Estimation of polyacrylamide gel pore size from Ferguson plots of linear DNA fragments. II. Comparison of gels with different crosslinker concentrations, added agarose and added linear polyacrylamide.

The mobilities of various DNA fragments in two normally migrating molecular weight ladders were studied in polyacrylamide gels containing different concentrations of the crosslinker N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide (Bis). The acrylamide concentration ranged from 2.5-10.5%T (w/v); the Bis concentration ranged from 0.5-10%C (w/w), with respect to total acrylamide. Ferguson plots were constructed for each of the DNA fragments in gels of each composition. The Ferguson plots of the different multimers in each molecular weight ladder were nearly parallel in gels containing 0.5-3%C, converged close to a common intercept at zero gel concentration in gels containing 4%C, and crossed at approximately 1.5%T in gels containing 5 and 10%C. If the mobilities observed for the different DNA fragments at zero gel concentration were also extrapolated to zero DNA molecular weight, a common limiting mobility was observed in gels of all crosslinker concentrations. This limiting mobility was approximately equal to the free solution mobility of DNA. The effective pore radius of each gel was estimated from Ferguson plots based on relative mobilities, using the mobility of the smallest DNA fragment in each molecular weight ladder as the reference mobility. The calculated gel pore radii ranged from 142 nm to 19 nm, respectively, for gels containing 4.6%T, 1.5%C, and 10.5%T, 5 or 10%C. These pore radii are an order of magnitude larger than previously accepted values, but are consistent with scanning electron microscope measurements (Rüchel, R., et al., J. Chromatogr. 1978, 42, 77-90).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Formamide modified polyacrylamide gels for DNA sequencing by capillary gel electrophoresis.

Compressions are occasionally found during the separation of DNA sequencing fragments, particularly in G/C-rich regions and in gels operated at room temperature. Addition of at least 10% formamide to urea/polyacrylamide sequencing gels improves the denaturing capacity of the gel, minimizing compressions. Addition of 20% or more formamide decreases the separation rate, theoretical plate count, and resolution for normally migrating fragments. An optimum concentration of 10% formamide improves resolution of compressed regions without degrading the other characteristics of the gel. Operation of gels at room temperature simplifies the engineering associated with automated sequencers based on capillary gel electrophoresis.     

Microelectrophoresis for the separation of DNA fragments.

A methodology has been developed which significantly reduces the linear dimension necessary for the electrophoretic separation of DNA fragments and oligonucleotides. DNA fragments are rapidly separated into compact, resolvable microscopic banding patterns which can be detected using a high-resolution electronic imaging system. Separations can be carried out in either capillary tube or thin-layer (slab) microgel formats of one centimeter or less in length. The complete separation of all eleven fragments (1353 to 72 base pairs) of the pi X174 DNA/HaeIII restriction ladder was achieved in a total running distance of less than 2 mm and in less than 2 min. The observed band widths for the larger fragments (1353-603 bp) ranged from 18 to 25 microns, with the intermediate and smaller fragments (310 to 72 bp) ranging from 30 microns to 60 microns. The ethidium bromide-stained microgels were analyzed using an epifluorescent microscope combined with an intensified charged coupled device imaging system. In other experiments, single-base resolution of fluoresceinated oligonucleotides in the 20-30 nucleotide range was demonstrated. DNA sequencing may be possible with further optimization. This new methodology departs from the conventional gel formulations and electrophoretic procedures used for the separation DNA fragments. High voltage gradients and the use of highly concentrated and crosslinked homogeneous polyacrylamide gels effects the rapid separation of DNA fragments in very short distances. Analysis of the microgels with proteins of known size (Stokes radius) indicates that separations are occurring in gels with pore sizes close to the diameter of double-stranded DNA.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Mobility and activation energy of single-stranded DNA in denaturing cross-linked polyacrylamide slab gels

An original apparatus based on laser-induced fluorescence detection is presented. One lane migration combined to four equidistant detection points allows the study of the dynamics of DNA bands during electrophoresis. We focus this article on the study of the mobility of DNA sequencing fragments as a function of temperature; mobility is determined in 4% T, 5% C and 4.3% T, 5% C cross-linked polyacrylamide gels at an electric field of 45 V/cm [T=(g acrylamide+g N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide)/100 ml solution; C=g N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide/% T]. Activation energy has been investigated under these experimental conditions with a temperature varying from 25 to 50 degrees C. The activation energy for migration through the cross-linked polyacrylamide gel decreases with fragment length under our experimental conditions and it varies along the migration.     

