Enhanced selectivity for inhibition of analog-sensitive protein kinases through scaffold optimization

The ability to inhibit any protein kinase of interest with a small molecule is enabled by a combination of genetics and chemistry. Genetics is used to modify the active site of a single kinase to render it distinct from all naturally occurring kinases. Next, organic synthesis is used to develop a small molecule, which does not bind to wild-type kinases but is a potent inhibitor of the engineered kinase. This approach, termed chemical genetics, has been used to generate highly potent mutant kinase-specific inhibitors based on a pyrazolopyrimidine scaffold. Here, we asked if the selectivity of the resulting pyrazolopyrimidines could be improved, as they inhibit several wild-type kinases with low-micromolar IC₅₀ values. Our approach to improve the selectivity of allele-specific inhibitors was to explore a second kinase inhibitor scaffold. A series of 6,9-disubstituted purines was designed, synthesized, and evaluated for inhibitory activity against several kinases in vitro and in vivo. Several purines proved to be potent inhibitors against the analog-sensitive kinases and exhibited greater selectivity than the existing pyrazolopyrimidines.     

When Kinases Meet PROTACs

Small molecule drugs targeting kinases have revolutionized treatment options for millions of patients worldwide, especially in oncology. These targeted treatments have less side effects because they inhibit a specific dysfunctional kinase usually with relatively narrow selectivity. However, kinase inhibitors do have well‐established liabilities, most prominently the emergence of drug resistance. Moreover, the majority of kinases are multidomain and multifunctional proteins that in addition to their enzymatic activity have scaffolding and other roles, and inhibitors seldom address these alternative functions. Recently, small molecule mediated targeted protein degradation emerged as a new pharmacological strategy. The majority of small molecule degraders are bispecific molecules called proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs), and their mechanism of action is based on simultaneous recruitment of the target of interest and an E3 ligase, resulting in target polyubiquitination and eventual destruction by the proteasome. Over the last couple of years, PROTAC strategy has been developed and validated for a range of targets, including kinases. Here, we introduce the targeted protein degradation strategy, provide an overview of representative kinase PROTACs, and describe design rationales, efficacy and specificity. We also discuss their potential advantages, as well as comment on some of the limitations of this emerging pharmacological modality.     

High-throughput kinase profiling: a more efficient approach toward the discovery of new kinase inhibitors

Selective protein kinase inhibitors have only been developed against a small number of kinase targets. Here we demonstrate that "high-throughput kinase profiling" is an efficient method for the discovery of lead compounds for established as well as unexplored kinase targets. We screened a library of 118 compounds constituting two distinct scaffolds (furan-thiazolidinediones and pyrimido-diazepines) against a panel of 353 kinases. A distinct kinase selectivity profile was observed for each scaffold. Selective inhibitors were identified with submicromolar cellular activity against PIM1, ERK5, ACK1, MPS1, PLK1-3, and Aurora A,B kinases. In addition, we identified potent inhibitors for so far unexplored kinases such as DRAK1, HIPK2, and DCAMKL1 that await further evaluation. This inhibitor-centric approach permits comprehensive assessment of a scaffold of interest and represents an efficient and general strategy for identifying new selective kinase inhibitors.     

Assessing the Inhibitory Potential of Kinase Inhibitors In Vitro: Major Pitfalls and Suggestions for Improving Comparability of Data Using CK1 Inhibitors as an Example

Phosphorylation events catalyzed by protein kinases represent one of the most prevalent as well as important regulatory posttranslational modifications, and dysregulation of protein kinases is associated with the pathogenesis of different diseases. Therefore, interest in developing potent small molecule kinase inhibitors has increased enormously within the last two decades. A critical step in the development of new inhibitors is cell-free in vitro testing with the intention to determine comparable parameters like the commonly used IC₅₀ value. However, values described in the literature are often biased as experimental setups used for determination of kinase activity lack comparability due to different readout parameters, insufficient normalization or the sheer number of experimental approaches. Here, we would like to hold a brief for highly sensitive, radioactive-based in vitro kinase assays especially suitable for kinases exhibiting autophosphorylation activity. Therefore, we demonstrate a systematic workflow for complementing and validating results from high-throughput screening as well as increasing the comparability of enzyme-specific inhibitor parameters for radiometric as well as non-radiometric assays. Using members of the CK1 family of serine/threonine-specific protein kinases and established CK1-specific inhibitors as examples, we clearly demonstrate the power of our proposed workflow, which has the potential to support the generation of more comparable data for biological characterization of kinase inhibitors.     

