Teaching values and valued teaching in the mathematics classroom: toward a research agenda

In this paper, we first discuss the teaching of values by focusing on the kinds of values that have been discussed and studied in the other papers in this special journal issue and elsewhere. Then we raise a number of issues about the product-based values in mathematics education, which we identify as teaching values and which can be realized through classroom instruction. In the second section, we discuss the process-based valued teaching methods used to maximize the realization of the teaching values in the classroom. As valued teaching may be perceived differently by different people, in the discussion we analyze how it is seen from both students?? and teachers?? perspectives. We end this paper by discussing a number of methodological issues in studying teaching values and valued teaching as well as offering suggestions for future research.     

Contingent conceptions of accomplished practice: the cultural specificity of discourse in and about the mathematics classroom

Classroom discourse and professional discourse about classrooms constitute forms of social performance undertaken within affordances and constraints that can be both cultural and linguistic. The nature of those discourses performed in mathematics classrooms provides a key indicator of pedagogical principles underlying classroom practice and the theories of learning on which these principles are implicitly founded. The discourses about mathematics classrooms give expression to these pedagogical principles sometimes explicitly and sometimes through embedding privileged forms of practice in the naming conventions by which the mathematics classroom is described. The research reported in this paper suggests that each of these discourses is culturally and linguistically specific. As a consequence, conceptions of accomplished practice are contingent on the history of custom and insight embedded in the conventions of practice and the language with which that practice is described.     

Mathematics teaching development as a human practice: identifying and drawing the threads

The didactic triangle links mathematics, teachers and students in a consideration of teaching?Clearning interactions in mathematics classrooms. This paper focuses on teachers and teaching in the development of fruitful learning experiences for students with mathematics. It recognises primarily that teachers are humans with personal characteristics, subject to a range of influences through the communities of which they are a part, and considers aspects of teachers?? personhood, identity and agency in designing teaching for the benefit of their students. Teaching is seen as a developmental process in which inquiry plays a central role, both in doing mathematics in the classroom and in exploring teaching practice. The teacher-as-inquirer in collaboration with outsider researchers leads to growth of knowledge in teaching through development of identity and agency for both groups. The inclusion of the outsider researcher brings an additional node into the didactic triangle.     

Exemplary mathematics instruction and its development in selected education systems in East Asia

What may teachers do in developing and carrying out exemplary or high-quality mathematics classroom instruction? What can we learn from teachers’ instructional practices that are often culturally valued in different education systems? In this article, we aim to highlight relevant issues that have long been interests of mathematics educators worldwide in identifying and examining teachers’ practices in high-quality mathematics classroom instruction, and outline what articles published herein can help further our understanding of such issues with cases of exemplary mathematics instruction valued in the Chinese Mainland, Hong Kong, Japan, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan.     

The Impact of Enacted Mathematics Curriculum Models on Prospective Elementary Teachers' Course Perceptions and Beliefs

This paper communicates the impact of prospective teachers' learning of mathematics using novel curriculum materials in an innovative classroom setting. Two sections of a mathematics content course for prospective elementary teachers used different text materials and instructional approaches. The primary mathematical authorities were the instructor and text in the textbook section and the prospective teachers in the curriculum materials section. After one semester, teachers in the curriculum materials section (n= 34) placed significantly more importance on classroom group work and discussions, less on instructor lecture and explanation, and less on textbooks having practice problems, examples, and explanations. They valued student exploration over practice. In the textbook section (n= 19), there was little change in the teachers' beliefs, in which practice was valued over exploration. These results highlight the positive impact of experiences with innovative curriculum materials on prospective elementary teachers' beliefs about mathematics instruction.     

