Induction of instability in water-in-oil-in-water double emulsions by freeze-thaw cycling

Individual water-in-oil-in-water (W1/O/W2) double-emulsion globules loaded with fluorescently labeled bovine serum albumin (FITC-BSA) were optically monitored within cylindrical capillaries during freeze-thaw cycling. Coalescence of internal aqueous droplets (W1) and external aqueous phase (W2), termed external coalescence, was not observed before or during freezing of the oil phase (O). On the other hand, this instability mechanism was readily promoted during thawing. This realization confirms the previously suggested potential of W1/O/W2 double emulsions to trigger release upon oil thawing and demonstrates that it is a direct result of globule breakage through external coalescence. The presented results also identified a threshold in the relative W1 droplet size above which instability occurred, while smaller droplets remained unperturbed and therefore indicate that optimization of the delivery can be achieved by tuning the size of W1 droplets. In addition, we propose a possible explanation for the occurrence of instability during oil thawing and its dependence on the size of W1 droplets. Because this alternative globule-breakage mechanism simply uses temperature increase (solid-to-liquid-phase transition) as external stimulus, W1/O/W2 double-emulsion delivery systems can be easily tailored by choosing an oil phase with the appropriate phase-transition temperature.     

Water mass transfer in W/O emulsions

Water transportation through the oil phase in W/O emulsions and in W1/O/W2 systems (W/O emulsion in contact with water) was examined. Substance diffusion through interfaces led to interface instability and spontaneous emulsification which caused nanodispersion formation. The photomicrographs of Pt/C replicas of emulsions showed the presence in the continuous oil phase a lot of nanodispersion droplets with a diameter in the range 17-25 nm. Diffusion coefficient (D) of water calculated on the base of Lifshiz-Slezov-Wagner (LSW) equation was about 15 times lower than the coefficients of molecular diffusion. Since such emulsions were extremely unstable toward coalescence, the growth of water droplets took place through as Ostwald ripening as coalescence. In three-phase W1/O/W2 systems diffusion of water, Rhodamine C, and ethanol was studied. D calculated on the base of the equation of nonstationary diffusion were approximately 1000 times lower than molecular ones. It was assumed, that nanodispersion droplets were more likely water carriers in investigated W/O emulsions stabilized by sorbitan monooleate.     

Multiple emulsion stability: pressure balance and interfacial film strength

The objective of this study was to investigate the significance of inner and outer phase pressure, as well as interfacial film strength on W/O/W multiple emulsion stability using microscopy and long-term stability tests. It was observed that immediately upon applying a coverslip to samples the multiple droplets deformed and there was coalescence of the inner aqueous droplets. Under certain conditions (such as lipophilic surfactant concentration and internal phase osmotic pressure) the destabilized multiple emulsions formed unique metastable structures that had a "dimpled" appearance. The formation of these metastable structures correlated with the real-time instability of the W/O/W multiple emulsions investigated. Multiple emulsion stability also correlated with the interfacial film strength (measured by interfacial elasticity) of the hydrophobic surfactant at the mineral oil/external continuous aqueous phase interface. The formation of the metastable dimpled structures and the long-term stability of the multiple emulsions were dependent on the osmotic pressure of the inner droplets and the Laplace curvature pressure as described by the Walstra Equation (P. Walstra, "Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology" (P. Becher, Ed.), Vol. 4. Dekker, New York, 1996). It appears that the effect of coverslip pressure on multiple emulsions may be useful as an accelerated stability testing method or for initial formulation screening.     

Stabilization of Water‐Soluble Antioxidant in Water‐in‐Oil‐in‐Water Double Emulsions

Abstract

In this study, we are introducing a method that can effectively stabilize antioxidants in water‐in‐oil‐in‐water (W/O/W) double emulsions. Preliminarily, stable W/O/W double emulsions were produced by manipulating the characteristics of internal aqueous phase via two‐stage emulsification, resulting consequently in the formation of fine internal water droplets in the dispersed oil droplets. From conductivity measurements that can determine the elution amount of internal aqueous phase, it was confirmed that the double emulsion stability could be improved by treating the internal aqueous phase with a hydroxypropyl‐beta‐cyclodextrin. In this study, kojic acid, 5‐hydroxy‐2‐(hydroxymethyl)‐4‐pyrone was selected as a model antioxidant. The stabilization of kojic acid was attempted by locating it in the internal water droplets of the stable W/O/W double emulsions. The stability of kojic acid in the double emulsion system could be maintained at 90% for 10 weeks at high temperature. We believe that these stable W/O/W double emulsions could be used meaningfully as a carrier for many unstable antioxidants.     

