Carboxylation Reactions with Carbon Dioxide Using N‐Heterocyclic Carbene‐Copper Catalysts

The development of versatile catalyst systems and new transformations for the utilization of carbon dioxide (CO₂) is of great interest and significance. This Personal Account reviews our studies on the exploration of the reactions of CO₂ with various substrates by the use of N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC)‐copper catalysts. The carboxylation of organoboron compounds gave access to a wide range of carboxylic acids with excellent functional group tolerance. The C?H bond carboxylation with CO₂ emerged as a straightforward protocol for the preparation of a series of aromatic carboxylic esters and butenoates from simple substrates. The hydrosilylation of CO₂ with hydrosilanes provided an efficient method for the synthesis of silyl formate on gram scale. The hydrogenative or alkylative carboxylation of alkynes, ynamides and allenamides yielded useful α,β‐unsaturated carboxylic acids and α,β‐dehydro amino acid esters. The boracarboxylation of alkynes or aldehydes afforded the novel lithium cyclic boralactone or boracarbonate products, respectively. The NHC‐copper catalysts generally featured excellent functional group compatibility, broad substrate scope, high efficiency, and high regio‐ and stereoselectivity. The unique electronic and steric properties of the NHC‐copper units also enabled the isolation and structural characterization of some key intermediates for better understanding of the catalytic reaction mechanisms.     

Cu‐Catalyzed Alkylative Carboxylation of Ynamides with Dialkylzinc Reagents and Carbon Dioxide

Alkylative carboxylation of ynamides with CO₂ and dialkylzinc reagents using a N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC)–copper catalyst has been developed. A variety of ynamides, both cyclic and acyclic, undergo this transformation under mild conditions to afford the corresponding α,β‐unsaturated carboxylic acids, which contain the α,β‐dehydroamino acid skeleton. The present alkylative carboxylation formally consists of Cu‐catalyzed carbozincation of ynamides with dialkylzinc reagents with the subsequent nucleophilic carboxylation of the resulting alkenylzinc species with CO₂. Dialkylzinc reagents bearing a β‐hydrogen atom such as Et₂Zn and Bu₂Zn still afford the alkylated products despite the potential for β‐hydride elimination. This protocol would be a desirable method for the synthesis of highly substituted α,β‐ dehydroamino acid derivatives due to its high regio‐ and stereoselectivity, simple one‐pot procedure, and its use of CO₂ as a starting material.     

The Renaissance of an Old Problem: Highly Regioselective Carboxylation of 2‐Alkynyl Bromides with Carbon Dioxide

A steric effect‐controlled, zinc‐mediated carboxylation of different 2‐alkynyl bromides under an atmospheric pressure of CO₂ has been developed by careful tuning of different reaction parameters, including the metal, solvent, temperature, and additive. 2‐Substituted 2,3‐allenoic acids were afforded from primary 2‐alkynyl bromides, whereas the carboxylation of secondary 2‐alkynyl bromides yielded 3‐alkynoic acids in decent yields. A rationale for the observed regioselectivity has been proposed.     

A Light/Ketone/Copper System for Carboxylation of Allylic C−H Bonds of Alkenes with CO2

A photo‐induced carboxylation reaction of allylic C?H bonds of simple alkenes with CO₂ is prompted by means of a ketone and a copper complex. The unique carboxylation reaction proceeds through a sequence of an endergonic photoreaction of ketones with alkenes forming homoallyl alcohol intermediates and a thermal copper‐catalyzed allyl transfer reaction from the homoallyl alcohols to CO₂ through C?C bond cleavage.     

Non‐natural Cofactor and Formate‐Driven Reductive Carboxylation of Pyruvate

A non‐natural cofactor and formate driven system for reductive carboxylation of pyruvate is presented. A formate dehydrogenase (FDH) mutant, FDH*, that favors a non‐natural redox cofactor, nicotinamide cytosine dinucleotide (NCD), for generation of a dedicated reducing equivalent at the expense of formate were acquired. By coupling FDH* and NCD‐dependent malic enzyme (ME*), the successful utilization of formate is demonstrated as both CO₂ source and electron donor for reductive carboxylation of pyruvate with a perfect stoichiometry between formate and malate. When ¹³C‐isotope‐labeled formate was used in in vitro trials, up to 53 % of malate had labeled carbon atom. Upon expression of FDH* and ME* in the model host E. coli, the engineered strain produced more malate in the presence of formate and NCD. This work provides an alternative and atom‐economic strategy for CO₂ fixation where formate is used in lieu of CO₂ and offers dedicated reducing power.     