Novel library of selenocompounds as kinase modulators

Although the causes of cancer lie in mutations or epigenic changes at the genetic level, their molecular manifestation is the dysfunction of biochemical pathways at the protein level. The 518 protein kinases encoded by the human genome play a central role in various diseases, a fact that has encouraged extensive investigations on their biological function and three dimensional structures. Selenium (Se) is an important nutritional trace element involved in different physiological functions with antioxidative, antitumoral and chemopreventive properties. The mechanisms of action for selenocompounds as anticancer agents are not fully understood, but kinase modulation seems to be a possible pathway. Various organosulfur compounds have shown antitumoral and kinase inhibition effects but, in many cases, the replacement of sulfur by selenium improves the antitumoral effect of compounds. Although Se atom possesses a larger atomic volume and nucleophilic character than sulfur, Se can also formed interactions with aminoacids of the catalytic centers of proteins. So, we propose a novel chemical library that includes organoselenium compounds as kinase modulators. In this study thirteen selenocompounds have been evaluated at a concentration of 3 or 10 μM in a 24 kinase panel using a Caliper LabChip 3000 Drug Discover Platform. Several receptor (EGFR, IGFR1, FGFR1…) and non-receptor (Abl) kinases have been selected, as well as serine/threonine/lipid kinases (AurA, Akt, CDKs, MAPKs…) implicated in main cancer pathways: cell cycle regulation, signal transduction, angiogenesis regulation among them. The obtained results showed that two compounds presented inhibition values higher than 50% in at least four kinases and seven derivatives selectively inhibited one or two kinases. Furthermore, three compounds selectively activated IGF-1R kinase with values ranging from -98% to -211%. In conclusion, we propose that the replacement of sulfur by selenium seems to be a potential and useful strategy in the search of novel chemical compound libraries against cancer as kinase modulators.     

A peptide microarray for the detection of protein kinase activity in cell lysate.

DNA microarray enables the analysis of DNA or mRNA expression levels, but it has not been possible to completely understand life using obtained information. Consequently, protein or peptide arrays have attracted much interest. Since the development of a practical protein microarray is still far away in light of handling difficulties, the peptide microarray is a promising tool for analyzing protein functions. We have developed a peptide microarray to detect protein kinase activity in cell lysate. All substrate peptides for kinases were immobilized chemoselectively on amino-coated glass slides. After phosphorylation of the immobilized peptides, phosphorylation was detected by fluorescence imaging. We detected the protein kinase activities, including that in cell lysate, in response to drug stimulation. Therefore, this peptide microarray would be useful for a high-throughput kinase assay of intracellular signals and would be applicable to drug screening.     

Chemical genomic and proteomic methods for determining kinase inhibitor selectivity

The clinical success of the Bcr-Abl tyrosine kinase inhibitor Gleevec((R)) and the recent clinical approval of a number of small molecule drugs that target protein kinases have intensified the search for novel protein kinase inhibitors. Since most small molecule kinase inhibitors target the highly conserved ATP-binding pocket of this enzyme family, the target selectivity of these molecules is a major concern. Due to the large size of the human kinome, it is a formidable challenge to determine the absolute specificity of a given protein kinase inhibitor, but recent technological developments have made substantial progress in achieving this goal. This review summarizes some of the most recent experimental techniques that have been developed for the determination of protein kinase inhibitor selectivity. Special emphasis is placed on the results of these screens and the general insights that they provide into kinase inhibitor target selectivity.     

MASPIT: three-hybrid trap for quantitative proteome fingerprinting of small molecule-protein interactions in mammalian cells

Organic small molecules generally act by perturbing the function of one or more cellular target proteins, the identification of which is essential to an understanding of the molecular basis of drug action. Here we describe the application of methotrexate-linked small molecule ligands to a mammalian three-hybrid interaction trap for proteome-wide identification of small molecule targets, quantification of the targeting potency of unmodified small molecules for such targets in intact cells, and screening for inhibitors of small molecule-protein interactions. During the course of this study we also identified the pyrido[2,3-d]pyrimidine PD173955, a known SRC kinase inhibitor, as a potent inhibitor of several ephrin receptor tyrosine kinases. This finding could perhaps be exploited in the design of inhibitors for this kinase subfamily, members of which have been implicated in the pathogenesis of various diseases, including cancer.     

