Rational design of a “dual lock-and-key” supramolecular photosensitizer based on aromatic nucleophilic substitution for specific and enhanced photodynamic therapy

Photosensitizing agents are essential for precise and efficient photodynamic therapy (PDT). However, most of the conventional photosensitizers still suffer from limitations such as aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) in physiological environments and toxic side-effects on normal tissues during treatment, leading to reduced therapeutic efficacy. Thus, integrating excellent photophysical properties and accurate carcinoma selectivity in a photosensitizer system remains highly desired. Herein, a “dual lock-and-key” supramolecular photosensitizer BIBCl–PAE NPs for specific and enhanced cancer therapy is reported. BIBCl–PAE NPs are constructed by encapsulating a rationally designed glutathione (GSH)-activatable photosensitizer BIBCl in a pH-responsive diblock copolymer. In normal tissues, BIBCl is “locked” in the hydrophobic core of the polymeric micelles due to ACQ. Under the “dual key” activation of low pH and high levels of GSH in a tumor microenvironment, the disassembly of micelles facilitates the reaction of BIBCl with GSH to release water-soluble BIBSG with ideal biocompatibility, enabling the highly efficient PDT. Moreover, benefiting from the Förster resonance energy transfer effect of BIBSG, improved light harvesting ability and ¹O₂ production are achieved. In vitro and vivo experiments have demonstrated that BIBCl–PAE NPs are effective in targeting and inhibiting carcinoma. BIBCl–PAE NPs show superior anticancer efficiency relative to non-activatable controls.

The “dual lock-and-key” supramolecular photosensitizers enable specific and enhanced photodynamic therapy (PDT).     

Rational design of an “all-in-one” phototheranostic

We report here porphodilactol derivatives and their corresponding metal complexes. These systems show promise as “all-in-one” phototheranostics and are predicated on a design strategy that involves controlling the relationship between intersystem crossing (ISC) and photothermal conversion efficiency following photoexcitation. The requisite balance was achieved by tuning the aromaticity of these porphyrinoid derivatives and forming complexes with one of two lanthanide cations, namely Gd³⁺ and Lu³⁺. The net result led to a metalloporphodilactol system, Gd-trans-2, with seemingly optimal ISC efficiency, photothermal conversion efficiency and fluorescence properties, as well as good chemical stability. Encapsulation of Gd-trans-2 within mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSN) allowed its evaluation for tumour diagnosis and therapy. It was found to be effective as an “all-in-one” phototheranostic that allowed for NIR fluorescence/photoacoustic dual-modal imaging while providing an excellent combined PTT/PDT therapeutic efficacy in vitro and in vivo in 4T1-tumour-bearing mice.

We report here porphodilactol derivatives and their corresponding metal complexes as “all-in-one” phototheranostics by controlling the relationship between intersystem crossing (ISC) and photothermal conversion efficiency following photoexcitation.     

“Eggs in egg cartons”: co-crystallization to embed molecular cages into crystalline lattices

Discrete (M₃L₂)_n cages assembled from a tripodal ligand (L) and metal ions (M: Cu(i) or Ag(i)) are embedded in networked coordination hosts formed by partial dissociation of the same discrete cages during the crystallization process. The resulting “eggs-in-an-egg-carton” structures provide unique examples of the co-crystallization of discrete and infinite coordination frameworks.

Discrete coordination cages were connected into the infinite lattices via shape-complementary co-crystallization with networked coordination hosts in the “eggs-in-an-egg-carton” styles.     

The inorganic cation-tailored “trapdoor” effect of silicoaluminophosphate zeolite for highly selective CO2 separation

Functional nanoporous materials are widely explored for CO₂ separation, in particular, small-pore aluminosilicate zeolites having a “trapdoor” effect. Such an effect allows the specific adsorbate to push away the sited cations inside the window followed by exclusive admission to the zeolite pores, which is more advantageous for highly selective CO₂ separation. Herein, we demonstrated that the protonated organic structure-directing agent in the small-pore silicoaluminophosphate (SAPO) RHO zeolite can be directly exchanged with Na⁺, K⁺, or Cs⁺ and that the Na⁺ form of SAPO-RHO exhibited unprecedented separation for CO₂/CH₄, superior to all of the nanoporous materials reported to date. Rietveld refinement revealed that Na⁺ is sited in the center of the single eight-membered ring (s8r), while K⁺ and Cs⁺ are sited in the center of the double 8-rings (d8rs). Theoretical calculations showed that the interaction between Na⁺ and the s8r in SAPO-RHO was stronger than that in aluminosilicate RHO, giving an enhanced “trapdoor” effect and record high selectivity for CO₂ with the separation factor of 2196 for CO₂/CH₄ (0.02/0.98 bar). The separation factor of Na-SAPO-RHO for CO₂/N₂ was 196, which was the top level among zeolitic materials. This work opens a new avenue for gas separation by using diverse silicoaluminophosphate zeolites in terms of the cation-tailored “trapdoor” effect.