Interface composition of multiple emulsions: rheology as a probe

We have investigated the dynamic rheological properties of concentrated multiple emulsions to characterize their amphiphile composition at interfaces. Multiple emulsions (W1/O/W2) consist of water droplets (W1) dispersed into oil globules (O), which are redispersed in an external aqueous phase (W2). A small-molecule surfactant and an amphiphilic polymer were used to stabilize the inverse emulsion (W1 in oil globules) and the inverse emulsion (oil globules in W2), respectively. Rheological and interfacial tension measurements show that the polymeric surfactant adsorbed at the globule interface does not migrate to the droplet interfaces through the oil phase. This explains, at least partly, the stability improvement of multiple emulsions as polymeric surfactants are used instead of small-molecule surfactants.     

Polyols,High Pressure,and Refractive Indices Equalization for Improved Stability of W/O Emulsions for Food Applications

Mixtures of polyols (glycerol, propylene glycol, glucose) and water were emulsified in oil (isopropyl myristate (IPM), medium chain triglycerides (MCT), long chain triglycerides (LCT), and d-limonene) under elevated pressures and homogenization, in the presence of polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR), glycerol monooleate (GMO), and their mixture as emulsifiers to form water-in-oil emulsions. High pressures was applied to: a) the emulsion, b) the aqueous phase and c) the oil phase in the presence of the emulsifiers (PGPR and GMO). Under optimal pressure (2000 atms) applied to the ready-made emulsion or to the aqueous phase prior to its emulsification, and with optimal composition (30wt% polyol in the aqueous phase and MCT as the oil phase), the aqueous droplets were stable for months and submicron in size (0.1 μm). Moreover, due to equalization of the oil and the aqueous phases refractive indices, the emulsions were almost transparent. Pressure and polyols have synergistic effects on the emulsions stability. During preparation, surface tensions and interfacial tensions were dramatically reduced until an optimal water/polyols ratio was achieved, which allows rupturing of the droplets to submicronal size (0.1 μm) without recoalescence and fast diffusion to the interface. These unique W/O emulsions are suitable for preparing W/O/W double emulsions for sustained release of active materials for food applications.     

W/O/W多重乳液中水传递的控制

建立了简化的W/O/W(水/油/水)多重乳液乳珠模型——统计平均半径模型, 预测出当W/O/W多重乳液内水相水滴之间以及内外水相之间均达到水传递平衡时的内外水相中盐的浓度, 从而实现对水传递的控制, 以维持W/O/W多重乳液的稳定. 按理论预测制备出了不同稳定态的W/O/W多重乳液, 利用差分扫描量热仪(DSC)检测了多重乳液中水的传递过程, 确定体系在实验状态下的稳定程度, 实验结果与理论预测基本吻合.     

On the escape process during phase inversion of an emulsion

This paper deals with a phenomenon which plays an important role in the phase inversion process of emulsions. This process is governed by the interplay of coalescence of droplets, often leading to double emulsions, and the escape of those internal droplets. The latter process retards the inversion process. Coalescence has been the subject of many studies, contrary to the escape event. This paper addresses the escape process both theoretically and experimentally. The model developed analyses the rate of the escape of internal droplets from the mother droplet via a coalescence process, where the internal flow, as generated by the external flow, generates the viscous force for coalescence. Incomplete mixing in the droplet has been assumed. Experimental data on the escape rate of oil droplets from O/W/O emulsions have been analysed using a Computational Fluid Dynamics approach, where the model as indicated above has been incorporated. Experimental data and simulations compare very well. Data have been compared on varying the size of the inner droplets and the rotational speed of the vessel where the double emulsion has been formed and where the escape took place.     

