A combined quantum chemical/molecular mechanical study of hydrogen-bonded systems

A computational approach, which involves the combination of the OPLS force field and molecular orbital MNDO , AM 1, and PM 3 methods, has been developed to describe the effects of a large, molecular mechanically simulated environment on the Hamiltonian of a quantum chemical system. To test the validity of the combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM /MM ) potential, a systematic study of the structures and energies of neutral and charged hydrogen-bonded complexes has been carried out, including comparisons with pure semiempirical calculations and available experimental and ab initio data. It is shown that, in many cases, the hybrid QM /MM potential behaves better than do related MNDO /M , AM 1, and PM 3 methods. As a case in point, the draw-back of AM 1 favoring bifurcated H-bonded structures over single ones is not presented in the combined AM 1/OPLS scheme. Possible ways of improvement of the combined QM /MM potential are discussed. © 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Performance assessment of semiempirical molecular orbital methods in describing halogen bonding: quantum mechanical and quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical-molecular dynamics study

The performance of semiempirical molecular-orbital methods--MNDO, MNDO-d, AM1, RM1, PM3 and PM6--in describing halogen bonding was evaluated, and the results were compared with molecular mechanical (MM) and quantum mechanical (QM) data. Three types of performance were assessed: (1) geometrical optimizations and binding energy calculations for 27 halogen-containing molecules complexed with various Lewis bases (Two of the tested methods, AM1 and RM1, gave results that agree with the QM data.); (2) charge distribution calculations for halobenzene molecules, determined by calculating the solvation free energies of the molecules relative to benzene in explicit and implicit generalized Born (GB) solvents (None of the methods gave results that agree with the experimental data.); and (3) appropriateness of the semiempirical methods in the hybrid quantum-mechanical/molecular-mechanical (QM/MM) scheme, investigated by studying the molecular inhibition of CK2 protein by eight halobenzimidazole and -benzotriazole derivatives using hybrid QM/MM molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations with the inhibitor described at the QM level by the AM1 method and the rest of the system described at the MM level. The pure MM approach with inclusion of an extra point of positive charge on the halogen atom approach gave better results than the hybrid QM/MM approach involving the AM1 method. Also, in comparison with the pure MM-GBSA (generalized Born surface area) binding energies and experimental data, the calculated QM/MM-GBSA binding energies of the inhibitors were improved by replacing the G(GB,QM/MM) solvation term with the corresponding G(GB,MM) term.     

Reaction path potential for complex systems derived from combined ab initio quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical calculations

Combined ab initio quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical calculations have been widely used for modeling chemical reactions in complex systems such as enzymes, with most applications being based on the determination of a minimum energy path connecting the reactant through the transition state to the product in the enzyme environment. However, statistical mechanics sampling and reaction dynamics calculations with a combined ab initio quantum mechanical (QM) and molecular mechanical (MM) potential are still not feasible because of the computational costs associated mainly with the ab initio quantum mechanical calculations for the QM subsystem. To address this issue, a reaction path potential energy surface is developed here for statistical mechanics and dynamics simulation of chemical reactions in enzymes and other complex systems. The reaction path potential follows the ideas from the reaction path Hamiltonian of Miller, Handy and Adams for gas phase chemical reactions but is designed specifically for large systems that are described with combined ab initio quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical methods. The reaction path potential is an analytical energy expression of the combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical potential energy along the minimum energy path. An expansion around the minimum energy path is made in both the nuclear and the electronic degrees of freedom for the QM subsystem internal energy, while the energy of the subsystem described with MM remains unchanged from that in the combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical expression and the electrostatic interaction between the QM and MM subsystems is described as the interaction of the MM charges with the QM charges. The QM charges are polarizable in response to the changes in both the MM and the QM degrees of freedom through a new response kernel developed in the present work. The input data for constructing the reaction path potential are energies, vibrational frequencies, and electron density response properties of the QM subsystem along the minimum energy path, all of which can be obtained from the combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical calculations. Once constructed, it costs much less for its evaluation. Thus, the reaction path potential provides a potential energy surface for rigorous statistical mechanics and reaction dynamics calculations of complex systems. As an example, the method is applied to the statistical mechanical calculations for the potential of mean force of the chemical reaction in triosephosphate isomerase.     

Importance of accurate charges in molecular docking: quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) approach

The extent to which accuracy of electric charges plays a role in protein-ligand docking is investigated through development of a docking algorithm, which incorporates quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations. In this algorithm, fixed charges of ligands obtained from force field parameterization are replaced by QM/MM calculations in the protein environment, treating only the ligands as the quantum region. The algorithm is tested on a set of 40 cocrystallized structures taken from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) and provides strong evidence that use of nonfixed charges is important. An algorithm, dubbed "Survival of the Fittest" (SOF) algorithm, is implemented to incorporate QM/MM charge calculations without any prior knowledge of native structures of the complexes. Using an iterative protocol, this algorithm is able in many cases to converge to a nativelike structure in systems where redocking of the ligand using a standard fixed charge force field exhibits nontrivial errors. The results demonstrate that polarization effects can play a significant role in determining the structures of protein-ligand complexes, and provide a promising start towards the development of more accurate docking methods for lead optimization applications.     

