Spherical FAIMS: comparison of curved electrode geometries

High-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) can operate at atmospheric pressure to separate gas-phase ions on the basis of a difference in the mobility of an ion at high fields relative to its mobility at low field strengths. Several novel cell geometries have been proposed in addition to the commercially available planar and cylindrical designs. Nevertheless, there is still much to explore about three-dimensional (3-D) curved cell geometries (spherical and hemispherical) and comparison to two-dimensional (2-D) curved geometries (cylindrical). The geometry of a FAIMS cell is one of the essential features affecting the transmission, resolution, and resolving power of FAIMS. Electric fields in a spherical design allow advantages such as virtual potential wells that can induce atmospheric-pressure near-trapping conditions and help reduce ion losses. Curvature of electrodes enables the ions to remain focused near the gap median, which help to improve sensitivity and ion trapping at higher pressures. Here we detail the design and characterization of a novel FAIMS cell having spherical electrode geometry and compare it to hemispherical and cylindrical cells. These FAIMS cells were interfaced with a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer in this study. Several structural classes of common explosives were employed to evaluate the separation power of these geometries. FAIMS spectra were generated by scanning the compensation voltage (CV) while operating the mass spectrometer in total ion mode. The identification of ions was accomplished through mass spectra acquired at fixed values of CVs. The performance of FAIMS using cylindrical, hemispherical, and spherical cells was compared and trends identified. For all trials, the best transmission was obtained by the spherical FAIMS cell while hemispherical FAIMS provided the best resolution and resolving power.     

Scaling of the resolving power and sensitivity for planar FAIMS and mobility-based discrimination in flow- and field-driven analyzers

Continuing development of the technology and applications of field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) calls for better understanding of its limitations and factors that govern them. While key performance metrics such as resolution and ion transmission have been calculated for specific cases employing numerical simulations, the underlying physical trends remained obscure. Here we determine that the resolving power of planar FAIMS scales as the square root of separation time and sensitivity drops exponentially at the rate controlled by absolute ion mobility and several instrument parameters. A strong dependence of ion transmission on mobility severely discriminates against species with higher mobility, presenting particular problems for analyses of complex mixtures. While the time evolution of resolution and sensitivity is virtually identical in existing FAIMS systems using gas flow and proposed devices driven by electric field, the distributions of separation times are not. The inverse correlation between mobility (and thus diffusion speed) and residence time for ions in field-driven FAIMS greatly reduces the mobility-based discrimination and provides much more uniform separations. Under typical operating conditions, the spread of elimination rates for commonly analyzed ions is reduced from >5 times in flow-driven to 1.6 times in field-driven FAIMS while the difference in resolving power decreases from approximately 60% to approximately 15%.     

Ion mobility spectrometer—field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometer-mass spectrometry

Since the development of electrospray ionization (ESI) for ion mobility spectrometry mass spectrometry (IMMS), IMMS have been extensively applied for characterization of gas-phase bio-molecules. Conventional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), defined as drift tube IMS (DT-IMS), is typically a stacked ring design that utilizes a low electric field gradient. Field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) is a newer version of IMS, however, the geometry of the system is significantly different than DT-IMS and data are collected using a much higher electric field. Here we report construction of a novel ambient pressure dual gate DT-IMS coupled with a FAIMS system and then coupled to a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer (QITMS) to form a hybrid three-dimensional separation instrument, DT-IMS-FAIMS-QITMS. The DT-IMS was operated at ~3 Townsend (electric field/number density (E/N) or (Td)) and was coupled in series with a FAIMS, operated at ~80 Td. Ions were mobility-selected by the dual gate DT-IMS into the FAIMS and from the FAIMS the ions were detected by the QITMS for as either MS or MSⁿ. The system was evaluated using cocaine as an analytical standard and tested for the application of separating three isomeric tri-peptides: tyrosine-glycine-tryptophan (YGW), tryptophan-glycine-tyrosine (WGY) and tyrosine-tryptophan-glycine (YWG). All three tri-peptides were separated in the DT-IMS dimension and each had one mobility peak. The samples were partially separated in the FAIMS dimension but two conformation peaks were detected for the YWG sample while YGW and WGY produced only one peak. Ion validation was achieved for all three samples using QITMS.     

