A class of on-line scheduling algorithms to minimize total completion time

We consider the problem of scheduling jobs on-line on a single machine and on identical machines with the objective to minimize total completion time. We assume that the jobs arrive over time. We give a general 2-competitive algorithm for the single machine problem. The algorithm is based on delaying the release time of the jobs, i.e., making the jobs artificially later available to the on-line scheduler than the actual release times. Our algorithm includes two known algorithms for this problem that apply delay of release times. The proposed algorithm is interesting since it gives the on-line scheduler a whole range of choices for the delays, each of which leading to 2-competitiveness.We also show that the algorithm is 2α competitive for the problem on identical machines where α is the performance ratio of the Shortest Remaining Processing Time first rule for the preemptive relaxation of the problem.     

Preemptive Semi-online Algorithms for Parallel Machine Scheduling with Known Total Size

This paper investigates preemptive semi-online scheduling problems on m identical parallel machines, where the total size of all jobs is known in advance. The goal is to minimize the maximum machine completion time or maximize the minimum machine completion time. For the first objective, we present an optimal semi-online algorithm with competitive ratio 1. For the second objective, we show that the competitive ratio of any semi-online algorithm is at least （2m-3）/（m-1） for any m〉2 and present optimal semi-online algorithms for m = 2, 3.     

Parallel machine covering with limited number of preemptions简

In this paper,we investigate the i-preemptive scheduling on parallel machines to maximize the minimum machine completion time,i.e.,machine covering problem with limited number of preemptions. It is aimed to obtain the worst case ratio of the objective value of the optimal schedule with unlimited preemptions and that of the schedule allowed to be preempted at most i times. For the m identical machines case,we show the worst case ratio is 2m.i.1 m,and we present a polynomial time algorithm which can guarantee the ratio for any 0 ≤ i ≤ m. 1. For the i-preemptive scheduling on two uniform machines case,we only need to consider the cases of i = 0 and i = 1. For both cases,we present two linear time algorithms and obtain the worst case ratios with respect to s,i.e.,the ratio of the speeds of two machines.     

Parallel machine scheduling with a convex resource consumption function

We consider some problems of scheduling jobs on identical parallel machines where job-processing times are controllable through the allocation of a nonrenewable common limited resource. The objective is to assign the jobs to the machines, to sequence the jobs on each machine and to allocate the resource so that the makespan or the sum of completion times is minimized. The optimization is done for both preemptive and nonpreemptive jobs. For the makespan problem with nonpreemptive jobs we apply the equivalent load method in order to allocate the resources, and thereby reduce the problem to a combinatorial one. The reduced problem is shown to be NP-hard. If preemptive jobs are allowed, the makespan problem is shown to be solvable in O(n²) time. Some special cases of this problem with precedence constraints are presented and the problem of minimizing the sum of completion times is shown to be solvable in O(n log n) time.     

Heuristic constructive algorithms for open shop scheduling to minimize mean flow time

In this paper, we consider the problem of scheduling n jobs on m machines in an open shop environment so that the sum of completion times or mean flow time becomes minimal. For this strongly NP-hard problem, we develop and discuss different constructive heuristic algorithms. Extensive computational results are presented for problems with up to 50 jobs and 50 machines, respectively. The quality of the solutions is evaluated by a lower bound for the corresponding preemptive open shop problem and by an alternative estimate of mean flow time. We observe that the recommendation of an appropriate constructive algorithm strongly depends on the ratio n/m.     

Online scheduling with general machine cost functions

For most scheduling problems the set of machines is fixed initially and remains unchanged for the duration of the problem. Recently online scheduling problems have been investigated with the modification that initially the algorithm possesses no machines, but that at any point additional machines may be purchased. In all of these models the assumption has been made that each machine has unit cost. In this paper we consider the problem with general machine cost functions. Furthermore we also consider a more general version of the problem where the available machines have speed, the algorithm may purchase machines with speed 1 and machines with speed s. We define and analyze some algorithms for the solution of these problems and their special cases. Moreover we prove some lower bounds on the possible competitive ratios.     

Coordinating multi-location production and customer delivery

We study two parallel machine scheduling problems with equal processing time jobs and delivery times and costs. The jobs are processed on machines which are located at different sites, and delivered to a customer by a single vehicle. The first objective considered is minimizing the sum of total weighted completion time and total vehicle delivery costs. The second objective considered is minimizing the sum of total tardiness and total vehicle delivery costs. We develop several interesting properties of an optimal scheduling and delivery policy, and show that both problems can be solved by reduction to the Shortest-Path problem in a corresponding network. The overall computational effort of both algorithms is O(n ^m2+m+1) (where n and m are the number of jobs and the number of machines, respectively) by the application of the Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) method. We also discuss several special cases for which the overall computational effort can be significantly reduced.     