Preparation of a stable double emulsion (W1/O/W2): role of the interfacial films on the stability of the system

This paper presents new protocols enabling preparation of W1/O/W2 double emulsions: one, using soybean oil as the O phase, that yields edible emulsions with industrial applications, and a second that yields emulsions with a previously unattainable concentration 15% (w/w) of surfactants in the external phase (the 15% target was chosen to meet the typical industry standard). Preparation of a stable W1/O emulsion was found to be critical for the stability of the system as a whole. Of the various low HLB primary surfactants tested, only cethyl dimethicone copolyol (Abil EM90), A-B-A block copolymer (Arlacel P135), and polyglycerol ester of ricinoleic acid (Grinstead PGR-90) yielded a stable W/O emulsion. Investigation of the surface properties of those surfactants using the monolayer technique found two significant similarities: (1) stable, compressible, and reversibly expandable monolayers; and (2) high elasticity and surface potential. The high degree of elasticity of the interfacial film between W1 and O makes it highly resilient under stress; its failure to break contributes to the stability of the emulsion. The high surface potential values observed suggest that the surfactant molecules lie flat at the O/W interfaces. In particular, in the case of PGR-90, the hydroxyl (-OH) groups on the fatty acid chains serve as anchors at the O/W interfaces and are responsible for the high surface potential. The long-term stability of the double emulsion requires a balance between the Laplace and osmotic pressures (between W1 droplets in O and between W1 droplets and the external aqueous phase W2). The presence of a thickener in the outer phase is necessary in order to reach a viscosity ratio (preferably approximately 1) between the W1/O and W2 phases, allowing dispersion of the viscous primary emulsion into the W2 aqueous phase. The thickener, which also serves as a dispersant and consequently prevents phase separation due to its thixotropic properties, must be compatible with the surfactants. Finally, the interactions between the low and high HLB emulsifiers at the O/W2 interface should not destabilize the films. It was observed that such destructive interaction for the system could be prevented by the use of two high HLB surfactants in the outer aqueous phase: an amphoteric surfactant, Betaine, and an anionic surfactant, sodium lauryl ether sulfate. The combination of such pairs of surfactants was found to contribute to the films' stability.     

Ethanol-in-oil emulsion (E/O) stabilized by polyglycerol polyricinoleate: A potential delivery system for ethanolic extract

This study evaluated how variations in polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR) concentration and ethanol dispersed phase content affect the stability of ethanol-in-oil (E/O) emulsions. Results indicate that the stable 10?wt% E/O emulsions can be produced using 2?wt% PGPR. Increasing the ethanol dispersed phased content at constant PGPR concentration caused instability in emulsion. These emulsions remained stable to droplet flocculation and coalescence in the presence of Centella asiatica ethanol extract. PGPR does not greatly decrease the interfacial tension of the ethanol–oil interface. However, it adsorbed at the interface and stabilized the ethanol droplets in the emulsion via steric mechanism.     

The effects of emulsifier type,phase ratio,and homogenization methods on stability of the double emulsion

The double emulsion technology has a potential effect on the development of diversity and quality of functional foods by means of decreasing oil or salt concentration, encapsulating and controlling release of valuable components. In this study, it was aimed to formulate stable double emulsions to be used in food systems. W1/O ratios of primary emulsions, stabilized by polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR), were designed as 2:8 and 4:6, and (W1/O)/W2 ratios of the double emulsions were used as 2:8 and 4:6. W/O/W phase ratios, homogenization methods applied to primary emulsion (high-speed homogenization, ultrasonic homogenization), and emulsifier types used in W2 phase [sodium caseinate (SC), xanthan gum, lecithin-whey protein concentrate] were used as independent variables. Particle size and distributions, stability, encapsulation efficiency (EE), rheological properties, long-term stability, and morphological properties of the double emulsions were investigated.

The double emulsions prepared with SC and (W1/O)/W2 ratio of 4:6, were found to have the higher stability values, higher apparent viscosity, and lower particle size. High-speed homogenization applied to primary emulsion reduced particle size of the double emulsion and increased apparent viscosity, but did not affect stability and EE of the double emulsions, significantly.     

Rheology of double emulsions

New equations for the viscosity of concentrated double emulsions of core-shell droplets are developed using a differential scheme. The equations developed in the paper predict the relative viscosity (eta(r)) of double emulsions to be a function of five variables: a/b (ratio of core drop radius to shell outer radius), lambda(21) (ratio of shell liquid viscosity to external continuous phase viscosity), lambda(32) (ratio of core liquid viscosity to shell liquid viscosity), phi(DE) (volume fraction of core-shell droplets in double emulsion), and phi(m)(DE) (the maximum packing volume fraction of un-deformed core-shell droplets in double emulsion). Two sets of experimental data are obtained on the rheology of O/W/O (oil-in-water-in-oil) double emulsions. The data are compared with the predictions of the proposed equations. The proposed equations describe the experimental viscosity data of double emulsions reasonably well.     

