Effective Born radii in the generalized Born approximation: the importance of being perfect

Generalized Born (GB) models provide, for many applications, an accurate and computationally facile estimate of the electrostatic contribution to aqueous solvation. The GB models involve two main types of approximations relative to the Poisson equation (PE) theory on which they are based. First, the self-energy contributions of individual atoms are estimated and expressed as "effective Born radii." Next, the atom-pair contributions are estimated by an analytical function f(GB) that depends upon the effective Born radii and interatomic distance of the atom pairs. Here, the relative impacts of these approximations are investigated by calculating "perfect" effective Born radii from PE theory, and enquiring as to how well the atom-pairwise energy terms from a GB model using these perfect radii in the standard f(GB) function duplicate the equivalent terms from PE theory. In tests on several biological macromolecules, the use of these perfect radii greatly increases the accuracy of the atom-pair terms; that is, the standard form of f(GB) performs quite well. The remaining small error has a systematic and a random component. The latter cannot be removed without significantly increasing the complexity of the GB model, but an alternative choice of f(GB) can reduce the systematic part. A molecular dynamics simulation using a perfect-radii GB model compares favorably with simulations using conventional GB, even though the radii remain fixed in the former. These results quantify, for the GB field, the importance of getting the effective Born radii right; indeed, with perfect radii, the GB model gives a very good approximation to the underlying PE theory for a variety of biomacromolecular types and conformations.     

Dependency of ligand free energy landscapes on charge parameters and solvent models

We performed replica-exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) simulations of six ligands to examine the dependency of their free energy landscapes on charge parameters and solvent models. Six different charge parameter sets for each ligand were first generated by RESP and AM1-BCC methods using three different conformations independently. RESP charges showed some conformational dependency. On the other hand, AM1-BCC charges did not show conformational dependency and well reproduced the overall trend of RESP charges. The free energy landscapes obtained from the REMD simulations of ligands in vacuum, Generalized-Born (GB), and TIP3P solutions were then analyzed. We found that even small charge differences can produce qualitatively different landscapes in vacuum condition, but the differences tend to be much smaller under GB and TIP3P conditions. The simulations in the GB model well reproduced the landscapes in the TIP3P model using only a fraction of the computational cost. The protein-bound ligand conformations were rarely the global minimum states, but similar conformations were found to exist in aqueous solution without proteins in regions close to the global minimum, local minimum or intermediate states.     

Solvent models for protein–ligand binding: Comparison of implicit solvent poisson and surface generalized born models with explicit solvent simulations

Solvent effects play a crucial role in mediating the interactions between proteins and their ligands. Implicit solvent models offer some advantages for modeling these interactions, but they have not been parameterized on such complex problems, and therefore, it is not clear how reliable they are. We have studied the binding of an octapeptide ligand to the murine MHC class I protein using both explicit solvent and implicit solvent models. The solvation free energy calculations are more than 10³ faster using the Surface Generalized Born implicit solvent model compared to FEP simulations with explicit solvent. For some of the electrostatic calculations needed to estimate the binding free energy, there is near quantitative agreement between the explicit and implicit solvent model results; overall, the qualitative trends in the binding predicted by the explicit solvent FEP simulations are reproduced by the implicit solvent model. With an appropriate choice of reference system based on the binding of the discharged ligand, electrostatic interactions are found to enhance the binding affinity because the favorable Coulomb interaction energy between the ligand and protein more than compensates for the unfavorable free energy cost of partially desolvating the ligand upon binding. Some of the effects of protein flexibility and thermal motions on charging the peptide in the solvated complex are also considered. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 22: 591–607, 2001     

Continuum solvation models in the linear interaction energy method

The linear interaction energy (LIE) method in combination with two different continuum solvent models has been applied to calculate protein-ligand binding free energies for a set of inhibitors against the malarial aspartic protease plasmepsin II. Ligand-water interaction energies are calculated from both Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) and Generalized Born (GB) continuum models using snapshots from explicit solvent simulations of the ligand and protein-ligand complex. These are compared to explicit solvent calculations, and we find close agreement between the explicit water and PB solvation models. The GB model overestimates the change in solvation energy, and this is caused by consistent underestimation of the effective Born radii in the protein-ligand complex. The explicit solvent LIE calculations and LIE-PB, with our standard parametrization, reproduce absolute experimental binding free energies with an average unsigned error of 0.5 and 0.7 kcal/mol, respectively. The LIE-GB method, however, requires a constant offset to approach the same level of accuracy.     

