In‐capillary approach to eliminate SDS interferences in antibody analysis by capillary electrophoresis coupled to mass spectrometry

Capillary electrophoresis is an important technique for the characterization of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), especially in the pharmaceutical context. However, identification is difficult as upscaling and hyphenation of used methods directly to mass spectrometry is often not possible due to separation medium components that are incompatible with MS detection. Here a CE‐MS method for the analysis of mAbs is presented analyzing SDS‐complexed samples. To obtain narrow and intensive peaks of SDS‐treated antibodies, an in‐capillary strategy was developed based on the co‐injection of positively charged surfactants and methanol as organic solvent. For samples containing 0.2% (v/v) of SDS, recovered MS peak intensities up to 97 and 95% were achieved using cetyltrimethylammonium bromide or benzalkonium chloride, respectively. Successful removal of SDS was shown in neutral coated capillaries but also in a capillary with a positively charged coating applying reversed polarity. The usefulness of this in‐capillary strategy was demonstrated also for other proteins and for antibodies dissolved in up to 10% v/v SDS solution, and in other SDS‐containing matrices, including the sieving matrix used in a standard CE‐SDS method and gel‐buffers applied in SDS‐PAGE methods. The developed CE‐MS approaches enable fast and reproducible characterization of SDS‐complexed antibodies.     

Development,validation, and implementation of capillary gel electrophoresis as a replacement for SDS‐PAGE for purity analysis of IgG2 mAbs

Capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE) methods with UV detection were developed for reduced and non‐reduced mAb analysis. These methods can be used to evaluate mAb purity, offering more reproducible quantitation compared with that of traditional SDS‐PAGE methods. These CGE methods have been utilized as platform technology for bioprocess development, formulation development, mAb characterization, drug substance/drug product release testing as well as a required methodology for stability testing. We have found these CGE methods to be applicable across a platform of mAbs in preclinical and clinical development, with the majority of mAbs requiring no modification to the method conditions. This methodology has been ICH validated and transferred to several supporting organizations. The data presented herein describes the development of CGE methodology, platform application to mAb purity analysis, ICH validation, reliability metrics, and considerations on technology enhancement for improved performance and throughput.     

Applications of CE SDS gel in development of biopharmaceutical antibody-based products

CE SDS gel technique offers many advantages over the traditional labor-intensive SDS PAGE slab gel technology. The CE-based method has increasingly been applied to many protein analysis applications. Specific examples are provided for monoclonal antibody (mAb), though the technique can be adapted to many other therapeutic protein products. Applications of CE SDS gel method using Beckman PA800 with UV detection are presented and discussed with respect to mAb analysis, such as purity, quantitation of non-glycosylated heavy chain (NGHC) peak, identity, and stability. The stability of mAb is evaluated with respect to formulation buffer, accelerated temperature stress, UV light-exposure, and high pH conditions. Both reducing and non-reducing CE SDS gel conditions were applied and optimized to characterize mAb products. The data presented provides a "taste" of what CE SDS gel method can do to support the development of mAb products from early clone screening for product quality to the final product characterization. Since the CE SDS gel method is automatable, quantitative, robust, and allows for relatively high throughput, it provides both great analytical capacity and product coverage for a wide spectrum of protein product development in biopharmaceutical industry.     

MALDI analysis of proteins after extraction from dissolvable ethylene glycol diacrylate cross‐linked polyacrylamide gels

Although the extraction of intact proteins from polyacrylamide gels followed by mass spectrometric molecular mass determination has been shown to be efficient, there is room for alternative approaches. Our study evaluates ethylene glycol diacrylate, a cleavable cross‐linking agent used for a new type of dissolvable gels. It attains an ester linkage that can be hydrolyzed in alkali conditions. The separation performance of the new gel system was tested by 1D and 2D SDS‐PAGE using the outer chloroplast envelope of Pisum sativum as well as a soluble protein fraction of human lymphocytes, respectively. Gel spot staining (CBB), dissolving, and extracting were conducted using a custom‐developed workflow. It includes protein extraction with an ammonia–SDS buffer followed by methanol treatment to remove acrylamide filaments. Necessary purification for MALDI‐TOF analysis was implemented using methanol–chloroform precipitation and perfusion HPLC. Both cleaning procedures were applied to several standard proteins of different molecular weight as well as ‘real’ biological samples (8–75 kDa). The protein amounts, which had to be loaded on the gel to detect a peak in MALDI‐TOF MS, were in the range of 0.1 to 5 μg, and the required amount increased with increasing mass.     

