Coherent switching with decay of mixing: an improved treatment of electronic coherence for non-Born-Oppenheimer trajectories

The self-consistent decay-of-mixing (SCDM) semiclassical trajectory method for electronically nonadiabatic dynamics is improved by modifying the switching probability that determines the instantaneous electronic state toward which the system decoheres. This method is called coherent switching with decay of mixing (CSDM), and it differs from the previously presented SCDM method in that the electronic amplitudes controlling the switching of the decoherent state are treated fully coherently in the electronic equations of motion for each complete passage through a strong interaction region. It is tested against accurate quantum mechanical calculations for 12 atom-diatom scattering test cases. Also tested are the SCDM method and the trajectory surface hopping method of Parlant and Gislason that requires coherent passages through each strong interaction region, and which we call the "exact complete passage" trajectory surface hopping (ECP-TSH) method. The results are compared with previously presented results for the fewest switches with time uncertainty and Tully's fewest switches (TFS) surface hopping methods and the semiclassical Ehrenfest method. We find that the CSDM method is the most accurate of the semiclassical trajectory methods tested. Including coherent passages improves the accuracy of the SCDM method (i.e., the CSDM method is more accurate than the SCDM method) but not of the trajectory surface hopping method (i.e., the ECP-TSH method is not more accurate on average than the TFS method).     

Conical intersections and semiclassical trajectories: comparison to accurate quantum dynamics and analyses of the trajectories

Semiclassical trajectory methods are tested for electronically nonadiabatic systems with conical intersections. Five triatomic model systems are presented, and each system features two electronic states that intersect via a seam of conical intersections (CIs). Fully converged, full-dimensional quantum mechanical scattering calculations are carried out for all five systems at energies that allow for electronic de-excitation via the seam of CIs. Several semiclassical trajectory methods are tested against the accurate quantum mechanical results. For four of the five model systems, the diabatic representation is the preferred (most accurate) representation for semiclassical trajectories, as correctly predicted by the Calaveras County criterion. Four surface hopping methods are tested and have overall relative errors of 40%-60%. The semiclassical Ehrenfest method has an overall error of 66%, and the self-consistent decay of mixing (SCDM) and coherent switches with decay of mixing (CSDM) methods are the most accurate methods overall with relative errors of approximately 32%. Furthermore, the CSDM method is less representation dependent than both the SCDM and the surface hopping methods, making it the preferred semiclassical trajectory method. Finally, the behavior of semiclassical trajectories near conical intersections is discussed.     

Algorithmic decoherence time for decay-of-mixing non-Born-Oppenheimer dynamics

The performance of an analytical expression for algorithmic decoherence time is investigated for non-Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics. There are two terms in the function that represents the dependence of the decoherence time on the system parameters; one represents decoherence due to the quantum time-energy uncertainty principle and the other represents a back reaction from the decoherent force on the classical trajectory. We particularly examine the question of whether the first term should dominate. Five one-dimensional two-state model systems that represent limits of multidimensional nonadiabatic dynamics are designed for testing mixed quantum-classical methods and for comparing semiclassical calculations with exact quantum calculations. Simulations are carried out with the semiclassical Ehrenfest method (SE), Tully's fewest switch version (TFS) of the trajectory surface hopping method, and the decay-of-mixing method with natural switching, coherent switching (CSDM), and coherent switching with reinitiation (CSDM-D). The CSDM method is demonstrated to be the most accurate method, and it has several desirable features: (i) It behaves like the representation-independent SE method in the strong nonadiabatic coupling regions; (ii) it behaves physically like the TFS method in noninteractive region; and (iii) the trajectories are continuous with continuous momenta. The CSDM method is also demonstrated to balance coherence well with decoherence, and the results are nearly independent of whether one uses the adiabatic or diabatic representation. The present results provide new insight into the formulation of a physically correct decoherence time to be used with the CSDM method for non-Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamic simulations.     