The sodium form of silicoaluminophosphate RHO zeolite exhibits a pronounced cation-tailored “trapdoor” effect, showing an unprecedented selectivity adsorption separation performance for CO₂/CH₄ and CO₂/N₂.     

A new type of noncovalent surface–π stacking interaction occurring on peroxide-modified titania nanosheets driven by vertical π-state polarization

Noncovalent π stacking of aromatic molecules is a universal form of noncovalent interactions normally occurring on planar structures (such as aromatic molecules and graphene) based on sp²-hybridized atoms. Here we reveal a new type of noncovalent surface–π stacking unusually occurring between aromatic groups and peroxide-modified titania (PMT) nanosheets, which can drive versatile aromatic adsorptions. We experimentally explore the underlying electronic-level origin by probing the perturbed changes of unoccupied Ti 3d states with near-edge X-ray absorption fine structures (NEXAFS), and find that aromatic groups can vertically attract π electrons in the surface peroxo-Ti states and increase their delocalization regions. Our discovery updates the concept of noncovalent π-stacking interactions by extending the substrates from carbon-based structures to a transition metal oxide, and presents an approach to exploit the surface chemistry of nanomaterials based on noncovalent interactions.

A new type of noncovalent surface–π stacking interaction occurring on a transition metal oxide, titania, is reported, which is different from the traditional forms on sp²-hybridized planar structures like graphene.     

Ex vivo identification of circulating tumor cells in peripheral blood by fluorometric “turn on” aptamer nanoparticles

The detection of the circulating tumor cells (CTCs) detached from solid tumors has emerged as a burgeoning topic for cancer diagnosis and treatment. The conventional CTC enrichment and identification mainly rely on the specific binding of the antibodies on the capture interface of the magnetic nanoparticles with the corresponding biomarkers on the cell membranes. However, these methods could easily generate false-negative results due to the extremely low concentration of CTCs and the internal heterogeneity of the tumor cells. Herein, with the aim of selectively identifying CTCs and improving the detection accuracy in peripheral blood, we designed the fluorometric “turn on” Au nanoparticles (DHANs) with the modification of a tumor-targeted moiety, dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) and a fluorometric aptamer, which could be “switched-on” by an over-expressed intracellular protein, namely hypoxia-inducible factor-1α (HIF 1α). This novel nanoformulated detection platform demonstrated the great capacity for visualizing various CTCs in peripheral blood with significantly improved detection efficiency and sensitivity. As a result, the nanoplatform has a great potential to be further applied for CTC detection in vitro or in vivo, which holds promise for extensive CTC studies.

The detection of the circulating tumor cells (CTCs) detached from solid tumors has emerged as a burgeoning topic for cancer diagnosis and treatment.     

Correction: Rational design of a “dual lock-and-key” supramolecular photosensitizer based on aromatic nucleophilic substitution for specific and enhanced photodynamic therapy

Correction for ‘Rational design of a “dual lock-and-key” supramolecular photosensitizer based on aromatic nucleophilic substitution for specific and enhanced photodynamic therapy’ by Kun-Xu Teng et al., Chem. Sci., 2020, 11, 9703–9711, DOI: 10.1039/D0SC01122C.

The authors regret an error in Fig. 1f. The correct image is shown below.Open in a separate windowFig. 1(f) Fluorescence decay curves of BSG and BIBSG, and the detection wavelength is 600 nm in DMSO.Additionally, there was a minor error in Fig. 4a. The correct image is shown below.Open in a separate windowFig. 4(a) Evaluation of ¹O₂ generation in HepG2 cells with DCFH-DA and SOSG. The scale bar represents 20 μm.The Royal Society of Chemistry apologises for these errors and any consequent inconvenience to authors and readers.     