Uniform parallel machine scheduling problems with fixed machine cost

This paper considers two uniform parallel machine scheduling problems with fixed machine cost under the background of cloud manufacturing. The goal is to minimize the makespan with a given budget of total cost, \(\hat{U}\). All the jobs are homogeneous, i.e., the processing times of the jobs are identical. Non-preemptive and preemptive problems are studied. For the non-preemptive problem, we give a \(2[1+1{/}(h-1)]\)-approximation algorithm, where h is the number of the machine which can not be selected the first time. For the preemptive problem, we give an algorithm whose worst-case bound equals to \(1+1{/}(h-1)\). Preliminary experimental results indicate that the proposed algorithms are reasonably accurate compared with the lower bounds.     

On the optimality of list scheduling for online uniform machines scheduling

This paper considers classical online scheduling problems on uniform machines. We show the tight competitive ratio of LS for any combinations of speeds of three machines. We prove that LS is optimal when s ₃ ≥ s ₂ ≥ s ₁ = 1 and ${s_3^2\geq s_2^2+s_2s_3+s_2}$ , where s ₁, s ₂, s ₃ are the speeds of three machines. On the other hand, LS can not be optimal for all combinations of machine speeds, even restricted to the case of 1 = s ₁ = s ₂ < s ₃. For m ≥ 4 machines, LS remains optimal when one machine has very large speed, and the remaining machines have the same speed.     

Optimal on-line flow time with resource augmentation

We study the problem of scheduling n jobs that arrive over time. We consider a non-preemptive setting on a single machine. The goal is to minimize the total flow time. We use extra resource competitive analysis: an optimal off-line algorithm which schedules jobs on a single machine is compared to a more powerful on-line algorithm that has ? machines. We design an algorithm of competitive ratio , where Δ is the maximum ratio between two job sizes, and provide a lower bound which shows that the algorithm is optimal up to a constant factor for any constant ?. The algorithm works for a hard version of the problem where the sizes of the smallest and the largest jobs are not known in advance, only Δ and n are known. This gives a trade-off between the resource augmentation and the competitive ratio.We also consider scheduling on parallel identical machines. In this case the optimal off-line algorithm has m machines and the on-line algorithm has ?m machines. We give a lower bound for this case. Next, we give lower bounds for algorithms using resource augmentation on the speed. Finally, we consider scheduling with hard deadlines, and scheduling so as to minimize the total completion time.     

A better semi-online algorithm for Q3/s1 = s2≤ s3/Cmin with the known largest size

This paper investigates the semi-online machine covering problem on three special uniform machines with the known largest size. Denote by sj the speed of each machine, j = 1, 2, 3. Assume 0 < s1 = s2 = r ≤ t = s3, and let s = t/r be the speed ratio. An algorithm with competitive ratio max{2, (3s+6)/(s+6) } is presented. We also show the lower bound is at least max{2, (3s)/(s+6)}. For s ≤ 6, the algorithm is an optimal algorithm with the competitive ratio 2. Besides, its overall competitive ratio is 3 which matches the overall lower bound. The algorithm and the lower bound in this paper improve the results of Luo and Sun.     

LP-based online scheduling: from single to parallel machines

We study classic machine sequencing problems in an online setting. Specifically, we look at deterministic and randomized algorithms for the problem of scheduling jobs with release dates on identical parallel machines, to minimize the sum of weighted completion times: Both preemptive and non-preemptive versions of the problem are analyzed. Using linear programming techniques, borrowed from the single machine case, we are able to design a 2.62-competitive deterministic algorithm for the non-preemptive version of the problem, improving upon the 3.28-competitive algorithm of Megow and Schulz. Additionally, we show how to combine randomization techniques with the linear programming approach to obtain randomized algorithms for both versions of the problem with competitive ratio strictly smaller than 2 for any number of machines (but approaching two as the number of machines grows). Our algorithms naturally extend several approaches for single and parallel machine scheduling. We also present a brief computational study, for randomly generated problem instances, which suggests that our algorithms perform very well in practice. A preliminary version of this work appears in the Proceedings of the 11th conference on integer programming and combinatorial optimization (IPCO), Berlin, 8–10 June 2005.     

带机器准备时间的两台同型机复合半在线排序问题

本文研究了预知两种信息,带机器准备时间的两台同型平行机复合半在线排序问题,即已知所有工件加工时间总和和工件按加工时间非增顺序到达,目标为极小化最大机器完工时间的半在线排序模型.我们分析了它的下界,并给出了竞争比为7/6的最优算法.     

Comments on “Competitive analysis of a better on-line algorithm to minimize total completion time on a single-machine”

For the single machine scheduling problem of minimizing the total completion time, Montoya Torres (J Glob Opt 27:97–103, 2003) presented a semi-online algorithm under the assumption that release dates are known in advance, and showed that it was \({\sqrt{3}}\)-competitive. However, there are flaws in the proof, and the conclusion about the competitive ratio is not correct. In this note, we show that the semi-online algorithm cannot perform better than the best non-clairvoyant online algorithm with a competitive ratio of 2.     

