Multidimensional LC x LC analysis of phenolic and flavone natural antioxidants with UV-electrochemical coulometric and MS detection

A comprehensive 2-D LC x LC system was developed for the separation of phenolic and flavone antioxidants, using a PEG-silica column in the first dimension and a C(18) column with porous-shell particles or a monolithic column in the second dimension. Combination of PEG and C18 or C8 stationary phase chemistries provide low selectivity correlations between the first dimension and the second dimension separation systems. This was evidenced by large differences in structural contributions to the retention by -COOH, -OH and other substituents on the basic phenol or flavone structure. Superficially porous columns with fused core particles or monolithic columns improve the resolution and speed of second dimension separation in comparison to a fully porous particle C(18) column. Increased peak capacity and high orthogonality in different 2-D setups was achieved by using gradients with matching profiles running in parallel in the two dimensions over the whole 2-D separation time range. Multi-dimensional set-up combining the LC x LC separation on-line with UV and multi-channel coulometric detection and off-line with MS/MS technique allowed positive peak identification. The Coularray software compensates for the effects of the baseline drift during the gradient elution and is compatible with parallel gradient comprehensive LC x LC technique. Furthermore, it provides significant improvement in the sensitivity and selectivity of detection in comparison to both UV and MS detection. The utility of these systems has been demonstrated in the analysis of beer samples.     

Optimization of separation in two-dimensional high-performance liquid chromatography by adjusting phase system selectivity and using programmed elution techniques

The overall peak capacity in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatographic (LC x LC) separation can be considerably increased using efficient columns and carefully optimized mobile phases providing large differences in the retention mechanisms and separation selectivity between the first and the second dimension. Gradient-elution operation and fraction-transfer modulation by matching the retention and the elution strength of the mobile phases in the two dimensions are useful means to suppress the band broadening in the second dimension and to increase the number of sample compounds separated in LC x LC. Matching parallel gradients in the first and second dimension eliminate the necessity of second-dimension column re-equilibration after the independent gradient runs for each fraction, increase the use of the available second-dimension separation time and can significantly improve the regularity of the coverage of the available retention space in LC x LC separations, especially with the first- and second-dimension systems showing partial selectivity correlations. Systematic development of an LC x LC method with parallel two-dimensional gradients was applied for separation of phenolic acids and flavone compounds. Several types of bonded C18, amide, phenyl, pentafluorophenyl and poly(ethylene glycol) columns were compared using the linear free energy relationship method to find suitable column combination with low correlation of retention of representative standards. The phase systems were optimized step-by-step to find the mobile phases and gradients providing best separation selectivity for phenolic compounds. The optimization of simultaneous parallel gradients in the first and second dimension resulted in significant improvement in the utilization of the available two-dimensional retention space.     

Effects of the gradient profile, sample volume and solvent on the separation in very fast gradients, with special attention to the second-dimension gradient in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Gradient elution provides significant improvement in peak capacity with respect to isocratic conditions and therefore should be used in comprehensive two-dimensional LC×LC, both in the first and in the second dimension, where, however, gradients are limited to a short time period available for separation, usually 1 min or less. Gradient conditions spanning over a broad mobile phase composition range in each second-dimension fraction analysis are used with generic "full in fraction" (FIF) gradients. "Segment in fraction" (SIF) gradients cover a limited gradient range adjusted independently to suit changing lipophilicity range of compounds transferred to the second dimension during the first-dimension gradient run and to provide regular coverage of the two-dimensional retention space. Optimization of the gradient profiles is important tool for achieving high two-dimensional peak capacity and savings of the separation time in comprehensive LC×LC. Calculations based on the well-established gradient-elution theory can be used to predict the elution times and bandwidths in fast gradients, taking into account increased probability of pre-gradient or post-gradient elution. The fraction volumes transferred into the second dimension may significantly affect the second-dimension bandwidths, especially at high elution strength of the fraction solvent, which may cause even band distortion or splitting in combined normal-phase (HILIC)-RP systems, but also in some two-dimensional RP-RP systems. In the present work, the effects of the fast gradient profile, of the sample volume and solvent on the elution time and bandwidths were investigated on a short column packed with fused-core porous-shell particles, providing narrow bandwidths and fast separations at moderate operating pressure.     

