Free volume hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics method for the absolute free energy of liquids

The hypothetical scanning (HS) method is a general approach for calculating the absolute entropy, S, and free energy, F, by analyzing Boltzmann samples obtained by Monte Carlo (MC) or molecular dynamics (MD) techniques. With HS applied to a fluid, each configuration i of the sample is reconstructed by gradually placing the molecules in their positions at i using transition probabilities (TPs). With our recent version of HS, called HSMC-EV, each TP is calculated from MC simulations, where the simulated particles are excluded from the volume reconstructed in previous steps. In this paper we remove the excluded volume (EV) restriction, replacing it by a "free volume" (FV) approach. For liquid argon, HSMC-FV leads to an improvement in efficiency over HSMC-EV by a factor of 2-3. Importantly, the FV treatment greatly simplifies the HS implementation for liquids, allowing a much more natural application of the method for MD simulations. Given the success and popularity of MD, the present development of the HSMD method for liquids is an important advancement for HS methodology. Results for the HSMD-FV approach presented here agree well with our HSMC and thermodynamic integration results. The efficiency of HSMD-FV is equivalent to HSMC-EV. The potential use of HSMC(MD)-FV in protein systems with explicit water is discussed.     

Calculation of the entropy and free energy by the hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo method: application to peptides

A new approach, the hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo (HSMC), for calculating the absolute entropy, S, and free energy, F, has been introduced recently and applied first to fluids (argon and water) and later to peptides. In this paper the method is further developed for peptide chains in vacuum. S is calculated from a given MC sample by reconstructing each sample conformation i step-by-step, i.e., calculating transition probabilities (TPs) for the dihedral and bond angles and fixing the related atoms at their positions. At step k of the process the chain's coordinates that have already been determined are kept fixed (the "frozen past") and TP(k) is obtained from a MC simulation of the "future" part of the chain whose TPs as yet have not been determined; when the process is completed the contribution of conformation i to the entropy is, S(i) approximately -ln Pi(k) TP(k). In a recent paper we studied polyglycine chains, modeled by the AMBER force field with constant bond lengths and bond angles (the rigid model). Decaglycine [(Gly)(10)] was studied in the helical, extended, and hairpin microstates, while (Gly)(16) was treated only in the first two microstates. In this paper the samples are increased and restudied, (Gly)(16) is also investigated in the hairpin microstate, and for (Gly)(10) approximations are tested where only part of the future is considered for calculating the TPs. We calculate upper and lower bounds for F and demonstrate that like for fluids, F can be obtained from multiple reconstructions of a single conformation. We also test a more realistic model of (Gly)(10) where the bond angles are allowed to move (the flexible model). Very accurate results for S and F are obtained which are compared to results obtained by the quasiharmonic approximation and the local states method. Thus, differences in entropy and free energy between the three microstates are obtained within errors of 0.1-0.3 kcal/mol. The HSMC method can be applied to a macromolecule with any degree of flexibility, ranging from local fluctuations to a random coil. The present results demonstrate that the difference in stability, DeltaF(mn)=F(m)-F(n) between significantly different microstates m and n, can be obtained from two simulations only without the need to resort to thermodynamic integration. Our long-term goal is to extend this method to any peptide and apply it to a peptide immersed in a box with explicit water.     

Calculation of the entropy of random coil polymers with the hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo method

Hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo (HSMC) is a method for calculating the absolute entropy S and free energy F from a given MC trajectory developed recently and applied to liquid argon, TIP3P water, and peptides. In this paper HSMC is extended to random coil polymers by applying it to self-avoiding walks on a square lattice--a simple but difficult model due to strong excluded volume interactions. With HSMC the probability of a given chain is obtained as a product of transition probabilities calculated for each bond by MC simulations and a counting formula. This probability is exact in the sense that it is based on all the interactions of the system and the only approximation is due to finite sampling. The method provides rigorous upper and lower bounds for F, which can be obtained from a very small sample and even from a single chain conformation. HSMC is independent of existing techniques and thus constitutes an independent research tool. The HSMC results are compared to those obtained by other methods, and its application to complex lattice chain models is discussed; we emphasize its ability to treat any type of boundary conditions for which a reference state (with known free energy) might be difficult to define for a thermodynamic integration process. Finally, we stress that the capability of HSMC to extract the absolute entropy from a given sample is important for studying relaxation processes, such as protein folding.     