Non-Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics of Na...FH photodissociation

The accuracy of non-Born-Oppenheimer (electronically nonadiabatic) semiclassical trajectory methods for simulations of "deep quantum" systems is reevaluated in light of recent quantum mechanical calculations of the photodissociation of the Na...FH van der Waals complex. In contrast to the conclusion arrived at in an earlier study, semiclassical trajectory methods are shown to be qualitatively accurate for this system, thus further validating their use for systems with large electronic energy gaps. Product branching in semiclassical surface hopping and decay-of-mixing calculations is affected by a region of coupling where the excited state is energetically forbidden. Frustrated hops in this region may be attributed to a failure of the treatment of decoherence, and a stochastic model for decoherence is introduced into the surface hopping method and is shown to improve the agreement with the quantum mechanical results. A modification of the decay-of-mixing method resulting in faster decoherence in this region is shown to give similarly improved results.     

Adiabatic states derived from a spin-coupled diabatic transformation: semiclassical trajectory study of photodissociation of HBr and the construction of potential curves for LiBr+

The development of spin-coupled diabatic representations for theoretical semiclassical treatments of photodissociation dynamics is an important practical goal, and some of the assumptions required to carry this out may be validated by applications to simple systems. With this objective, we report here a study of the photodissociation dynamics of the prototypical HBr system using semiclassical trajectory methods. The valence (spin-free) potential energy curves and the permanent and transition dipole moments were computed using high-level ab initio methods and were transformed to a spin-coupled diabatic representation. The spin-orbit coupling used in the transformation was taken as that of atomic bromine at all internuclear distances. Adiabatic potential energy curves, nonadiabatic couplings and transition dipole moments were then obtained from the diabatic ones and were used in all the dynamics calculations. Nonadiabatic photodissociation probabilities were computed using three semiclassical trajectory methods, namely, coherent switching with decay of mixing (CSDM), fewest switches with time uncertainty (FSTU), and its recently developed variant with stochastic decoherence (FTSU/SD), each combined with semiclassical sampling of the initial vibrational state. The calculated branching fraction to the higher fine-structure level of the bromine atom is in good agreement with experiment and with more complete theoretical treatments. The present study, by comparing our new calculations to wave packet calculations with distance-dependent ab initio spin-orbit coupling, validates the semiclassical trajectory methods, the semiclassical initial state sample scheme, and the use of a distance-independent spin-orbit coupling for future applications to polyatomic photodissociation. Finally, using LiBr(+) as a model system, it is shown that accurate spin-coupled potential curves can also be constructed for odd-electron systems using the same strategy as for HBr.     

Independent trajectory implementation of the semiclassical Liouville method: application to multidimensional reaction dynamics

We describe an independent trajectory implementation of semiclassical Liouville method for simulating quantum processes using classical trajectories. In this approach, a single ensemble of trajectories describes all semiclassical density matrix elements of a coupled electronic state problem, with the ensemble evolving classically under a single reference Hamiltonian chosen on the basis of physical grounds. In this paper, we introduce an additional uncoupled trajectory approximation, allowing the members of the ensemble to evolve independently of one another and eliminating the major computational costs of our previous coupled trajectory implementation. The accuracy of the method is demonstrated for model one-dimensional problems. In addition, the approach is applied to the chemical reaction dynamics of a collinear triatomic system, yielding excellent agreement with exact calculations. This method allows molecular dynamics involving coupled electronic surfaces to be modeled with essentially the same effort as classical molecular dynamics and ensemble averaging.     

Characterizing the mechanism of the double proton transfer in the formamide dimer

The double proton transfer in the formamide dimer is characterized computationally by combining density functional theory and ab initio methods. The intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) is obtained at the B3LYP level of theory. Energies of several points along the IRC are treated by the more rigorous focal point method to test the validity of the B3LYP functional. The reaction mechanism is examined in terms of the energy profile, the reaction force, the chemical potential, and the reaction electronic flux. The energy profile for the activation process of the formamide dimer to the imino ether product obtained with the B3LYP functional is in agreement with the results of the focal point method. Together with the reaction force analysis and the reaction electronic flux a precise assignment of the structural and electronic contributions to the activation barrier becomes possible. The results show that the reaction starts with a structural rearrangement, where the two dimers approach each other, and is followed by electronic changes before the system reaches the transition state. This electronic contribution to the activation barrier steers the activation process. After the transition state is reached, deviations of the B3LYP functional from the more accurate focal point energies become apparent, where the errors may be rationalized in terms of the treatment of exchange. The inconsistency could be assigned to the incapacity of the functional to describe delocalization effects over the whole system.     