Columns and optimum gradient conditions for fast second-dimension separations in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Gradient elution provides significantly higher peak capacity in comparison to the isocratic elution mode, hence it is very useful in online comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LC). We compared suitability of five commercial core-shell columns and one monolithic column for fast gradients in the second LC dimension, where the time of separation is strictly limited by the fraction cycle time. In two-dimensional reversed-phase systems with partially correlated retention, the resolution, the peak capacity, and the regularity of coverage of the second-dimension retention space can be improved by appropriate adjusting the gradient time and the gradient range to suit the sample properties. We developed a new strategy for adjusting the gradient mobile phase composition range in the second-dimension, employing the retention data of representative sample standards characterizing the sample properties, which can be calibrated using the reference alkylbenzene series. Optimized second-dimension gradients with single-step or segmented profiles covering two or more fraction ranges, employed for the separation of subsequent fractions from the first-dimension, improve significantly the resolution, the separation time, and the regularity of coverage of the two-dimensional retention plane. The approach was applied to the two-dimensional comprehensive separation of phenolic acids and flavonoid compounds occurring as natural antioxidants.     

Comparison of High-Temperature Gradient Heart-Cutting and Comprehensive LC × LC Systems for the Separation of Phenolic Antioxidants

Natural phenolic antioxidants were separated using comprehensive 2D HPLC on a Purospher Star RP-18e column in the first dimension and on two parallel Zirconia Carbon columns working in alternating cycles in the second dimension. The combination of the two columns provides great differences in separation selectivity in each dimension and an almost orthogonal 2D system. Temperature and solvent gradients were compared for the separation of the first-dimension fraction in the stop-flow heart-cutting 2D setup. Temperature gradients provide shorter separation times in comparison with solvent gradients. However, the time required for post-run column equilibration is too long for comprehensive LC × LC. High-temperature isocratic separation was employed in the second dimension of the comprehensive setup, allowing improvement of the fraction transfer frequency between the two dimensions and shorter 2D separation time in comparison to the earlier published method. The approach was applied to the analysis of beer and wine.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography with parallel gradients for separation of phenolic and flavone antioxidants

Various combinations of PEG-silica, phenyl-silica and C18 columns in a single-column or serial (tandem) arrangement in the first dimension and a monolithic Chromolith column in the second dimension were tested for comprehensive two-dimensional (2D) LCxLC separation of phenolic and flavone natural antioxidants. The combinations of different stationary phase chemistries provided low selectivity correlations between the first-dimension and the second-dimension separation systems. Improvement in system orthogonality, bandwidths suppression, more regular band distribution over the whole 2D retention plane and increased peak capacity in different 2D setups was achieved by using gradients with matching profiles running in parallel in the two dimensions over the whole 2D separation time range. Instead of two sampling loops, two alternating trapping XTerra columns were used for sample fraction transfer from the first-dimension column to the second dimension. Stronger retention on the XTerra columns in comparison to PEG-silica or phenyl-silica columns in the first dimension allowed using focusing of sample fractions in narrow zones on the top of a trapping column and back-flushing into the second dimension in a very low volume of the mobile phase. This fraction transfer modulation provided significant bandwidth suppression in the second dimension. 2D systems with optimized stationary phase selectivity, parallel gradients and fraction transfer modulation using two trapping columns were applied for the analysis of natural antioxidants in beer and wine samples.     

