Structural investigations of paramagnetic metalloproteins using high-resolution NMR spectroscopy: iron-sulfur and copper proteins

Current approaches to the structural investigations of paramagnetic metal-containing proteins in solution using NMR spectroscopy are surveyed taking iron-sulfur and copper-containing proteins as examples.     

13C and 15N NMR studies of iron-bound cyanides of heme proteins and related model complexes: sensitive probe for detecting hydrogen-bonding interactions at the proximal and distal sides

Studies of the 13C and 15N NMR paramagnetic shifts of the iron-bound cyanides in the ferric cyanide forms of various heme proteins containing the proximal histidine and related model complexes are reported. The paramagnetic shifts of the 13C and 15N NMR signals of the iron-bound cyanide are not significantly affected by the substitution of the porphyrin side chains. On the other hand, the paramagnetic shifts of both the 13C and 15N NMR signals decrease with an increase in the donor effect of the proximal ligand, and the 13C NMR signal is more sensitive to a modification of the donor effect of the proximal ligand than the 15N NMR signal. With the tilt of the iron-imidazole bond, the paramagnetic shift of the 13C NMR signal increases, whereas that of the 15N NMR signal decreases. The hydrogen-bonding interaction of the iron-bound cyanide with a solvent decreases the paramagnetic shift of both 13C and 15N NMR signals, and the effect is more pronounced for the 15N NMR signal. Data on the 13C and 15N NMR signals of iron-bound cyanide for various heme proteins are also reported and analyzed in detail. Substantial differences in the 13C and 15N NMR shifts for the heme proteins can be explained on the basis of the results for the model complexes and structures around the heme in the heme proteins. The findings herein show that the paramagnetic shift of the 13C NMR signal of the iron-bound cyanide is a good probe to estimate the donor effect of the proximal imidazole and that the ratio of 15N/13C NMR shifts allows the hydrogen-bonding interaction on the distal side to be estimated.     

The first solution structure of a paramagnetic copper(II) protein: the case of oxidized plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC6803.

The NMR solution structure of oxidized plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC6803 is here reported. The protein contains paramagnetic copper(II), whose electronic relaxation times are quite unfavorable for NMR solution studies. The structure has been solved on the basis of 1041 meaningful NOESY cross-peaks, 18 1D NOEs, 26 T(1) values, 96 dihedral angle constraints, and 18 H-bonds. The detection of broad hyperfine-shifted signals and their full assignment allowed the identification of the copper(II) ligands and the determination of the Cu-S-C-H dihedral angle for the coordinated cysteine. The global root-mean-square deviation from the mean structure for the solution structure family is 0.72 +/- 0.14 and 1.16 +/- 0.17 A for backbone and heavy atoms, respectively. The structure is overall quite satisfactory and represents a breakthrough, in that it includes paramagnetic copper proteins among the metalloproteins for which solution structures can be afforded. The comparison with the available X-ray structure of a triple mutant is also performed.     

Bioconjugation of Proteins with a Paramagnetic NMR and Fluorescent Tag

Site‐specific labeling of proteins with lanthanide ions offers great opportunities for investigating the structure, function, and dynamics of proteins by virtue of the unique properties of lanthanides. Lanthanide‐tagged proteins can be studied by NMR, X‐ray, fluorescence, and EPR spectroscopy. However, the rigidity of a lanthanide tag in labeling of proteins plays a key role in the determination of protein structures and interactions. Pseudocontact shift (PCS) and paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) are valuable long‐range structure restraints in structural‐biology NMR spectroscopy. Generation of these paramagnetic restraints generally relies on site‐specific tagging of the target proteins with paramagnetic species. To avoid nonspecific interaction between the target protein and paramagnetic tag and achieve reliable paramagnetic effects, the rigidity, stability, and size of lanthanide tag is highly important in paramagnetic labeling of proteins. Here 4′‐mercapto‐2,2′: 6′,2′′‐terpyridine‐6,6′′‐dicarboxylic acid (4MTDA) is introduced as a a rigid paramagnetic and fluorescent tag which can be site‐specifically attached to a protein by formation of a disulfide bond. 4MTDA can be readily immobilized by coordination of the protein side chain to the lanthanide ion. Large PCSs and RDCs were observed for 4MTDA‐tagged proteins in complexes with paramagnetic lanthanide ions. At an excitation wavelength of 340 nm, the complex formed by protein–4MTDA and Tb³⁺ produces high fluorescence with the main emission at 545 nm. These interesting features of 4MTDA make it a very promising tag that can be exploited in NMR, fluorescence, and EPR spectroscopic studies on protein structure, interaction, and dynamics.     

