Solving the bicriteria traffic equilibrium problem with variable demand and nonlinear path costs

In this paper, we present an algorithm for solving the bicriteria traffic equilibrium problem with variable demand and nonlinear path costs. The path cost function considered is comprised of two attributes, travel time and toll, that are combined into a nonlinear generalized cost. Travel demand is determined endogenously according to a travel disutility function. Travelers choose routes with the minimum overall generalized costs. The algorithm involves two components: a bicriteria shortest path routine to implicitly generate the set of non-dominated paths and a projection and contraction method to solve the nonlinear complementarity problem (NCP) describing the traffic equilibrium problem. Numerical experiments are conducted to demonstrate the feasibility of the algorithm to this class of traffic equilibrium problems.     

交通拥堵管理中可交易电子券方案的公平性分析

利用损失厌恶理论中的参照依赖模型,构建用户的感知出行成本函数,在固定需求的交通网络中加入电子券交易费用率,建立均衡条件下的变分不等式模型。通过模拟仿真,说明市场交易费用率会影响电子券交易市场,政府可通过调节交易费用率提高电子券方案公平性。选取路网中所有起讫对间出行成本变化率波动的加权平均值,度量可交易电子券方案的公平性,综合考虑最小化系统出行总成本和最大化方案公平性两个目标,构造效用函数,分析不同权重下市场交易费用率对可交易电子券方案的影响,以期对电子券方案的公平性进行优化。     

Sensitivity analysis for the asymmetric network equilibrium problem

We consider the asymmetric continuous traffic equilibrium network model with fixed demands where the travel cost on each link of the transportation network may depend on the flow on this as well as other links of the network and we perform stability and sensitivity analysis. Assuming that the travel cost functions are monotone we first show that the traffic equlibrium pattern depends continuously upon the assigned travel demands and travel cost functions. We then focus on the delicate question of predicting the direction of the change in the traffic pattern and the incurred travel costs resulting from changes in the travel cost functions and travel demands and attempt to elucidate certain counter intuitive phenomena such as ‘Braess' paradox’. Our analysis depends crucially on the fact that the governing equilibrium conditions can be formulated as a variational inequality. This work was supported by the Program of University Research, U.S. Department of Transportation (Project number DTRS 5680-C-00007).     

A semismooth Newton method for traffic equilibrium problem with a general nonadditive route cost

Computing traffic equilibria with a general nonadditive route cost disutility function is considered in this paper. Following the user equilibrium (UE) condition, that is, no driver can unilaterally change route to achieve less travel costs, the traffic equilibrium problem (TEP) can be formulated as a nonlinear complementary problem (NCP). In this paper, we propose a semismooth Newton method with a penalized Fischer–Burmeister (PFB) NCP function to solve the NCP formulation of the TEP, and also, we investigate the properties of the proposed method. Numerical results are provided and compared with the classical TEP with additive route cost functions. The results show the algorithm can achieved substantially better performance than the existing approaches. A sensitivity analysis is also conducted to examine the parameter of the proposed nonadditive route cost function.     

Turning restriction design in traffic networks with a budget constraint

The restriction (prohibition) of certain turns at intersections is a very common task employed by the managers of urban traffic networks. Surprisingly, this approach has received little attention in the research literature. The turning restriction design problem (TRDP) involves finding a set of turning restrictions at intersections to promote flow in a congested urban traffic network. This article uses a successive linear approximation (SLA) method for identifying approximate solutions to a nonlinear model of the TRDP. It aims to adjust the current turning restriction regime in a given network in order to minimize total user travel cost when route choice is driven by user equilibrium principles. Novel features of the method include the facts that it is based on link capacity-based arc travel costs and there is a budget constraint on the total cost of all turning restriction alterations. It has been tested using standard network examples from the literature. One of the tests utilized a multi-start approach which improved the solutions produced by the SLA method. The method was also employed to identify turning restrictions for an actual medium-sized urban traffic network in Brazil. Computational experience with the proposed method is promising.     

Sensitivity Analysis Based Method for Optimal Road Network Pricing

Road pricing is an important economic measure for optimal management of transportation networks. The optimization objectives can be the total travel time or total cost incurred by all the travelers, or some other environmental objective such as minimum emission of dioxide, an so on. Suppose a certain toll is posed on some link on the network, this will give an impact on flows over the whole network and brings about a new equilibrium state. An equilibrium state is a state of traffic network at which no traveler could decrease the perceived travel cost by unilaterally changing the route. The aim of the toll setting is to achieve such an equilibrium state that a certain objective function is optimized. The problem can be formulated as a mathematical program with equilibrium constraints (MPEC). A key step for solving such a MPEC problem is the sensitivity analysis of traffic flows with respect to the change of link characteristics such as the toll prices. In this paper a sensitivity analysis based method is proposed for solving optimal road pricing problems.     

