measured at wavelengths from 350 to 760 nm for the enhancement of phototropism in Arabidopsis thulium L. (Heynh) strain “Estland” by an irradiation at each of these wavelengths, given 2 h prior to a 450 nm inductive unilateral irradiation. Action spectra have been constructed from these fluence-response relationships based on: (i) the fluence required to obtain a curvature of 25° (corresponding to an enhancement of 15°), (ii) the fluence required to obtain 50% of the maximum enhancement and (iii) the fluence threshold for enhancement by a pre-irradiation. The action spectra exhibit two maxima, one at 669 nm and a second at 378 nm. The height of the maximum at 669 nm is approximately 4 times the height of the maximum at 378 nm. Based on the action spectra, it is concluded that the enhancement of phototropism in A. thaliana is mediated by phytochrome.     

RESPONSES OF LIGHT-GROWN WILD-TYPE and LONG-HYPOCOTYL MUTANT CUCUMBER SEEDLINGS TO NATURAL and SIMULATED SHADE LIGHT*

The photomorphogenic control of hypocotyl extension growth was characterized in wild type (WT) and long hypocotyl (Ih) mutant seedlings of cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) grown under natural radiation in outdoor and glasshouse experiments. Hypocotyl extension growth of WT plants was promoted by supplementing sunlight with far-red light during the photoperiod, by reducing the amount of blue light reaching either the whole shoot or the hypocotyl, and by reducing the amount of UV reaching the whole shoot.The Ih seedlings only responded to a reduction in UV-B levels. Both WT and Ih seedlings showed phototropic responses to the direction of blue light. Increasing degrees of vegetational shade promoted hypocotyl growth of WT plants. The Ih mutant showed no hypocotyl growth promotion by natural shade in glasshouse experiments (no UV-B, low water demand) and a reduced response (10-23% of the WT response, according to pretreatment conditions) in outdoor experiments (UV-B, high water demand).     

EFFECT OF UV IRRADIATION ON LETHAL INFECTION OF MICE WITH Candida albicans

Exposure of mice to UV radiation inhibits the induction and elicitation of the delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to Candida albicans. To determine whether UV irradiation also affects the pathogenesis of systemic C. albicans infection, C3H mice were exposed to a single dose of 48 kJ/m² UV-B radiation from FS40 sunlamps 5 days before or 5 days after sensitization with formalin-fixed C. albicans and challenged intravenously (i.v.) with a lethal dose of viable fungi 6 days after sensitization (11 or 1 days after UV irradiation). Exposing unsensitized mice to UV radiation 11 days before lethal challenge had no effect on survival, but the survival time of mice exposed to UV radiation 1 day before challenge was reduced by more than 50%. In the latter group, decreased survival time correlated with persistence of C. albicans in the brain and progressive growth of C. albicans in the kidneys. Sensitization of unirradiated mice with formalin-fixed C. albicans extended their survival time following lethal i.v. challenge with viable C. albicans. Exposing the mice to UV radiation 5 days before sensitization did not abrogate this beneficial effect of sensitization on survival, even though it significantly reduced the DTH response. Thus, immunity to systemic infection did not depend on the ability of the mice to exhibit a DTH response to C. albicans. The beneficial effect of sensitization on survival after lethal infection was abrogated, however, in mice exposed to UV radiation 1 day before lethal challenge with C. albicans. Furthermore, these mice were unable to contain the progressive growth of C. albicuns in the kidneys, in contrast to sensitized, unirradiated mice. The induction of cutaneous inflammation with turpentine had no effect on the survival rate of mice lethally infected with C. albicans, suggesting that inflammation alone is not sufficient to decrease the survival time of C. albicans-infected mice.     

Outdoor ultraviolet polychromatic action spectra for growth responses of Bellis perennis and Cynosurus cristatus

Polychromatic ultraviolet (UV) action spectra for various growth responses of the dicotyledon Bellis perennis L. (daisy) and the grass Cynosurus cristatus L. (crested dog's-tail) have been measured. The plants were grown in the natural environment and ambient daylight was supplemented with five different UV irradiances centred at eight different wavelengths (313, 318, 320, 322, 339, 348, 356 and 377 nm). Destructive growth analysis was performed on B. perennis and C. cristatus after 300 and 122 days respectively. Dose response curves were created to construct action spectra for individual responses. Different spectral responses were observed in these two plant types. B. perennis exhibited a substantial action maximum at 313 nm for the inhibition of aerial, root and total dry weight; a similar action maximum at 313 nm for the inhibition of leaf expansion was observed. Longer wavelengths were relatively ineffective on these growth parameters, with the exception of a small but statistically significant (P < 0.05) response to 320 nm radiation. By contrast, C. cristatus showed negligible response to 313 nm radiation, for inhibition of aerial, root and total dry weight but substantial responses to longer wavelengths, especially at 339 and 348 nm. These action spectra add weight to suggestions in the literature that UV-A has a role to play in responses in this region of the spectrum. The possible implications of these observations are discussed.