‘Excellent’ primary mathematics teachers’ espoused and enacted values of effective lessons

This paper reports a study that explored the characteristics of mathematics lessons that were espoused as effective by six ??excellent?? mathematics teachers and how they enacted their values in their classroom practice. In this study, we define espoused values as values that we want other people to believe we hold, and enacted values as values that we actually practice. Qualitative data were collected through video-recorded lesson observations (3 lessons for each teacher) and in-depth interviews with teachers after each observation. At the end of the project, stimulated-recall focus group interviews were used to allow teachers to define the meaning of an effective mathematics lesson as well as to recall and reflect on a 10-min edited video clip of one of their teaching lessons. The findings showed that these teachers shared five common characteristics of effective mathematics lessons: achieving teaching objectives; pupils?? cognitive development; affective achievement of pupils; focus on low-attaining pupils; and active participation of pupils in mathematics activities. These values were espoused explicitly as well as enacted in the lessons observed.     

Pursuing excellence in mathematics classroom instruction through exemplary lesson development in China: a case study

In this article, we aim to examine the features of mathematics classroom instruction excellence valued in China. The popular approach to pursuing mathematics classroom instruction excellence through exemplary lesson development is also investigated to demonstrate the nature of teaching culture that has been advocated and nurtured in China. Features of an exemplary lesson are analyzed in detail, and the practicing teacher’s experience through participating in the development of the exemplary lesson is examined as well. Finally, the implications of developing exemplary lessons for pursuing excellence in mathematics classroom instruction as a culturally valued approach in China are also discussed.     

Facing the change and meeting the challenge: mathematics curriculum of Tongwen Guan in China in the second half of the nineteenth century

It is commonly recognized that the second wave of transmission of Western science and mathematics into China took place in the second half of the nineteenth century, thereby starting a process of modernization which has become synonymous with ??westernization?? of the country. In this context mathematics education in China also went through a process of modernization. During this period of great change reformers faced serious challenge and went through a ??mental struggle??. This paper discusses this challenge and mental struggle by taking a close look at the controversy over the establishment of Tianwen Suanxue Guan (School of Astronomy and Mathematics) in Tongwen Guan (School of Combined Learning), one of the schools of Western learning at the time. The attempt to integrate Western mathematics with Chinese traditional mathematics is also discussed through the study of some questions sampled from examinations and students?? homework assignments of this school.     

Teachers and didacticians: key stakeholders in the processes of developing mathematics teaching

This paper sets the scene for a special issue of ZDM—The International Journal on Mathematics Education—by tracing key elements of the fields of teacher and didactician/teacher-educator learning related to the development of opportunities for learners of mathematics in classrooms. It starts from the perspective that joint activity of these two groups (teachers and didacticians), in creation of classroom mathematics, leads to learning for both. We trace development through key areas of research, looking at forms of knowledge of teachers and didacticians in mathematics; ways in which teachers or didacticians in mathematics develop their professional knowledge and skill; and the use of theoretical perspectives relating to studying these areas of development. Reflective practice emerges as a principal goal for effective development and is linked to teachers’ and didacticians’ engagement with inquiry and research. While neither reflection nor inquiry are developmental panaceas, we see collaborative critical inquiry between teachers and didacticians emerging as a significant force for teaching development. We include a summary of the papers of the special issue which offer a state of the art perspective on developmental practice.     

Linguistic indexicality in algebra discussions

In discussion-oriented classrooms, students create mathematical ideas through conversations that reflect growing collective knowledge. Linguistic forms known as indexicals assist in the analysis of this collective, negotiated understanding. Indexical words and phrases create meaning through reference to the physical, verbal and ideational context. While some indexicals such as pronouns and demonstratives (e.g. this, that) are fairly well-known in mathematics education research, other structures play significant roles in math discussions as well. We describe students’ use of entailing and presupposing indexicality, verbs of motion, and poetic structures to express and negotiate mathematical ideas and classroom norms including pedagogical responsibility, conjecturing, evaluating and expressing reified mathematical knowledge. The multiple forms and functions of indexical language help describe the dynamic and emergent nature of mathematical classroom discussions. Because interactive learning depends on linguistically established connections among ideas, indexical language may prove to be a communicative resource that makes collaborative mathematical learning possible.     