Phase inversion of the Pickering emulsions stabilized by plate-shaped clay particles

We investigated the phase inversion of Pickering emulsions stabilized by plate-shaped clay particles. Addition of water induced a phase inversion from a water-in-oil (W/O) emulsion to an oil-in-water (O/W) emulsion when the amount of the oil phase exceeded a limiting amount of oil absorption to solid particles. On the other hand, a phase inversion from a powdery state to an O/W emulsion state through an oil-separated state is observed when the amount of an oil phase is less than the limiting amount of the oil absorption. Interestingly, the oil separated is re-dispersed as emulsion droplets into the O/W emulsion phase. This type of phase inversion, which is a feature of the Pickering emulsions stabilized by the clay particles, is caused by a change in the aggregate structures of particles.     

Effect of Emulsifier Type on the Characterization of O/W Emulsions Using a Spectroscopy Technique

The droplet size distribution (DSD) of emulsions is the result of two competitive effects that take place during emulsification process, i.e., drop breakup and drop coalescence, and it is influenced by the formulation and composition variables, i.e., nature and amount of emulsifier, mixing characteristics, and emulsion preparation, all of which affect the emulsion stability. The aim of this study is to characterize oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions (droplet size and stability) in terms of surfactant concentration and surfactant composition (sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate (SDBS)/Tween 80 mixture). Ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) transmission spectroscopy has been applied to obtain droplet size and stability of the emulsions and the verification of emulsion stability with the relative cleared volume technique (time required for a certain amount of emulsion to separate as a cleared phase). It is demonstrated that the DSD of the emulsions is a function of the oil concentration and the surfactant composition with higher stability for emulsions prepared with higher SDBS ratio and lower relative cleared volume with the time. Results also show that smaller oil droplets are generated with increasing Tween 80 ratio and emulsifier concentration.     

Preparation characteristics of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions using microchannel emulsification

Microchannel (MC) emulsification is a novel technique for preparing monodispersed emulsions. This study demonstrates preparing water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) emulsions using MC emulsification. The W/O/W emulsions were prepared by a two-step emulsification process employing MC emulsification as the second step. We investigated the behavior of internal water droplets penetrating the MCs. Using decane, ethyl oleate, and medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) as oil phases, we observed successful MC emulsification and prepared monodispersed oil droplets that contained small water droplets. MC emulsification was possible using triolein as the oil phase, but polydispersed oil droplets were formed from some of the channels. No leakage of the internal water phase was observed during the MC emulsification process. The internal water droplets penetrated the MC without disruption, even though the internal water droplets were larger than the resulting W/O/W emulsion droplets. The W/O/W emulsion entrapment yield was measured fluorometrically and found to be 91%. The mild action of droplet formation based on spontaneous transformation led to a high entrapment yield during MC emulsification.     

Effects of a phospholipid cosurfactant on external coalescence in water-in-oil-in-water double-emulsion globules

The activated form of N-glutaryl-phosphatidylethanolamine (aNGPE) has been incorporated into water-in-oil-in-water (W₁/O/W₂) double-emulsion globules. Preparation of individual globules within a cylindrical capillary and video microscopy of their behavior enabled determination of the rate of coalescence of internal aqueous droplets (W₁) with the external aqueous phase (W₂), termed external coalescence. The presence of Tween 80 in the external phase at concentrations of 0.01 and 0.012 M effected such coalescence. The concentration of Span 80 in the oil phase exceeded that of aNGPE considerably, with the ratio of Span 80 to aNGPE molecules ranging from 60 to 1363. Despite the low relative concentration of aNGPE, external coalescence of the internal droplets was prolonged in globules containing this cosurfactant as compared to globules containing only Span 80. Increasing the amount of phospholipid in the oil phase did not significantly affect the rate of release, indicating that within our range of concentrations (22.0–91.3 μM) there was little variation in the amount of phospholipid adsorbing at the interface. These results indicate that, in addition to its suitable protein-binding functionality, aNGPE can prolong the release of internal droplets in a W₁/O/W₂ globule; its use as a cosurfactant shows potential benefits for drug-delivery applications.     