Evaluation of agarose gel electrophoresis for characterization of silver nanoparticles in industrial products

Agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE) has been used extensively for characterization of pure nanomaterials or mixtures of pure nanomaterials. We have evaluated the use of AGE for characterization of Ag nanoparticles (NPs) in an industrial product (described as strong antiseptic). Influence of different stabilizing agents (PEG, SDS, and sodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate), buffers (TBE and Tris Glycine), and functionalizing agents (mercaptosuccinic acid (TMA) and proteins) has been investigated for the characterization of AgNPs in the industrial product using different sizes‐AgNPs standards. The use of 1% SDS, 0.1% TMA, and Tris Glycine in gel, electrophoresis buffer and loading buffer led to the different sizes‐AgNPs standards moved according to their size/charge ratio (obtaining a linear relationship between apparent mobility and mean diameter). After using SDS and TMA, the behavior of the AgNPs in the industrial product (containing a casein matrix) was completely different, being not possible their size characterization. However we demonstrated that AGE with LA‐ICP‐MS detection is an alternative method to confirm the protein corona formation between the industrial product and two proteins (BSA and transferrin) maintaining NPs‐protein binding (what is not possible using SDS‐PAGE).     

Simplified method for concentration of mitochondrial membrane protein complexes

Extracting and concentrating mitochondrial protein complexes from gel strips after blue native PAGE (BN‐PAGE) can be daunting tasks using the traditional methods, such as electroelution, passive diffusion and centrifugal concentration. We present a simplified gel electrophoresis method to concentrate mitochondrial protein complexes with excellent recovery rate. Mitochondrial complex I present in a long gel strip from BN‐PAGE can be easily concentrated into a 0.8 cm gel strip when a second BN‐PAGE is performed with a Y‐shaped gel and the addition of 0.01% n‐dodecyl β‐D ‐maltoside and 0.001% SDS in the cathode buffer. Once completed, the concentrated protein complex in the gel strip is ready for SDS‐PAGE or proteomic studies.     

Simultaneous electrophoretic analysis of proteins of very high and low molecular mass using Tris‐acetate polyacrylamide gels

To separate and analyze giant and small proteins in the same electrophoresis gel, we have used a 3–15% polyacrylamide gradient gel containing 2.6% of the crosslinker bisacrylamide and 0.2 M of Tris‐acetate buffer (pH 7.0). Samples were prepared in a sample buffer containing lithium dodecyl sulphate and were run in the gel described above using Tris‐Tricine‐SDS‐sodium bisulfite buffer, pH 8.2, as electrophoresis buffer. Here, we show that this system can be successfully used for general applications of SDS‐PAGE such as CBB staining and immunoblot. Thus, by using Tris‐acetate 3–15% polyacrylamide gels, it is possible to simultaneously analyze proteins, in the mass range of 10–500 kDa, such as HERC1 (532 kDa), HERC2 (528 kDa), mTOR (289 kDa), Clathrin heavy chain (192 kDa), RSK (90 kDa), S6K (70 kDa), β‐actin (42 kDa), Ran (24 kDa) and LC3 (18 kDa). This system is highly sensitive since it allows detection from as low as 10 μg of total protein per lane. Moreover, it has a good resolution, low cost, high reproducibility and allows for analysis of proteins in a wide range of weights within a short period of time. All these features together with the use of a standard electrophoresis apparatus make the Tris‐acetate‐PAGE system a very helpful tool for protein analysis.     

