Self-assembled BLMs: biomembrane models and biosensor applications

In the last few years, there have been a number of research papers on self-assemblies of molecules as ‘advanced’ or ‘smart’ materials. The inspiration for this exciting research, without question, comes from the biological world, where, for example, the lipid bilayer of the cell membrane is the most important self-assembling system. Although the first report on self-assembled bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs) in vitro was published in 1962, interface science, including surface and colloid science, has been dealing with these interfacial self-assemblies of amphiphilic molecules since Robert Hooke's time (1672). BLMs have been used in a number of applications, ranging from basic membrane biophysics studies to the conversion of solar energy via water photolysis, and to biosensor development using supported bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLMs and sb-BLMs). This paper briefly summarizes the past research on the use of BLMs as models of biological membranes and describes some details of our current work on supported BLMs as practical biosensors. Additionally, experiments carried out in close collaboration with others on s-BLMs and sb-BLMs are presented.     

The 40th anniversary of bilayer lipid membrane research

This paper presents a historic perspective on the origin of the lipid bilayer concept and its experimental realization. Additionally, current studies in close collaboration with our colleagues on the use of supported BLMs as biosensors and molecular devices are delineated. Further, recent research of others on BLMs (planar lipid bilayers) is referenced.     

Effects of direct current bias voltages on supported bilayer lipid membranes on a glassy carbon electrode

The effects of dc bias voltages on supported bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLMs) on a glassy carbon (GC) electrode have been investigated by cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The experiments suggested that an appropriate positive bias voltage facilitated the formation of electrically dense membranes, but if the voltage is enough high, the lacunas on s-BLMs increased, and eventually caused the complete oxidation of the lipid membrane. While negative bias voltages could induce the damage of supported membranes to different extent. The changes of the form and quantity of graphite oxide on the surface of the electrode caused by dc bias voltages and the electroporation and damage of the membrane at high potentials may be responsible for the effects.     

Biophysical aspects of agar-gel supported bilayer lipid nembranes: a new method for forming and studying planar bilayer lipid membranes

Conventional bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs), formed by either the painting method or the Langmuir-Blodgett technique, lack the desired stability. This paper presents a simple method for forming long-lived BLMs on agar-gel supports. The supported BLM reported has a greatly improved mechanical stability and also has desirable dynamic properties. These self-assembled BLMs are of significant interest, in view of their similarity of biological membranes, their molecular dimension and their spontaneous formation.     

Nitric oxide enhances the capacitance of self-assembled,supported bilayer lipid membranes

The effect of nitric oxide (NO) at biologically relevant concentrations on the electrochemical features of the membrane was investigated by cyclic voltammetry (CV) at self-assembled, stainless steel supported lipid bilayer membranes (s-BLMs) using a three-electrode system. The results showed that the membrane capacitance (C_m) of s-BLMs was dramatically enhanced by the presence of increasing NO concentration from 0 to 70 μM. For comparison, fullerene C₆₀ doped s-BLMs (C₆₀@s-BLMs) was also studied. The C_m of C₆₀@s-BLMs increased with NO concentration from 0 to 16 μM and gradually reached a plateau value when NO concentration was over 16 μM. We concluded that (i) NO accumulated inside lipid bilayer increases the C_m of s-BLMs, and (ii) C₆₀ inside s-BLMs changes the dielectric constant of lipid bilayer, thus reducing the effect of NO on the C_m of C₆₀@s-BLMs. This novel self-assembled lipid modified probe provides a simple yet interesting model to study the effect of NO on the electrical conductance of the membrane.     

Fabrication and photoelectric properties of self-assembled bilayer lipid membranes on conducting glass

Supported bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLMs with and without the doping of fullerene C60) self-assembled on indium-tin oxide (ITO) glass were fabricated and characterized by cyclic voltammetry and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy using a three-electrode system. The photoelectric properties of the ITO supported planar lipid bilayers were studied. Light intensity of irradiation, bias voltage, and concentration of donors have been found to be limiting factors of the transmembrane photocurrent. The facilitation effect of C60 doping in s-BLMs on the photoinduced electron transfer across s-BLM is discussed. This novel self-assembled ITO/s-BLM system may provide a simple and mechanically stable model for the study of the photoelectric and photodynamic properties of biomembranes.     