Estimation of polyacrylamide gel pore size from Ferguson plots of normal and anomalously migrating DNA fragments. I. Gels containing 3% N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide

The mobilities of normal and anomalously migrating DNA fragments were determined in polyacrylamide gels of different acrylamide concentrations, polymerized with 3% N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide as the crosslinker. The DNA samples were a commercially available 123-bp ladder and two molecular weight ladders containing multiple copies of two 147-base pair (bp) restriction fragments, obtained from the MspI digestion of plasmid pBR322. One of the 147 bp fragments is known to migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels. Ferguson plots were constructed for all multimer ladders, using both absolute mobilities and relative mobilities with respect to the smallest DNA molecule in each data set. If the retardation coefficients were calculated from the relative mobilities, and the rms radius of gyration was used as the measure of DNA size, the Ogston equations were obeyed and the gel fiber parameters could be calculated. The effective pore sizes of the gels were estimated from the gel concentration at which the mobility of a given DNA molecule was reduced to one-half its mobility at zero gel concentration. The estimated pore radii ranged from approximately 130 nm for 3.5% gels to approximately 70 nm for 10.5% gels. These values are much larger than the pore sizes previously determined for the polyacrylamide matrix.     

An automated capillary electrophoresis system for high-speed separation of DNA fragments based on a short capillary

A high-speed DNA fragment separation system was developed based on a short capillary and a slotted-vial array automated sample introduction system. The injection process of DNA sample in a short capillary was investigated systematically with three injection techniques including constant-field-strength, low-field-strength and translational spontaneous injections. Under the optimized conditions, picoliter-scale sample plugs (corresponding to ca. 20-μm plug length) were obtained, which ensure the high-speed and high-efficiency separation for DNA fragments with a short effective separation length. Other separation conditions including the sieving matrix concentration, separation field strength and effective separation length were also optimized. The present system was applied in the separation of ΦX174-Hae III digest DNA marker. With an effective separation length of 2.5 cm, the separation could be achieved in <100 s with plate heights ranging from 0.21 to 0.74 μm (corresponding to plate numbers from 4.86 × 10(6) to 1.36 × 10(6)/m). The repeatabilities for the migration time of the eleven fragments were between 0.4 and 1.1% RSD (n=8). By using the automated continuous injection method, the separation for four different DNA samples could be achieved within 250 s. The present system was further applied in the fast sizing of real DNA samples of PCR products.     

Low-cost, high-sensitivity laser-induced fluorescence detection for DNA sequencing by capillary gel electrophoresis.

A low cost, 0.75-mW helium neon laser, operating in the green region at 534.5 nm, is used to excite fluorescence from tetramethylrhodamine isothiocyanate-labelled DNA fragments that have been separated by capillary gel electrophoresis. The detection limit (3 sigma) for the dye is 500 ymol [1 yoctomole (1 ymol) = 10(-24) mol] or 300 analyte molecules in capillary zone electrophoresis; the detection limit for labeled primer separated by capillary gel electrophoresis is 2 zmol [1 zeptomole (1 zmol) = 10(-21) mol]. The Richardson-Tabor peak-height encoded sequencing technique is used to prepare DNA sequencing samples. In 6% T, 5% C acrylamide, 7 M urea gels, sequencing rates of 300 bases/hour are produced at an electric field strength of 200 V/cm; unfortunately, the data are plagued by compressions. These compressions are eliminated with addition of 20% formamide to the sequencing gel; the gel runs slowly and sequencing data are generated at a rate of about 70 bases/hour.     

