Directed graphs of structurally stable potential energy surfaces representing a-priori reaction pathways

An intrinsic property of potential energy surfaces (PES) that holds within the adiabatic approximation is established: its structural stability.We derive the condition that ensures this property: There cannot be any integral curve of the gradient field of the PES that connects two classical transition state configurations without passing through another critical configuration in between.Under this situation, we can establish a one-to-one correspondence: a whole class of adiabatic PES defining one reaction mechanism is associated to a directed graph. Thus, the problem of finding a-priori pathways involving a given number m of chemical species narrows down to a classifying certain directed graphs with m sinks. The combinatorial method is derived in this paper.Detailed examples on a-priori pathways for degenerate thermal rearrangements and on 1-2 hydrocarbon shifts are worked out and found in agreement with experimental evidence.     

Newton trajectories for finding stationary points on molecular potential energy surfaces

We present a new algorithm for computing Newton trajectories based on the Quadratic String Method (QSM) and explain how this can be used to find key stationary points on the molecular potential energy surface (PES). This method starts by using the intersections of Newton trajectories to locate stationary points on the PES. These points could then be used to determine the minimum energy path. The new method, called QSM-NT, is shown to be efficient and reliable for both analytical potential energy surfaces and potential energy surfaces computed from quantum chemistry calculations. The advantages and pitfalls of this method for exploring PES are discussed. In particular, the problem of discontinuous Newton trajectories is elucidated.     

Searching for saddle points of potential energy surfaces by following a reduced gradient

The old coordinate driving procedure to find transition structures in chemical systems is revisited. The well-known gradient criterion, ∇E( x )= 0 , which defines the stationary points of the potential energy surface (PES), is reduced by one equation corresponding to one search direction. In this manner, abstract curves can be defined connecting stationary points of the PES. Starting at a given minimum, one follows a well-selected coordinate to reach the saddle of interest. Usually, but not necessarily, this coordinate will be related to the reaction progress. The method, called reduced gradient following (RGF), locally has an explicit analytical definition. We present a predictor–corrector method for tracing such curves. RGF uses the gradient and the Hessian matrix or updates of the latter at every curve point. For the purpose of testing a whole surface, the six-dimensional PES of formaldehyde, H₂CO, was explored by RGF using the restricted Hartree–Fock (RHF) method and the STO-3G basis set. Forty-nine minima and saddle points of different indices were found. At least seven stationary points representing bonded structures were detected in addition to those located using another search algorithm on the same level of theory. Further examples are the localization of the saddle for the HCN⇌CNH isomerization (used for steplength tests) and for the ring closure of azidoazomethine to 1H-tetrazole. The results show that following the reduced gradient may represent a serious alternative to other methods used to locate saddle points in quantum chemistry. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 19: 1087–1100, 1998     

Potential energy surface of the reaction of imidazole with peroxynitrite: Density functional theory study

This article presents a theoretical investigation of the reaction mechanism of imidazole nitration by peroxynitrite using density functional theory calculations. Understanding this reaction mechanism will help in elucidating the mechanism of guanine nitration by peroxynitrite, which is one of the assumed chemical pathways for damaging DNA in cells. This work focuses on the analysis of the potential energy surface (PES) for this reaction in the gas phase. Calculations were carried out using Hartree–Fock (HF) and density functional theory (DFT) Hamiltonians with double‐zeta basis sets ranging from 6‐31G(d) to 6‐31++G(d,p), and the triple‐zeta basis set 6‐311G(d). The computational results reveal that the reaction of imidazole with peroxynitrite in gas phase produces the following species: (i) hydroxide ion and 2‐nitroimidazole, (ii) hydrogen superoxide ion and 2‐nitrosoimidazole, and (iii) water and 2‐nitroimidazolide. The rate‐determining step is the formation of a short‐lived intermediate in which the imidazole C₂ carbon is covalently bonded to peroxynitrite nitrogen. Three short‐lived intermediates were found in the reaction path. These intermediates are involved in a proton‐hopping transport from C₂ carbon to the terminal oxygen of the ? O? O moiety of peroxynitrite via the nitroso (ON? ) oxygen. Both HF and DFT calculations (using the Becke3–Lee–Yang–Parr functional) lead to similar reaction paths for proton transport, but the landscape details of the PES for HF and DFT calculations differ. This investigation shows that the reaction of imidazole with peroxynitrite produces essentially the same types of products (nitro‐ and nitroso‐) as observed experimentally in the reaction of guanine with peroxynitrite, which makes the former reaction a good model to study by computation the essential characteristics of the latter reaction. Nevertheless, the computationally determined activation energy for imidazole nitration by peroxynitrite in the gas phase is 84.1 kcal/mol (calculated at the B3LYP/6‐31++G(d,p) level), too large for an enzymatic reaction. Exploratory calculations on imidazole nitration in solution, and on the reaction of 9‐methylguanine with peroxynitrite in the gas phase and solution, show that solvation increases the activation energy for both imidazole and guanine, and that the modest decrease (15 kcal mol^?1) in the activation energy, due to the adjacent six member ring of guanine, is counterbalanced by solvation. These results lead to the speculation that proton tunneling may be at the origin of experimentally observed high reaction rate of guanine nitration by peroxynitrite in solution. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2005     