Temperature effects on separation on zirconia columns: applications to one- and two-dimensional LC separations of phenolic antioxidants

The effects of temperature and mobile phase on LC chromatographic separation of phenolic antioxidants on zirconia-based columns were investigated. Unlike silica-based materials, zirconia columns show excellent thermal stability over a wide range of temperatures and enable high-temperature separations. Enthalpic and entropic contributions to the retention of phenolic compounds on ZR-Carbon and ZR-Carbon C18 columns were determined from retention versus temperature plots in order to elucidate the retention mechanism of sample compounds over the temperature range up to 14 degrees C. High-temperature liquid chromatography on ZR-Carbon columns was used for comprehensive LC x LC two-dimensional separation systems based on the different selectivity of a Zorbax SB micro-column used in the first dimension and a ZR-Carbon column used in the second dimension. Two-dimensional LC x LC systems employing a setup with two alternately operated parallel ZR-Carbon columns in the second dimension were used for the analysis of phenolic antioxidants in beer and wine samples.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional high-performance liquid chromatography for the separation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

A comprehensive two-dimensional HPLC system for the separation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons was developed using a pentabromobenzyl column as the first dimension and two short monolithic C18 columns as the second dimension. The primary column and two secondary columns were coupled by a 10-port 2-position valve. The effluent from the first dimension was repetitively injected into the second dimension every 12 s. Due to its resolution, this technique is a powerful tool for the separation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in a complex matrix such as environmental samples.     

Development of different comprehensive two dimensional systems for the separation of phenolic antioxidants

Three different comprehensive 2-D HPLC systems for the separation of phenolic antioxidants have been developed on the basis of different selectivities of a PEG-silica column in the first dimension and a packed or monolithic C18 or a ZR-CARBON column, respectively, in the second dimension. Two-dimensional comprehensive liquid chromatography using a serially connected short PEG-silica column and a conventional C18-silica or a ZR-CARBON column in the second dimension was tested to improve the resolution of the earlier eluting compounds in the first dimension. Various types of interface were used to connect the columns in the first and in the second dimension: i) two injection sampling loops of 100 microL in conventional arrangement; ii) a 10-port 2-position valve equipped with two trapping X-Terra columns instead of loops; and iii) two analytical D2 columns in parallel. The mobile phase in the first dimension has a lower elution strength than in the second dimension, allowing band compression of the solutes transferred from the first to the second dimension. This effect was enhanced using trapping columns instead of sampling loops as the interface between the two dimensions, thus allowing a decrease in the time of analysis. These systems were used for the analysis of beer samples. The relative location of the components in the 2-D retention plane varied in relation to their chemical structure in each instrumental set-up and allowed positive peak identification.     

Use of shift gradient in the second dimension to improve the separation space in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LC?×?LC) has received much attention because it offers much higher peak capacities than separation in a single dimension. The advantageous peak capacity makes it attractive for the separation of complex samples. Various gradient methods have been used in LC?×?LC systems. The use of continuous shift gradient is advantageous because it combines the peak compression effect of full gradient mode and the tailed gradient program in parallel gradient mode. Here, a comparison of LC?×?LC analysis of Chinese herbal medicine with full gradient mode and shift gradient mode in the second dimension was performed. A correlation between the first and second dimensions was found in full gradient mode, and this was significantly reduced with shift gradient mode. The orthogonality increased by 43.7 %. The effective peak distribution area increased significantly, which produced better separation.     

Use of partially porous column as second dimension in comprehensive two-dimensional system for analysis of polyphenolic antioxidants

In the present work, a comprehensive LC system using a microbore HPLC column in the first dimension and a partially porous column in the second dimension was developed and applied to the separation of polyphenolic components in a red wine sample. The performance of the partially porous short column (3.0 cm) was compared to that of a monolithic column, of comparable dimensions. The results obtained demonstrated the possibility to use partially porous columns to obtain fast analyses, using high flow rates, under repetitive gradient conditions and with very brief reconditioning times. A conventional HPLC system was used since the backpressure generated by the shell-packed column, even at very high flow rates, was well within the operational limits. The use of an increased column temperature (60 degrees C) allowed a further pressure-drop decrease, with no stationary phase degradation, or loss in column performance.     