The electric field dependence of DNA mobilities in agarose gels: a reinvestigation

The electric field dependence of the electrophoretic mobility of linear DNA fragments in agarose gels was reinvestigated in order to correct the observed mobilities for the different temperatures actually present in the gel during electrophoresis in different electric field gradients. When corrected to a common temperature, the electrophoretic mobilities of DNA fragments less than or equal to 1 kilobase pairs (kbp) in size were independent of electric field strength at all field strengths from 0.6 to 4.6 V/cm if the gels contained less than or equal to 1.4% agarose. The mobilities of larger DNA fragments increased approximately linearly with electric field strength. If the agarose concentration was higher than 2%, the mobilities of all DNA fragments increased with increasing electric field strength. The electric field dependence of the mobility was larger in gels cast and run in Tris-borate buffer (TBE) than in gels cast and run in Tris-acetate buffer (TAE), and was more pronounced in gels without ethidium bromide incorporated in the matrix. Ferguson plots were constructed for the various DNA fragments, both with and without extrapolating the temperature-corrected mobilities to zero electric field strength. Linear Ferguson plots were obtained for all fragments less than or equal to 12 kbp in size in agarose gels less than or equal to 1.4% in concentration if the mobilities were first extrapolated to zero electric field strength. Concave upward curvature of the Ferguson plots was observed for DNA fragments greater than or equal to 2 kbp in size at finite electric field strengths. Convex downward curvature of the Ferguson plots was observed for DNA fragments greater than or equal to 1 kbp in size in agarose gels greater than or equal to 2% in concentration. The mobilities of the various DNA fragments, extrapolated to zero agarose concentration and zero electric field strength, decreased with increasing DNA molecular weight; extrapolating to zero molecular weight gave an "intrinsic" DNA mobility of 2.7 x 10(-4) cm2/Vs at 20 degrees C. The pore sizes of LE agarose gels cast and run in TAE and TBE buffers were estimated from the mobility of the DNA fragments.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Influence of branch length asymmetry on the electrophoretic mobility of rigid rod-like DNA

The electrophoretic mobility of three-arm asymmetric star DNA molecules, produced by incorporating a short DNA branch at the midpoint of rigid-rod linear DNA fragments, is investigated in polyacrylamide gels. We determine how long the added branch must be to separate asymmetric star DNA from linear DNA with the same total molecular weight. This work focuses on two different geometric progressions of small DNA molecules. First, branches of increasing length were introduced at the center of a linear DNA fragment of constant length. At a given gel concentration, we find that relatively small branch lengths are enough to cause a detectable reduction in electrophoretic mobility. The second geometric progression starts with a small branch on a linear DNA fragment. As the length of this branch is increased, the DNA backbone length is decreased such that the total molar mass of the molecule remains constant. The branch length was then increased until the asymmetric branched molecule becomes a symmetric three-arm star polymer, allowing the effect of molecular topology on mobility to be studied independent of size effects. DNA molecules with very short branches have a mobility smaller than linear DNA of identical molar mass. The reason for this change in mobility when branching is introduced is not known, however, we explore two possible explanations in this article. (i) The branched DNA could have a greater interaction with the gel than linear DNA, causing it to move slower; (ii) the linear DNA could have modes of motion or access to pores that are unavailable to the branched DNA.     

Activation energy of single-stranded DNA moving through cross-linked polyacrylamide gels at 300 V/cm effect of temperature on sequencing rate in high-electric-field capillary gel electrophoresis

In DNA sequencing, single-stranded DNA fragments are separated by gel electrophoresis. This separation is based on a sieving mechanism where DNA fragments are retarded as they pass through pores in the gel. In this paper, we present the mobility of DNA sequencing fragments as a function of temperature; mobility is determined in 4% T LongRanger gels at an electric field of 300 V/cm. The temperature dependence is compared with the predictions of the biased reptation model. The model predicts that the fragment length for the onset of biased reptation with stretching increases with the square of temperature; the data show that the onset of biased reptation with stretching decreases with temperature. Biased reptation fails to model accurately the temperature dependence of mobility. We analyzed the data and extracted the activation energy for passage of sequencing fragments through the gel. For fragments containing less than ca. 200 bases, the activation energy increases linearly with the number of bases at a rate of 25 J/mol per base; for longer fragments, the activation energy increases at a rate of 6.5 J/mol per base. This transition in the activation energy presumably reflects a change in conformation of the DNA fragments; small fragments exist in a random coil configuration and larger fragments migrate in an elongated configuration.     