Doubly uncertain transportation network: Degradable capacity and stochastic demand

This study developed a methodology to model doubly uncertain transportation network with stochastic link capacity degradation and stochastic demand. We consider that the total travel demand comprises of two parts, infrequent travelers and commuters. The traffic volume of infrequent travelers is stochastic, which adds to the network traffic in a random manner based on fixed route choice proportions. On the other hand, the traffic volume of commuters is stable or deterministic. Commuters acquire the network travel time variability from past experiences, factor them into their route choice considerations, and settle into a long-term habitual route choice equilibrium in which they have no incentive of switching away. To define this equilibrium, we introduce the notion of “travel time budget” to relate commuters’ risk aversion on route choices in the presence of travel time variability. The travel time budget varies among commuters according to their degrees of risk aversion and requirements on punctual arrivals. We then developed a mixed-equilibrium formulation to capture these stochastic considerations and illustrated its properties through some numerical studies.     

ATIS和道路收费下混合SUE相对于SSO的效率损失

在ATIS和道路收费共同作用的异质性交通网络中,基于用户在信息接受程度与时间价值上的异质性,对用户进行合理分类,所有用户均按照随机方式进行择路.构建了多用户混合随机均衡等价的变分不等式模型,以及多用户随机社会最优模型.以用户感知的总出行成本作为系统性能评价的指标,当收费作为系统总成本的一部分时,分别在时间准则与费用准则下研究了多用户混合随机均衡相对于随机社会最优的绝对效率损失问题.研究结果表明,时间准则下的绝对效率损失上界与路段出行时间函数和混合随机均衡时系统的实际总出行时间有关,费用准则下的绝对效率损失上界还与出行者的社会经济特性和随机社会最优时系统的实际总出行时间有关.     

Stochastic equilibrium assignment with variable demand: Theoretical and implementation issues

Recently, it has been pointed out that transport models should reflect all significant traveler choice behavior. In particular, trip generation, trip distribution, modal split as well as route choice should be modeled in a consistent process based on the equilibrium between transport supply and travel demand. In this paper a general fixed-point approach that allows dealing with multi-user stochastic equilibrium assignment with variable demand is presented. The main focus was on investigating the effectiveness of internal and external approaches and of different algorithmic specifications based on the method of successive averages within the internal approach. The vector demand function was assumed non-separable, non-symmetric cost functions were adopted and implementation issues, such updating step and convergence criterion, were investigated. In particular the aim was threefold: (i) compare the internal and the external approaches; (ii) investigate the effectiveness of different algorithmic specifications to solve the variable demand equilibrium assignment problem through the internal approach; (iii) investigate the incidence of the number of the links with non-separable and/or asymmetrical cost functions. The proposed analyses were carried out with respect to two real-scale urban networks regarding medium-size urban contexts in Italy.     

A column generation algorithm for the estimation of origin–destination matrices in congested traffic networks

The general problem of estimating origin–destination (O–D) matrices in congested traffic networks is formulated as a mathematical programme with equilibrium constraints, referred to as the demand adjustment problem (DAP). This approach integrates the O–D matrix estimation and the network equilibrium assignment into one process. In this paper, a column generation algorithm for the DAP is presented. This algorithm iteratively solves a deterministic user equilibrium model for a given O–D matrix and a DAP restricted to the previously generated paths, whose solution generates a new O–D trip matrix estimation. The restricted DAP is formulated via a single level optimization problem. The convergence on local minimum of the proposed algorithm requires only the continuity of the link travel cost functions and the gauges used in the definition of the DAP.     

多用户类多准则交通分配的势博弈与拥挤定价

交通管理者在解决路网拥挤问题时,并不知道出行者的出行效用,同时管理者难以对出行者的路径选择行为做出准确的观测.运用势博弈理论分析多用户类多准则交通行为的演化过程,得到了固定需求和弹性需求情形下的可容许动态(一种刻画出行者通过转换路径增加当前效用的近似调整行为的演化动态),证明当路段时间函数和逆需求函数为严格单调、连续、可微时,所对应的交通分配是势博弈问题的惟一Nash均衡点.进一步研究了固定需求下的可变拥挤道路收费问题,得到了在当前系统状态下实现系统最优交通分配的拥挤收费水平.     