Cu‐Catalyzed Formal Methylative and Hydrogenative Carboxylation of Alkynes with Carbon Dioxide: Efficient Synthesis of α,β‐Unsaturated Carboxylic Acids

The sequential hydroalumination or methylalumination of various alkynes catalyzed by different catalyst systems, such those based on Sc, Zr, and Ni complexes, and the subsequent carboxylation of the resulting alkenylaluminum species with CO₂ catalyzed by an N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC)–copper catalyst have been examined in detail. The regio‐ and stereoselectivity of the overall reaction relied largely on the hydroalumination or methylalumination reactions, which significantly depended on the catalyst and alkyne substrates. The subsequent Cu‐catalyzed carboxylation proceeded with retention of the stereoconfiguration of the alkenylaluminum species. All the reactions could be carried out in one‐pot to afford efficiently a variety of α,β‐unsaturated carboxylic acids with well‐controlled configurations, which are difficult to construct by previously reported methods. This protocol could be practically useful and attractive because of its high regio‐ and stereoselectivity, simple one‐pot reaction operation, and the use of CO₂ as a starting material.     

Insertion of CO2 Mediated by a (Xantphos)NiI–Alkyl Species

The incorporation of CO₂ into organometallic and organic molecules represents a sustainable way to prepare carboxylates. The mechanism of reductive carboxylation of alkyl halides has been proposed to proceed through the reduction of Ni^II to Ni^I by either Zn or Mn, followed by CO₂ insertion into Ni^I‐alkyl species. No experimental evidence has been previously established to support the two proposed steps. Demonstrated herein is that the direct reduction of (tBu‐Xantphos)Ni^IIBr₂ by Zn affords Ni^I species. (tBu‐Xantphos)Ni^I‐Me and (tBu‐Xantphos)Ni^I‐Et complexes undergo fast insertion of CO₂ at 22 °C. The substantially faster rate, relative to that of Ni^II complexes, serves as the long‐sought‐after experimental support for the proposed mechanisms of Ni‐catalyzed carboxylation reactions.     

Lactonization of C(sp2)—H Bonds in Enamides with CO2

Herein, we report a novel synthesis of 1,3‐oxazin‐6‐ones from enamides with CO₂ through C—H carboxylation and one‐pot cyclization. This transition‐metal‐free and redox‐neutral process features broad substrate scope, good functional group tolerance and facile product derivatization. The nucleophilic attack to CO₂ from the electron‐rich alkene is demonstrated for this reaction.     

Mechanistic Insights into the Ni‐Catalyzed Reductive Carboxylation of C−O Bonds in Aromatic Esters with CO2: Understanding Remarkable Ligand and Traceless‐Directing‐Group Effects

The mechanism of the Ni⁰‐catalyzed reductive carboxylation reaction of C(sp²)?O and C(sp³)?O bonds in aromatic esters with CO₂ to access valuable carboxylic acids was comprehensively studied by using DFT calculations. Computational results revealed that this transformation was composed of several key steps: C?O bond cleavage, reductive elimination, and/or CO₂ insertion. Of these steps, C?O bond cleavage was found to be rate‐determining, and it occurred through either oxidative addition to form a Ni^II intermediate, or a radical pathway that involved a bimetallic species to generate two Ni^I species through homolytic dissociation of the C?O bond. DFT calculations revealed that the oxidative addition step was preferred in the reductive carboxylation reactions of C(sp²)?O and C(sp³)?O bonds in substrates with extended π systems. In contrast, oxidative addition was highly disfavored when traceless directing groups were involved in the reductive coupling of substrates without extended π systems. In such cases, the presence of traceless directing groups allowed for docking of a second Ni⁰ catalyst, and the reactions proceed through a bimetallic radical pathway, rather than through concerted oxidative addition, to afford two Ni^I species both kinetically and thermodynamically. These theoretical mechanistic insights into the reductive carboxylation reactions of C?O bonds were also employed to investigate several experimentally observed phenomena, including ligand‐dependent reactivity and site‐selectivity.     