Global reaction route mapping on potential energy surfaces of formaldehyde, formic acid, and their metal-substituted analogues

Global reaction route mapping of equilibrium structures, transition structures, and their connections on potential energy surface (PES) has been done for MCHO (M = H, Li, Na, Al, Cu) and HCO2M (M = H, Li). A one-after-another technique based on the scaled hypersphere search method has been successfully applied to exploring unknown chemical structures, transition structures, and reaction pathways for organometallic systems. Upon metal substitution, considerable changes of stable structures, reaction pathways, and relative heights of transition structures have been discovered, though some features are similar among the analogues. Al and Cu atoms were found to behave as very strong scissors to cut the CO double bond in MCHO. Energy profiles of the CO insertion into Li-H and Li-CH3 bonds were found to be very similar, especially around the structures where the Li atom is not directly connected with the methyl group, which indicates little effects of alkyl substitution on the reaction route topology.     

Embedding of the saddle point of index two on the PES of the ring opening of cyclobutene

The ring opening of cyclobutene is characterized by a competition of the two different pathways: a usual pathway over a saddle of index one (SP₁) along the conrotatory behavior of the end groups, as well as a “forbidden” pathway over a saddle point of index two (SP₂) along the disrotatory behavior of the end CH₂ groups. We use the system of ordinary differential equations for the method of the gentlest ascent dynamics (GAD) to determine saddle points of the potential energy surface (PES) of the ring opening of cyclobutene to cis‐butadiene. We apply generalized GAD formulas for the search of a saddle point of index two. To understand the relation of the different regions of the PES (around minimums, around SPs of index one or two) we also calculate valley‐ridge inflection (VRI) points on the PES using Newton trajectories (NT). VRIs and the corresponding singular NTs subdivide the regions of “attraction” of the different SPs. We calculate the connections of the SP₂ (in its different symmetry versions) with different SPs of index one of the PES by different “reaction pathways.” We compare the possibilities of the tool of the GAD curves for the exploration of PESs with these of NT. The barrier of the disrotatory SP₂ is somewhat higher than the barrier of the conrotatory SP₁, however, pathways across the slope to the SP₂ open additional reaction valleys. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

New global potential energy surface of the MgH2 system and dynamics studies of the reaction H + MgH → Mg + H2

A new global potential energy surface for the ground state of MgH₂ was constructed using the permutation invariant polynomial neural network method. About 70 000 ab initio energy points were calculated via the multi‐reference configuration interaction method method with aug‐cc‐pVTZ and aug‐cc‐pVQZ basis sets, and these points were used to construct the potential energy surface (PES). To avoid basis set superposition error, the basis set was extrapolated to the complete basis set limit using the two point energy extrapolation formula. The root mean square error of the present PES is only 8.85 meV. Initial state (v = 0, j = 0) dynamics studies were performed using the time‐dependent wave packet method with a second‐order split operator for the total angular momentum J up to a value of 50. Furthermore, the reaction probability, integral cross section, and thermal rate constant are reported and compared with available theoretical studies.     

Global exploration of isomers and isomerization channels on the quantum chemical potential energy surface of H3CNO3

Global exploration of isomers and isomerization channels on the quantum chemical potential energy surface (PES) is performed for H₃CNO₃ using the Scaled Hypersphere Search‐Anharmonic Downward Distortion Following (SHS‐ADDF) method. The molecular formula of H₃CNO₃ includes functional groups of CH₃, OH, NH₂, COOH, NO, NO₂, and NO₃, which are very important in connection with amino acids and NOx. Geometrical structures and interconversion pathways are disclosed after 18719781 force calculations and 534726 Hessian calculations at the level of B3LYP/6‐31G(d). The explored results are confirmed to be valid, especially for the important lower energy regions, by re‐optimization at the higher level of B3LYP/6‐311++G(d,p). A global reaction route‐mapping using SHS‐ADDF demonstrates the entire view and undeveloped landscapes on PES of H₃CNO₃. Typical compounds of H₃CNO₃, aminoxy formic acid, hydroxycarbamic acid, aminoperformic acid, hydroxymethyl nitrite, nitromethanol, methyl nitrate, methyl peroxynitrite, and dioxaziridine, are well separated from others by very high energy‐barriers. The stable‐most conformer of H₃CNO₃ is difficult to be determined, because of seven structures existing with nearly the same energies within 5.7 kJ/mol at the level of CCSD(T)/aug‐cc‐pVTZ. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Using swarm intelligence for finding transition states and reaction paths