‘Sacrificial’ supramolecular assembly and pressure-induced polymerization: toward sequence-defined functionalized nanothreads

Limited supramolecular strategies have been utilized to synthesize sequence-defined polymers, despite the prominence of noncovalent interactions in materials design. Herein, we illustrate the utility of ‘sacrificial’ aryl-perfluoroaryl supramolecular synthons to synthesize sp³-hybridized nanothreads from sp²-enriched reactants. Our strategy features A–B reactant pairs in the form of a phenol:pentafluorophenol co-crystal that is preorganized for an electronically-biased and sequence-defined polymerization. The polymerization, initiated at 12 GPa, affords an alternating copolymer featuring exogenous –OH functionalities. The external substitution is confirmed through IR spectroscopy. Importantly, the inclusion of the functional unit provides the first experimental glimpse at reaction mechanism: keto–enol tautomerization that can only occur during cycloaddition is observed through IR spectroscopy. Our approach realizes the first example of a functionalized nanothread and attains sequence definition through sacrificial supramolecular preorganization and presents a further approach for de novo design of complex nanothreads.

Supramolecular synthons are exploited to synthesize –OH functionalized sp³-rich sequence-defined nanothreads using pressure-induced polymerization of a phenol:pentafluorophenol co-crystal.      

Elucidating dissociation activation energies in host–guest assemblies featuring fast exchange dynamics

The ability to mediate the kinetic properties and dissociation activation energies (E_a) of bound guests by controlling the characteristics of “supramolecular lids” in host–guest molecular systems is essential for both their design and performance. While the synthesis of such systems is well advanced, the experimental quantification of their kinetic parameters, particularly in systems experiencing fast association and dissociation dynamics, has been very difficult or impossible with the established methods at hand. Here, we demonstrate the utility of the NMR-based guest exchange saturation transfer (GEST) approach for quantifying the dissociation exchange rates (k_out) and activation energy (E_a,out) in host–guest systems featuring fast dissociation dynamics. Our assessment of the effect of different monovalent cations on the extracted E_a,out in cucurbit[7]uril:guest systems with very fast k_out highlights their role as “supramolecular lids” in mediating a guest''s dissociation E_a. We envision that GEST could be further extended to study kinetic parameters in other supramolecular systems characterized by fast kinetic properties and to design novel switchable host–guest assemblies.

GEST-NMR is utilized for quantifying the dissociation activation energy (E_a,out) in host-guest systems featuring fast dissociation dynamics.     

Thermal effects – an alternative mechanism for plasmon-assisted photocatalysis

Recent experiments claimed that the catalysis of reaction rates in numerous bond-dissociation reactions occurs via the decrease of activation barriers driven by non-equilibrium (“hot”) electrons in illuminated plasmonic metal nanoparticles. Thus, these experiments identify plasmon-assisted photocatalysis as a promising path for enhancing the efficiency of various chemical reactions. Here, we argue that what appears to be photocatalysis is much more likely thermo-catalysis, driven by the well-known plasmon-enhanced ability of illuminated metallic nanoparticles to serve as heat sources. Specifically, we point to some of the most important papers in the field, and show that a simple theory of illumination-induced heating can explain the extracted experimental data to remarkable agreement, with minimal to no fit parameters. We further show that any small temperature difference between the photocatalysis experiment and a control experiment performed under external heating is effectively amplified by the exponential sensitivity of the reaction, and is very likely to be interpreted incorrectly as “hot” electron effects.

A simple Arrhenius-based theory of heating, rather than “hot electrons”, can reproduce some high-profile photocatalysis experimental results to remarkable accuracy. Flaws in temperature measurement may have led to wrong conclusions.     

Triboluminescence of a new family of CuI–NHC complexes in crystalline solid and in amorphous polymer films

Triboluminescent compounds that generate emission of light in response to mechanical stimulus are promising targets in the development of “smart materials” and damage sensors. Among triboluminescent metal complexes, rare-earth europium and terbium complexes are most widely used, while there is no systematic data on more readily available and inexpensive Cu complexes. We report a new family of photoluminescent Cu–NHC complexes that show bright triboluminescence (TL) in the crystal state visible in ambient indoor light under air. Moreover, when these complexes are blended into amorphous polymer films even at small concentrations, TL is easily observed. Observation of TL in polymer films overcomes the limitation of using crystals and opens up possibilities for the development of mechanoresponsive coatings and materials based on inexpensive metals such as Cu. Our results may also have implications for the understanding of the TL effect''s origin in polymer films.

Triboluminescent compounds that generate emission of light in response to mechanical stimulus are promising targets in the development of “smart materials” and damage sensors.     