Interfacing the GROMOS (bio)molecular simulation software to quantum‐chemical program packages

The newly implemented quantum‐chemical/molecular‐mechanical (QM/MM) functionality of the Groningen molecular simulation (GROMOS) software for (bio)molecular simulation is described. The implementation scheme is based on direct coupling of the GROMOS C++ software to executables of the quantum‐chemical program packages MNDO and TURBOMOLE, allowing for an independent further development of these packages. The new functions are validated for different test systems using program and model testing techniques. The effect of truncating the QM/MM electrostatic interactions at various QM/MM cutoff radii is discussed and the application of semiempirical versus density‐functional Hamiltonians for a solute molecule in aqueous solution is compared. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

MM and QM/MM Modeling of Threonyl-tRNA Synthetase: Model Testing and Simulations

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are centrally important enzymes in protein synthesis. We have investigated threonyl-tRNA synthetase from E. coli, complexed with reactants, using molecular mechanics and combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) techniques. These modeling methods have the potential to provide molecular level understanding of enzyme catalytic processes. Modeling of this enzyme presents a number of challenges. The procedure of system preparation and testing is described in detail. For example, the number of metal ions at the active site, and their positions, were investigated. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the system is most stable when it contains only one magnesium ion, and the zinc ion is removed. Two different QM/MM methods were tested in models based on the findings of MM molecular dynamics simulations. AM1/CHARMM calculations resulted in unrealistic structures for the phosphates in this system. This is apparently due to an error of AM1. PM3/CHARMM calculations proved to be more suitable for this enzyme system. These results will provide a useful basis for future modeling investigations of the enzyme mechanism and dynamics.     

Molecular dynamics and free energy perturbation study of hydride-ion transfer step in dihydrofolate reductase using combined quantum and molecular mechanical model

We used molecular dynamics simulation and free energy perturbation (FEP) methods to investigate the hydride-ion transfer step in the mechanism for the nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH)-dependent reduction of a novel substrate by the enzyme dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR). The system is represented by a coupled quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) model based on the AM1 semiempirical molecular orbital method for the reacting substrate and NADPH cofactor fragments, the AMBER force field for DHFR, and the TIP3P model for solvent water. The FEP calculations were performed for a number of choices for the QM system. The substrate, 8-methylpterin, was treated quantum mechanically in all the calculations, while the larger cofactor molecule was partitioned into various QM and MM regions with the addition of “link” atoms (F, CH₃, and H). Calculations were also carried out with the entire NADPH molecule treated by QM. The free energies of reaction and the net charges on the NADPH fragments were used to determine the most appropriate QM/MM model. The hydride-ion transfer was also carried out over several FEP pathways, and the QM and QM/MM component free energies thus calculated were found to be state functions (i.e., independent of pathway). A ca. 10 kcal/mol increase in free energy for the hydride-ion transfer with an activation barrier of ca. 30 kcal/mol was calculated. The increase in free energy on the hydride-ion transfer arose largely from the QM/MM component. Analysis of the QM/MM energy components suggests that, although a number of charged residues may contribute to the free energy change through long-range electrostatic interactions, the only interaction that can account for the 10 kcal/mol increase in free energy is the hydrogen bond between the carboxylate side chain of Glu30 (avian DHFR) and the activated (protonated) substrate. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 19: 977–988, 1998     

Contributions of pauli repulsions to the energetics and physical properties computed in QM/MM methods

Conventional combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) methods lack explicit treatment of Pauli repulsions between the quantum‐mechanical and molecular‐mechanical subsystems. Instead, classical Lennard‐Jones (LJ) potentials between QM and MM nuclei are used to model electronic Pauli repulsion and long‐range London dispersion, despite the fact that the latter two are inherently of quantum nature. Use of the simple LJ potential in QM/MM methods can reproduce minimal geometries and energies of many molecular clusters reasonably well, as compared to full QM calculations. However, we show here that the LJ potential cannot correctly describe subtle details of the electron density of the QM subsystem because of the neglect of Pauli repulsions between the QM and MM subsystems. The inaccurate electron density subsequently affects the calculation of electronic and magnetic properties of the QM subsystem. To explicitly consider Pauli interactions with QM/MM methods, we propose a method to use empirical effective potentials on the MM atoms. The test case of the binding energy and magnetic properties of a water dimer shows promising results for the general application of effective potentials to mimic Pauli repulsions in QM/MM calculations. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