A cell-based screening method for specifically detecting kinase activity

No universal approach has been reported for specific monitoring of the catalytic activity of a wide range of kinases in cells. The present study describes an original platform for detecting the autonomous activity of serine/threonine kinases in cells through the introduction of expression vectors encoding modified substrate kinase fusion proteins. The surrogate substrate used consists of the p53 tumor suppressor protein fused with individual kinase domains (Chk1, DYRK3, and Cdk5) at its carboxy-terminal through four tandem Gly-Gly-Gly-Gly-Ser repeats. After transfection into cells, phosphorylation of the p53 moiety could be specifically induced by the catalytic activity of kinases contained in the fusion protein. Moreover, p53 phosphorylation was significantly blocked when a kinase-inactive mutant was used as the fusion partner instead of the active kinase. Using this system, the cell-based evaluation of several Cdk5 inhibitors was demonstrated. Thus, this approach provides a novel platform for the specific, cell-based screening of inhibitors of a wide prospective range of protein kinases and is of tremendous potential for drug discovery efforts.     

Characterization of a conserved structural determinant controlling protein kinase sensitivity to selective inhibitors

Some protein kinases are known to acquire resistance to selective small molecule inhibitors upon mutation of a conserved threonine at the ATP binding site to a larger residue. Here, we performed a comprehensive mutational analysis of this structural element and determined the cellular sensitivities of several disease-relevant tyrosine kinases against various inhibitors. Mutant kinases possessing a larger side chain at the critical site showed resistance to most compounds tested, such as ZD1839, PP1, AG1296, STI571, and a pyrido[2,3-d]pyrimidine inhibitor. In contrast, indolinones affected both wild-type and mutant kinases with similar potencies. Resistant mutants were established for pharmacological analysis of betaPDGF receptor-mediated signaling and allowed the generation of a drug-inducible system of cellular Src kinase activity. Our data establish a conserved structural determinant of protein kinase sensitivity relevant for both signal transduction research and drug development.     

Conversion of SB 203580-insensitive MAP kinase family members to drug-sensitive forms by a single amino-acid substitution

Background: Specific inhibitors of protein kinases have great therapeutic potential, but the molecular basis underlying their specificity is only poorly understood. We have investigated the drug SB 203580 which belongs to a class of pyridinyl imidazoles that inhibits the stress-activated protein (SAP) kinases SAPK2a/p38 and SAPK2b/p38β2 but not other mitogen-activated protein kinase family members. Like inhibitors of other protein kinases, SB 203580 binds in the ATP-binding pocket of SAPK2a/p38. Results: The SAP kinases SAPK1γ/JNK1, SAPK3 and SAPK4 are not inhibited by SB 203580, because they have methionine in the position equivalent to Thr106 in the ATP-binding region of SAPK2a/p38 and SAPK2b/p38β2. Using site-directed mutagenesis of five SAP kinases and the type I and type II TGFβ receptors, we have established that for a protein kinase to be inhibited by SB 203580, the sidechain of this residue must be no larger than that of threonine. Sensitivity to inhibition by SB 203580 is greatly enhanced when the sidechain is even smaller, as in serine, alanine or glycine. Thus, the type I TGFβ receptor, which has serine at the position equivalent to Thr106 of SAPK2a/p38 and SAPK2b/p38β2, is inhibited by SIB 203580. Conclusions: These findings explain how drugs that target the ATP-binding site can inhibit protein kinases specifically, and show that the presence of threonine or a smaller amino acid at the position equivalent to Thr106 of SAPK2a/p38 and SAPK2b/p38β2 is diagnostic of whether a protein kinase is sensitive to the pyridinyl imidazole class of inhibitor.     