Separation of Ions from Volatile Organic Compounds Using High-Field Asymmetric Waveform Ion Mobility Spectrometry-Mass Spectrometer

A combination of high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) with mass spectrometer (MS) was analyzed. FAIMS separates ions from the volatile organic compounds in the gas-phase as an ion-filter for MS. The sample ions were created at ambient pressure by ion source, which was equipped with a 10.6 eV UV discharge lamp (λ=116.5 nm).The drift tube of FAIMS is composed of two parallel planar electrodes and the dimension is 10 mm×8 mm×0.5 mm. FAIMS was investigated when driven by the high-filed rectangular asymmetric waveform with the peak-to-peak voltage of 1.36 kV at the frequency of 1 MHz and the duty cycle of 30%. The acetone, the butanone, and their mixture were adopted to characterize the FAIMS-MS. The mass spectra obtained from MS illustrate that there are ion-molecular reactions between the ions and the sample neutral molecular. And the proton transfer behavior in the mixture of the acetone and the butanone is also observed.With the compensation voltage tuned from -30 V to 10 V with a step size of 0.1 V, the ion pre-separation before MS is realized.     

Feasibility of higher-order differential ion mobility separations using new asymmetric waveforms

Technologies for separating and characterizing ions based on their transport properties in gases have been around for three decades. The early method of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) distinguished ions by absolute mobility that depends on the collision cross section with buffer gas atoms. The more recent technique of field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) measures the difference between mobilities at high and low electric fields. Coupling IMS and FAIMS to soft ionization sources and mass spectrometry (MS) has greatly expanded their utility, enabling new applications in biomedical and nanomaterials research. Here, we show that time-dependent electric fields comprising more than two intensity levels could, in principle, effect an infinite number of distinct differential separations based on the higher-order terms of expression for ion mobility. These analyses could employ the hardware and operational procedures similar to those utilized in FAIMS. Methods up to the 4th or 5th order (where conventional IMS is 1st order and FAIMS is 2nd order) should be practical at field intensities accessible in ambient air, with still higher orders potentially achievable in insulating gases. Available experimental data suggest that higher-order separations should be largely orthogonal to each other and to FAIMS, IMS, and MS.     

Using a nanoelectrospray-differential mobility spectrometer-mass spectrometer system for the analysis of oligosaccharides with solvent selected control over ESI aggregate ion formation

Differential mobility spectrometry (DMS), also commonly referred to as high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) is a rapidly advancing technology for gas-phase ion separation. The interfacing of DMS with mass spectrometry (MS) offers potential advantages over the use of mass spectrometry alone. Such advantages include improvements to mass spectral signal/noise, orthogonal/complementary ion separation to mass spectrometry, enhanced ion and complexation structural analysis, and the potential for rapid analyte quantitation. In this report, we demonstrate the successful use of our nanoESI-DMS-MS system, with a methanol drift gas modifier, for the separation of oligosaccharides. The tendency for ESI to form oligosaccharide aggregate ions and the negative impact this has on nanoESI-DMS-MS oligosaccharide analysis is described. In addition, we demonstrate the importance of sample solvent selection for controlling nanoESI oligosaccharide aggregate ion formation and its effect on glycan ionization and DMS separation. The successful use of a tetrachloroethane/methanol solvent solution to reduce ESI oligosaccharide aggregate ion formation while efficiently forming a dominant MH(+) molecular ion is presented. By reducing aggregate ion formation in favor of a dominant MH(+) ion, DMS selectivity and specificity is improved. In addition to DMS, we would expect the reduction in aggregate ion complexity to be beneficial to the analysis of oligosaccharides for other post-ESI separation techniques such as mass spectrometry and ion mobility. The solvent selected control over MH(+) molecular ion formation, offered by the use of the tetrachloroethane/methanol solvent, also holds promise for enhancing MS/MS structural characterization analysis of glycans.     

High field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry: an investigation of leucine enkephalin ions produced by electrospray ionization

High field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) provides atmospheric pressure, room temperature, low-resolution separation of gas-phase ions. The FAIMS analyzer acts as an ion filter that can continuously transmit one type of ion, independent of m/z. The combination of FAIMS with electrospray ionization and mass spectrometry (ESI-FAIMS-MS) is a powerful technique and is used in this study to investigate the cluster ions of leucine enkephalin (YGGFL). Separation by FAIMS of leucine enkephalin ions having the same m/z (m/z 556.5), [M + H]⁺ and [2M + 2H]²⁺, was observed. In addition, four complex ions of leucine enkephalin, [2M + H]⁺, [4M + 2H]²⁺, [6M + 3H]³⁺, and [8M + 4H]⁴⁺, all having m/z 1112, were shown to be separated in FAIMS. Fragmentation of ions as the result of harsh conditions within the mass spectrometer interface (FAIMS-MS) was shown to provide similar information to that obtained from MS/MS experiments in conventional ESI-MS.     