Orientation of the axial ligands and magnetic properties of the hemes in the cytochrome c7 family from Geobacter sulfurreducens determined by paramagnetic NMR

Geobacter sulfurreducens is a sediment bacterium that contains a large number of multiheme cytochromes. The family of five c(7) triheme periplasmic cytochromes from Geobacter sulfurreducens shows structural diversity of the heme core. Structural characterization of the relative orientation of the axial ligands of these proteins by (13)C-paramagnetic NMR was carried out. The structures in solution were compared with those obtained by X-ray crystallography. For some hemes significant differences exist between the two methods such that orientation of the magnetic axes obtained from NMR data and the orientation taken from the X-ray coordinates differ. The results allowed the orientation of the magnetic axes to be defined confidently with respect to the heme frame in solution, a necessary step for the use of paramagnetic constraints to improve the complete solution structure of these proteins.     

Engineering encodable lanthanide-binding tags into loop regions of proteins

Lanthanide-binding tags (LBTs) are valuable tools for investigation of protein structure, function, and dynamics by NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and luminescence studies. We have inserted LBTs into three different loop positions (denoted L, R, and S) of the model protein interleukin-1β (IL1β) and varied the length of the spacer between the LBT and the protein (denoted 1?3). Luminescence studies demonstrate that all nine constructs bind Tb3+ tightly in the low nanomolar range. No significant change in the fusion protein occurs from insertion of the LBT, as shown by two X-ray crystallographic structures of the IL1β-S1 and IL1β-L3 constructs and for the remaining constructs by comparing the 1H?15N heteronuclear single-quantum coherence NMR spectra with that of the wild-type IL1β. Additionally, binding of LBT-loop IL1β proteins to their native binding partner in vitro remains unaltered. X-ray crystallographic phasing was successful using only the signal from the bound lanthanide. Large residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) could be determined by NMR spectroscopy for all LBT-loop constructs and revealed that the LBT-2 series were rigidly incorporated into the interleukin-1β structure. The paramagnetic NMR spectra of loop-LBT mutant IL1β-R2 were assigned and the Δχ tensor components were calculated on the basis of RDCs and pseudocontact shifts. A structural model of the IL1β-R2 construct was calculated using the paramagnetic restraints. The current data provide support that encodable LBTs serve as versatile biophysical tags when inserted into loop regions of proteins of known structure or predicted via homology modeling.     

Structure determination of protein-ligand complexes by transferred paramagnetic shifts

Rational drug design depends on the knowledge of the three-dimensional (3D) structure of complexes between proteins and lead compounds of low molecular weight. A novel nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy strategy based on the paramagnetic effects from lanthanide ions allows the rapid determination of the 3D structure of a small ligand molecule bound to its protein target in solution and, simultaneously, its location and orientation with respect to the protein. The method relies on the presence of a lanthanide ion in the protein target and on fast exchange between bound and free ligand. The binding affinity of the ligand and the paramagnetic effects experienced in the bound state are derived from concentration-dependent (1)H and (13)C spectra of the ligand at natural isotopic abundance. Combined with prior knowledge of the crystal or solution structure of the protein and of the magnetic susceptibility tensor of the lanthanide ion, the paramagnetic data define the location and orientation of the bound ligand molecule with respect to the protein from simple 1D NMR spectra. The method was verified with the ternary 30 kDa complex between the lanthanide-labeled N-terminal domain of the epsilon exonuclease subunit from the Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III, the subunit theta, and thymidine. The binding mode of thymidine was found to be very similar to that of thymidine monophosphate present in the crystal structure.     

Recent developments in the <Superscript>13</Superscript>C NMR spectroscopic analysis of paramagnetic hemes and heme proteins

Despite the wealth of information that has been obtained from the study of paramagnetic hemes and heme proteins by ¹H NMR spectroscopy, there are certain limitations imposed by the nature of paramagnetically affected resonances that are difficult to overcome. Although it has long been recognized that ¹³C NMR spectroscopy is likely to be a powerful complementary technique to overcome some of these limitations, the low sensitivity and low natural abundance of ¹³C nuclei has resulted in a lag in the application of ¹³C NMR spectroscopy to the study of paramagnetic hemes and heme proteins. The tremendous advances in methodology and instrumentation witnessed in the NMR field, coupled to the advent of recombinant DNA methods that have made possible the preparation and purification of significant quantities of proteins, and the biosynthesis of ¹³C-labeled heme, have contributed to an increased interest in the study of paramagnetic heme active sites by ¹³C NMR spectroscopy. As a consequence, ¹³C NMR spectroscopy is emerging as a powerful tool to study heme electronic structure and structure–function relationships in heme-containing proteins. In this report we strive to summarize some of the recent developments in the analysis of paramagnetic hemes and heme-containing proteins by ¹³C NMR spectroscopy.     