Planar bilayer lipid memebranes

The planar bilayer lipid membrane, also known as lipid bilayer membrane, black lipid membrane or simply BLM(s), for short, has been investigated since its inception in 1960, the details of which have been described in a monograph published in 1974. This review is a report on the advances in the BLM research since that time.After a brief introduction, the first five sections consider various aspects of experimental methods, optical properties, thermodynamics of lipid bilayers, permeability, and electrical properties of BLMs. Section 7 deals with the use of BLM as energy transducer, particularly the transduction of light into electrical energy. Section 8, the longest portion of the paper, is devoted to modelling of biomembranes, such as the plasma membrane of cells, the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts, the cristae membrane of mitochondria, the visual receptor membrane of the eye, and the nerve membrane. The concluding section points out that studies of BLMs facilitate the initial testing of working hypothses and may lead to a better choice of appropriate $\text{in vivo}$ and reconstituted membrane experiments.     

Bilayer lipid membranes: An experimental system for biomolecular electronic devices development

The lipid bilayer postulated as the basic structural matrix of biological membranes is widely accepted. At present, the planar bilayer lipid membrane (BLM) together with spherical lipid bilayers (liposomes), upon suitable modification, serves as a most appropriate model for biological membranes. In recent years, advances in microelectronics and interest in ultrathin organic films, including BLMs and Langmuir-Blodgett (L-B) films, have resulted in a unique fusion of ideas toward the development of biosensors and transducers. Furthermore, recent trends in interdisciplinary studies in chemistry, electronics, and biology have led to a new field of research: biomolecular electronics. This exciting new field of scientific-technological endeavor is part of a more general approach toward the development of a new, post-semiconductor electronic technology, namely, molecular electronics with a long-term goal of molecular computers.

Recently, it has been demonstrated that BLMs, after suitable modification, can function as electrodes and exhibit nonlinear electronic properties. These and other experimental findings relevant to sensor development and to “biomolecular electronic devices” (BED) will be described in more details in the present review article. Also the potential use of the BLM system together with its modifications in the development of a new class of organic diodes, switches, biosensors, electrochemical photocells, and biofuel cells will be discussed. Additionally, this paper reports also a novel technique for obtaining BLMs (or lipid bilayers) on solid supports. The presence of solid support on one side of the BLM greatly enhances its mechanical stability, while retaining the dynamic properties of the lipid bilayer. Advantages of the new techniques for self-assembling amphiphilic molecules on rigid substrates are discussed in terms of their possible uses. It is evident that the new BLM system (s-BLMs) is potentially useful for technological applications in the area of biosensors and enzyme electrodes as well as molecular electronics.     

Tethered bilayer lipid membranes studied by simultaneous attenuated total reflectance infrared spectroscopy and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy

The formation of tethered lipid bilayer membranes (tBLMs) from unilamelar vesicles of egg yolk phosphatidylcholine (EggPC) on mixed self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) from varying ratios of 6-mercaptohexanol and EO(3)Cholesteryl on gold has been monitored by simultaneous attenuated total reflectance Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The influence of the lipid orientation (and hence the anisotropy) of lipids on a gold film on the dichroic ratio was studied by simulations of spectra with a matrix method for anisotropic layers. It is shown that for certain tilt angles of the dielectric tensor of the adsorbed anisotropic layer dispersive and negative absorption bands are possible. The experimental data indicate that the structure of the assemblies obtained varies with varying SAM composition. On SAMs with a high content of EO(3)Cholesteryl, tBLMs with reduced fluidity are formed. For SAMs with a high content of 6-mercaptohexanol, the results are consistent with the adsorption of flattened vesicles, and spherical vesicles have been found in a small range of surface compositions. The kinetics of the adsorption process is consistent with the assumption of spherical vesicles as long-living intermediates for surfaces of a high 6-mercaptohexanol content. No long-living spherical vesicles have been detected for surfaces with a large fraction of EO(3)Cholesteryl tethers. The observed differences between the surfaces suggest that for the formation of tBLMs (unlike supported BLMs) no critical surface coverage of vesicles is needed prior to lipid bilayer formation.     