A multichannel gel electrophoresis and continuous fraction collection apparatus for high‐throughput protein separation and characterization

To facilitate a direct interface between protein separation by PAGE and protein identification by mass spectrometry, we developed a multichannel system that continuously collects fractions as protein bands migrate off the bottom of gel electrophoresis columns. The device was constructed using several short linear gel columns, each of a different percent acrylamide, to achieve a separation power similar to that of a long gradient gel. A “Counter Free‐Flow” elution technique then allows continuous and simultaneous fraction collection from multiple channels at low cost. We demonstrate that rapid, high‐resolution separation of a complex protein mixture can be achieved on this system using SDS‐PAGE. In a 2.5 h electrophoresis run, for example, each sample was separated and eluted into 48–96 fractions over a mass range of ～10–150 kDa; sample recovery rates were 50% or higher; each channel was loaded with up to 0.3 mg of protein in 0.4 mL; and a purified band was eluted in two to three fractions (200 μL/fraction). Similar results were obtained when running native gel electrophoresis, but protein aggregation limited the loading capacity to about 50 μg per channel and reduced resolution.     

Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis of Insulin

Abstract

Four kinds of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) were applied to insulin and peroxynitrite‐treated insulin. The Native‐PAGE had a better resolution than sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)‐PAGE, SDS‐urea‐PAGE, and even Tricine‐SDS‐PAGE. Reduction and nonreduction of insulin and peroxynitrite‐treated insulin in Native‐PAGE showed that four tyrosine residues in insulin molecular could be nitrated by peroxynitrite and that alkylation with iodoacetamide was better than no alkylation and alkylation with iodoacetic acid, which would introduce negative charges to the peptides. The method of Native‐PAGE was suitable to analysis of insulin and its analogs, even other peptides of low molecular weight.     

Property and Application of BACy‐Based Functional Hydrogels

Conventional polyacrylamide hydrogels prepared from the free radical polymerization between acrylamide and N,N′‐methylenebisacrylamide (NMBA) have been frequently used in the biochemical technique like the sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS‐PAGE) to resolve protein mixtures. In this study, we have prepared an alternative polyacrylamide hydrogel from the cross‐linking of acrylamide and N,N′‐bisacrylylcystamine (BACy). In addition, we have compared the BACy‐based hydrogel with the NMBA‐based polyacrylamide hydrogel for their physical properties such as swelling ratio, shear modulus, crosslink density and morphology. Moreover, we further determined whether BACy‐based polyacrylamide hydrogel could be applied to SDS‐PAGE and proteomics research. The results showed that this type of hydrogel is capable of separating proteins and facilitates further in‐gel protein digestion and the following protein identifications by mass spectrometry. In summary, our study provides a basis for the putative application of BACy‐based hydrogels.     

Development of a novel two-dimensional gel electrophoresis protocol with agarose native gel electrophoresis

A new protocol for conducting two-dimensional (2D) electrophoresis was developed by combining the recently developed agarose native gel electrophoresis with either vertical sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) or flat SDS agarose gel electrophoresis. Our innovative technique utilizes His/MES buffer (pH 6.1) during the first-dimensional (1D) agarose native gel electrophoresis, which allows for the simultaneous and clear visualization of basic and acidic proteins in their native states or complex structures. Our agarose gel electrophoresis is a true native electrophoresis, unlike blue native–PAGE, which relies on the intrinsic charged states of the proteins and their complexes without the need for dye binding. In the 2D, the gel strip from the 1D agarose gel electrophoresis is soaked in SDS and placed on top of the vertical SDS–PAGE gels or the edge of the flat SDS–MetaPhor high-resolution agarose gels. This allows for customized operation using a single electrophoresis device at a low cost. This technique has been successfully applied to analyze various proteins, including five model proteins (BSA, factor Xa, ovotransferrin, IgG, and lysozyme), monoclonal antibodies with slightly different isoelectric points, polyclonal antibodies, and antigen–antibody complexes, as well as complex proteins such as IgM pentamer and β-galactosidase tetramer. Our protocol can be completed within a day, taking approximately 5–6 h, and can be expanded further into Western blot analysis, mass spectrometry analysis, and other analytical methods.     