Calculation of the Entropy of Lattice Polymer Models from Monte Carlo Trajectories

While lattice models are used extensively for macromolecules (synthetic polymers proteins, etc.), calculation of the absolute entropy, S, and the free energy, F, from a given Monte Carlo (MC) trajectory is not straightforward. Recently, we have developed the hypothetical scanning MC (HSMC) method for calculating S and F of fluids. Here we extend HSMC to self-avoiding walks on a square lattice and discuss its wide applicability to complex polymer lattice models. HSMC is independent of existing techniques and thus constitutes an independent research tool; it provides rigorous upper and lower bounds for F, which can be obtained from a very small sample and even from a single chain conformation.     

Lower and upper bounds for the absolute free energy by the hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo method: application to liquid argon and water

The hypothetical scanning (HS) method is a general approach for calculating the absolute entropy S and free energy F by analyzing Boltzmann samples obtained by Monte Carlo or molecular dynamics techniques. With HS applied to a fluid, each configuration i of the sample is reconstructed by gradually placing the molecules in their positions at i using transition probabilities (TPs). At each step of the process the system is divided into two parts, the already treated molecules (the "past"), which are fixed, and the as yet unspecified (mobile) "future" molecules. Obtaining the TP exactly requires calculating partition functions over all positions of the future molecules in the presence of the frozen past, thus it is customary to invoke various approximations to best represent these quantities. In a recent publication [Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 9235 (2004)] we developed a version of HS called complete HSMC, where each TP is calculated from an MC simulation involving all of the future molecules (the complete future); the method was applied very successfully to Lennard-Jones systems (liquid argon) and a box of TIP3P water molecules. In its basic implementation the method provides lower and upper bounds for F, where the latter can be evaluated only for relatively small systems. Here we introduce a new expression for an upper bound, which can be evaluated for larger systems. We also propose a new exact expression for F and verify its effectiveness. These free energy functionals lead to significantly improved accuracy (as applied to the liquid systems above) which is comparable to our thermodynamic integration results. We formalize and discuss theoretical aspects of HSMC that have not been addressed in previous studies. Additionally, several functionals are developed and shown to provide the free energy through the analysis of a single configuration.     

Monte Carlo vs molecular dynamics for all-atom polypeptide folding simulations

An efficient Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm including concerted rotations is directly compared to molecular dynamics (MD) in all-atom statistical mechanics folding simulations of small polypeptides. The previously reported algorithm "concerted rotations with flexible bond angles" (CRA) has been shown to successfully locate the native state of small polypeptides. In this study, the folding of three small polypeptides (trpzip2/H1/Trp-cage) is investigated using MC and MD, for a combined sampling time of approximately 10(11) MC configurations and 8 micros, respectively. Both methods successfully locate the experimentally determined native states of the three systems, but they do so at different speed, with 2-2.5 times faster folding of the MC runs. The comparison reveals that thermodynamic and dynamic properties can reliably be obtained by both and that results from folding simulations do not depend on the algorithm used. Similar to previous comparisons of MC and MD, it is found that one MD integration step of 2 fs corresponds to one MC scan, revealing the good sampling of MC. The simplicity and efficiency of the MC method will enable its future use in folding studies involving larger systems and the combination with replica exchange algorithms.     

Monte Carlo versus molecular dynamics simulations in heterogeneous systems: an application to the n-pentane liquid-vapor interface

The Monte Carlo (MC) and molecular dynamics (MD) methodologies are now well established for computing equilibrium properties in homogeneous fluids. This is not yet the case for the direct simulation of two-phase systems, which exhibit nonuniformity of the density distribution across the interface. We have performed direct MC and MD simulations of the liquid-gas interface of n-pentane using a standard force-field model. We obtained density and pressure components profiles along the direction normal to the interface that can be very different, depending on the truncation and long range correction strategies. We discuss the influence on predicted properties of different potential truncation schemes implemented in both MC and MD simulations. We show that the MD and MC profiles can be made in agreement by using a Lennard-Jones potential truncated via a polynomial function that makes the first and second derivatives of the potential continuous at the cutoff distance. In this case however, the predicted thermodynamic properties (phase envelope, surface tension) deviate from experiments, because of the changes made in the potential. A further readjustment of the potential parameters is needed if one wants to use this method. We conclude that a straightforward use of bulk phase force fields in MD simulations may lead to some physical inconsistencies when computing interfacial properties.     