Two-dimensional separation system of coupling capillary liquid chromatography to capillary electrophoresis for analysis of Escherichia coli metabolites

A two-dimensional (2-D) separation system of coupling chromatography to electrophoresis was developed for profiling Escherichia coli metabolites. Capillary liquid chromatography (LC) with a monolithic silica-octadecyl silica column (500 x 0.2 mm ID) was used as the first dimension, from which the effluent fractions were further analyzed by capillary electrophoresis (CE) acting as the second dimension. Field-enhanced stacking was selectively employed as a concentration strategy to interface the two dimensions, which proved to be beneficial for the detection of metabolites. An artificial sample containing 118 standards, some of which lack chromophores or have weak UV absorbance, was used to optimize the 2-D separation system. Under the optimum conditions, 63 components in the artificial sample having absorbance at 254 nm could be well resolved and detected. The utility of the system was demonstrated by comprehensive analysis of E. coli metabolites. Comparing with the previous 2-D separation system we published in Anal. Chem. 2004, 76, 1419-1428, using a longer monolithic column in the first dimension improved the separation efficiency and offered the possibility of increasing the injection volume without compromising the separation efficiency. In the second dimension, field-enhanced stacking was used to improve the concentration sensitivity of the metabolites, and more metabolites in E. coli cell extract were detected and identified using the developed 2-D separation system. In addition, preliminary investigation for future CE-mass spectrometry coupling was also made in the study by using volatile buffers in the capillary LC and CE techniques.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography applying two parallel columns in the second dimension

The design of a new interface for comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LC x LC) is described. To the conventionally used LC x LC system with the loop-type interface consisting of a two-position/ten-port switching valve equipped with two loops, an extra two-position/ten-port switching valve, a detector, a pump and a second column placed in parallel with the column in the second dimension, are added. The features of the interface are that the separation space in the second dimension is significantly enlarged and that the number of fractions transferred from the first to the second dimension can be increased, reducing the risk to lose resolution of the primary dimension. The potential of the system in NPLC x 2RPLC is illustrated with the analysis of a standard mixture and a lemon oil extract. For the lemon oil analysis, the effective peak capacity was increased from 437 using a conventional interface to 1095 with the new interface. RPLC x 2RPLC in combination with reduced modulation times was applied to the analysis of steroids and to the detection of impurities at the 0.05% relative concentration level in a sulfonamide drug sample.     

A theoretical basis for parameter selection and instrument design in comprehensive size-exclusion chromatography x liquid chromatography

A novel approach for the selection of the operational parameters (linear velocity, column length) for a comprehensive 2D-LC system is discussed. Starting point for the calculations is a given second dimension ((2)D) separation and a desired peak capacity for the 2D system. Using the theory developed here the optimum settings for the first dimension ((1)D) column can be derived. Theory clearly indicates that the choice of the (1)D conditions is basically limited to just one set of column lengths and linear velocities. The new method is tested on a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography system which uses size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) followed by reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC). A novel LC/LC interface, using a six-port valve rather than storage loops, joins the two chromatographic dimensions. From a theoretical comparison of continuous low flow and stop-flow operation the latter method was found to be an attractive mode of interfacing. The common idea that stop-flow operation results in additional band broadening is shown to be incorrect. The new interface design operated in the stop-flow mode permits the use of conventional analytical diameter HPLC columns, 7.8mm for SEC and 4.6mm for RPLC. The reversed phase chromatography utilizes a monolithic C-18 modified silica column, which produces fast and efficient analyses. As test samples complex mixtures of peptides were analyzed.     