Insights into partially folded or unfolded States of metalloproteins from nuclear magnetic resonance

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) provides detailed insights into the conformational features of unfolded and partially folded proteins. In the case of metalloproteins, special attention should be devoted to the characterization of the properties of the metal binding sites, and specific approaches need to be developed depending on the nature of the metal ion and its coordination environment. At the same time, metal-based NMR parameters may help in getting a better picture of the average structural properties of the metalloprotein. A critical evaluation of the limits of applicability of paramagnetic effects for solution structure determination in partially folded or unfolded proteins is presented. The coupling between NMR characterization of structure and dynamic of the polypeptide chain and of the metal environment provides insights into the stabilizing role of metal ions in metalloproteins. The overall approach is illustrated for some case examples of increasing flexibility obtained far from native conditions for cytochrome c and superoxide dismutase, two metalloproteins that have been extensively studied in our lab and whose misfolded forms may be relevant for important biological processes.     

顺磁性镧系金属有机配合物的~1H核磁共振研究

顺磁类的核磁共振研究大多是简单化合物,偏重理论方面的研究,对镧系配合物曾有报道。由于这类样品对空气和湿气极为敏感,在国内外研究顺磁性~1H谱甚少。本文研究了含氯桥的醚基取代环戊二烯镧系配合物二聚体的~1H化学位移,线宽,弛豫时间T_1和磁化率,从中找出了顺磁类有机镧系配合物~1H NMR的规律。     

NMR Spectroscopy of Paramagnetic Complexes

Serviceable NMR spectra can, with a few exceptions^[1,6], be recorded for paramagnetic complexes in solution. These spectra provide information about the structure of the complexes and the distribution of the unpaired electrons, and hence also about reactive centers in the molecule. The elucidation of intermolecular and intramolecular exchange phenomena, e.g. the determination of ligand exchange rate constants, the determination of rotation barriers, and the detection of contact complexes in solution, or even of occupation equilibria of the electrons, is possible in this way. It can be seen, therefore, that NMR studies on paramagnetic complexes can be a rich source of information.     

Noncovalent Tagging Proteins with Paramagnetic Lanthanide Complexes for Protein Study

The site‐specific labeling of proteins with paramagnetic lanthanides offers unique opportunities for NMR spectroscopic analysis in structural biology. Herein, we report an interesting way of obtaining paramagnetic structural restraints by employing noncovalent interaction between a lanthanide metal complex, [Ln(L)₃]^n? (L=derivative of dipicolinic acid, DPA), and a protein. These complexes formed by lanthanides and DPA derivatives, which have different substitution patterns on the DPA derivatives, produce diverse thermodynamic and paramagnetic properties when interacting with proteins. The binding affinity of [Ln(L)₃]^n? with proteins, as well as the determined paramagnetic tensor, are tunable by changing the substituents on the ligands. These noncovalent interactions between [Ln(L)₃]^n? and proteins offer great opportunities in the tagging of proteins with paramagnetic lanthanides. We expect that this method will be useful for obtaining multiple angles and distance restraints of proteins in structural biology.     

Rapid recycle (13)C',(15)N and (13)C,(13)C' heteronuclear and homonuclear multiple quantum coherence detection for resonance assignments in paramagnetic proteins: example of Ni(2+)-containing acireductone dioxygenase

NMR resonance assignments in the vicinity of paramagnetic metals in proteins are often difficult or impossible to make using conventional 1H detected 2-D and 3-D methods due to paramagnetic line broadening. The applicability of 13Calpha{13C'} and 13C'{15N} multiple quantum coherence methods for residue-specific assignments of resonances near paramagnetic centers is described, using the Ni2+-containing enzyme acireductone dioxygenase as an example.     

Thiol-ene reaction: a versatile tool in site-specific labelling of proteins with chemically inert tags for paramagnetic NMR

Site-specific tagging of proteins with paramagnetic lanthanides generates valuable long-range structure restraints for structural biology by NMR spectroscopy. We show that the thiol-ene addition reaction offers a powerful tool for tagging proteins in a chemically stable manner with very small lanthanide tags.     

3‐Mercapto‐2,6‐Pyridinedicarboxylic Acid: A Small Lanthanide‐Binding Tag for Protein Studies by NMR Spectroscopy

Paramagnetic effects from lanthanide ions present powerful tools for protein studies by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy provided that the lanthanide can be site‐specifically and rigidly attached to the protein. A new, particularly small and rigid lanthanide‐binding tag, 3‐mercapto‐2,6‐pyridinedicarboxylic acid (3MDPA), was synthesized and attached to two different proteins via a disulfide bond. The complexes of the N‐terminal domain of the E. coli arginine repressor (ArgN) with seven different paramagnetic lanthanide ions and Co²⁺ were analyzed in detail by NMR spectroscopy. The magnetic susceptibility anisotropy (Δχ) tensors and metal position were determined from pseudocontact shifts. The 3MDPA tag generated very different Δχ tensor orientations compared to the previously studied 4‐mercaptomethyl‐DPA tag, making it a highly complementary and useful tool for protein NMR studies.     