Accurate and efficient generalized born model based on solvent accessibility: derivation and application for LogP octanol/water prediction and flexible peptide docking

A novel method for fast and accurate evaluation of the generalized Born radii in macromolecular solvation electrostatics calculations is proposed, based on the solvent accessibility of the first two solvation layers around an atom. The reverse generalized Born radii calculated by the method have correlation coefficient of 98.7% and RMSD of 0.031 A(-1) with the values obtained using a precise but significantly slower numerical boundary element solution. The method is applied to derive an estimate of the free solvation energy difference between octanol and water and to predict LogP octanol-water. A nine-parameter model is optimized on an 81 compound training set and applied to predict LogP(ow) for an external evaluation set of 19 drug molecules with RMSD of 0.9. The new GB approximation is also tested in Monte Carlo docking simulations of the fully flexible p53 peptide fragment to MDM2. The best energy solution found in the simulations has RMSD of 2.8 A to the X-ray structure.     

The importance of excluded solvent volume effects in computing hydration free energies

Continuum dielectric methods such as the Born equation have been widely used to compute the electrostatic component of the solvation free energy, DeltaG(solv)(elec), because they do not need to include solvent molecules explicitly and are thus far less costly compared to molecular simulations. All of these methods can be derived from Gauss Law of Maxwell's equations, which yields an analytical solution for the solvation free energy, DeltaG(Born), when the solute is spherical. However, in Maxwell's equations, the solvent is assumed to be a structureless continuum, whereas in reality, the near-solute solvent molecules are highly structured unlike far-solute bulk solvent. Since we have recently reformulated Gauss Law of Maxwell's equations to incorporate the near-solute solvent structure by considering excluded solvent volume effects, we have used it in this work to derive an analytical solution for the hydration free energy of an ion. In contrast to continuum solvent models, which assume that the normalized induced solvent electric dipole density P(n) is constant, P(n) mimics that observed from simulations. The analytical formula for the ionic hydration free energy shows that the Born radius, which has been used as an adjustable parameter to fit experimental hydration free energies, is no longer ill defined but is related to the radius and polarizability of the water molecule, the hydration number, and the first peak position of the solute-solvent radial distribution function. The resulting DeltaG(solv)(elec) values are shown to be close to the respective experimental numbers.     

Calculation of absolute ligand binding free energy to a ribosome-targeting protein as a function of solvent model

A comparative analysis is provided of the effect of different solvent models on the calculation of a potential of mean force (PMF) for determining the absolute binding affinity of the small molecule inhibitor pteroic acid bound to ricin toxin A-chain (RTA). Solvent models include the distance-dependent dielectric constant, several different generalized Born (GB) approximations, and a hybrid explicit/GB-based implicit solvent model. We found that the simpler approximation of dielectric screening and a GB model, with Born radii fitted to a switching-window dielectric-boundary surface Poisson solvent model, severely overpredicted the binding affinity as compared to the experimental value, estimated to range from -4.4 to -6.0 kcal/mol. In contrast, GB models that are parametrized to fit the Lee-Richards molecular surface performed much better, predicting binding free energy within 1-3 kcal/mol of experimental estimates. However, the predicted free-energy profiles of these GB models displayed alternative binding modes not observed in the crystal structure. Finally, the most rigorous and computationally costly approach in this work, which used a hybrid explicit/implicit solvent model, correctly determined a binding funnel in the PMF near the crystallographic bound state and predicted an absolute binding affinity that was 2 kcal/mol more favorable than the estimated experimental binding affinity.     

Treecode-based generalized Born method

We have developed a treecode-based O(N log N) algorithm for the generalized Born (GB) implicit solvation model. Our treecode-based GB (tGB) is based on the GBr6 [J. Phys. Chem. B 111, 3055 (2007)], an analytical GB method with a pairwise descreening approximation for the R6 volume integral expression. The algorithm is composed of a cutoff scheme for the effective Born radii calculation, and a treecode implementation of the GB charge-charge pair interactions. Test results demonstrate that the tGB algorithm can reproduce the vdW surface based Poisson solvation energy with an average relative error less than 0.6% while providing an almost linear-scaling calculation for a representative set of 25 proteins with different sizes (from 2815 atoms to 65456 atoms). For a typical system of 10k atoms, the tGB calculation is three times faster than the direct summation as implemented in the original GBr6 model. Thus, our tGB method provides an efficient way for performing implicit solvent GB simulations of larger biomolecular systems at longer time scales.     