Optimal gradient operation in comprehensive liquid chromatography × liquid chromatography systems with limited orthogonality

A novel strategy is described for designing optimal second dimension (²D) gradient conditions for a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography system where the two dimensions are not fully orthogonal. Using the approach developed here, the initial and final organic modifier content values resulting in the highest coverage of separation space can be derived for each ²D gradient run. Theory indicates that these values can be determined by adapting ²D gradient operation to the degree of orthogonality. The new method is tested on a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography system that uses reversed phase (RP) columns showing different selectivities in the two dimensions. A comparison between analyses carried out using normal and optimized ²D gradients showed that the latter allow a more efficient use of analysis time. This can result either in an improved peak capacity or in decreasing total analysis time, depending on the final goal of the experiment. In the latter scenario, the number of separated peaks is comparable to that obtained using gradients spanning a wide range of organic modifier but, now, in half the time. As test samples complex mixtures of peptides were analyzed.     

Phase system selectivity and two-dimensional separations in liquid column chromatography

Correlations between the separation selectivity in aqueous and non-aqueous reversed-phase systems and in normal-phase LC systems were investigated for samples containing different numbers of two repeat structural elements. Such samples are best separated in "orthogonal" two-dimensional chromatographic systems, showing selectivity for one type of the repeat structural element only in the first dimension and for the other structural element only in the second dimension. The number of resolved compounds improves as the degree of orthogonality of the separation systems increases with decreasing correlation between the selectivities for the sample structural distribution in the two dimensions. Orthogonal systems with non-correlated selectivities for each repeat structural element provide the highest number of separated peaks and regular arrangement of the peaks over the two-dimensional retention space according to the individual structural element distribution and the best use of the available peak capacity. Fully orthogonal systems are difficult to find in practice. Partially orthogonal system with correlated selectivities for one structural type distribution, but with one system non-distinguishing the distribution for the other structural element are still useful for the two-dimensional separations. The correlations between the selectivities for repeat regular structural increments were employed to evaluate the suitability of phase systems for two-dimensional HPLC separations. The selectivity correlation in various reversed-phase and normal-phase systems was evaluated for two sample types: (1) Various RP columns show significantly inversely correlated selectivities for acyl lengths and numbers of double bonds distribution, but the differences in the double bond selectivity can be used for practical separations of triacylglycerols with the same equivalent carbon numbers. (2) Synthetic EO-PO block (co)oligomers with two-dimensional distribution of oxyethylene and oxypropylene monomer units were separated according to the two distribution types using on-line two-dimensional reversed-phase-normal-phase LC with a C18 column in the first dimension and an aminopropyl silica column in the second dimension.     

Determination of flavanones in Citrus juices by means of one- and two-dimensional liquid chromatography

1-D and 2-D comprehensive (LC×LC) liquid chromatography methods have been developed and compared for the separation and quantification of flavanones in various Citrus juices. 1-D analyses were carried out on a superficially porous C18 column, whereas the 2-D LC approach was composed of a polyethylene glycol silica narrow-bore column packed with totally porous particles in the first dimension (D1) and a superficially porous C18 column in the second dimension (D2). Low-selectivity correlations were ensured by the complementary separation mechanisms offered by the D1 and D2 columns. Quantification was carried out both manually and by means of a software capable of detecting and quantifying each peak from the 2-D plot. Limit of detection (LOD) values as low as 0.023 μg/mL were obtained for hesperidin used as reference material for 1-D LC analyses, whereas values as high as 0.432 μg/mL were obtained by comprehensive LC. This discrepancy can be traced back to the minor sensitivity experienced in comprehensive LC due to both sample dilution in D1 and the high flow rates employed in D2. On the other hand, the separation capabilities of the LC×LC approach allowed to reduce the interferences coming from the matrix and to achieve the separation of some critical pairs, e.g. hesperidin/naringin difficult to accomplish in 1-D LC.     