A minisensor for the rapid screening of atenolol in pharmaceutical preparations based on surface-stabilized bilayer lipid membranes with incorporated DNA

This work describes an electrochemical technique that is suitable for the rapid and sensitive screening of atenolol based on surface-stabilized bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLMs) composed from egg phosphatidylcholine (PC). The interactions of atenolol with s-BLMs produced electrochemical ion current increases that reproducible appeared within a few seconds after the exposure of the membranes to the drug. The current signal increase was related to the concentration of atenolol in bulk solution in the micromolar range. The present lipid film-based sensor provided fast response (i.e. on the order of a few seconds) to alterations of atenolol concentration (20 to 200 micro M) in electrolyte solution. ssDNA incorporated into s-BLMs can interact with atenolol, and decreased the detection limit of this drug by one order of magnitude. The oligomers used were single stranded deoxyribonucleic acids: thymidylic acid icosanucleotide terminated with a C-16 alkyl chain to assist incorporation into s-BLMs (5'-hexadecyl-deoxythymidylic acid icosanucleotide, dT(20)-C(16)). The electrochemical transduction of the interactions of atenolol with s-BLMs was applied in the determination of these compounds in pharmaceutical preparations by using the present minisensor.     

Evaluation of a glassy carbon electrode modified by a bilayer lipid membrane with incorporated DNA

The objective of the present work was the evaluation and characterization of a glassy carbon (GC) electrode modified by a bilayer lipid membrane (BLM) with incorporated single-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid fss DNA). Various procedures were developed and tested for the incorporation of ss DNA at the electrode modified by the lipidic membrane: Differential pulse voltammetry (i.e. oxidation of guanine and adenine residues) was used to monitor the incorporation of ss DNA at the GC electrode modified by the BLM. The results have shown that the lipid membrane enhances the stability of ss DNA during a "medium-exchange" of the electrode and prohibits its diffusion from the electrode surface. The third scheme was proven to be the most appropriate as both electrode modification by the BLM and DNA adsorption occur in one stage and much faster (as no BLM thinning process is required) as compared to the former two techniques; furthermore, maximized loading of DNA in BLMs is achieved which reduces by ca. 10-fold the DNA amounts that can be detected electrochemically. Conventional planar "free-suspended" and self-assembled metal supported BLMs were used to monitor in situ the incorporation of ss DNA in these membranes. The results have shown that the adsorption of ss DNA at lipid membranes (as a medium for DNA incorporation on an electrode surface) can occur much faster, using milder conditions and smaller amounts of DNA than by previously described techniques.     

Incorporation of Na(+),K(+)-ATP-ase into the thiolipid biomimetic assemblies via the fusion of proteoliposomes

The black lipid membranes (BLMs) are artificial membrane systems that have been widely used in the study of different biological processes. In this paper the planar bilayer lipid membranes have been used to study the behavior of thiolipid molecules-dipalmitoyl-phosphatidyl-ethanolamine-mercaptopropionamide (DPPE-MPA) and cholesteryl 3-mercaptopropionate (Chs-MPA)-as compared to classical BLM made of natural lipids. We present our experiments on black thiolipid bilayer (BTM) formation from a thiolipid solution and basic results of pump currents generated by sodium-potassium pump-Na(+),K(+)-ATP-ase-introduced to such bilayer systems via proteoliposome adsorption with subsequent fusion. Our results imply that no substantial difference exists between BLMs formed from classical lipids and those made from thiolipids used in this study. The same thiolipid molecules were subsequently used for the formation of covalently bound, tethered bilayer lipid membranes (t-BLMs) on polycrystalline gold electrodes. Similarly, as in the case of BLMs, we took advantage of proteoliposome adsorption/fusion to obtain a t-BLM system with reconstituted enzyme. The vesicle fusion on hydrophobic or hydrophilic substrates is one of the main ways to obtain a bilayer system with incorporated biological species. In this paper we present also our preliminary results of electrochemical experiments using rapid solution exchange technique on such t-BLMs systems and their comparison with painted solid supported membranes (SSMs) and BLMs. We have also followed the process of vesicles fusion onto thiolipid monolayer by means of in situ atomic force microscopy in tapping mode (TM-AFM). On the basis of these experiments, we conclude that DPPE-MPA and Chs-MPA molecules used in our experiments preserve lipid properties, allowing for at least partial reconstitution of Na(+),K(+)-ATP-ase into such t-BLMs. On the other hand, the relatively compact organization on polycrystalline gold and the hydrophobic nature of the first monolayer of tethered thiolipids slows down the proteoliposome fusion onto such monolayers and consequently hinders the protein insertion. However, this effect can be overcome by mechanical stimulus that facilitates proteoliposome delamination onto the self-assembled monolayer.     