Humans-with-media and continuing education for mathematics teachers in online environments

This paper begins by situating online mathematics education in Brazil within the context of research on digital technology over the past 25?years. I argue that Brazilian research on technology in mathematics education can be divided into four phases, and then present an example that ??blends?? aspects of the second and third phases. Phase two can be characterized by research with software designed to address traditional mathematics topics, such as functions, while the third phase is characterized by online courses. The data presented show creative solutions for a problem designed for collectives of humans-with-function-software. The paper is analyzed from a perspective that emphasizes the role of different technologies as teachers and professors collaborate to produce knowledge about the use of mathematical software in regular face-to-face classrooms. A model of online education is presented. Finally, the paper discusses how technology may change collaboration and teaching approaches in continuing education, as it allows for greater integration of online learning with teachers?? classroom activities in schools. In this case, the online platform plays an active role in the learning collective composed of humans-with-media.     

An evolving framework for describing student engagement in classroom activities

Student engagement in classroom activities is usually described as a function of factors such as human needs, affect, intention, motivation, interests, identity, and others. We take a different approach and develop a framework that models classroom engagement as a function of students’ conceptual competence in the specific content (e.g., the mathematics of motion) of an activity. The framework uses a spatial metaphor—i.e., the classroom activity as a territory through which students move—as a way to both capture common engagement-related dynamics and as a communicative device. In this formulation, then, students’ engaged participation can be understood in terms of the nature of the “regions” and overall “topography” of the activity territory, and how much student movement such a territory affords. We offer the framework not in competition with other instructional design approaches, but rather as an additional tool to aid in the analysis and conduct of engaging classroom activities.     

Weighted intriguing sets of finite generalised quadrangles

We construct and analyse interesting integer valued functions on the points of a generalised quadrangle which lie in the orthogonal complement of a principal eigenspace of the collinearity relation. These functions generalise the intriguing sets introduced by Bamberg et al. (Combinatorica 29(1):1?C17, 2009), and they provide the extra machinery to give new proofs of old results and to establish new insight into the existence of certain configurations of generalised quadrangles. In particular, we give a geometric characterisation of Payne??s tight sets, we give a new proof of Thas?? result that an m-ovoid of a generalised quadrangle of order (s,s ²) is a hemisystem, and we give a bound on the values of m for which it is possible for an m-ovoid of the four dimensional Hermitian variety to exist.     

Transformation!—A graphing calculator activity to practice transformations of functions

An understanding of function transformation is essential for mastering mathematics in high school and beyond. The classroom activity presented here and the game,Transformation!, are designed so that students can develop fluency in working with transformations of functions. Both take advantage of the technology of the graphing calculator and the method of cooperative learning.     

What do the Chinese value in (mathematics) education?

The achievement in mathematics among the Chinese has aroused the interest of educationalists, sociologists and psychologists worldwide. The coining of the term Confucian Heritage Culture learner??s phenomenon mistakenly led researchers to look for direct attributions from Confucianism, without realizing that Confucianism is just one Chinese school of thought, and it is over-simplistic to draw causal relationships between schools of thought and social phenomena. This paper begins by introducing three major Chinese schools of thought??Confucianism, Daoism and Buddhism??and their views on education. The discussion will then focus on how these schools of thought might impact education in general and mathematics education in particular.     

On the Ekeland–Ghoussoub–Preiss and Stuart criteria for locating Cerami sequences

A classical result of Ekeland, based on an idea of Ghoussoub and Preiss, asserts that under technical conditions, Cerami sequences for a real valued functional ${\Phi}$ on a Banach space X can be found in the vicinity of suitable closed subsets W of X. In this statement, ??vicinity?? is defined by means of an associated geodesic distance on X. Recently, under virtually the same hypotheses, Stuart discovered a similar property with a much clearer content since it can very simply be expressed in terms of the norm of X and the corresponding standard distance. In this paper, we prove that the Ekeland?CGhoussoub?CPreiss and Stuart criteria are in fact equivalent. We also show that this equivalence need not be true when Cerami sequences are replaced by more general, yet admissible sequences, but that the equivalence is preserved, in part or in totality, under simple additional conditions. These results are also applicable to more general linking geometries than considered by Ekeland?CGhoussoub?CPreiss or Stuart and to nonsmooth functionals.