A new set of atomic radii for accurate estimation of solvation free energy by Poisson–Boltzmann solvent model

The Poisson–Boltzmann implicit solvent (PB) is widely used to estimate the solvation free energies of biomolecules in molecular simulations. An optimized set of atomic radii (PB radii) is an important parameter for PB calculations, which determines the distribution of dielectric constants around the solute. We here present new PB radii for the AMBER protein force field to accurately reproduce the solvation free energies obtained from explicit solvent simulations. The presented PB radii were optimized using results from explicit solvent simulations of the large systems. In addition, we discriminated PB radii for N‐ and C‐terminal residues from those for nonterminal residues. The performances using our PB radii showed high accuracy for the estimation of solvation free energies at the level of the molecular fragment. The obtained PB radii are effective for the detailed analysis of the solvation effects of biomolecules. © 2014 The Authors Journal of Computational Chemistry Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Coupled semiempirical quantum mechanics and molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations on the aqueous solvation free energies of ionized molecules

The aqueous solvation free energies of ionized molecules were computed using a coupled quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) model based on the AM1, MNDO, and PM3 semiempirical molecular orbital methods for the solute molecule and the TIP3P molecular mechanics model for liquid water. The present work is an extension of our model for neutral solutes where we assumed that the total free energy is the sum of components derived from the electrostatic/polarization terms in the Hamiltonian plus an empirical “nonpolar” term. The electrostatic/polarization contributions to the solvation free energies were computed using molecular dynamics (MD) simulation and thermodynamic integration techniques, while the nonpolar contributions were taken from the literature. The contribution to the electrostatic/polarization component of the free energy due to nonbonded interactions outside the cutoff radii used in the MD simulations was approximated by a Born solvation term. The experimental free energies were reproduced satisfactorily using variational parameters from the vdW terms as in the original model, in addition to a parameter from the one-electron integral terms. The new one-electron parameter was required to account for the short-range effects of overlapping atomic charge densities. The radial distribution functions obtained from the MD simulations showed the expected H-bonded structures between the ionized solute molecule and solvent molecules. We also obtained satisfactory results by neglecting both the empirical nonpolar term and the electronic polarization of the solute, i.e., by implementing a nonpolarization model. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 20: 1028–1038, 1999     

Influence of water-protein hydrogen bonding on the stability of Trp-cage miniprotein. A comparison between the TIP3P and TIP4P-Ew water models

We report extensive replica exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) simulations on the folding/unfolding equilibrium of Trp-cage miniprotein using the Amber ff99SB all atom forcefield and TIP3P and TIP4P-Ew explicit water solvent models. REMD simulation-lengths in the 500 ns to the microsecond regime per replica are required to adequately sample the folding/unfolding equilibrium. We observe that this equilibrium is significantly affected by the choice of the water model. Compared with experimental data, simulations using the TIP3P solvent describe the stability of the Trp-cage quite realistically, providing a melting point which is just a few Kelvins above the experimental transition temperature of 317 K. The TIP4P-Ew model shifts the equilibrium towards the unfolded state and lowers the free energy of unfolding by about 3 kJ mol(-1) at 280 K, demonstrating the need to fine-tune the protein-forcefield depending on the chosen water model. We report evidence that the main difference between the two water models is mostly due to the different solvation of polar groups of the peptide. The unfolded state of the Trp-cage is stabilized by an increasing number of hydrogen bonds, destabilizing the α-helical part of the molecule and opening the R-D salt bridge. By reweighting the strength of solvent-peptide hydrogen bonds by adding a hydrogen bond square well potential, we can fully recover the effect of the different water models and estimate the shift in population as due to a difference in hydrogen bond-strength of about 0.4 kJ mol(-1) per hydrogen bond.     

FACTS: Fast analytical continuum treatment of solvation

An efficient method for calculating the free energy of solvation of a (macro)molecule embedded in a continuum solvent is presented. It is based on the fully analytical evaluation of the volume and spatial symmetry of the solvent that is displaced from around a solute atom by its neighboring atoms. The two measures of solvent displacement are combined in empirical equations to approximate the atomic (or self) electrostatic solvation energy and the solvent accessible surface area. The former directly yields the effective Born radius, which is used in the generalized Born (GB) formula to calculate the solvent-screened electrostatic interaction energy. A comparison with finite-difference Poisson data shows that atomic solvation energies, pair interaction energies, and their sums are evaluated with a precision comparable to the most accurate GB implementations. Furthermore, solvation energies of a large set of protein conformations have an error of only 1.5%. The solvent accessible surface area is used to approximate the nonpolar contribution to solvation. The empirical approach, called FACTS (Fast Analytical Continuum Treatment of Solvation), is only four times slower than using the vacuum energy in molecular dynamics simulations of proteins. Notably, the folded state of structured peptides and proteins is stable at room temperature in 100-ns molecular dynamics simulations using FACTS and the CHARMM force field.     

Evaluation of Poisson solvation models using a hybrid explicit/implicit solvent method

Implicit solvent methods have become popular tools in the field of protein dynamics simulations, yet evaluation of their validity has been primarily limited to comparisons with experimental and theoretical data for small molecules. In this paper, we use a recently developed hybrid explicit/implicit solvent methodology to evaluate the accuracy of several Poisson-based implicit solvent models. Specifically, we focus on the calculation of electrostatic solvation free energies of various fixed conformations for two proteins. We show that, among various dielectric boundary definitions, the Lee-Richards molecular surface has the best agreement with hybrid solvent results. Furthermore, certain modifications of the molecular surface Poisson protocol provide varied results. For instance, simple modifications of atomic radii on charged residues generally improve absolute errors but do not significantly reduce relative errors among conformations. On the other hand, using a water-probe radius of 1.0 A, as opposed to the standard value of 1.4 A, to generate the molecular surface, moderately improves both absolute and relative results.     