Information on DNA conformation derived from the Ferguson plot of DNA fragments of up to 9 kb in size, using polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in a discontinuous buffer system.

The Ferguson plot in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE)(15%CDATD, moving boundary electrophoresis buffer system operative at pH 8.9, 4 degrees C, 8 mA/cm2 of gel) of DNA fragments up to 9.4 kb in size was found to exhibit a linear segment at polyacrylamide concentrations starting at 3% T and undergoing a gradual transition into a concave segment at higher gel concentrations, confirming previous findings by Stellwagen. The larger the DNA, and the higher the gel concentration, the less extended the linear and the more extended the concave segment of the plot. The lowest % T of the linear range for DNA in polyacrylamide remains unknown since mobilities at nongelling concentrations below 3% T have not as yet been measured. As previously suggested, the transition from the linear to the concave segment corresponds to that from the randomly oriented DNA to the anisotropically stretched, "reptating" DNA. For a DNA of 9.4 kb in size, the end of the linear range of the Ferguson plot can be extended from 3.5 to 5% T when 15% DATD rather than 2.5% Bis is used to crosslink the polyacrylamide. Increasing the temperature of PAGE from 4 degrees C to 25 and 50 degrees C widens the linear segment progressively, indicating an increasingly random orientation with rising temperature. When current density is increased from 8 to 40 mA/cm2, the concave curvature of the Ferguson plot of DNA 1 to 9.4 kb in size decreases, suggesting a transition from a "reptating" to a randomly distributed molecule, due to increased Joule heat.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Mobility, diffusion and dispersion of single-stranded DNA in sequencing gels

Electrophoresis of single-stranded DNA in denaturing polyacrylamide gels is presently a standard procedure for the sequencing of DNA fragments. A thorough understanding of the factors that determine the resolution of DNA fractionated in polyacrylamide gels is necessary to optimize the performance of DNA sequencers. Significant research on the mobility of double-stranded (ds)DNA molecules in agarose and polyacrylamide gels has been performed, and the phenomenon of band broadening of single-stranded (ss)DNA fragments in DNA sequencing gels has received attention only recently. In this paper, we present a detailed study of mobility, diffusion and dispersion of ssDNA in sequencing gels as a function of molecular size, gel concentration and electric field strength. DNA mobility is shown to be essentially independent of electric field in the range of 0-60 V/cm. The band broadening is greatly enhanced in the presence of an electric field and the dispersion coefficient (DE) can be an order of magnitude higher than the field-free diffusion coefficient. The measured migration parameters approximately follow the predictions of the biased reptation including fluctuations (BRF) theory. However, deviations due to nonidealities of the separation conditions are observed. The measured migration parameters can be used to optimize the performance of separation systems.     

Stability of capillary gels for automated sequencing of DNA.

Recent interest in capillary gel electrophoresis has been fueled by the Human Genome Project and other large-scale sequencing projects. Advances in gel polymerization techniques and detector design have enabled sequencing of DNA directly in capillaries. Efforts to exploit this technology have been hampered by problems with the reproducibility and stability of gels. Gel instability manifests itself during electrophoresis as a decrease in the current passing through the capillary under a constant voltage. Upon subsequent microscopic examination, bubbles are often visible at or near the injection (cathodic) end of the capillary gel. Gels have been prepared with the polyacrylamide matrix covalently attached to the silica walls of the capillary. These gels, although more stable, still suffer from problems with bubbles. The use of actual DNA sequencing samples also adversely affects gel stability. We examined the mechanisms underlying these disruptive processes by employing polyacrylamide gel-filled capillaries in which the gel was not attached to the capillary wall. Three sources of gel instability were identified. Bubbles occurring in the absence of sample introduction were attributed to electroosmotic force; replacing the denaturant urea with formamide was shown to reduce the frequency of these bubbles. The slow, steady decline in current through capillary sequencing gels interferes with the ability to detect other gel problems. This phenomenon was shown to be a result of ionic depletion at the gel-liquid interface. The decline was ameliorated by adding denaturant and acrylamide monomers to the buffer reservoirs. Sample-induced problems were shown to be due to the presence of template DNA; elimination of the template allowed sample loading to occur without complications.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Analysis of limiting factors of DNA band separation by a DNA sequencer using fluorescence detection.