Complementary middle‐down and intact monoclonal antibody proteoform characterization by capillary zone electrophoresis – mass spectrometry

High‐resolution capillary zone electrophoresis – mass spectrometry (CZE‐MS) has been of increasing interest for the analysis of biopharmaceuticals. In this work, a combination of middle‐down and intact CZE‐MS analyses has been implemented for the characterization of a biotherapeutic monoclonal antibody (mAb) with a variety of post‐translational modifications (PTMs) and glycosylation structures. Middle‐down and intact CZE separations were performed in an acidified methanol‐water background electrolyte on a capillary with a positively charged coating (M7C4I) coupled to an Orbitrap mass spectrometer using a commercial sheathless interface (CESI). Middle‐down analysis of the IdeS‐digested mAb provided characterization of PTMs of digestion fragments. High resolution CZE enabled separation of charge variants corresponding to 2X‐deamidated, 1X‐deamidated, and non‐deamidated forms at baseline resolution. In the course of the middle‐down CZE‐MS analysis, separation of glycoforms of the F_C/2 fragment was accomplished due to hydrodynamic volume differences. Several identified PTMs were confirmed by CZE‐MS². Incorporation of TCEP‐HCl reducing agent in the sample solvent resulted in successful analysis of reduced forms without the need for alkylation. CZE‐MS studies on the intact mAb under denaturing conditions enabled baseline separation of the 2X‐glycosylated, 1X‐glycosylated, and aglycosylated populations as a result of hydrodynamic volume differences. The presence of a trace quantity of dissociated light chain was also detected in the intact protein analysis. Characterization of the mAb under native conditions verified identifications achieved via intact analysis and allowed for quantitative confirmation of proteoforms. Analysis of mAbs using CZE‐MS represents a complementary approach to the more conventional liquid‐chromatography – mass spectrometry‐based approaches.     

Separation and recovery of nucleic acids with improved biological activity by acid‐degradable polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

One of the fundamental challenges in studying biomacromolecules (e.g. nucleic acids and proteins) and their complexes in a biological system is isolating them in their structurally and functionally intact forms. Electrophoresis offers convenient and efficient separation and analysis of biomacromolecules but recovery of separated biomacromolecules is a significant challenge. In this study, DNAs of various sizes were separated by electrophoresis in an acid‐degradable polyacrylamide gel. Almost 100% of the nucleic acids were recovered after the identified gel bands were hydrolyzed under a mildly acidic condition and purified using anion exchange resin. Further concentration by centrifugal filtration and a second purification using ion exchange column chromatography yielded 44–84% of DNA. The second conventional (non‐degradable) gel electrophoresis confirmed that the nucleic acids recovered from acid‐degradable gel bands preserved their electrophoretic properties through acidic gel hydrolysis, purification, and concentration processes. The plasmid DNA recovered from acid‐degradable gel transfected cells significantly more efficiently than the starting plasmid DNA (i.e. improved biological activity via acid‐degradable PAGE). Separation of other types of nucleic acids such as small interfering RNA using this convenient and efficient technique was also demonstrated.     

Comparison of antimicrobial peptide purification via free‐flow electrophoresis and gel filtration chromatography

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are usually small and cationic biomolecules with broad‐spectrum antimicrobial activities against pathogens. Purifying them from complex samples is essential to study their physiochemical properties. In this work, free‐flow zone electrophoresis (FFZE) was utilized to purify AMPs from yeast fermentation broth. Meanwhile, gel filtration chromatography (GFC) was conducted for comparison. The separation efficiency was evaluated by SDS‐PAGE analysis of the fractions from both methods. Our results demonstrated as follows: (i) FFZE had more than 30‐fold higher processing capacity as compared with GFC; (ii) FFZE could achieve 87% purity and 89% recovery rate while in GFC these parameters were about 93 and 82%, respectively; (iii) the former had ∼2‐fold dilution but the latter had ∼13‐fold dilution. Furthermore, Tricine‐SDS‐PAGE, Native‐PAGE, and gel IEF were carried out to characterize the purified AMPs. We found that two peptides existed as a pair with the molecular mass of ∼5.5 and 7.0 kDa, while the same pI 7.8. These two peptides were proved to have the antimicrobial activity through the standardized agar diffusion method. Therefore, FFZE could be used to continuously purify AMPs with high bioactivity, which will lead to its wide application in the clinical and pharmaceutical fields.     