YinYang atom: a simple combined ab initio quantum mechanical molecular mechanical model

A simple interface is proposed for combined quantum mechanical (QM) molecular mechanical (MM) calculations for the systems where the QM and MM regions are connected through covalent bonds. Within this model, the atom that connects the two regions, called YinYang atom here, serves as an ordinary MM atom to other MM atoms and as a hydrogen-like atom to other QM atoms. Only one new empirical parameter is introduced to adjust the length of the connecting bond and is calibrated with the molecule propanol. This model is tested with the computation of equilibrium geometries and protonation energies for dozens of molecules. Special attention is paid on the influence of MM point charges on optimized geometry and protonation energy, and it is found that it is important to maintain local charge-neutrality in the MM region in order for the accurate calculation of the protonation and deprotonation energies. Overall the simple YinYang atom model yields comparable results to some other QM/MM models.     

Smooth solvation method for d-orbital semiempirical calculations of biological reactions. 2. Application to transphosphorylation thio effects in solution

Density-functional and semiempirical quantum methods and continuum dielectric and explicit solvation models are applied to study the role of solvation on the stabilization of native and thio-substituted transphosphorylation reactions. Extensive comparison is made between results obtained from the different methods. For the semiempirical methods, explicit solvation was treated using a hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) approach and the implicit solvation was treated using a recently developed smooth solvation model implemented into a d-orbital semiempirical framework (MNDO/d-SCOSMO) within CHARMM. The different quantum and solvation methods were applied to the transesterification of a 3'-ribose,5'-methyl phosphodiester that serves as a nonenzymatic model for the self-cleavage reaction catalyzed by the hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes. Thio effects were studied for a double sulfur substitution at the nonbridging phosphoryl oxygen positions. The reaction profiles of both the native and double sulfur-substituted reactions from the MNDO/d-SCOSMO calculations were similar to the QM/MM results and consistent with the experimentally observed trends. These results underscore the need for a d-orbital semiempirical representation for phosphorus and sulfur for the study of experimentally observed thio effects in enzymatic and nonenzymatic phosphoryl transfer reactions. One of the major advantages of the present approach is that it can be applied to model chemical reactions at a significantly lower computational cost than either the density-functional calculations with implicit solvation or the semiempirical QM/MM simulations with explicit solvent.     

Quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical study on the mechanism of the enzymatic Baeyer-Villiger reaction

We report a combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) study on the mechanism of the enzymatic Baeyer-Villiger reaction catalyzed by cyclohexanone monooxygenase (CHMO). In QM/MM geometry optimizations and reaction path calculations, density functional theory (B3LYP/TZVP) is used to describe the QM region consisting of the substrate (cyclohexanone), the isoalloxazine ring of C4a-peroxyflavin, the side chain of Arg-329, and the nicotinamide ring and the adjacent ribose of NADP(+), while the remainder of the enzyme is represented by the CHARMM force field. QM/MM molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations at the semiempirical OM3/CHARMM level employ the same QM/MM partitioning. According to the QM/MM calculations, the enzyme-reactant complex contains an anionic deprotonated C4a-peroxyflavin that is stabilized by strong hydrogen bonds with the Arg-329 residue and the NADP(+) cofactor. The CHMO-catalyzed reaction proceeds via a Criegee intermediate having pronounced anionic character. The initial addition reaction has to overcome an energy barrier of about 9 kcal/mol. The formed Criegee intermediate occupies a shallow minimum on the QM/MM potential energy surface and can undergo fragmentation to the lactone product by surmounting a second energy barrier of about 7 kcal/mol. The transition state for the latter migration step is the highest point on the QM/MM energy profile. Gas-phase reoptimizations of the QM region lead to higher barriers and confirm the crucial role of the Arg-329 residue and the NADP(+) cofactor for the catalytic efficiency of CHMO. QM/MM calculations for the CHMO-catalyzed oxidation of 4-methylcyclohexanone reproduce and rationalize the experimentally observed (S)-enantioselectivity for this substrate, which is governed by the conformational preferences of the corresponding Criegee intermediate and the subsequent transition state for the migration step.     