The factors affecting the electrophoretic separation of DNA bands in DNA base sequencing using fluorescence detection are analyzed. All the factors contributing to DNA band spacing and band width are evaluated; DNA diffusion and thermal effects on gels are the main considerations. The dependence of the gel's electrical resistivity on gel temperature and the variation of temperature over gel thickness are associated with a broadening of DNA band width. As a result of the analyses the maximum separable base number is represented as a function of various electrophoretic variables. The best separations are possible with an electric field strength corresponding to gel thickness. The maximum separable base number increases as the gel thickness decreases. It also increases as the migration distance increases, but it becomes saturated and has an upper limit when the migration distance is long. This upper limit increases as gel thickness decreases. DNA fragments with 600 and 601 bases can be completely separated from each other under optimum conditions for a 0.2 mm thick gel plate. Furthermore, using the band spacing information, under the same conditions, 750 bases could be assigned separately.     

DNA electrophoresis in agarose gels: a simple relation describing the length dependence of mobility

Electrophoretic mobilities of DNA molecules ranging in length from 100 to 10 000 base pairs (bp) were measured in gels of eleven concentrations of agarose from 0.5 to 1.5%. Excellent fits of the dependence of mobility on DNA length were obtained with the relationship [equation: see text] showing an e(-L/gamma) crossover, where L is the length of a DNA fragment and gamma is a crossover length ranging from 8000 to 12000 bp. The other parameters in the fit are mu(s) the mobility of short DNA with unit charge in the limit as length is extrapolated to zero, and muI, the mobility of long DNA as length is extrapolated to infinity. This exponential relationship should be a useful interpolation function for determining DNA lengths over a wide range. The simplicity of this relationship may be of more fundamental significance and suggests that some common feature dominates the electrophoresis of double stranded DNA fragments in agarose gels, regardless of length.     

Reversible phospholipid nanogels for deoxyribonucleic acid fragment size determinations up to 1500 base pairs and integrated sample stacking

Phospholipid additives are a cost-effective medium to separate deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) fragments and possess a thermally-responsive viscosity. This provides a mechanism to easily create and replace a highly viscous nanogel in a narrow bore capillary with only a 10 °C change in temperature. Preparations composed of dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC) self-assemble, forming structures such as nanodisks and wormlike micelles. Factors that influence the morphology of a particular DMPC–DHPC preparation include the concentration of lipid in solution, the temperature, and the ratio of DMPC and DHPC. It has previously been established that an aqueous solution containing 10% phospholipid with a ratio of [DMPC]/[DHPC] = 2.5 separates DNA fragments with nearly single base resolution for DNA fragments up to 500 base pairs in length, but beyond this size the resolution decreases dramatically. A new DMPC–DHPC medium is developed to effectively separate and size DNA fragments up to 1500 base pairs by decreasing the total lipid concentration to 2.5%. A 2.5% phospholipid nanogel generates a resolution of 1% of the DNA fragment size up to 1500 base pairs. This increase in the upper size limit is accomplished using commercially available phospholipids at an even lower material cost than is achieved with the 10% preparation. The separation additive is used to evaluate size markers ranging between 200 and 1500 base pairs in order to distinguish invasive strains of Streptococcus pyogenes and Aspergillus species by harnessing differences in gene sequences of collagen-like proteins in these organisms. For the first time, a reversible stacking gel is integrated in a capillary sieving separation by utilizing the thermally-responsive viscosity of these self-assembled phospholipid preparations. A discontinuous matrix is created that is composed of a cartridge of highly viscous phospholipid assimilated into a separation matrix of low viscosity. DNA sample stacking is facilitated with longer injection times without sacrificing separation efficiency.     

Advances in DNA electrophoresis in polymer solutions.