We describe an algorithm that explores potential energy surfaces (PES) and finds approximate reaction paths and transition states. A few (≈6) evolving atomic configurations ("climbers") start near a local minimum M1 of the PES. The climbers seek a shallow ascent, low energy, path toward a saddle point S12, cross over to another valley of the PES, and climb down to a new minimum M2 that was not known beforehand. Climbers use both energy and energy derivatives to make individual decisions, and they use relative fitness to make team-based decisions. In sufficiently long runs, they keep exploring and may go through a sequence M1-S12-M2-S23-M3 ... of minima and saddle points without revisiting any of the critical points. We report results on eight small test systems that highlight advantages and disadvantages of the method. We also investigated the PES of Li(8), Al(7)(+), Ag(7), and Ag(2)NH(3) to illustrate potential applications of this new method.     

Reaction rates in a theory of mechanochemical pathways

If one applies mechanical stress to a molecule in a defined direction then one generates a new, effective potential energy surface (PES). Changes for minima and saddle points (SP) by the stress are described by Newton trajectories on the original PES (Quapp and Bofill, Theor. Chem. Acc. 2016, 135, 113). The barrier of a reaction fully breaks down for the maximal value of the norm of the gradient of the PES along a pulling Newton trajectory. This point is named barrier breakdown point (BBP). Depending on the pulling direction, different reaction pathways can be enforced. If the exit SP of the chosen pulling direction is not the lowest SP of the reactant valley, on the original PES, then the SPs must change their role anywhere: in this case the curve of the log(rate) over the pulling force of a forward reaction can show a deviation from the normal concave curvature. We discuss simple, two‐dimensional examples for this model to understand more deeply the mechanochemistry of molecular systems under a mechanical stress. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Conformational analysis and flexibility of carbohydrates using the CICADA approach with MM3

The potential energy hypersurfaces (PES) of several carbohydrate molecules were studied with a new algorithm for conformational searches, CICADA (Channels in Conformational Space Analyzed by Driver Approach) interfaced with the molecular mechanics program MM3(92). The method requires (1) one or a few low-energy conformations as starting points; and (2) designation of the torsion angles important for understanding the conformational behavior of the molecule. The PES is explored by driving separately each selected torsion angle (in both directions) with a concomitant full-geometry optimization at each increment (except for the driven angle). When a minimum has been detected, the molecule is freely optimized, and the minima so detected are then stored if not encountered previously. The new minima serve as starting structures for further explorations. The results from CICADA permit prediction of relative and absolute flexibility and conformational softness for both the entire molecule as well as for individual group rotations and local minima. The carbohydrates analyzed were Me-α-D -glucopyranoside, β-D -GlcNAc(1-2)α-D -Man, and α-D -GalNAc(1-3)[α-L -Fuc(1-2)]Gal-O-Me. All the low-energy conformers along with the transition states and flexibilities features were characterized. CICADA found all minima and low-energy conversion pathways for the disaccharide that were found by a traditional grid search. In contrast to the grid search method, CICADA concentrates mostly on the exploration of the low-energy regions of the PES, thereby saving a significant amount of computational time. The performance of the method opens new routes for exploring conformational space of larger molecules, such as oligosaccharides. © 1995 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Hybridizing rapidly exploring random trees and basin hopping yields an improved exploration of energy landscapes

The number of local minima of the potential energy landscape (PEL) of molecular systems generally grows exponentially with the number of degrees of freedom, so that a crucial property of PEL exploration algorithms is their ability to identify local minima, which are low lying and diverse. In this work, we present a new exploration algorithm, retaining the ability of basin hopping (BH) to identify local minima, and that of transition based rapidly exploring random trees (T‐RRT) to foster the exploration of yet unexplored regions. This ability is obtained by interleaving calls to the extension procedures of BH and T‐RRT, and we show tuning the balance between these two types of calls allows the algorithm to focus on low lying regions. Computational efficiency is obtained using state‐of‐the art data structures, in particular for searching approximate nearest neighbors in metric spaces. We present results for the BLN69, a protein model whose conformational space has dimension 207 and whose PEL has been studied exhaustively. On this system, we show that the propensity of our algorithm to explore low lying regions of the landscape significantly outperforms those of BH and T‐RRT. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Global X2A′ potential energy surface of Li2H and quantum dynamics of H + Li2 (X1Σg+) → Li + LiH (X1Σ+) reaction