Observation of individual transitions in magnetically equivalent spin systems

Individual transitions of magnetically equivalent spin systems such as methyl groups residing on isotropically tumbling molecules in solution usually cannot be observed as multiplet-split NMR lines. We propose a pair of NMR experiments, 2D [13C,1Halphaalpha]Methyl and [13C,1Hbetabeta]Methyl HSQC, to overcome this limitation and enable direct and selective observation of individual 1H transitions in 13C-labeled methyl spin systems. Immediate applications include quantitative measurements of 1H-1H residual dipolar couplings (RDC) and cross-correlated relaxation between 1H chemical shift anisotropy and 1H-1H dipole-dipole interactions. The use of the experiments for the measurement of RDCs is demonstrated with two proteins, one weakly aligned by means of Pf1 phages and the other using a naturally present paramagnetic heme group.     

High Accuracy Protein Structures from Minimal Sparse Paramagnetic Solid‐State NMR Restraints

There is a pressing need for new computational tools to integrate data from diverse experimental approaches in structural biology. We present a strategy that combines sparse paramagnetic solid‐state NMR restraints with physics‐based atomistic simulations. Our approach explicitly accounts for uncertainty in the interpretation of experimental data through the use of a semi‐quantitative mapping between the data and the restraint energy that is calibrated by extensive simulations. We apply our approach to solid‐state NMR data for the model protein GB1 labeled with Cu²⁺‐EDTA at six different sites. We are able to determine the structure to 0.9 Å accuracy within a single day of computation on a GPU cluster. We further show that in some cases, the data from only a single paramagnetic tag are sufficient for accurate folding.     

Double-lanthanide-binding tags: design, photophysical properties, and NMR applications

Lanthanide-binding tags (LBTs) are peptide sequences of up to 20 encoded amino acids that tightly and selectively complex lanthanide ions and can sensitize terbium (Tb3+) luminescence. On the basis of these properties, it was predicted that increasing the number of bound lanthanides would improve the capabilities of these tags. Therefore, using a structurally well-characterized single-LBT sequence as a starting point, a "double-LBT" (dLBT), which concatenates two lanthanide-binding motifs, was designed. Herein we report the generation of dLBT peptides and luminescence and NMR studies on a dLBT-tagged ubiquitin fusion protein. These lanthanide-bound constructs are shown to be improved luminescent tags with avid lanthanide binding and up to 3-fold greater luminescence intensity. NMR experiments were conducted on the ubiquitin construct, wherein bound paramagnetic lanthanides were used as alignment-inducing agents to gain residual dipolar couplings, which are valuable restraints for macromolecular structure determination. Together, these results indicate that dLBTs will be valuable chemical tools for biophysical applications leading to new approaches for studying the structure, function, and dynamics of proteins.     

A justification for using NMR model-free methods when investigating the solution structures of rhombic paramagnetic lanthanide complexes

The detailed analysis of the 1H NMR hyperfine shifts according to the model-free methods shows that the semi-rigid monometallic complexes [Ln(L)(NO3)3] (Ln = Eu-Yb) are isostructural in solution. The associated separation of contact and pseudo-contact contributions to the hyperfine NMR shifts in each rhombic lanthanide complex at room temperature provides paramagnetic susceptibility tensors whose principal magnetic axes match the expected symmetry requirements. Moreover, both axial (Delta chi(ax)) and rhombic (Delta chi(rh)) paramagnetic anisotropies display satisfactory linear dependence on Bleaney's factors, a correlation predicted by the approximate high-temperature expansion of the magnetic susceptibility limited to T(-2). Consequently, the simple, and chemically attracting NMR model-free methods are not limited to axial systems, and can be safely used for the investigation of the solution structures of any lanthanide complexes. Molecular-based structural criteria for the reliable estimation of paramagnetic susceptibility tensors by NMR are discussed, together with the assignment of the labels of the crystal-field and magnetic axes within Bleaney's approach.     

A general method for determining the electron self-exchange rates of blue copper proteins by longitudinal NMR relaxation

A general NMR method is presented that allows a precise determination of the second-order rate constant, k(ese), for the electron self-exchange in blue copper proteins, from the longitudinal relaxation rates of the nuclei in the protein. The method relies on the use of partly oxidized (paramagnetic) samples of the protein. In contrast to previous NMR approaches for the determination of electron self-exchange rates, the applicability of the method extends beyond the slow-exchange limit, k(ese)c < R(ip), i = 1, 2, where c is the protein concentration, and R(ip) is the paramagnetic relaxation enhancement of the observed nuclei.