Recent advances in quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical calculations of enzyme catalysis: hydrogen tunnelling in liver alcohol dehydrogenase and inhibition of elastase by α-ketoheterocycles

 Hybrid quantum mechanical (QM)/molecular mechanical (MM) calculations are used to study two aspects of enzyme catalysis, Kinetic isotope effects associated with the hydride ion transfer step in the reduction of benzyl alcohol by liver alcohol dehydrogenase are studied by employing variational transition-state theory and optimised multidimensional tunnelling. With the smaller QM region, described at the Hartree–Fock ab initio level, together with a parameterised zinc atom charge, good agreement with experiment is obtained. A comparison is made with the proton transfer in methylamine dehydrogenase. The origin of the large range in pharmacological activity shown by a series of α-ketoheterocycle inhibitors of the serine protease, elastase, is investigated by both force field and QM/MM calculations. Both models point to two different inhibition mechanisms being operative. Initial QM/MM calculations suggest that these are binding, and reaction to form a tetrahedral intermediate, the latter process occurring for only the more potent set of inhibitors. Recieved 3 October 2001 / Accepted: 6 September 2002 / Published online: 31 January 2003 Contribution to the Proceedings of the Symposium on Combined QM/MM Methods at the 222nd National Meeting of the American Chemical Society, 2001 Correspondence to: I. H. Hillier Acknowledgements. We thank EPSRC and BBSRC for support of the research and D.G. Truhlar for the use of the POLYRATE code.     

Design-atom approach for the quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical covalent boundary: a design-carbon atom with five valence electrons

A critical issue underlying the accuracy and applicability of the combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) methods is how to describe the QM/MM boundary across covalent bonds. Inspired by the ab initio pseudopotential theory, here we introduce a novel design atom approach for a more fundamental and transparent treatment of this QM/MM covalent boundary problem. The main idea is to replace the boundary atom of the active part with a design atom, which has a different number of valence electrons but very similar atomic properties. By modifying the Troullier-Martins scheme, which has been widely employed to construct norm-conserving pseudopotentials for density functional calculations, we have successfully developed a design-carbon atom with five valence electrons. Tests on a series of molecules yield very good structural and energetic results and indicate its transferability in describing a variety of chemical bonds, including double and triple bonds.     

The dynamo library for molecular simulations using hybrid quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical potentials

The Dynamo module library has been developed for the simulation of molecular systems using hybrid quantum mechanical (QM) and molecular mechanical (MM) potentials. Dynamo is not a program package but is a library of Fortran 90 modules that can be employed by those interested in writing their own programs for performing molecular simulations. The library supports a range of different types of molecular calculation including geometry optimizations, reaction‐path determinations and molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations. This article outlines the general structure and capabilities of the library and describes in detail Dynamo's semiempirical QM/MM hybrid potential. Results are presented to indicate three particular aspects of this implementation—the handling of long‐range nonbonding interactions, the nature of the boundary between the quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical atoms and how to perform path‐integral hybrid‐potential molecular dynamics simulations. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 21: 1088–1100, 2000     

Enzyme mechanisms with hybrid quantum and molecular mechanical potentials. I. Theoretical considerations

The application of hybrid quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) potentials to the study of chemical reactions in enzymes is outlined. The discussion is general and addresses the difficulties encountered in an enzyme QM/MM study. First, general criteria for determining whether a particular enzyme is an appropriate candidate for a QM/MM approach are outlined. Methods for obtaining starting structures are detailed. The importance of choosing appropriate levels of ab initio or semiempirical theory is emphasized. Approaches for interfacing the QM and MM regions are briefly discussed, with greater detail given to describing our CHARMM-GAMESS interface. Techniques for partitioning the system into QM and MM regions are explored. Link atom placement, as distant from reacting atoms as possible within the confines of computational efficiency, is examined in some detail. Methods for determining reaction paths are also discussed. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Dynamic structures of phosphodiesterase-5 active site by combined molecular dynamics simulations and hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical calculations

Various quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) geometry optimizations starting from an x-ray crystal structure and from the snapshot structures of constrained molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been performed to characterize two dynamically stable active site structures of phosphodiesterase-5 (PDE5) in solution. The only difference between the two PDE5 structures exists in the catalytic, second bridging ligand (BL2) which is HO- or H2O. It has been shown that, whereas BL2 (i.e. HO-) in the PDE5(BL2 = HO-) structure can really bridge the two positively charged metal ions (Zn2+ and Mg2+), BL2 (i.e. H2O) in the PDE5(BL2 = H2O) structure can only coordinate Mg2+. It has been demonstrated that the results of the QM/MM geometry optimizations are remarkably affected by the solvent water molecules, the dynamics of the protein environment, and the electronic embedding charges of the MM region in the QM part of the QMM/MM calculation. The PDE5(BL2 = H2O) geometries optimized by using the QM/MM method in different ways show strong couplings between these important factors. It is interesting to note that the PDE5(BL2 = HO-) and PDE5(BL2 = H2O) geometries determined by the QM/MM calculations neglecting these three factors are all consistent with the corresponding geometries determined by the QM/MM calculations that account for all of these three factors. These results suggest the overall effects of these three important factors on the optimized geometries can roughly cancel out. However, the QM/MM calculations that only account for some of these factors could lead to considerably different geometries. These results might be useful also in guiding future QM/MM geometry optimizations on other enzymes.