A global potential energy surface (PES) for the electronic ground state of Li₂H system is constructed over a large configuration space. About 30 000 ab initio energy points have been calculated by MRCI‐F12 method with aug‐cc‐pVTZ basis set. The neural network method is applied to fit the PES and the root mean square error of the current PES is only 1.296 meV. The reaction dynamics of the title reaction has been carried out by employing time‐dependent wave packet approach with second order split operator on the new PES. The reaction probability, integral cross section and thermal rate constant are obtained from the dynamics calculation. In most of the collision energy regions, the integral cross sections are in well agreement with the results reported by Gao et al. The rate constant calculated from the new PES increases in the temperature range of present investigation.     

Global mapping of equilibrium and transition structures on potential energy surfaces by the scaled hypersphere search method: applications to ab initio surfaces of formaldehyde and propyne molecules

Technical details of a new global mapping technique for finding equilibrium (EQ) and transition structures (TS) on potential energy surfaces (PES), the scaled hypersphere search (SHS) method (Ohno, K.; Maeda, S. Chem. Phys. Lett. 2004, 384, 277), are presented. On the basis of a simple principle that reaction pathways are found as anharmonic downward distortions of PES around an EQ point, the reaction pathways can be obtained as energy minima on the scaled hypersphere surface, which would have a constant energy when the potentials are harmonic. Connections of SHS paths between each EQ are very similar to corresponding intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) connections. The energy maximum along the SHS path reaches a region in close proximity to the TS of the reaction pathway, and the subsequent geometry optimization from the SHS maximum structure easily converges to the TS. The SHS method, using the one-after-another algorithm connecting EQ and TS, considerably reduces the multidimensional space to be searched to certain limited regions around the pathways connecting each EQ with the neighboring TS. Applications of the SHS method have been made to ab initio surfaces of formaldehyde and propyne molecules to obtain systematically five EQ and nine TS for formaldehyde and seven EQ and 32 TS for propyne.     

Dynamical properties and thermal rate coefficients for the Na + HF reaction using genetic algorithm

The genetic algorithm optimization technique (GAOT) was used to build a new potential energy surface (PES) to the Na + HF → NaF + H reaction. Quasi‐Classical Trajectories and Transition State Theory methods were used to obtain the dynamical properties and thermal rate coefficients (TRCs), respectively, of this new PES. These features were compared with the dynamical properties and TRCs available in the literature. It was found that the GAOT PES agrees very well with other PESs, in which the maximum difference found is smaller than 1.0 Ų for the cross‐sections. These results endow the GAOT approach as a method to build PESs of reactive scattering processes. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2010     

Global investigation on the potential energy surface of CH3CN: application of the scaled hypersphere search method

An extensive quantum chemical study of the potential energy surface (PES) for all possible isomerization and dissociation reactions of CH3CN is reported at the DFT (B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p)) and CCSD(T)/ cc-pVTZ//B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) levels of theory. The pathways around the equilibrium structures can be discovered by the scaled hypersphere search (SHS) method, which enables us to make a global analysis of the potential energy surface for a given chemical composition in combination with a downhill-walk algorithm. Seventeen equilibrium structures and 59 interconversion transition states have been found on the singlet PES. The four lowest lying isomers with thermodynamic stability are also kinetically stable with the lowest conversion barriers of 49.69-101.53 kcal/mol at the CCSD(T)/cc-pVTZ//B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) level, whereas three-membered-ring isomers c-CH2NCH, c-CH2CNH, and c-CHNHCH can be considered as metastable intermediates which can further convert into the low-lying chain-like isomers and higher lying acyclic isomers with the lowest conversion energies of 21.70-59.99 kcal/mol. Thirteen available dissociation channels depending on the different initial isomers have been identified. A prediction can be made for the possible mechanism explaining the migration of a hydrogen atom in competition with the CC bond dissociation. Several new energetically accessible pathways are found to be responsible for the migration of the hydrogen atom. The present results demonstrate that the SHS method is an efficient and powerful technique for global mapping of reaction pathways on PESs.     