General Method for the Synthesis of Salicylic Acids from Phenols through Palladium‐Catalyzed Silanol‐Directed CH Carboxylation

A silanol‐directed, palladium‐catalyzed C? H carboxylation reaction of phenols to give salicylic acids has been developed. This method features high efficiency and selectivity, and excellent functional‐group tolerance. The generality of this method was demonstrated by the carboxylation of estrone and by the synthesis of an unsymmetrically o,o′‐disubstituted phenolic compound through two sequential C? H functionalization processes.     

Regioselective Alkylative Carboxylation of Allenamides with Carbon Dioxide and Dialkylzinc Reagents Catalyzed by an N‐Heterocyclic Carbene–Copper Complex

The alkylative carboxylation of allenamide catalyzed by an N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC)–copper(I) complex [(IPr)CuCl] with CO₂ and dialkylzinc reagents was investigated. The reaction of allenamides with dialkylzinc reagents (1.5 equiv) and CO₂ (1 atm.) proceeded smoothly in the presence of a catalytic quantity of [(IPr)CuCl] to afford (Z)‐α,β‐dehydro‐β‐amino acid esters in good yields. The reaction is regioselective, with the alkyl group introduced onto the less hindered γ‐carbon, and the carboxyl group introduced onto the β‐carbon atom of the allenamides. The first step of the reaction was alkylative zincation of the allenamides to give an alkenylzinc intermediate followed by nucleophilic addition to CO₂. A variety of cyclic and acyclic allenamides were found to be applicable to this transformation. Dialkylzinc reagents bearing β‐hydrogen atoms, such as Et₂Zn or Bu₂Zn, also gave the corresponding alkylative carboxylation products without β‐hydride elimination. The present methodology provides an easy route to alkyl‐substituted α,β‐dehydro‐β‐amino acid ester derivatives under mild reaction conditions with high regio‐ and stereoselectivtiy.     

Homogeneous Light‐Driven Catalytic Direct Carboxylation with CO2

Carbon dioxide is a ubiquitous and inexpensive one‐carbon source for chemical synthesis, and the efficient incorporation of CO₂ into organic molecules is of widespread research interest both for economic and ecological reasons. The methodologies to employ carbon dioxide as a single‐carbon unit to construct molecules relevant for agrochemical and pharmaceutical research include many elegant approaches, including asymmetric transformations. Even though remarkable achievements have been made in the field of light‐driven catalysis, especially photoredox catalysis, homogeneous light‐driven catalytic carboxylation by employing CO₂ as the key reagent has only become a subject of increasing attention in recent years. Therefore, this concise review will discuss the latest advances in this research area.     

Nickel‐Catalyzed Direct Carboxylation of Olefins with CO2: One‐Pot Synthesis of α,β‐Unsaturated Carboxylic Acid Salts

The nickel‐catalyzed direct carboxylation of alkenes with the cheap and abundantly available C₁ building block carbon dioxide (CO₂) in the presence of a base has been achieved. The one‐pot reaction allows for the direct and selective synthesis of a wide range of α,β‐unsaturated carboxylates (TON>100, TOF up to 6 h^?1, TON=turnover number, TOF=turnover frequency). Thus, it is possible, in one step, to synthesize sodium acrylate from ethylene, CO₂, and a sodium salt. Acrylates are industrially important products, the synthesis of which has hitherto required multiple steps.     

Rh‐Catalyzed Direct Carboxylation of Alkenyl C−H Bonds of Alkenylpyrazoles

The Rh‐catalyzed direct carboxylation of alkenyl C?H bonds was achieved by using pyrazole as a removable directing group. In the presence of 5 mol% RhCl₃ ? 3H₂O, 6 mol% P(Mes)₃, and 2 equiv. of AlMe₂(OMe), the alkenyl C?H bond of various alkenylpyrazoles was directly carboxylated in good yields under CO₂ atmosphere. Furthermore, several useful transformations of the pyrazole moiety of the product were achieved to afford synthetically useful carboxylic acid derivatives in good yields.     