Mass spectrometric characterization of the zein protein composition in maize flour extracts upon protein separation by SDS‐PAGE and 2D gel electrophoresis

Highly homogenous α zein protein was isolated from maize kernels in an environment‐friendly process using 95% ethanol as solvent. Due to the polyploidy and genetic polymorphism of the plant source, the application of high resolution separation methods in conjunction with precise analytical methods, such as MALDI‐TOF‐MS, is required to accurately estimate homogeneity of products that contain natural zein protein. The α zein protein product revealed two main bands in SDS‐PAGE analysis, one at 25 kDa and other at 20 kDa apparent molecular mass. Yet, high resolution 2DE revealed approximately five protein spot groups in each row, the first at ca. 25 kDa and the second at ca. 20 kDa. Peptide mass fingerprinting data of the proteins in the two dominant SDS‐PAGE bands matched to 30 amino acid sequence entries out of 102 non‐redundant data base entries. MALDI‐TOF‐MS peptide mapping of the proteins from all spots indicated the presence of only α zein proteins. The most prominent ion signals in the MALDI mass spectra of the protein mixture of the 25 kDa SDS gel band after in‐gel digestion were found at m/z 1272.6 and m/z 2009.1, and the most prominent ion signals of the protein mixture of the 20 kDa band after in‐gel digestion were recorded at m/z 1083.5 and m/z 1691.8. These ion signals have been found typical for α zein proteins and may serve as marker ion signals which upon chymotryptic digestion reliably indicate the presence of α zein protein in two hybrid corn products.     

In‐gel equilibration for improved protein retention in 2DE‐based proteomic workflows

The 2DE is a powerful proteomic technique, with excellent protein separation capabilities where intact proteins are spatially separated by pI and molecular weight. 2DE is commonly used in conjunction with MS to identify proteins of interest. Current 2DE workflow requires several manual processing steps that can lead to experimental variability and sample loss. One such step is the transition between first dimension IEF and second‐dimension SDS‐PAGE, which requires exchanging denaturants and the reduction and alkylation of proteins. This in‐solution‐based equilibration step has been shown to be rather inefficient, losing up to 30% of the original starting material through diffusion effects. We have developed a refinement of this equilibration step using agarose stacking gels poured on top of the second‐dimension SDS‐PAGE gel, referred to as in‐gel equilibration. We show that in‐gel equilibration is effective at reduction and alkylation in SDS‐PAGE gels. Quantification of whole‐cell extracts separated on 2DE gels shows that in‐gel equilibration increases protein retention, decreased intergel variability, and simplifies 2DE workflow.     

Loss of PEG chain in routine SDS‐PAGE analysis of PEG‐maleimide modified protein

SDS‐PAGE represents a quick and simple method for qualitative and quantitative analysis of protein and protein‐containing conjugates, mostly pegylated proteins. PEG‐maleimide (MAL) is frequently used to site‐specifically pegylate therapeutic proteins via free cysteine residue by forming a thiosuccinimide structure for pursuing homogeneous products. The C–S linkage between protein and PEG‐MAL is generally thought to be relatively stable. However, loss of intact PEG chain in routine SDS‐PAGE analysis of PEG‐maleimide modified protein was observed. It is a thiol‐independent thioether cleavage and the shedding of PEG chain exclusively happens to PEG‐MAL modified conjugates although PEG‐vinylsulfone conjugates to thiol‐containing proteins also through a C–S linkage. Cleavage kinetics of PEG40k‐MAL modified ciliary neurotrophic factor showed this kind of degradation could immediately happen even in 1 min incubation at high temperature and could be detected at physiological temperature and pH, although the rate was relatively slow. This may provide another degradation route for maleimide‐thiol conjugate irrespective of reactive thiol, although the specific mechanism is still not very clear for us. It would also offer a basis for accurate characterization of PEG‐MAL modified protein/peptide by SDS‐PAGE analysis.     