Leading coordinate analysis of reaction pathways in proton chain transfer: Application to a two-proton transfer model for the green fluorescent protein

The ‘leading coordinate’ approach to computing an approximate reaction pathway, with subsequent determination of the true minimum energy profile, is applied to a two-proton chain transfer model based on the chromophore and its surrounding moieties within the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Using an ab initio quantum chemical method, a number of different relaxed energy profiles are found for several plausible guesses at leading coordinates. The results obtained for different trial leading coordinates are rationalized through the calculation of a two-dimensional relaxed potential energy surface (PES) for the system. Analysis of the 2-D relaxed PES reveals that two of the trial pathways are entirely spurious, while two others contain useful information and can be used to furnish starting points for successful saddle-point searches. Implications for selection of trial leading coordinates in this class of proton chain transfer reactions are discussed, and a simple diagnostic function is proposed for revealing whether or not a relaxed pathway based on a trial leading coordinate is likely to furnish useful information.     

Ab initio MO study of potential energy surface of NH2 with CN reaction

An extensive quantum chemical study of the potential energy surfaces (PES) for the association reaction of NH₂ with CN and the subsequent isomerization and dissociation reactions has been carried out using density functional theory (DFT)/B3LYP/6‐311++G(3df,2p) level of theory on both singlet and triplet states. The reaction mechanism on the triplet surface is more complicated than that on the singlet surface. A total of 19 isomers and 46 transition states have been identified and characterized on the triplet PES. Among them, IM2 (IM2a), IM3 (IM3a, IM3b), and IM10 are the lowest‐lying isomers with thermodynamic stability. Twenty available dissociation channels, depending on the different initial isomers, have been identified. On the singlet surface, only 12 isomers and 16 transition states have been found, and among them IM1(S) and IM2(S) are the lowest‐lying isomers. The higher isomerization and dissociation barriers on the singlet surface indicate that the addition and the subsequent reactions of NH₂+CN are most likely to occur on the triplet PES because of the lower barriers. A prediction can be made for the possible mechanism explaining the production of H+HNCN. Besides HNCN, other major products are NH+HCN and NH+HNC, which are produced by direct dissociation reactions from triplet IM2 and IM3, respectively. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2006     

Application of the modified Shepard interpolation method to the determination of the potential energy surface for a molecule-surface reaction: H2 + Pt(111)

We have used a modified Shepard (MS) interpolation method, initially developed for gas phase reactions, to build a potential energy surface (PES) for studying the dissociative chemisorption of H2 on Pt(111). The aim was to study the efficiency and the accuracy of this interpolation method for an activated multidimensional molecule-surface reactive problem. The strategy used is based on previous applications of the MS method to gas phase reactions, but modified to take into account special features of molecule-surface reactions, like the presence of many similar reaction pathways which vary only slightly with surface site. The efficiency of the interpolation method was tested by using an already existing PES to provide the input data required for the construction of the new PES. The construction of the new PES required half as many ab initio data points as the construction of the old PES, and the comparison of the two PESs shows that the method is able to reproduce with good accuracy the most important features of the H2 + Pt(111) interaction potential. Finally, accuracy tests were done by comparing the results of dynamics simulations using the two different PESs. The good agreement obtained for reaction probabilities and probabilities for rotationally and diffractionally inelastic scattering shows clearly that the MS interpolation method can be used efficiently to yield accurate PESs for activated molecule-surface reactions.     

Optimizing the structures of minimum and transition state on the free energy surface

Presented here is the application of a scheme for optimizing the structures of minima and transition states on the free energy surface (FES) for a path along a fixed reaction coordinate with the aid of ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulation. In the direction of the reaction coordinate, the values corresponding to the stationary points were optimized using the quasi-Newton method, in which the gradient of the free energy along the reaction coordinate was obtained by a constraint AIMD method, and the Bofill Hessian update scheme was used. The equilibrium values for the other directions were taken as the corresponding averages in the dynamic simulation. This scheme was applied to several elementary bimolecular addition reactions: (A) BH(3) + H(2)O --> H(2)O.BH(3); (B) BF(3) + NH(3) --> FB(3).NH(3); (C) SO(3) + NH(3) --> O(3)S.NH(3); (D) C(2)H(4) + CCl(2) --> H(4)C(2).CCl(2); (E) Ni(NH(2))(2) + PH(3) --> (NH(2))(2)Ni.PH(3); (F) W(CO)(5) + CO --> W(CO)(6). For reactions A, B, C, and F, no transition state (TS) exists on the potential energy surface (PES). However there is a TS on the FES. This stems from the curvature difference of the PES and -TDeltaS as a function of the reaction coordinate. For all reactions, it is found that the TS shifts toward the complexation product with increasing temperature because of the curvature increase of -TDeltaS. The equilibrium bond distances for the inactive coordinates perpendicular to the reaction coordinate always increase with temperature, which is due to the thermal excitation and anharmonicity of the PES.