7-(2-Anilinopyrimidin-4-yl)-1-benzazepin-2-ones Designed by a “Cut and Glue” Strategy Are Dual Aurora A/VEGF-R Kinase Inhibitors

Although overexpression and hyperactivity of protein kinases are causative for a wide range of human cancers, protein kinase inhibitors currently approved as cancer drugs address only a limited number of these enzymes. To identify new chemotypes addressing alternative protein kinases, the basic structure of a known PLK1/VEGF-R2 inhibitor class was formally dissected and reassembled. The resulting 7-(2-anilinopyrimidin-4-yl)-1-benzazepin-2-ones were synthesized and proved to be dual inhibitors of Aurora A kinase and VEGF receptor kinases. Crystal structures of two representatives of the new chemotype in complex with Aurora A showed the ligand orientation in the ATP binding pocket and provided the basis for rational structural modifications. Congeners with attached sulfamide substituents retained Aurora A inhibitory activity. In vitro screening of two members of the new kinase inhibitor family against the cancer cell line panel of the National Cancer Institute (NCI) showed antiproliferative activity in the single-digit micromolar concentration range in the majority of the cell lines.     

Downfalls of Chemical Probes Acting at the Kinase ATP-Site: CK2 as a Case Study

Protein kinases are a large class of enzymes with numerous biological roles and many have been implicated in a vast array of diseases, including cancer and the novel coronavirus infection COVID-19. Thus, the development of chemical probes to selectively target each kinase is of great interest. Inhibition of protein kinases with ATP-competitive inhibitors has historically been the most widely used method. However, due to the highly conserved structures of ATP-sites, the identification of truly selective chemical probes is challenging. In this review, we use the Ser/Thr kinase CK2 as an example to highlight the historical challenges in effective and selective chemical probe development, alongside recent advances in the field and alternative strategies aiming to overcome these problems. The methods utilised for CK2 can be applied to an array of protein kinases to aid in the discovery of chemical probes to further understand each kinase’s biology, with wide-reaching implications for drug development.     

A general framework for inhibitor resistance in protein kinases

Protein kinases control virtually every aspect of normal and pathological cell physiology and are considered ideal targets for drug discovery. Most kinase inhibitors target the ATP binding site and interact with residue of a hinge loop connecting the small and large lobes of the kinase scaffold. Resistance to kinase inhibitors emerges during clinical treatment or as a result of in vitro selection approaches. Mutations conferring resistance to ATP site inhibitors often affect residues that line the ATP binding site and therefore contribute to selective inhibitor binding. Here, we show that mutations at two specific positions in the hinge loop, distinct from the previously characterized "gatekeeper," have general adverse effects on inhibitor sensitivity in six distantly related kinases, usually without consequences on kinase activity. Our results uncover a unifying mechanism of inhibitor resistance of protein kinases that might have widespread significance for drug target validation and clinical practice.     

Multiplexed tyrosine kinase activity detection in cancer cells using a hydrogel immobilized substrate

Kinases play a key role in cellular signaling, and the overactivation or overexpression of these kinases has been linked to a variety of cancers. Tyrosine kinase inhibitors treat the mechanism of these cancers by targeting the specific kinases that are overactive. Some patients, however, do not respond to these inhibitors or develop resistance to these inhibitors during treatment. Additionally, even within cancers of the same tissue type, different kinases may be overactive in different patients. For example, some lung cancers overexpress epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and respond to EGFR inhibitors, whereas other lung cancers do not overexpress EGFR and receive no benefit from this treatment. Even among patients exhibiting EGFR overexpression, some do not respond to EGFR kinase inhibitors because other kinases, such as Met kinase, are also overactivated. Here we describe a quantitative and specific multiplexed microfluidic assay using a hydrogel immobilized substrate for measuring the kinase activity of Met and Abl kinase from cancer cells. We immobilized kinase-specific substrates on macroporous hydrogel micropillars in microchannels. These microchannels were incubated with 6 μl of a kinase reaction solution containing cancer cell lysate, and we measured kinase activity via fluorescence detection of a phosphotyrosine antibody. We showed that the assay can specifically measure the activity of both Met and Abl kinase within one microchannel and has the potential to measure the activity of as many as five kinases within one microchannel. The assay also detected Met kinase inhibition from lysates of cancer cells grown in the Met kinase inhibitor PHA665752.