On nonadiabatic transition state theory

A nonseparable semiclassical transition state approximation for reactions involving more than one electronic surface is suggested. The single surface formulation in terms of quasiprobability distributions used by Miller is discussed along with a separable semiclassical approximation for the nonadiabatic rate suggested in the Soviet literature. A thermally averaged nonadiabatic rate is defined, and a semiclassical approximation is presented, wherein the surface through which flux is calculated in the transition state approach is determined by the intersection of adiabatic electronic surfaces viewed as functions of imaginary (or complex) time.     

Mixed quantum/classical investigation of the photodissociation of NH3(A) and a practical method for maintaining zero-point energy in classical trajectories

The photodissociation dynamics of ammonia upon excitation of the out-of-plane bending mode (mode nu(2) with n(2)=0,[ellipsis (horizontal)],6 quanta of vibration) in the A electronic state is investigated by means of several mixed quantum/classical methods, and the calculated final-state properties are compared to experiments. Five mixed quantum/classical methods are tested: one mean-field approach (the coherent switching with decay of mixing method), two surface-hopping methods [the fewest switches with time uncertainty (FSTU) and FSTU with stochastic decay (FSTU/SD) methods], and two surface-hopping methods with zero-point energy (ZPE) maintenance [the FSTUSD+trajectory projection onto ZPE orbit (TRAPZ) and FSTUSD+minimal TRAPZ (mTRAPZ) methods]. We found a qualitative difference between final NH(2) internal energy distributions obtained for n(2)=0 and n(2)>1, as observed in experiments. Distributions obtained for n(2)=1 present an intermediate behavior between distributions obtained for smaller and larger n(2) values. The dynamics is found to be highly electronically nonadiabatic with all these methods. NH(2) internal energy distributions may have a negative energy tail when the ZPE is not maintained throughout the dynamics. The original TRAPZ method was designed to maintain ZPE in classical trajectories, but we find that it leads to unphysically high internal vibrational energies. The mTRAPZ method, which is new in this work and provides a general method for maintaining ZPE in either single-surface or multisurface trajectories, does not lead to unphysical results and is much less time consuming. The effect of maintaining ZPE in mixed quantum/classical dynamics is discussed in terms of agreement with experimental findings. The dynamics for n(2)=0 and n(2)=6 are also analyzed to reveal details not available from experiment, in particular, the time required for quenching of electronic excitation and the adiabatic energy gap and geometry at the time of quenching.     

Using semiclassical surface hopping for coupled partial wave calculations on systems with non-spherically symmetric potentials

It is shown that a semiclassical surface hopping (SH) approach provides a simple and efficient method for scattering calculations with non-spherically symmetric potentials. The calculations are performed by expanding the wave function in an angular momentum state basis. Since the potential is not spherically symmetric, the different angular states are coupled. The semiclassical SH method, which is typically used for problems with coupled electronic states, can, in principle, be employed for any coupled state problem. The particular SH method employed is known to provide highly accurate results for coupled electronic state problems. The method is tested on model two angular state problems using potential surfaces and couplings arising from a non-spherically symmetric scattering problem. The results for these model problems are in excellent agreement with exact quantum calculations. Full calculations, which are converged with regard to the number of angular basis states, are also performed for the non-spherically symmetric problem. It is shown that an approximation to the surface hopping amplitudes that simplifies the numerical implementation of the method provides results in excellent agreement with the full surface hopping calculation.     

Why it is sometimes difficult to determine the accurate position of a hydrogen atom by the semiexperimental method: Structure of molecules containing the OH or the CH3 group

The semiexperimental (SE) technique, whereby equilibrium rotational constants are derived from experimental ground‐state rotational constants and corrections based on an ab initio cubic force field, has the reputation to be one of the most accurate methods to determine an equilibrium structure ( ). However, in some cases, it cannot determine accurately the position of the hydrogen. To investigate the origins of this difficulty, the SE structures of several molecules containing either the OH or the CH₃ group are determined and compared to their best ab initio counterparts. It appears that an important factor is the accuracy of the geometry used to calculate the force field, in particular when the least‐squares system is not well conditioned. In this case, the mixed regression method is often an easy way to circumvent this difficulty. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Semiclassical Liouville method for the simulation of electronic transitions: single ensemble formulation