Performance of nondenaturing micro 2-DE followed by third-dimension SDS-PAGE in the analysis of Escherichia coli soluble proteins

In a previous paper, we reported on the analysis of Escherichia coli (strain K‐12) soluble proteins by nondenaturing micro 2‐DE/3‐DE and MALDI‐MS‐PMF [Manabe, T., Jin, Y., Electrophoresis 2010, 31, 2740–2748]. To evaluate the performance of the 2‐DE/3‐DE technique, a nondenaturing 2‐DE gel just after the second‐dimension run was cut into 12 vertical strips, each 2 mm‐wide strip was set on a micro slab gel, and third‐dimension SDS‐PAGE was run in parallel. Each of the twelve 3‐DE gels showed about 150–200 CBB‐stained spots. Two of the 3‐DE gels were selected for the assignment of polypeptides using MALDI‐MS‐PMF and totally 161 polypeptides were assigned on the two 3‐DE gels, in which 81 have been assigned on the nondenaturing micro 2‐DE gel and 80 were newly assigned. Most of the newly assigned polypeptides resided in faintly stained spots on the 3‐DE gels, which indicates that the polypeptides were purified in the process of the third‐dimension separation. The comparisons of the apparent mass values estimated from the second‐dimension (nondenaturing pore‐gradient PAGE) mobility with those estimated from the third‐dimension (SDS‐PAGE) mobility suggested the oligomer structures of the assigned polypeptides and they matched well with those described in a database (UniProtKnowledgebase). The technique of nondenaturing micro 2‐DE/3‐DE, combined with MALDI‐MS‐PMF, could become an efficient method to obtain information on the quaternary structures of hundreds of cellular soluble proteins simultaneously because of its high efficiency in protein/polypeptide separation and assignment.     

Addition of urea and thiourea to electrophoresis sample buffer improves efficiency of protein extraction from TCA/acetone‐treated smooth muscle tissues for phos‐tag SDS‐PAGE

Phosphorylation analysis by using phos‐tag technique has been reported to be suitable for highly sensitive quantification of smooth muscle myosin regulatory light chain (LC₂₀) phosphorylation. However, there is another factor that will affect the sensitivity of phosphorylation analysis, that is, protein extraction. Here, we optimized the conditions for total protein extraction out of trichloroacetic acid (TCA)‐fixed tissues. Standard SDS sample buffer extracted less LC₂₀, actin and myosin phosphatase targeting subunit 1 (MYPT1) from TCA/acetone treated ciliary muscle strips. On the other hand, sample buffer containing urea and thiourea in addition to lithium dodecyl sulfate (LDS) or SDS extracted those proteins more efficiently, and thus increased the detection sensitivity up to 4–5 fold. Phos‐tag SDS‐PAGE separated dephosphorylated and phosphorylated LC₂₀s extracted in LDS/urea/thiourea sample buffer to the same extent as those in standard SDS buffer. We have concluded that LDS (or SDS) /urea/thiourea sample buffer is suitable for highly sensitive phosphorylation analysis in smooth muscle, especially when it is treated with TCA/acetone.     

Quantitative monitoring of His and Asp phosphorylation in a bacterial signaling system by using Phos‐tag Magenta/Cyan fluorescent dyes

In the bacterial signaling mechanisms known as two‐component systems (TCSs), signals are generally conveyed by means of a His–Asp phosphorelay. Each system consists of a histidine kinase (HK) and its cognate response regulator. Because of the labile nature of phosphorylated His and Asp residues, few approaches are available that permit a quantitative analysis of their phosphorylation status. Here, we show that the Phos‐tag dye technology is suitable for the fluorescent detection of His‐ and Asp‐phosphorylated proteins separated by SDS‐PAGE. The dynamics of the His–Asp phosphorelay of recombinant EnvZ‐OmpR, a TCS derived from Escherichia coli, were examined by SDS‐PAGE followed by simple rapid staining with Phos‐tag Magenta fluorescent dye. The technique permitted not only the quantitative monitoring of the autophosphorylation reactions of EnvZ and OmpR in the presence of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) or acetyl phosphate, respectively, but also that of the phosphotransfer reaction from EnvZ to OmpR, which occurs within 1 min in the presence of ATP. Furthermore, we demonstrate profiling of waldiomycin, an HK inhibitor, by using the Phos‐tag Cyan gel staining. We believe that the Phos‐tag dye technology provides a simple and convenient fluorometric approach for screening of HK inhibitors that have potential as new antimicrobial agents.