Miniaturized biochemical sensing devices based on planar bilayer lipid membranes

Methods of in-vitro artificial formation of bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) and their analytical applications are reviewed, on the basis of 122 literature references. Different techniques for preparation of free-suspended planar BLMs, and gel-, filter-, and solid-supported systems are presented. The analytical applications developed are based on direct interaction of analytes with chemically unmodified BLMs, and with systems modified by use of redox mediators, ionophores, ion-channel forming species, enzymes, antibodies, or DNA.     

Photosensitized damage of bilayer lipid membrane in the presence of haematoporphyrin dimethylether

The variations in electrical conductivity and surface tension of planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs) sensitized by a haematoporphyrin dimethylether (HpDME) on visible light irradiation are reported. The irradiation of BLMs immediately leads to a decrease in membrane surface tension. On irradiation the conductivity of BLMs remains constant for a certain period of time (induction time), followed by an increase, terminated by membrane breakage. The induction time is not dependent on stirring of the solution, the addition of azide or ferricyanide to the solution, the addition of antioxidant to the lipid or substitution of air for argon in the cell. The induction time decreases for repeated irradiations or for any new BLM formed in the same cell immediately after the previous membrane has been broken. The conductivity shift consists of reversible and irreversible components. These results suggest that the irradiation of BLMs sensitized by HpDME leads to an accumulation of photoproducts in the membrane which induce pore formation and to a decrease in BLM stability when the concentration of the photoproducts exceeds a critical level.     

Ion permeability through bilayer lipid membranes for biosensor development: control by chemical modification of interfacial regions between phase domains.

Based on the results of studies on cystic fibrosis, which implicated hydroxystearic acid (HSA) as a contributing factor in altered biomembrane function, solvent-free bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs) and monolayer films were prepared from a lipid mixture containing (by mass) 34% phosphatidylcholine, 19% dipalmitoylphosphatidyl serine, 47% cholesterol and variable amounts of 10- and 12-HSA (0-50%). Ion currents, resulting from K+ permeation through BLMs that were supported in 0.1 mol dm-3 KCl solutions buffered to pH 7.4, were monitored with use of a d.c. circuit. The structures of monolayer films at the air-water interface of a Langmuir-Blodgett trough were studied by pressure-area correlations and by further correlation with microscopic phase separation as revealed by fluorescence microscopy. In order to elucidate the role of the hydroxyl moieties in ion permeability, the transmembrane ion current was corrected for the effect of the negative surface charge of the carboxylic acid by replacement of the HSA component with stearic acid. The ion current was found to increase with the molar proportion of the HSAs. Two models for ion conduction through BLMs were considered: 'hopping' via hydrophilic sites within the hydrophobic zone of the BLMs, introduced by the hydroxyl moiety of 10- or 12-HSA; and transport through interfacial regions between phase domains that represent areas of low steric density and low structural order within monolayers. Although the two mechanisms are not distinct, the ion permeability results indicate a change in the response of ion current to HSA concentration at 35 mol-%, suggesting a change in the relative proportion of the mechanisms.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Incorporation of alpha-hemolysin in different tethered bilayer lipid membrane architectures

Tethered bilayer lipid membranes are stable solid supported model membrane systems. They can be used to investigate the incorporation and function of membrane proteins. In order to study ion translocation mediated via incorporated proteins, insulating membranes are necessary. The architecture of the membrane can have an important effect on both the electrical properties of the lipid bilayer as well as on the possibility to functionally host proteins. Alpha-hemolysin pores have been functionally incorporated into a tethered bilayer lipid membrane coupled to a gold electrode. The protein incorporation has been monitored optically and electrically and the influence of the molecular structure of the anchor lipids on the insertion properties has been investigated.     