Recent Advances in Pain Management: Relevant Protein Kinases and Their Inhibitors

The purpose of this review is to underline the protein kinases that have been established, either in fundamental approach or clinical trials, as potential biological targets in pain management. Protein kinases are presented according to their group in the human kinome: TK (Trk, RET, EGFR, JAK, VEGFR, SFK, BCR–Abl), CMGC (p38 MAPK, MEK, ERK, JNK, ASK1, CDK, CLK2, DYRK1A, GSK3, CK2), AGC (PKA, PKB, PKC, PKMζ, PKG, ROCK), CAMK, CK1 and atypical/other protein kinases (IKK, mTOR). Examples of small molecule inhibitors of these biological targets, demonstrating an analgesic effect, are described. Altogether, this review demonstrates the fundamental role that protein kinase inhibitors could play in the development of new pain treatments.     

Structural basis for selective inhibition of Src family kinases by PP1.

BACKGROUND: Small-molecule inhibitors that can target individual kinases are powerful tools for use in signal transduction research. It is difficult to find such compounds because of the enormous number of protein kinases and the highly conserved nature of their catalytic domains. Recently, a novel, potent, Src family selective tyrosine kinase inhibitor was reported (PP1). Here, we study the structural basis for this inhibitor's specificity for Src family kinases. RESULTS: A single residue corresponding to Ile338 (v-Src numbering; Thr338 in c-Src) in Src family tyrosine kinases largely controls PP1's ability to inhibit protein kinases. Mutation of Ile338 to a larger residue such as methionine or phenylalanine in v-Src makes this inhibitor less potent. Conversely, mutation of Ile338 to alanine or glycine increases PP1's potency. PP1 can inhibit Ser/Thr kinases if the residue corresponding to Ile338 in v-Src is mutated to glycine. We have accurately predicted several non-Src family kinases that are moderately (IC(50) approximately 1 microM) inhibited by PP1, including c-Abl and the MAP kinase p38. CONCLUSIONS: Our mutagenesis studies of the ATP-binding site in both tyrosine kinases and Ser/Thr kinases explain why PP1 is a specific inhibitor of Src family tyrosine kinases. Determination of the structural basis of inhibitor specificity will aid in the design of more potent and more selective protein kinase inhibitors. The ability to desensitize a particular kinase to PP1 inhibition of residue 338 or conversely to sensitize a kinase to PP1 inhibition by mutation should provide a useful basis for chemical genetic studies of kinase signal transduction.     

Substrate Activity Screening with Kinases: Discovery of Small‐Molecule Substrate‐Competitive c‐Src Inhibitors

Substrate‐competitive kinase inhibitors represent a promising class of kinase inhibitors, however, there is no methodology to selectively identify this type of inhibitor. Substrate activity screening was applied to tyrosine kinases. By using this methodology, the first small‐molecule substrates for any protein kinase were discovered, as well as the first substrate‐competitive inhibitors of c‐Src with activity in both biochemical and cellular assays. Characterization of the lead inhibitor demonstrates that substrate‐competitive kinase inhibitors possess unique properties, including cellular efficacy that matches biochemical potency and synergy with ATP‐competitive inhibitors.     

Inhibition of cyclin-dependent kinases, GSK-3beta and CK1 by hymenialdisine, a marine sponge constituent

BACKGROUND: Over 2000 protein kinases regulate cellular functions. Screening for inhibitors of some of these kinases has already yielded some potent and selective compounds with promising potential for the treatment of human diseases. RESULTS: The marine sponge constituent hymenialdisine is a potent inhibitor of cyclin-dependent kinases, glycogen synthase kinase-3beta and casein kinase 1. Hymenialdisine competes with ATP for binding to these kinases. A CDK2-hymenialdisine complex crystal structure shows that three hydrogen bonds link hymenialdisine to the Glu81 and Leu83 residues of CDK2, as observed with other inhibitors. Hymenialdisine inhibits CDK5/p35 in vivo as demonstrated by the lack of phosphorylation/down-regulation of Pak1 kinase in E18 rat cortical neurons, and also inhibits GSK-3 in vivo as shown by the inhibition of MAP-1B phosphorylation. Hymenialdisine also blocks the in vivo phosphorylation of the microtubule-binding protein tau at sites that are hyperphosphorylated by GSK-3 and CDK5/p35 in Alzheimer's disease (cross-reacting with Alzheimer's-specific AT100 antibodies). CONCLUSIONS: The natural product hymenialdisine is a new kinase inhibitor with promising potential applications for treating neurodegenerative disorders.