Probing the Complementarity of FAIMS and Strong Cation Exchange Chromatography in Shotgun Proteomics

High field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS), also known as differential ion mobility spectrometry, coupled with liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) offers benefits for the analysis of complex proteomics samples. Advantages include increased dynamic range, increased signal-to-noise, and reduced interference from ions of similar m/z. FAIMS also separates isomers and positional variants. An alternative, and more established, method of reducing sample complexity is prefractionation by use of strong cation exchange chromatography. Here, we have compared SCX-LC-MS/MS with LC-FAIMS-MS/MS for the identification of peptides and proteins from whole cell lysates from the breast carcinoma SUM52 cell line. Two FAIMS approaches are considered: (1) multiple compensation voltages within a single LC-MS/MS analysis (internal stepping) and (2) repeat LC-MS/MS analyses at different and fixed compensation voltages (external stepping). We also consider the consequence of the fragmentation method (electron transfer dissociation or collision-induced dissociation) on the workflow performance. The external stepping approach resulted in a greater number of protein and peptide identifications than the internal stepping approach for both ETD and CID MS/MS, suggesting that this should be the method of choice for FAIMS proteomics experiments. The overlap in protein identifications from the SCX method and the external FAIMS method was ~25 % for both ETD and CID, and for peptides was less than 20 %. The lack of overlap between FAIMS and SCX highlights the complementarity of the two techniques. Charge state analysis of the peptide assignments showed that the FAIMS approach identified a much greater proportion of triply-charged ions.      

Elimination of the helium requirement in high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS): beneficial effects of decreasing the analyzer gap width on peptide analysis

Cylindrical geometry high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) focuses and separates gas-phase ions at atmospheric pressure and room (or elevated) temperature. Addition of helium to a nitrogen-based separation medium offers significant advantages for FAIMS including improved resolution, selectivity and sensitivity. Aside from gas composition, ion transmission through FAIMS is governed by electric field strength (E/N) that is determined by the applied voltage, the analyzer gap width, atmospheric pressure and electrode temperature. In this study, the analyzer width of a cylindrical FAIMS device is varied from 2.5 to 1.25 mm to achieve average electric field strengths as high as 187.5 Townsend (Td). At these electric fields, the performance of FAIMS in an N(2) environment is dramatically improved over a commercial system that uses an analyzer width of 2.5 mm in 1:1 N(2) /He. At fields of 162 Td using electrodes at room temperature, the average effective temperature for the [M+2H](2+) ion of angiotensin II reaches 365 K. This has a dramatic impact on the curtain gas flow rate, resulting in lower optimum flows and reduced turbulence in the ion inlet. The use of narrow analyzer widths in a N(2) carrier gas offers previously unattainable baseline resolution of the [M+2H](2+) and [M+3H](3+) ions of angiotensin II. Comparisons of absolute ion current with FAIMS to conventional electrospray ionization (ESI) are as high as 77% with FAIMS versus standard ESI-MS.     

Tandem mass spectra of tryptic peptides at signal-to-background ratios approaching unity using electrospray ionization high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry/hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry

High-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) has been coupled to a quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer for the tandem mass spectrometric analysis of tryptic peptides of pig hemoglobin. Using FAIMS, low levels (fmol/microL) of multiply charged tryptic peptides were separated from relatively intense chemical background such that their tandem mass spectra (MS/MS) lacked many background-related fragment ions observed using a conventional ESI-QqTOFMS instrument. Substantial improvements in both first-order and tandem mass spectra were realized while maintaining approximately the same absolute intensities.     