An electrochemical approach tunes the electric property of benzoylferrocene-modified supported lipid membrane

A benzoylferrocene (BFc) supported 3-sn-phosphatidylcholine (PC) film electrode was prepared by casting the solution of BFc and PC in chloroform onto the surface of platinum (Pt). Cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) results showed that BFc, retained in the biological membrane, acted as a shuttle for electron transfer across the supported bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLMs). Doping of BFc increased membrane conductivity, while electrochemical oxidation of BFc greatly changed the membrane conductivity, the membrane impedance characterized by charge transfer resistance (R_ct) dramatically increased about 400 times (from 10.32 to 3919.67 kΩ). Interestingly, the electrochemical oxidized BFc buried in the membranes could be reduced by applying a low potential, and this led to recurrent of a conductive membrane. The conductivity of the s-BLMs could be controlled by the redox status of embedded BFc molecules. The approach provided a facile and novel way to electrochemically control the membrane conductance of s-BLMs by embedding BFc as a switchable redox mediator.     

直流偏压对于在玻碳电极上双层类脂膜成膜过程的影响

应用循环伏安法和电化学阻抗谱研究了直流偏压对卵磷脂在玻碳电极表面自组装成膜过程及其结构的影响.实验发现:无论在正偏压还是负偏压条件下,卵磷脂在玻碳电极上均可组装成膜.施加正偏压时,由于玻碳电极表面所带的正电荷与卵磷脂端基之间的静电作用,使得卵磷脂在电极表面倾向于形成双层的类脂膜,并在0.4V偏压下电极阻抗达到最大值.继续增大电极正向偏压,s-BLM缺陷增加,以至趋于被击穿.提出了适宜的等效电路,并据此非线性拟合电极过程,求得部分阻抗的模型参数.研究发现:膜电容和电荷传递电阻呈现良好的互补效应.     

Study on selectivity of permeating chiral complexes in bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs)

Electrical properties such as membrane potential (E_m) of planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs) are readily measured. Planar BLMs have been extensively used as models of biomembranes. In this paper we report BLMs formed in the solutions containing chiral complexes: d-K[Co(EDTA)], l-K[Co(EDTA)]; d-[Co(C₂O₄)(en)₂]I, and l-[Co(C₂O₄)(en)₂]I, whose E_m values display great differences, implying strong chiral selectivity. The permeability ratios of different chiral complexes calculated from E_m are the same as those obtained from human erythrocyte experiments. These results showed that chiral selectivity of cell uptake was mainly caused by the chirality of the membrane phospholipid itself. As a rapid and sensitive analytic tool, the BLM may be used to study permeating pathways and drug–membrane interactions. With further research, the BLM system may be developed into a useful method for drug screening.     

AFM-based force-clamp monitors lipid bilayer failure kinetics

The lipid bilayer rupture phenomenon is here explored by means of atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based force clamp, for the first time to our knowledge, to evaluate how lipid membranes respond when compressed under an external constant force, in the range of nanonewtons. Using this method, we were able to directly quantify the kinetics of the membrane rupture event and the associated energy barriers, for both single supported bilayers and multibilayers, in contradistinction to the classic studies performed at constant velocity. Moreover, the affected area of the membrane during the rupture process was calculated using an elastic deformation model. The elucidated information not only contributes to a better understanding of such relevant process, but also proves the suitability of AFM-based force clamp to study model structures as lipid bilayers. These findings on the kinetics of lipid bilayers rupture could be extended and applied to the study of other molecular thin films. Furthermore, systems of higher complexity such as models mimicking cell membranes could be studied by means of AFM-based force-clamp technique.