多方式弹性需求下公交定价双层规划模型

为描述多方式城市交通网络下公交定价与出行选择行为的相互作用与影响,将出行方式选择与路径选择涵盖于同一网络,建立了上层模型分别以企业利润最大化、乘客出行成本最小化和社会福利最大化为目标函数,下层模型为多方式弹性需求随机用户配流模型的公交定价双层规划模型。运用改进遗传算法对模型整体进行求解,下层模型采用综合对角化算法和MSA算法的组合求解算法。最后,设计了一个算例以说明模型应用。结果表明:运用双层规划模型所确定的公交票价较传统静态票价可使政府、企业及出行者三方都获得更高收益,且上层模型以社会福利最大化为目标函数能代表社会群体中多数人利益,优化效果最为理想。     

路段容量约束弹性需求交通均衡分配近似算法

本文研究了带路段容量约束弹性需求用户均衡交通分配问题及其近似解法.采用超需求模型将弹性需求转化为固定需求,提出了一种带路段容量约束弹性需求用户均衡交通分配近似算法.该算法在迭代过程中,通过不断自适应调节排队延误因子、误差因子来近似真实路段行驶时间,使路段流量逐步满足约束条件,最终达到广义用户均衡.这种方法克服了容量约束弹性需求用户均衡分配计算量大及随机分配法要求枚举所有路径的困难.随后证明了算法的收敛性,并对一个小型路网进行了数值试验.     

A turning restriction design problem in urban road networks

Turning restriction is one of the commonest traffic management techniques and an effective low cost traffic improvement strategy in urban road networks. However, the literature has not paid much attention to the turning restriction design problem (TRDP), which aims to determine a set of intersections where turning restrictions should be implemented. In this paper, a bi-level programming model is proposed to formulate the TRDP. The upper level problem is to minimize the total travel cost from the viewpoint of traffic managers, and the lower level problem is to depict travelers’ route choice behavior based on stochastic user equilibrium (SUE) theory. We propose a branch and bound method (BBM), based on the sensitivity analysis algorithm (SAA), to find the optimal turning restriction strategy. A branch strategy and a bound strategy are applied to accelerate the solution process of the TRDP. The computational experiments give promising results, showing that the optimal turning restriction strategy can obviously reduce system congestion and are robust to the variations of both the dispersion parameter of the SUE problem and the level of demand.     

Integrating link-based discrete credit charging scheme into discrete network design problem

In this paper, we present an optimization model for integrating link-based discrete credit charging scheme into the discrete network design problem, to improve the transport performance from the perspectives of both transport network planning and travel demand management. The proposed model is a mixed-integer nonlinear bilevel programming problem, which includes an upper level problem for the transport authority and a lower level problem for the network users. The lower level sub-model is the traffic network user equilibrium (UE) formulation for a given network design strategy determined by the upper level problem. The network user at the lower level tries to minimize his/her own generalized travel cost (including both the travel time and the value of the credit charged for using the link) by choosing his/her route. While the transport authority at the upper level tries to find the optimal number of lanes and credit charging level with their locations to minimize the total system travel time (or maximize the transportation system performance). A genetic algorithm is used to solve the proposed mixed-integer nonlinear bilevel programming problem. Numerical experiments show the efficiency of the proposed model for traffic congestion mitigation, reveal that interaction effects across the tradable credit scheme and the discrete network design problem which amplify their individual effects. Moreover, the integrated model can achieve better performance than the sequential decision problems.     

Parking Capacity and Pricing in Park'n Ride Trips: A Continuous Equilibrium Network Design Problem

In this paper we consider the problem of designing parking facilities for park'n ride trips. We present a new continuous equilibrium network design problem to decide the capacity and fare of these parking lots at a tactical level. We assume that the parking facilities have already been located and other topological decisions have already been taken.The modeling approach proposed is mathematical programming with equilibrium constraints. In the outer optimization problem, a central Authority evaluates the performance of the transport network for each network design decision. In the inner problem a multimodal traffic assignment with combined modes, formulated as a variational inequality problem, generates the share demand for modes of transportation, and for parking facilities as a function of the design variables of the parking lots. The objective is to make optimal parking investment and pricing decisions in order to minimize the total travel cost in a subnetwork of the multimodal transportation system.We present a new development in model formulation based on the use of generalized parking link cost as a design variable.The bilevel model is solved by a simulated annealing algorithm applied to the continuous and non-negative design decision variables. Numerical tests are reported in order to illustrate the use of the model, and the ability of the approach to solve applications of moderate size.     