Electroreductive Cobalt‐Catalyzed Carboxylation: Cross‐Electrophile Electrocoupling with Atmospheric CO2

The chemical use of CO₂ as an inexpensive, nontoxic C1 synthon is of utmost topical interest in the context of carbon capture and utilization (CCU). We present the merger of cobalt catalysis and electrochemical synthesis for mild catalytic carboxylations of allylic chlorides with CO₂. Styrylacetic acid derivatives were obtained with moderate to good yields and good functional group tolerance. The thus‐obtained products are useful as versatile synthons of γ‐arylbutyrolactones. Cyclic voltammetry and in operando kinetic analysis were performed to provide mechanistic insights into the electrocatalytic carboxylation with CO₂.     

Access to α‐Arylglycines by Umpolung Carboxylation of Aromatic Imines with Carbon Dioxide

A straightforward and transition‐metal‐free approach for the efficient synthesis of α‐arylglycine derivatives from aromatic imines and carbon dioxide was enabled by an umpolung carboxylation reaction. Various substituted diphenylmethimines underwent the carboxylation smoothly with carbon dioxide in the presence of potassium tert‐butoxide and 18‐crown‐6 to give the corresponding carboxylated products in good to high yields. Besides the enhancement of the solubility of potassium tert‐butoxide in THF, 18‐crown‐6 also plays key roles in suppressing the reverse protonation or 1, 3‐proton shift isomerization as well as by stabilizing the carboxylated intermediate.     

General Method for the Synthesis of Salicylic Acids from Phenols through Palladium‐Catalyzed Silanol‐Directed C?H Carboxylation

A silanol‐directed, palladium‐catalyzed C H carboxylation reaction of phenols to give salicylic acids has been developed. This method features high efficiency and selectivity, and excellent functional‐group tolerance. The generality of this method was demonstrated by the carboxylation of estrone and by the synthesis of an unsymmetrically o,o′‐disubstituted phenolic compound through two sequential C H functionalization processes.     

Highly Regioselective Palladium‐Catalyzed Carboxylation of Allylic Alcohols with CO2

Various allylic alcohols were carboxylated in the presence of a catalytic amount of PdCl₂ and PPh₃ using ZnEt₂ as a stoichiometric transmetalation agent under a CO₂ atmosphere (1 atm). This carboxylation proceeded in a highly regioselective manner to afford branched carboxylic acids predominantly. The β,γ‐unsaturated carboxylic acid thus obtained was successfully converted into an optically active γ‐butyrolactone, a known intermediate of (R)‐baclofen.     

Carboxylation of Phenols with CO2 at Atmospheric Pressure

A convenient and efficient method for the ortho‐carboxylation of phenols under atmospheric CO₂ pressure has been developed. This method provides an alternative to the previously reported Kolbe–Schmitt method, which requires very high pressures of CO₂. The addition of a trisubstituted phenol has proved essential for the successful carboxylation of phenols with CO₂ at standard atmospheric pressure, allowing the efficient preparation of a broad variety of salicylic acids.     

N‐Heterocyclic Olefin–Carbon Dioxide and –Sulfur Dioxide Adducts: Structures and Interesting Reactivity Patterns

Depending on the amount of methanol present in solution, CO₂ adducts of N‐heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) and N‐heterocyclic olefins (NHOs) have been found to be in fully reversible equilibrium with the corresponding methyl carbonate salts [EMIm][OCO₂Me] and [EMMIm][OCO₂Me]. The reactivity pattern of representative 1‐ethyl‐3‐methyl‐NHO–CO₂ adduct 4 has been investigated and compared with the corresponding NHC–CO₂ zwitterion: The protonation of 4 with HX led to the imidazolium salts [NHO–CO₂H][X], which underwent decarboxylation to [EMMIm][X] in the presence of nucleophilic catalysts. NHO–CO₂ zwitterion 4 can act as an efficient carboxylating agent towards CH acids such as acetonitrile. The [EMMIm] cyanoacetate and [EMMIm]₂ cyanomalonate salts formed exemplify the first C?C bond‐forming carboxylation reactions with NHO‐activated CO₂. The reaction of the free NHO with dimethyl carbonate selectively led to methoxycarbonylated NHO, which is a perfect precursor for the synthesis of functionalized ILs [NHO–CO₂Me][X]. The first NHO‐SO₂ adduct was synthesized and structurally characterized; it showed a similar reactivity pattern, which allowed the synthesis of imidazolium methyl sulfites upon reaction with methanol.