二维液相色谱接口的改进及其在蛋白质组学研究中的应用

随着蛋白质组学、本草物质组学等组学概念的提出,所需分析的样品的成分越来越复杂,因此具有强大分离能力的多维液相色谱技术受到人们越来越多的关注。二维液相色谱中第二维的分离性能和速度是整个分离系统性能的关键。基于捕集柱模式,我们采用经特殊设计的流路系统,使得双捕集柱型接口具有预分离的功能。样品从第一维流出以后被富集在捕集柱1的柱头,经过脱盐后,正冲捕集柱,捕集柱1与第二维色谱柱联用对富集的样品进行分离,增加了第二维分离效率。当捕集柱上的样品全部被洗脱到第二维色谱柱上时,捕集柱2已经完成对第一维洗脱液中样品的捕集和脱盐,此时将阀进行切换,捕集柱2与第二维色谱柱直接相连进行洗脱。循环切换捕集柱1和捕集柱2,维持较高的阀切换频率,实现了第二维色谱柱的连续洗脱。因此保证了第二维分离具有较快速度,同时具有较高的分离效率。使用35 mm长捕集柱和十通阀为接口,以弱阴离子交换(WAX)色谱为第一维分离模式,以反相(RP)色谱为第二维分离模式,构建了WAX-RP二维液相色谱系统(2D-LC system)。以小鼠血清为样品对系统进行了初步评价。色谱流出曲线出现了明显的界面现象,这是由于捕集柱流动相中含有的较多盐分流出时的背景吸收造成的。同时,由于界面两侧的流动相黏度不同产生了黏性指进(VF)现象。当第二维色谱柱长度为50 mm时,理论上可将第二维分离效能提高70%。该接口可以应用于多种二维液相色谱模式,适用于蛋白质组学和本草物质组学研究中对于复杂样品的分离分析。     

Optimization of a comprehensive two-dimensional normal-phase and reversed-phase liquid chromatography system

The present investigation is based on the evaluation of the performance of a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LCxLC) system during method optimization. The LCxLC set-up, operated in normal phase (NP) mode (adsorption) in the first dimension (1D) and reversed-phase (RP) mode in the second dimension (2D), is equipped with a 1D microbore silica column and a 2D monolithic C(18) column with a 10-port two position valve as the interface. A photodiode array detector is used after the 2D separation. A possible cause of peak distorsion because of the immiscibility of the mobile phases employed in the two dimensions is resolved. The optimization of the analytical run time and flow rate for both dimensions and the initial gradient in the 2D is carried out with various standard compounds. The potential and versatility of this LCxLC approach is demonstrated through the separation of 11 standard components, most of them allergens. The latter, which are characterized by a scattered distribution on the 2D space plane, underwent separation on both a hydrophobicity and polarity basis.     

Development of a comprehensive two-dimensional hydrophilic interaction chromatography/quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry system and its application in separation and identification of saponins from Quillaja saponaria

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) was used in two dimensions in a comprehensive two-dimensional HILIC hyphenated with a quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (HILICxHILIC-Q-TOF-MS) system for the analysis of complex samples of hydrophilic compounds. A TSKgel Amide-80 column was employed as the first dimension, and a short PolyHydroxyethyl A column was as the second dimension. The column system showed moderate orthogonality at defined operational conditions. A high speed Q-TOF-MS detector as a third complementary dimension significantly improved the peak capacity. The separation capability of the developed HILICxHILIC-Q-TOF-MS system was tested by separating an extract from Quillaja saponaria. The major components, quillaja saponins, in the extract were well identified by means of [M-H](-) ions, characteristic product ions, and their two-dimensional retention behaviors. Several pairs of isomers, which were often co-eluted on conventional LC-MS methods and had similar fragmentation characteristics in MS/MS spectra, were well separated on the two-dimensional system based on their different hydrophilicity. The developed comprehensive two-dimensional HILIC system demonstrates unique selectivity for hydrophilic compounds and satisfactory peak capacity and resolution for analogues by making sufficient use of two-dimensional separation plane.