DNA electrophoresis in gels and solutions of agarose and polyacrylamide was objectively evaluated with regard to separation efficiency at optimal polymer concentrations. In application to DNA fragments, polyacrylamide gels were superior for separating fragments of less than 7800 bp, and agarose gels are the best choice for larger fragments. Agarose solutions are nearly as good as polyacrylamide gels for small DNA (< 300 bp). Agarose solutions have a higher efficiency than polyacrylamide solutions for DNA of less than 1200 bp. Separation efficiency sharply decreases with increasing length of DNA. Retardation in polyacrylamide solutions was found to depend on polymer length in a biphasic fashion. The choice of resolving polymer concentrations depends on the progressive stretching of DNA in proportion to polymer concentration. The rate of that stretching appears higher in polyacrylmide solution than in gels or in liquid or gelled agarose. Application of polymer solutions to capillary electrophoresis raises further problems concerning agarose plugs, DNA interactions with the polymers, operation at low field strength and long durations as well as detection sensitivity.     

Band broadening of DNA fragments isolated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in capillary electrophoresis

Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) is used frequently for isolation and purification of DNA fragments. In the present study, DNA fragments extracted from polyacrylamide gels showed significant band broadening in capillary electrophoresis (CE). A pHY300PLK (a shuttle vector functioning in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis) marker, which contained nine fragments ranging from 80 to 4870 bp, was separated by PAGE, and each fragment was isolated by phenol/chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. After extraction from the polyacrylamide gel, the peaks of the isolated DNA fragments exhibited band broadening in CE, where a linear poly(ethylene oxide) was used as a sieving matrix. The theoretical plate numbers of the DNA fragments contained in the pHY300PLK marker were >10⁶ for all the fragments before extraction. However, the DNA fragments extracted from the polyacrylamide gel showed decreased theoretical plate numbers (5–20 times smaller). The degradation of the theoretical plate number was significant for middle sizes of the DNA fragments ranging from 489 to 1360 bp, whereas the largest and smallest fragments (80 and 4870 bp) had no obvious influence. The band broadening was attributed to contamination of the DNA fragments by polyacrylamide fibers during the separation and extraction process.     

Curved DNA molecules migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels even at zero gel concentration

The electrophoretic mobilities of curved and normal DNA molecules of the same size have been measured in polyacrylamide gels containing various acrylamide concentrations and cross-linker ratios. Ferguson plots were constructed to extrapolate the observed mobilities to zero gel concentration. The DNA samples were two 147-bp restriction fragments, called 12A and 12B, obtained from the MspI digestion of plasmid pBR322, and head-to-tail multimers of each fragment. Fragment 12A is stably curved and migrates anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels; fragment 12B has the conformation of normal DNA and migrates with normal electrophoretic mobilities. The extrapolated mobilities of the curved fragment 12A and its multimers at zero gel concentration are lower than the extrapolated mobilities of the normal fragment 12B and its multimers. The free solution mobility of the curved fragment 12A, measured by CE, is also lower than that of the normal fragment 12B. The combined results indicate that the extrapolated mobilities observed for curved DNA molecules at zero polyacrylamide gel concentration reflect the intrinsic differences in their free solution mobilities.     

Temperature-dependence of preconditioning for lengthened capillary DNA sequencing

A previous study shows that electrophoretic preconditioning of a commercial polymer solution increases the spacing and resolution of DNA fragments fractionated in this solution by CE at 50 degrees C (Griess, G. A. et al., Electrophoresis 2005, 26, 102). The present study shows that this preconditioning effect on peak spacing progressively increases when the temperature of preconditioning increases to 70 degrees C, though fractionation is still performed at 50 degrees C. An increase in peak sharpness accompanies the increase in peak separation for DNA fragments longer than 200 bases. Changing the preconditioning temperature from 50 to 70 degrees C optimally improves resolution of fragment analysis in the range of 600-2000 nucleotides. When DNA sequencing is performed with automated base calling and 70 degrees C preconditioning at 319 V/cm (47 cm long capillary, Applied Biosystems 310 apparatus), the range of high-quality base calls is increased by 25% to 750; the range of low-quality base calls is increased by about 100% to 1200 in comparison to DNA sequencing without preconditioning.