Insights into uranyl chemistry from molecular dynamics simulations

First-principles and purely classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations for complexes of the uranyl ion (UO(2)(2+)) are reviewed. Validation of Car-Parrinello MD simulations for small uranyl complexes in aqueous solution is discussed. Special attention is called to the mechanism of ligand-exchange reactions at the uranyl centre and to effects of solvation and hydration on coordination and structural properties. Large-scale classical MD simulations are surveyed in the context of liquid-liquid extraction, with uranyl complexes ranging from simple hydrates to calixarenes, and nonaqueous phases from simple organic solvents and supercritical CO(2) to ionic liquids.     

Convergence of replica exchange molecular dynamics

Replica exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) method is one of the generalized-ensemble algorithms which performs random walk in energy space and helps a system to escape from local energy traps. In this work, we studied the accuracy and efficiency of REMD by examining its ability to reproduce the results of multiple extended conventional molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and to enhance conformational sampling. Two sets of REMD simulations with different initial configurations, one from the fully extended and the other from fully helical conformations, were conducted on a fast-folding 21-amino-acid peptide with a continuum solvent model. Remarkably, the two REMD simulation sets started to converge even within 1.0 ns, despite their dramatically different starting conformations. In contrast, the conventional MD within the same time and with identical starting conformations did not show obvious signs of convergence. Excellent convergence between the REMD sets for T>300 K was observed after 14.0 ns REMD simulations as measured by the average helicity and free-energy profiles. We also conducted a set of 45 MD simulations at nine different temperatures with each trajectory simulated to 100.0 and 200.0 ns. An excellent agreement between the REMD and the extended MD simulation results was observed for T>300 K, showing that REMD can accurately reproduce long-time MD results with high efficiency. The autocorrelation times of the calculated helicity demonstrate that REMD can significantly enhance the sampling efficiency by 14.3+/-6.4, 35.1+/-0.2, and 71.5+/-20.4 times at, respectively, approximately 360, approximately 300, and approximately 275 K in comparison to the regular MD. Convergence was less satisfactory at low temperatures (T<300 K) and a slow oscillatory behavior suggests that longer simulation time was needed to reach equilibrium. Other technical issues, including choice of exchange frequency, were also examined.     

Calculation of the entropy and free energy from monte carlo simulations of a peptide stretched by an external force

Hypothetical scanning Monte Carlo (HSMC) is a method for calculating the absolute entropy, S, and free energy, F, from a trajectory generated by any simulation technique. HSMC was applied initially to fluids (argon and water) and later to peptides and self-avoiding walks on a lattice. In this paper we make a step further and apply it to a model of decaglycine (at T = 300 K) in vacuum with constant bond lengths where external stretching forces are exerted at the end points; the changes in S and F are calculated as the forces are increased. The molecule is placed initially in a helical structure, which is changed to an extended structure after a short simulation time due to the exerted forces. This study has relevance to problems in polymers (e.g., rubber elasticity) and to the analysis of experiments where individual molecules are stretched by atomic force microscopy (AFM), for example. The results for S and F are accurate and are significantly better than those obtained by the quasi-harmonic approximation and the local states method. However, the molecule is quite stiff due to the strong bond angle potentials and the extensions are small even for relatively large forces. Correspondingly, as the force is increased the decrease in the entropy is relatively small while the potential energy is enhanced significantly. Still, differences, TDeltaS, for different forces are obtained with very good accuracy of approximately 0.2 kcal/mol.     

Calculation of the Absolute Free Energy of Binding and Related Entropies with the HSMD-TI Method: The FKBP12-L8 Complex

The hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics (HSMD) method is used here for calculating the absolute free energy of binding, ΔA(0) of the complex of the protein FKBP12 with the ligand SB2 (also denoted L8) - a system that has been studied previously for comparing the performance of different methods. Our preliminary study suggests that considering long-range electrostatics is imperative even for a hydrophobic ligand such as L8. Therefore the system is modeled by the AMBER force field using Particle Mesh Ewald (PME). HSMD consists of three stages applied to both the ligand-solvent and ligand-protein systems. (1) A small set of system configurations (frames) is extracted from an MD trajectory. (2) The entropy of the ligand in each frame is calculated by a reconstruction procedure. (3) The contribution of water and protein to ΔA(0) is calculated for each frame by gradually increasing the ligand-environment interactions from zero to their full value using thermodynamic integration (TI). Unlike the conventional methods, the structure of the ligand is kept fixed during TI, and HSMD is thus free from the end-point problem encountered with the double annihilation method (DAM); therefore, the need for applying restraints is avoided. Furthermore, unlike the conventional methods, the entropy of the ligand and water is obtained directly as a byproduct of the simulation. In this paper, in addition to the difference in the internal entropies of the ligand in the two environments, we calculate for the first time the external entropy of the ligand, which provides a measure for the size of the active site. We obtain ΔA(0) = -10.7 ±1.0 as compared to the experimental values -10.9 and -10.6 kcal/mol. However, a protein/water system treated by periodic boundary conditions grows significantly with increasing protein size and the computation of ΔA(0) would become expensive by all methods. Therefore, we also apply HSMD to FKBP12-L8 described by the GSBP/SSBP model of Roux's group (implemented in the software CHARMM) where only part of the protein and water around the active site are considered and long-range electrostatic effects are taken into account. For comparison this model was also treated by the double decoupling method (DDM). The two methods have led to comparable results for ΔA(0) which are somewhat lower than the experimental value. The ligand was found to be more confined in the active site described by GSBP/SSBP than by PME where its entropy in solvent is larger than in the active site by 1.7 and by 5.5 kcal/mol, respectively.     

Existence of specific "folds" in polyproline II ensembles of an "unfolded"alanine peptide detected by molecular dynamics

Equilibrium ensembles of octaalanine (Ac-Ala8-NHMe) in water, prepared with MD, are analyzed for contributing microstates with an RMSD-based conformational clustering algorithm. The extracted ensemble-averaged properties are in excellent agreement with numerous spectroscopic measurements reported with small alanine model peptides in water. However, the dominantly polyproline II-like ensemble of the peptide is found to be populated with a handful of highly position-specific "folds", including beta-turns, beta-hairpins, and helix nuclei, which could be the "seeds" that initiate proteins along their folding pathways.     

Structure and dynamics of the homologous series of alanine peptides: a joint molecular dynamics/NMR study

The phi,psi backbone angle distribution of small homopolymeric model peptides is investigated by a joint molecular dynamics (MD) simulation and heteronuclear NMR study. Combining the accuracy of the measured scalar coupling constants and the atomistic detail of the all-atom MD simulations with explicit solvent, the thermal populations of the peptide conformational states are determined with an uncertainty of <5 %. Trialanine samples mainly ( approximately 90%) a poly-l-proline II helix-like structure, some ( approximately 10%) beta extended structure, but no alphaR helical conformations. No significant change in the distribution of conformers is observed with increasing chain length (Ala(3) to Ala(7)). Trivaline samples all three major conformations significantly. Triglycine samples the four corner regions of the Ramachandran space and exists in a slow conformational equilibrium between the cis and trans conformation of peptide bonds. The backbone angle distribution was also studied for the segment Ala3 surrounded by either three or eight amino acids on both N- and C-termini from a sequence derived from the protein hen egg white lysozyme. While the conformational distribution of the central three alanine residues in the 9mer is similar to that for the small peptides Ala(3)-Ala(7), major differences are found for the 19mer, which significantly (30-40%) samples alphaR helical stuctures.     

Systematic coarse-graining of nanoparticle interactions in molecular dynamics simulation

A recently developed multiscale coarse-graining procedure [Izvekov, S.; Voth, G. A. J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109, 2469] is extended to derive coarse-grained models for nanoparticles. The methodology is applied to C(60) and to carbonaceous nanoparticles produced in combustion environments. The coarse-graining of the interparticle force field is accomplished applying a force-matching procedure to data obtained from trajectories and forces from all-atom MD simulations. The CG models are shown to reproduce accurately the structural properties of the nanoparticle systems studied, while allowing for MD simulations of much larger self-assembled nanoparticle systems.     

A molecular dynamics study of water between Lennard-Jones walls

An MD simulation of 216 ST2 water molecules between 12-6 Lennard-Jones walls has been performed which extend over 20 ps at an average temperature of 287 K. The oxygen atom density profile is reported the influence of the walls on the orientation of the water molecules on the self-diffusion coefficient have been investigated The results are compared with those from MC and MD simulations of similar systems.     

Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations of the sphere to rod transition in surfactant micelles

Surfactant molecules self-assemble in aqueous solutions to form various micellar structures such as spheres, rods, or lamellae. Although phase transitions in surfactant solutions have been studied experimentally, their molecular mechanisms are still not well understood. In this work, we show that molecular dynamics (MD) simulations using the coarse-grained (CG) MARTINI force field and explicit CG solvent, validated against atomistic MD studies, can accurately represent micellar assemblies of cetyltrimethylammonium chloride (CTAC). The effect of salt on micellar structures is studied for aromatic anionic salts, e.g., sodium salicylate, and simple inorganic salts, e.g., sodium chloride. Above a threshold concentration, sodium salicylate induces a sphere to rod transition in the micelle. CG MD simulations are shown to capture the dynamics of this shape transition and support a mechanism based on the reduction in the micelle-water interfacial tension induced by the adsorption of the amphiphilic salicylate ions. At the threshold salt concentration, the interface is nearly saturated with adsorbed salicylate ions. Predictions of the effect of salt on the micelle structure in different CG solvent models, namely, single-site standard water and three-site polarizable water, show qualitative agreement. This suggests that phase transitions in aqueous micelle solutions could be investigated by using standard CG water models which allow for 3 orders of magnitude reduction in the computational time as compared to that required for atomistic MD simulations.     

Application of torsion angle molecular dynamics for efficient sampling of protein conformations

We investigate the application of torsion angle molecular dynamics (TAMD) to augment conformational sampling of peptides and proteins. Interesting conformational changes in proteins mainly involve torsional degrees of freedom. Carrying out molecular dynamics in torsion space does not only explicitly sample the most relevant degrees of freedom, but also allows larger integration time steps with elimination of the bond and angle degrees of freedom. However, the covalent geometry needs to be fixed during internal coordinate dynamics, which can introduce severe distortions to the underlying potential surface in the extensively parameterized modern Cartesian-based protein force fields. A "projection" approach (Katritch et al. J Comput Chem 2003, 24, 254-265) is extended to construct an accurate internal coordinate force field (ICFF) from a source Cartesian force field. Torsion crossterm corrections constructed from local molecular fragments, together with softened van der Waals and electrostatic interactions, are used to recover the potential surface and incorporate implicit bond and angle flexibility. MD simulations of dipeptide models demonstrate that full flexibility in both the backbone phi/psi and side chain chi1 angles are virtually restored. The efficacy of TAMD in enhancing conformational sampling is then further examined by folding simulations of small peptides and refinement experiments of protein NMR structures. The results show that an increase of several fold in conformational sampling efficiency can be reliably achieved. The current study also reveals some complicated intrinsic properties of internal coordinate dynamics, beyond energy conservation, that can limit the maximum size of the integration time step and thus the achievable gain in sampling efficiency.     

Isomolar semigrand ensemble molecular dynamics: development and application to liquid-liquid equilibria

An extended system molecular dynamics method for the isomolar semigrand ensemble (fixed number of particles, pressure, temperature, and fugacity fraction) is developed and applied to the calculation of liquid-liquid equilibria (LLE) for two Lennard-Jones mixtures. The method utilizes an extended system variable to dynamically control the fugacity fraction xi of the mixture by gradually transforming the identity of particles in the system. Two approaches are used to compute coexistence points. The first approach uses multiple-histogram reweighting techniques to determine the coexistence xi and compositions of each phase at temperatures near the upper critical solution temperature. The second approach, useful for cases in which there is no critical solution temperature, is based on principles of small system thermodynamics. In this case a coexistence point is found by running N-P-T-xi simulations at a common temperature and pressure and varying the fugacity fraction to map out the difference in chemical potential between the two species A and B (mu(A)-mu(B)) as a function of composition. Once this curve is known the equal-distance/equal-area criterion is used to determine the coexistence point. Both approaches give results that are comparable to those of previous Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. By formulating this approach in a molecular dynamics framework, it should be easier to compute the LLE of complex molecules whose intramolecular degrees of freedom are often difficult to properly sample with MC techniques.     

Simple and effective application of the Wang-Landau method for multicanonical molecular dynamics simulation

We propose a novel application of the Wang-Landau method (WLM) for multicanonical molecular dynamics (McMD) simulations. Originally, WLM was developed for Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Fundamentally, WLM remarkably reduces simulation efforts because it estimates the optimal multicanonical energy function automatically. When WLM is applied to McMD, not only the multicanonical energy but also energy gradient must be estimated adequately. However, because of the rugged multicanonical energy function at the early simulation stage, applications of WLM for MD simulations are difficult and require a smoothing procedure: simulation efforts such as cubic-spline extrapolation and gathering multiple preruns are utilized for smoothing. We propose a simple and effective smoothing method that requires only one additional equation and two time-dependent parameters. As a result, our method produced the correct multicanonical energy function and succeeded in the flat sampling of a small biomolecule with reduced simulation effort.