In this paper, we describe a single ensemble implementation of the semiclassical Liouville method for simulating quantum processes using classical trajectories. In this approach, one ensemble of trajectories supports the evolution of all semiclassical density matrix elements, rather than employing a distinct ensemble for each. The ensemble evolves classically under a single reference Hamiltonian, which is chosen based on physical grounds; for electronic relaxation of an initially excited state, the initially populated upper surface Hamiltonian is the natural choice. Classical trajectories evolving on the reference potential then represent the time-dependent upper state population density and also the electronic coherence and the ground state density created by electronic transition. The error made in the classical motion of the trajectories for these latter distributions is compensated for by incorporating the difference between the correct and reference Liouville propagators into the calculation of the coefficients of the individual trajectories. This approach gives very accurate results for a number of model problems and cases describing ultrafast electronic relaxation dynamics.     

Using molecular dynamics and quantum mechanics calculations to model fluorescence observables

We provide a critical examination of two different methods for generating a donor-acceptor electronic coupling trajectory from a molecular dynamics (MD) trajectory and three methods for sampling that coupling trajectory, allowing the modeling of experimental observables directly from the MD simulation. In the first coupling method we perform a single quantum-mechanical (QM) calculation to characterize the excited state behavior, specifically the transition dipole moment, of the fluorescent probe, which is then mapped onto the configuration space sampled by MD. We then utilize these transition dipoles within the ideal dipole approximation (IDA) to determine the electronic coupling between the probes that mediates the transfer of energy. In the second method we perform a QM calculation on each snapshot and use the complete transition densities to calculate the electronic coupling without need for the IDA. The resulting coupling trajectories are then sampled using three methods ranging from an independent sampling of each trajectory point (the independent snapshot method) to a Markov chain treatment that accounts for the dynamics of the coupling in determining effective rates. The results show that the IDA significantly overestimates the energy transfer rate (by a factor of 2.6) during the portions of the trajectory in which the probes are close to each other. Comparison of the sampling methods shows that the Markov chain approach yields more realistic observables at both high and low FRET efficiencies. Differences between the three sampling methods are discussed in terms of the different mechanisms for averaging over structural dynamics in the system. Convergence of the Markov chain method is carefully examined. Together, the methods for estimating coupling and for sampling the coupling provide a mechanism for directly connecting the structural dynamics modeled by MD with fluorescence observables determined through FRET experiments.     

A diabatic representation including both valence nonadiabatic interactions and spin-orbit effects for reaction dynamics

A diabatic representation is convenient in the study of electronically nonadiabatic chemical reactions because the diabatic energies and couplings are smooth functions of the nuclear coordinates and the couplings are scalar quantities. A method called the fourfold way was devised in our group to generate diabatic representations for spin-free electronic states. One drawback of diabatic states computed from the spin-free Hamiltonian, called a valence diabatic representation, for systems in which spin-orbit coupling cannot be ignored is that the couplings between the states are not zero in asymptotic regions, leading to difficulties in the calculation of reaction probabilities and other properties by semiclassical dynamics methods. Here we report an extension of the fourfold way to construct diabatic representations suitable for spin-coupled systems. In this article we formulate the method for the case of even-electron systems that yield pairs of fragments with doublet spin multiplicity. For this type of system, we introduce the further simplification of calculating the triplet diabatic energies in terms of the singlet diabatic energies via Slater's rules and assuming constant ratios of Coulomb to exchange integrals. Furthermore, the valence diabatic couplings in the triplet manifold are taken equal to the singlet ones. An important feature of the method is the introduction of scaling functions, as they allow one to deal with multibond reactions without having to include high-energy diabatic states. The global transformation matrix to the new diabatic representation, called the spin-valence diabatic representation, is constructed as the product of channel-specific transformation matrices, each one taken as the product of an asymptotic transformation matrix and a scaling function that depends on ratios of the spin-orbit splitting and the valence splittings. Thus the underlying basis functions are recoupled into suitable diabatic basis functions in a manner that provides a multibond generalization of the switch between Hund's cases in diatomic spectroscopy. The spin-orbit matrix elements in this representation are taken equal to their atomic values times a scaling function that depends on the internuclear distances. The spin-valence diabatic potential energy matrix is suitable for semiclassical dynamics simulations. Diagonalization of this matrix produces the spin-coupled adiabatic energies. For the sake of illustration, diabatic potential energy matrices are constructed along bond-fission coordinates for the HBr and the BrCH(2)Cl molecules. Comparison of the spin-coupled adiabatic energies obtained from the spin-valence diabatics with those obtained by ab initio calculations with geometry-dependent spin-orbit matrix elements shows that the new method is sufficiently accurate for practical purposes. The method formulated here should be most useful for systems with a large number of atoms, especially heavy atoms, and/or a large number of spin-coupled electronic states.     