Pyrazolone ligation-mediated versatile sequential bioconjugations

Bioconjugation chemistries are critical tools in biotherapeutics discovery. The past efforts have been exclusively focused on two-segment conjugations. However, emerging research directions, such as polypharmacy biotherapeutics, desire multiple-component bioconjugations where more than two pharmacologically related biomolecules can be assembled into a single construct in high efficiency. We present here a set of sequential bioconjugation chemistries centered on a pyrazolone structural motif. It starts with a clickable “pyrazolone ligation” between a hydrazine group and a β-ketoester moiety followed by the conjugation between the newly formed pyrazolone core and an aldehyde-bearing biomolecule through a Knoevenagel reaction forming a Michael addition acceptor that can effectively capture a thiol-bearing biomolecule. When utilized intermolecularly, it quickly assembles four segments together forming a quadruple functional construct. When applied intramolecularly, it offers a set of highly diverse biomolecule scaffolds including stapled peptides and poly-macrocyclic peptides. We envision broad utilities of such sequential ligation chemistries.

A multiple component sequential bioconjugation chemistry establishes upon the joined force of hydrazine, β-keto ester, thiol and aldehyde.     

Understanding the geometric diversity of inorganic and hybrid frameworks through structural coarse-graining

Much of our understanding of complex structures is based on simplification: for example, metal–organic frameworks are often discussed in the context of “nodes” and “linkers”, allowing for a qualitative comparison with simpler inorganic structures. Here we show how such an understanding can be obtained in a systematic and quantitative framework, combining atom-density based similarity (kernel) functions and unsupervised machine learning with the long-standing idea of “coarse-graining” atomic structure. We demonstrate how the latter enables a comparison of vastly different chemical systems, and we use it to create a unified, two-dimensional structure map of experimentally known tetrahedral AB₂ networks – including clathrate hydrates, zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs), and diverse inorganic phases. The structural relationships that emerge can then be linked to microscopic properties of interest, which we exemplify for structural heterogeneity and tetrahedral density.

A coarse-graining approach enables structural comparisons across vastly different chemical spaces, from inorganic polymorphs to hybrid framework materials.     

A protecting group strategy to access stable lacunary polyoxomolybdates for introducing multinuclear metal clusters

Although metal-containing polyoxomolybdates (molybdenum oxide clusters) exhibit outstanding catalytic properties, their precise synthetic method has not yet been developed. This is mainly because the very low stability of the multivacant lacunary polyoxomolybdates limited their use as synthetic precursors. Here, we present a “protecting group strategy” in polyoxometalate synthesis and successfully develop an efficient method for synthesising multinuclear metal-containing polyoxomolybdates using pyridine as a protecting group for unstable trivacant lacunary Keggin-type polyoxomolybdate [PMo₉O₃₄]⁹⁻. Specifically, tetranuclear cubane- and planar-type manganese clusters were selectively synthesised in the polyoxomolybdates using the present method. The importance of this work is that, in addition to being the first practical way of utilizing multivacant lacunary polyoxomolybdates as precursors, this new “protecting group strategy” will make it possible to produce polyoxometalates with unexplored structures and properties.

A “protecting group strategy” for unstable lacunary polyoxomolybdates enabled successful synthesis of two types of tetranuclear manganese clusters.     

Supramolecular agents for combination of photodynamic therapy and other treatments

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a promising treatment for cancers such as superficial skin cancers, esophageal cancer, and cervical cancer. Unfortunately, PDT often does not have sufficient therapeutic benefits due to its intrinsic oxygen dependence and the limited permeability of irradiating light. Side effects from “always on” photosensitizers (PSs) can be problematic, and PDT cannot treat tumor metastases or recurrences. In recent years, supramolecular approaches using non-covalent interactions have attracted attention due to their potential in PS development. A supramolecular PS assembly could be built to maximize photodynamic effects and minimize side effects. A combination of two or more therapies can effectively address shortcomings while maximizing the benefits of each treatment regimen. Using the supramolecular assembly, it is possible to design a multifunctional supramolecular PS to exert synergistic effects by combining PDT with other treatment methods. This review provides a summary of important research progress on supramolecular systems that can be used to combine PDT with photothermal therapy, chemotherapy, and immunotherapy to compensate for the shortcomings of PDT, and it provides an overview of the prospects for future cancer treatment advances and clinical applications.

This review provides a summary of important research progress on supramolecular systems that can be used to combine photodynamic therapy (PDT) with photothermal therapy, chemotherapy, and immunotherapy to compensate for the shortcomings of PDT.     