Behaviour of tetraalkylammonium ions in high‐field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry

High‐field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) is an ion‐filtering technique recently adapted for use with liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) to remove interferences during analysis of complex matrices. This is the first systematic study of a series of singly charged tetraalkylammonium ions by FAIMS‐MS. The compensation voltage (CV) is the DC offset of the waveform which permits the ion to emerge from FAIMS and it was determined for each member of the series under various conditions. The electrospray ionization conditions explored included spray voltage, vaporizer temperature, and sheath and auxiliary gas pressure. The FAIMS conditions explored included carrier gas flow rate, electrode temperature and composition of the carrier gas. Optimum desolvation was achieved using sufficient carrier gas (flow rate ≥2 L/min) to ensure stable response. Low‐mass ions (m/z 100–200) are more susceptible to changes in electrode temperature and gas composition than high mass ions (m/z 200–700). As a result of this study, ions are reliably analyzed using standard FAIMS conditions (dispersion voltage ?5000 V, carrier gas flow rate 3 L/min, 50% helium/50%nitrogen, inner electrode temperature 70°C and outer electrode temperature 90°C). Variation of FAIMS conditions may be of great use for the separation of very low mass tetraalkylammonium (TAA) ions from other TAA ions. The FAIMS conditions do not appear to have a major effect on higher mass ions. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Ultrasensitive single-cell proteomics workflow identifies >1000 protein groups per mammalian cell

We report on the combination of nanodroplet sample preparation, ultra-low-flow nanoLC, high-field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS), and the latest-generation Orbitrap Eclipse Tribrid mass spectrometer for greatly improved single-cell proteome profiling. FAIMS effectively filtered out singly charged ions for more effective MS analysis of multiply charged peptides, resulting in an average of 1056 protein groups identified from single HeLa cells without MS1-level feature matching. This is 2.3 times more identifications than without FAIMS and a far greater level of proteome coverage for single mammalian cells than has been previously reported for a label-free study. Differential analysis of single microdissected motor neurons and interneurons from human spinal tissue indicated a similar level of proteome coverage, and the two subpopulations of cells were readily differentiated based on single-cell label-free quantification.

The combination of nanodroplet sample preparation, ultra-low-flow nanoLC, high-field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) and latest-generation mass spectrometry instrumentation provides dramatically improved single-cell proteome profiling.     

Monte Carlo simulation of ion transport in non-linear ion mobility spectrometry

A program for Monte Carlo simulation of ion transport in non-linear ion mobility spectrometry, also known as field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) or differential mobility spectrometry (DMS), has been developed. Simulations are based on elastic collisions between the ions and the gas particles, and take into account the effects of flow dynamics and asymmetric electric fields. Using this program, the separation and diffusion of the ions moving in a planar DMS filtration gap are demonstrated. Ion focusing in a cylindrical filtration gap is also confirmed. A characteristic compensation voltage is found to provide insight for understanding separation in non-linear ion mobility spectrometry. The simulation program is used to study the characteristics of non-linear ion mobility spectrometry, the effect of the carrier gas flow, and the dependence of the compensation voltage and nonlinear mobility coefficient (α) on the applied asymmetric electric field.     

Optimum waveforms for differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS)

Differential mobility spectrometry or field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) is a new tool for separation and identification of gas-phase ions, particularly in conjunction with mass spectrometry. In FAIMS, ions are filtered by the difference between mobilities in gases (K) at high and low electric field intensity (E) using asymmetric waveforms. An infinite number of possible waveform profiles make maximizing the performance within engineering constraints a major issue for FAIMS technology refinement. Earlier optimizations assumed the non-constant component of mobility to scale as E(2), producing the same result for all ions. Here we show that the optimum profiles are defined by the full series expansion of K(E) that includes terms beyond the first that is proportional to E(2). For many ion/gas pairs, the first two terms have different signs, and the optimum profiles at sufficiently high E in FAIMS may differ substantially from those previously reported, improving the resolving power by up to 2.2 times. This situation arises for some ions in all FAIMS systems, but becomes more common in recent miniaturized devices that employ higher E. With realistic K(E) dependences, the maximum waveform amplitude is not necessarily optimum, and reducing it by up to approximately 20% to 30% is beneficial in some cases. The present findings are particularly relevant to targeted analyses where separation depends on the difference between K(E) functions for specific ions.     

Investigation of bovine ubiquitin conformers separated by high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry: Cross section measurements using energy-loss experiments with a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer

High-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) was used to separate gas-phase conformers of bovine ubiquitin produced by electrospray ionization. These conformers were sampled by a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer where energy-loss experiments, following the work of Douglas and co-workers, were used to determine their cross sections. The measured cross sections for some conformers were readily altered by the voltages applied to the interface ion optics, therefore very gentle mass spectrometer interface conditions were required to preserve gas-phase conformers separated by FAIMS. Cross sections for 19 conformers (charge states +5 through +13) were measured. Two conformers for the +12 charge state, which were readily separated in FAIMS, were found to have similar cross sections. Based on a method to calibrate the collision gas thickness, the cross sections measured using the FAIMS/energy-loss method were compared with literature values determined using drift tube ion mobility spectrometry. The comparison illustrated that the conformers of bovine ubiquitin that were identified using drift tube ion mobility spectrometry were also observed using the FAIMS device.     