First ultraviolet absorption band of methane: an ab initio study

Quantum mechanical calculations of the cross sections for photodissociation of CH4 and CD4 in the 1t2-->3s band are presented. The potential energy surfaces for the three states correlating with the 1 1T2 state at tetrahedral geometries are calculated. The elements of the (3x3) matrix representing the electronic Hamiltonian in the diabatic basis are expanded in powers of nuclear coordinates, up to the second order. The expansion coefficients are based on accurate multireference configuration interaction calculations. The electronically nonadiabatic dynamics is treated with the multiconfiguration time-dependent Hartree approach. All nine internal degrees of methane are included in the quantum dynamics simulations. The calculated cross section agrees well with experiment. Semiclassical calculations using the reflection principle suggest that the peaks in the spectrum correspond to the three adiabatic electronic states correlating with the 1 1T2 state at Td geometries. However, the non-Born-Oppenheimer terms in the Hamiltonian have a strong effect on the positions of the peaks in the absorption spectrum. The results of semiclassical calculations, which neglect these terms, are therefore quite different from the accurate quantum results and experiment.     

Importance of anharmonicity, recrossing effects, and quantum mechanical tunneling in transition state theory with semiclassical tunneling. A test case: the H2 + Cl hydrogen abstraction reaction

The hydrogen abstraction reaction from H2 by the Cl atom is studied by means of the variational transition state theory with semiclassical tunneling coefficients on the BW2 potential energy surface. Vibrational anharmonicity and coupling between the bending modes are taken into account. The occurrence of trajectories that recross the transition state is estimated by means of the canonical unified statistical method and by classical trajectories calculations. Different semiclassical methods for tunneling calculations are tested. Our results show that anharmonicity has a small but nonnegligible effect on the thermal rate constants, recrossing can be neglected, and tunneling is adequately described by the least-action approximation, and less successfully by the large-curvature version 3 approximation. However, the large-curvature version 4 and small-curvature approximations lead to a severe underestimation of tunneling. Thermal rate constants calculated using transition state theory including anharmonicity and tunneling agree very well with accurate quantal thermal rate constants over a wide temperature range, although the improvement over the harmonic transition state theory with the microcanonically optimized semiclassical tunneling approximation (based on version 3 of the large-curvature tunneling method) used in a previous study of this reaction is only marginal.     

Simulation of environmental effects on coherent quantum dynamics in many-body systems

In this paper we describe an application of the trajectory-based semiclassical Liouville method for modeling coherent molecular dynamics on multiple electronic surfaces to the treatment of the evolution and decay of quantum electronic coherence in many-body systems. We consider a model representing the coherent evolution of quantum wave packets on two excited electronic surfaces of a diatomic molecule in the gas phase and in rare gas solvent environments, ranging from small clusters to a cryogenic solid. For the gas phase system, the semiclassical trajectory method is shown to reproduce the evolution of the electronic-nuclear coherence nearly quantitatively. The dynamics of decoherence are then investigated for the solvated systems using the semiclassical approach. It is found that, although solvation in general leads to more rapid and extensive loss of quantum coherence, the details of the coupled system-bath dynamics are important, and in some cases the environment can preserve or even enhance quantum coherence beyond that seen in the isolated system.     

First principles semiclassical calculations of vibrational eigenfunctions

Vibrational eigenfunctions are calculated on-the-fly using semiclassical methods in conjunction with ab initio density functional theory classical trajectories. Various semiclassical approximations based on the time-dependent representation of the eigenfunctions are tested on an analytical potential describing the chemisorption of CO on Cu(100). Then, first principles semiclassical vibrational eigenfunctions are calculated for the CO(2) molecule and its accuracy evaluated. The multiple coherent states initial value representations semiclassical method recently developed by us has shown with only six ab initio trajectories to evaluate eigenvalues and eigenfunctions at the accuracy level of thousands trajectory semiclassical initial value representation simulations.