Expected and unexpected photoreactions of 9-(10-)substituted anthracene derivatives in cucurbit[n]uril hosts

By arranging substrates in a “reaction ready” state through noncovalent interactions, supramolecular nanoreactors/catalysts show high selectivity and/or rate acceleration features. Herein, we report the host–guest complexation of 9-(10-)substituted anthracene derivatives (G1–G3) with cucurbit[n]uril (CB[n], n = 8, 10), and the photoreactions of these derivatives in the presence of CB[n] hosts. Both CB[10] and CB[8] showed no obvious effects on the photoreaction of 9,10-disubstituted derivative G1. For G2 and G3, CB[10] operated as either a nanoreactor or catalyst (10%) for the photodimerization of two compounds with high selectivity and high yield. However, although CB[8] formed a 1 : 2 complex with G2, as also observed with CB[10], the photosolvolysis product (9-anthracenemethanol) was obtained quantitatively after photoirradiation of the CB[8]·2G2 complex. This unexpected photosolvolysis was rationalized by a plausible catalytic cycle in which anthracene acts as a photoremovable protecting group (PPG) and the carbonium ion intermediate is stabilized by CB[8].

The photodimerization of 9-substituted anthracene derivative was tremendously promoted by a catalytic amount of cucurbit[10]uril (CB[10]) in water. While CB[8] exclusively induced the photosolvolysis of the anthracene derivative.     

Long-lived lanthanide emission via a pH-sensitive and switchable LRET complex

Lanthanide-based luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) can be used as a tool to enhance lanthanide emission for time-resolved cellular imaging applications. By shortening lanthanide emission lifetimes whilst providing an alternative radiative pathway to the formally forbidden, weak lanthanide-only emission, the photon flux of such systems is increased. With this aim in mind, we investigated energy transfer in differently spaced donor–acceptor terbium–rhodamine pairs with the LRET “on” (low pH) and LRET “off” (high pH). Results informed the design, preparation and characterisation of a compound containing terbium, a spectrally-matched pH-responsive fluorophore and a receptor-targeting group. By combining these elements, we observed switchable LRET, where the targeting group sensitises lanthanide emission, resulting in an energy transfer to the rhodamine dye with an efficiency of E = 0.53. This strategy can be used to increase lanthanide emission rates for brighter optical probes.

A pH-sensitive luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) was explored as a method to increase photon flux in a terbium-rhodamine-receptor targeting group construct. At low pH, long-lived dye emission and shorter terbium lifetimes were observed.     

Long-lived triplet charge-separated state in naphthalenediimide based donor–acceptor systems

1,4,5,8-Naphthalenediimides (NDIs) are widely used motifs to design multichromophoric architectures due to their ease of functionalisation, their high oxidative power and the stability of their radical anion. The NDI building block can be incorporated in supramolecular systems by either core or imide functionalization. We report on the charge-transfer dynamics of a series of electron donor–acceptor dyads consisting of a NDI chromophore with one or two donors linked at the axial, imide position. Photo-population of the core-centred π–π* state is followed by ultrafast electron transfer from the electron donor to the NDI. Due to a solvent dependent singlet–triplet equilibrium inherent to the NDI core, both singlet and triplet charge-separated states are populated. We demonstrate that long-lived charge separation in the triplet state can be achieved by controlling the mutual orientation of the donor–acceptor sub-units. By extending this study to a supramolecular NDI-based cage, we also show that the triplet charge-separation yield can be increased by tuning the environment.

Ultrafast electron transfer from singlet and triplet excited states in equilibrium results in the population of both singlet and triplet charge-separated states.     

Hydrogen and proton exchange at carbon. Imbalanced transition state and mechanism crossover

A recent remarkable study of the C–H oxidation of substituted fluorenyl-benzoates together with the transfer of a proton to an internal receiving group by means of electron transfer outer-sphere oxidants, in the noteworthy absence of hydrogen-bonding interactions, is taken as an example to uncover the existence of a mechanism crossover, making the reaction pass from a CPET pathway to a PTET pathway as the driving force of the global reaction decreases. This was also the occasion to stress that considerations based on “imbalanced” or “asynchronous” transition states cannot replace activation/driving force models based on the quantum mechanical treatment of both electrons and transferring protons.

Using the remarkable study of C–H oxidation of substituted fluorenyl-benzoates as an example, we have shown that a mechanism crossover takes place upon decreasing the driving force, from a CPET pathway to a PTET pathway.