Modeling the resolution and sensitivity of FAIMS analyses

Field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) is rapidly gaining acceptance as a robust, versatile tool for post-ionization separations prior to mass-spectrometric analyses. The separation is based on differences between ion mobilities at high and low electric fields, and proceeds at atmospheric pressure. Two major advantages of FAIMS over condensed-phase separations are its high speed and an ion focusing effect that often improves sensitivity. While selected aspects of FAIMS performance are understood empirically, no physical model rationalizing the resolving power and sensitivity of the method and revealing their dependence on instrumental variables has existed. Here we present a first-principles computational treatment capable of simulating the FAIMS analyzer for virtually any geometry (including the known cylindrical and planar designs) and arbitrary operational parameters. The approach involves propagating an ensemble of ion trajectories through the device in real time under the influence of applied asymmetric potential, diffusional motion incorporating the high-field and anisotropic phenomena, and mutual Coulomb repulsion of ionic charges. Calculations for both resolution and sensitivity are validated by excellent agreement with measurements in different FAIMS modes for ions representing diverse types and analyte classes.     

Characterization of a temperature-Controlled FAIMS system

High-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) focuses and separates gas-phase analyte ions from chemical background, offering substantial improvements in the detection of targeted species in biological matrices. Ion separations have been typically performed at atmospheric pressure and ambient temperature, although routine small molecule quantitation by LC-MS (and thus LC-FAIMS-MS) is generally performed at liquid flow rates (e.g., in excess of 200 microL/min) in which atmospheric pressure ionization sources (e.g., APCI and ESI) need to be run at elevated temperatures to enhance ion desolvation. Heat from the ionization source and/or the mass spectrometer capillary interface is shown to have a significant impact on the performance of a conventional FAIMS electrode set. This study introduces a new FAIMS system that uses gas heating/cooling to quickly reach temperature equilibrium independent of the external temperature conditions. A series of equations and balance plots, which look at the effect of temperature and other variables, on the normalized field strength (E/N), are introduced and used to explain experimental observations. Examples where the ion behavior deviates from the predicted behavior are presented and explanations based on clusters or changes in ion-neutral interactions are given. Consequences of the use of temperature control, and in particular advantages of using different temperature settings on the inner and outer electrodes, for the purpose of manipulating ion separation are described.     

Separation of leucine and isoleucine by electrospray ionization-high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry

An electrospray ionization (ESI) source was used to generate gas-phase molecular anions of the amino acids leucine and isoleucine ((M–H)⁻; m/z −130), which were separated by high- field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) and detected by quadrupole mass spectrometry (MS). This combination of ESI-FAIMS-MS enabled selective determination of either amino acid in mixtures that contained at least a 625-fold excess of the other. Comparisons with conventional ESI-MS showed a 50-fold improvement in the signal to background ratio for a 1 μM solution of leucine.     

Separation and Classification of Lipids Using Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Correlations between the dimensions of a 2-D separation create trend lines that depend on structural or chemical characteristics of the compound class and thus facilitate classification of unknowns. This broadly applies to conventional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS)/mass spectrometry (MS), where the major biomolecular classes (e.g., lipids, peptides, nucleotides) occupy different trend line domains. However, strong correlation between the IMS and MS separations for ions of same charge has impeded finer distinctions. Differential IMS (or FAIMS) is generally less correlated to MS and thus could separate those domains better. We report the first observation of chemical class separation by trend lines using FAIMS, here for lipids. For lipids, FAIMS is indeed more independent of MS than conventional IMS, and subclasses (such as phospho-, glycero-, or sphingolipids) form distinct, often non-overlapping domains. Even finer categories with different functional groups or degrees of unsaturation are often separated. As expected, resolution improves in He-rich gases: at 70% He, glycerolipid isomers with different fatty acid positions can be resolved. These results open the door for application of FAIMS to lipids, particularly in shotgun lipidomics and targeted analyses of bioactive lipids.