An efficient hybrid explicit/implicit solvent method for biomolecular simulations

We present a new hybrid explicit/implicit solvent method for dynamics simulations of macromolecular systems. The method models explicitly the hydration of the solute by either a layer or sphere of water molecules, and the generalized Born (GB) theory is used to treat the bulk continuum solvent outside the explicit simulation volume. To reduce the computational cost, we implemented a multigrid method for evaluating the pairwise electrostatic and GB terms. It is shown that for typical ion and protein simulations our method achieves similar equilibrium and dynamical observables as the conventional particle mesh Ewald (PME) method. Simulation timings are reported, which indicate that the hybrid method is much faster than PME, primarily due to a significant reduction in the number of explicit water molecules required to model hydration effects.     

Competition between intramolecular hydrogen bonds and solvation in phosphorylated peptides: simulations with explicit and implicit solvent

The atomic-level mechanisms of protein regulation by post-translational phosphorylation remain poorly understood, except in a few well-studied systems. Molecular mechanics simulations can in principle be used to help understand and predict the effects of protein phosphorylation, but the accuracy of the results will of course depend on the quality of the force field parameters for the phosphorylated residues as well as the quality of the solvent model. The phosphorylated residues typically carry a -2 charge at physiological pH; however, the effects of phosphorylation can sometimes be mimicked by substituting Asp or Glu for the phosphorylated residue. Here we examine the suitability of explicit and implicit solvent models for simulating phospho-serine in both the -1 and -2 charge states. Specifically, we simulate a capped phosphorylated peptide, Ace-Gly-Ser-pSer-Ser-Nme, and compare the results to each other and to experimental observables from an NMR experiment. The first major conclusion is that explicit water models (TIP3P, TIP4P and SPC/E) and a Generalized Born implicit solvent model provide reasonable agreement with the experimental observables, given appropriate partial charges for the phosphate group. The Generalized Born results, however, show greater hydrogen bonding propensity than the explicit solvent results. Distance dependent dielectric treatments perform poorly. The second major conclusion is that many ensemble-averaged properties obtained for the phosphopeptide in the -1 and -2 charge states are strikingly similar; the -1 species has a slightly higher propensity to form internal hydrogen bonds. All of the results can be rationalized by quantifying the strength of the P-O/H-N hydrogen bond, which depends on a sensitive balance between strongly favorable charge/dipole and dipole/dipole interactions and strongly unfavorable desolvation.     

Comparison of solvation-effect methods for the simulation of peptide interactions with a hydrophobic surface

In this study we investigated the interaction behavior between thirteen different small peptides and a hydrophobic surface using three progressively more complex methods of representing solvation effects: a united-atom implicit solvation method [CHARMM 19 force field (C19) with Analytical Continuum Electrostatics (ACE)], an all-atom implicit solvation method (C22 with GBMV), and an all-atom explicit solvation method (C22 with TIP3P). The adsorption behavior of each peptide was characterized by the calculation of the potential of mean force as a function of peptide-surface separation distance. The results from the C22/TIP3P model suggest that hydrophobic peptides exhibit relatively strong adsorption behavior, polar and positively-charged peptides exhibit negligible to relatively weak favorable interactions with the surface, and negatively-charged peptides strongly resist adsorption. Compared to the TIP3P model, the ACE and GBMV implicit solvent models predict much stronger attractions for the hydrophobic peptides as well as stronger repulsions for the negatively-charged peptides on the CH(3)-SAM surface. These comparisons provide a basis from which each of these implicit solvation methods may be reparameterized to provide closer agreement with explicitly represented solvation in simulations of peptide and protein adsorption to functionalized surfaces.     

New analytic approximation to the standard molecular volume definition and its application to generalized Born calculations

In a recent article (Lee, M. S.; Salsbury, F. R. Jr.; Brooks, C. L., III. J Chem Phys 2002, 116, 10606), we demonstrated that generalized Born (GB) theory provides a good approximation to Poisson electrostatic solvation energy calculations if one uses the same definitions of molecular volume for each. In this work, we present a new and improved analytic method for reproducing the Lee-Richards molecular volume, which is the most common volume definition for Poisson calculations. Overall, 1% errors are achieved for absolute solvation energies of a large set of proteins and relative solvation energies of protein conformations. We also introduce an accurate SASA approximation that uses the same machinery employed by our GB method and requires a small addition of computational cost. The combined methodology is shown to yield an efficient and accurate implicit solvent representation for simulations of biopolymers.