Fat crystals: A tool to inhibit molecular transport in W/O/W double emulsions

Water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) double emulsions are a promising technology for encapsulation applications of water soluble compounds with respect to functional food systems. Yet molecular transport through the oil phase is a well-known problem for liquid oil-based double emulsions. The influence of network crystallization in the oil phase of W/O/W globules was evaluated by NMR and laser light scattering experiments on both a liquid oil-based double emulsion and a solid fat-based double emulsion. Water transport was assessed by low-resolution NMR diffusometry and by an osmotically induced swelling or shrinking experiment, whereas manganese ion permeation was followed by means of T₂-relaxometry. The solid fat-based W/O/W globules contained a crystal network with about 80% solid fat. This W/O/W emulsion showed a reduced molecular water exchange and a slower manganese ion influx in the considered time frame, whereas its globule size remained stable under the applied osmotic gradients. The reduced permeability of the oil phase is assumed to be caused by the increased tortuosity of the diffusive path imposed by the crystal network. This solid network also provided mechanical strength to the W/O/W globules to counteract the applied osmotic forces.     

van der Waals interaction between internal aqueous droplets and the external aqueous phase in double emulsions

A mathematical model for analyzing the van der Waals interaction between the internal aqueous droplets (W(1)) and the external aqueous phase (W(2)) of double emulsions has been established. The effects of Hamaker constants of the materials forming the system, especially those of the two different adsorbed surfactant layers with uniform density (A(1) and A(2)), on the van der Waals interaction were investigated. The overall van der Waals interaction across the oil film is a combined result of four individual parts, that is, W(1)-W(2), A(1)-A(2), W(1)-A(1), and A(2)-W(2) van der Waals interaction, and it may be either attractive or repulsive depending on many factors. It was found that the overall van der Waals interaction is dominated by the W(1)-W(2) interaction at large separation distances between the W(1)/O and O/W(2) interfaces, while it is mostly determined by the A(1)-A(2) interaction when the two interfaces are extremely close. Specifically, in the cases when the value of the Hamaker constant of the oil phase is intermediate between those of W(1) and W(2) and there is a thick oil film separating the two interfaces, a weak repulsive overall van der Waals interaction will prevail. If the Hamaker constant of the oil phase is intermediate between those of A(1) and A(2) and the two interfaces are very close, the overall van der Waals interaction will be dominated by the strong repulsive A(1)-A(2) interaction. The repulsive van der Waals interaction at such cases helps stabilize the double emulsions.     

Steric repulsion between internal aqueous droplets and the external aqueous phase in double emulsions

A theoretical model for analyzing the steric repulsion energy between internal aqueous droplets and the external aqueous phase in double emulsions, which results from the steric interaction between the surfactant molecules adsorbed at the two interfaces, has been established. The steric interaction is dependent on the separation distance between the internal aqueous droplets and the external aqueous phase, the thicknesses of the two adsorbed surfactant layers, and the size of the internal aqueous droplets and the oil globules, all of which determine the extent of the compression of the adsorbed surfactant molecules. The thickness of each of the two surfactant layers have the same effect on the steric repulsion, and stronger steric interaction can be achieved with thicker adsorbed layers, which can effectively prevent coalescence between the internal aqueous droplets and the external aqueous phase. Increasing the internal aqueous droplet size can produce stronger steric repulsion; however, larger oil globules will weaken the steric repulsion, indicating that a more stable double-emulsion system can be achieved by preparing the system with smaller oil globules and larger internal aqueous droplets.     

Composition Ripening in Mixed Water-in-Oil Emulsions Stabilized with Solid Particles

Water and oil transport in emulsified systems is far from being elucidated. Calorimetric analysis has proved to be an appropriate technique to study composition ripening in mixed water in oil emulsions. In this article, the role of the stabilizing agent is studied and particular attention is given to emulsions stabilized solely with solid particles. Mixed emulsions are prepared by mixing two simple water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions, one with pure water droplets and one with droplets containing an aqueous urea solution. At different time intervals, a sample is introduced in a calorimeter cell and submitted to successive cooling and heating cycles. During the cooling phase, the aqueous internal phase solidifies at a temperature which depends on its composition. Just after the mixed emulsion was prepared, the calorimetric experiment identified two solidification peaks, one corresponding to pure water droplets, and the other one to urea solutions. After a long enough stabilization time, just one peak was observed, showing that the systems evolved toward one type of droplets characterized by a unique composition, due to water transfer between the two aqueous phases. The effect of emulsion stabilizing agent (particles or nonionic emulsifier) on the kinetics of water transfer was investigated.