Tight upper bounds for semi-online scheduling on two uniform machines with known optimum

We consider a semi-online version of the problem of scheduling a sequence of jobs of different lengths on two uniform machines with given speeds 1 and s. Jobs are revealed one by one (the assignment of a job has to be done before the next job is revealed), and the objective is to minimize the makespan. In the considered variant the optimal offline makespan is known in advance. The most studied question for this online-type problem is to determine the optimal competitive ratio, that is, the worst-case ratio of the solution given by an algorithm in comparison to the optimal offline solution. In this paper, we make a further step towards completing the answer to this question by determining the optimal competitive ratio for s between \(\frac{5 + \sqrt{241}}{12} \approx 1.7103\) and \(\sqrt{3} \approx 1.7321\), one of the intervals that were still open. Namely, we present and analyze a compound algorithm achieving the previously known lower bounds.

     

Approximability results for the resource-constrained project scheduling problem with a single type of resources

In this paper, we consider the well-known resource-constrained project scheduling problem. We give some arguments that already a special case of this problem with a single type of resources is not approximable in polynomial time with an approximation ratio bounded by a constant. We prove that there exist instances for which the optimal makespan values for the non-preemptive and the preemptive problems have a ratio of O(logn), where n is the number of jobs. This means that there exist instances for which the lower bound of Mingozzi et al. has a bad relative error of O(logn), and the calculation of this bound is an NP-hard problem. In addition, we give a proof that there exists a type of instances for which known approximation algorithms with polynomial time complexity have an approximation ratio of at least equal to $O(\sqrt{n})$ , and known lower bounds have a relative error of at least equal to O(logn). This type of instances corresponds to the single machine parallel-batch scheduling problem 1|p?batch,b=∞|C _max.     

On scheduling with the non-idling constraint

In this paper, we give an overview of the main results obtained on the complexity of scheduling under the non-idling constraint, i.e, when the jobs assigned to each machine must be processed with no intermediate delay. That constraint is met in practice when the cost of intermediate idle time is too high due to the idle time itself and/or the machine restarting. The non idling constraint is a strong constraint that often needs a new solving approach and most results about classical scheduling problems do not easily extend to the non-idling variant of the problem. In this survey, we mainly consider the non-idling variants of the basic scheduling problems. So, we first present basic properties, complexity results and some algorithms concerning the one-machine non-idling scheduling problem. Then we consider the $m$ -machine non idling scheduling problem. We show that a few basic problems may be solved by rather easy extensions of the algorithm solving their classical counterpart. However, the complexity status of the non idling version of quite easy polynomial basic problems remains an open question. We finally consider a more constrained version of non-idling, called the “homogeneously non idling” constraint, where for any subset of machines, the union of their busy intervals must make an interval and we present the structural property that leads to a polynomial algorithm for unit time jobs and a weak precedence. We conclude by giving some research directions that seem quite interesting to study both for theoretical and practical issues.     

带机器准备时间的机器覆盖问题的在线、半在线算法

研究以极大化最小机器负载为目标的机器带准备时间的同型机排序问题.证明了LS算法是求解该问题的最好的在线算法,它的最坏情况界为1/m.同时给出了求解两台机的预先知道工件最大加工时间,预先知道工件集的总加工时间以及预先知道工件从大到小到达这三种情形下最好的半在线算法,这三个算法的最坏情况界分别为2/3,2/3以及3/4.     

Polynomial time approximation schemes for general multiprocessor job shop scheduling

We study preemptive and non-preemptive versions of the general multiprocessor job shop scheduling problem: Given a set of n tasks each consisting of at most μ ordered operations that can be processed on different (possibly all) subsets of m machines with different processing times, compute a schedule (preemptive or non-preemptive, depending on the model) with minimum makespan where operations belonging to the same task have to be scheduled according to the specified order. We propose algorithms for both preemptive and non-preemptive variants of this problem that compute approximate solutions of any positive ε accuracy and run in O(n) time for any fixed values of m, μ, and ε. These results include (as special cases) many recent developments on polynomial time approximation schemes for scheduling jobs on unrelated machines, multiprocessor tasks, and classical open, flow and job shops.     

Online C-benevolent job scheduling on multiple machines

We consider scheduling a sequence of C-benevolent jobs on multiple homogeneous machines. For two machines, we propose a 2-competitive Cooperative Greedy algorithm and provide a lower bound of 2 for the competitive ratio of any deterministic online scheduling algorithms on two machines. For multiple machines, we propose a Pairing-m Greedy algorithm, which is deterministic 2-competitive for even number of machines and randomized \((2+2/{\hbox {m}})\)-competitive for odd number of machines. We provide a lower bound of 1.436 for the competitive ratio of any deterministic online scheduling algorithms on three machines, which is the best known lower bound for competitive ratios of deterministic scheduling algorithms on three machines.