Using fuzzy integral for evaluating subjectively perceived travel costs in a traffic assignment model

A good traffic assignment model can be a powerful tool to describe the characteristics of traffic behavior in a road network. The traffic assignment results often play an important role in transportation planning, e.g., an optimal and economical network design. Many traditional traffic assignment models rely heavily on the travel cost function established by Wardrop’s principles; however, the Wardrop’s travel cost function has been proven to be weak for explaining the uncertainty and interactivity of traffic among links. This study tries to construct a traffic assignment model that is different from Wardrop’s in many aspects. First, it considers the cross-effect among the links. Second, a fuzzy travel cost function is established based on the possibility concept instead of precise calculation of traffic volumes. Third, the techniques of fuzzy measure and fuzzy integral are applied to calculate the subjectively perceived travel costs during traffic assignment. Furthermore, in order to validate our model, a detailed network with 22 nodes and 36 links is used to illustrate it. Study results show that our model explains more interactivity and uncertainty of traffic among links when compared with the traditional model of Wardrop’s.     

双模式网络停车限制交通需求管理模型与方法研究

在轨道网和公路网并存的双模式交通网络, 合理设计出行终点的停车容量可优化汽车出行需求, 改善路网交通环境。本文通过分析私家车与城市轨道两种交通模式的出行需求, 并考虑私家车模式的终点停车收费服务, 建立了一种带路段环境容量和终点停车需求容量共同约束的交通需求管理模型。模型中路网使用者的出行模式采用二元Logit模型来计算, 而私家车的路线选择行为服从Logit随机用户均衡, 因此该模型是一个带不动点约束的数学规划问题。针对模型求解困难, 文中采用灵敏度分析来获取各路段流量和需求量关于终点容量波动的梯度信息, 进而设计了一种新的灵敏度分析求解算法.最后通过数值仿真实验, 验证了算法的有效性, 同时分析了不同停车收费参数对模型各指标变化趋势的影响。     

A self-adaptive projection and contraction algorithm for the traffic assignment problem with path-specific costs

This paper considers solving a special case of the nonadditive traffic equilibrium problem presented by Gabriel and Bernstein [Transportation Science 31 (4) (1997) 337–348] in which the cost incurred on each path is made up of the sum of the arc travel times plus a path-specific cost for traveling on that path. A self-adaptive projection and contraction method is suggested to solve the path-specific cost traffic equilibrium problem, which is formulated as a nonlinear complementarity problem (NCP). The computational effort required per iteration is very modest. It consists of only two function evaluations and a simple projection on the nonnegative orthant. A self-adaptive technique is embedded in the projection and contraction method to find suitable scaling factor without the need to do a line search. The method is simple and has the ability to handle a general monotone mapping F. Numerical results are provided to demonstrate the features of the projection and contraction method.     

A continuous day-to-day traffic assignment model and the existence of a continuous dynamic user equilibrium

Suppose that a road network model is given, together with some given demand for travel by (say) car and that the demand for travel varies with time of day but not from day to day. Suppose that this demand is given in the form of specified total outflow rates from each origin headed towards each destination, for each origin-destination pair and for each time of day, and that some initial time-dependent routeinflow rates, meeting the given demand, are given. Finally, suppose that within-day time is represented by a continuous variable. This paper specifies a natural smooth day-to-day route-swapping procedure wherein drivers swap toward less expensive routes as day succeeds day, and shows that under reasonable conditions there is an equilibrium state of this dynamical system. If such a collection of route-inflows has arisen today, say, then there is no incentive for any route-inflow to change tomorrow, in the sense that at each moment of today each of today's route-inflows isalready on a route which today yielded the smallest travel cost. Such a set of no-incentive-to-change route-inflows is called adynamic equilibrium, or adynamic user-equilibrium, and may be regarded as a solution of the dynamic equilibrium traffic assignment problem. Thus, the paper introduces a smooth day-to-day dynamic assignment model and, using this model, shows that there is a dynamic user-equilibrium in a continuous time setting. The paper briefly considers the day-to-day stability of the route-swapping process, also in a continuous setting. Finally, the paper gives a simple dynamical example illustrating the stability of the route-swapping process in a simple two-route network when there is deterministic queueing at bottlenecks.