Extended surface chirality for enantiospecific adsorption

A rapid development of nanotechnology opens up a way for the fabrication of solid surfaces containing unique adsorption properties. In this article, we present the concept of a chiral nanostructured surface as a potential environment for the separation of chiral molecules. In particular, we focus on the effect of size and shape of the adsorbing molecules on the effectiveness of their separation on a surface with a special distribution of active sites. The Monte Carlo simulation method was used to study enantiospecific adsorption of model chiral molecules that differ in molecular footprint and adsorption energy. It was demonstrated that manipulating the footprint offers many possibilities for tuning the preference of the surface for adsorption of a selected enantiomer. One interesting finding was that subtle differences in the interaction pattern of the molecule with the chiral surface can lead to a reversal of enantioselectivity. The results of this work highlight the role of extended surface chirality in enantiospecific adsorption of enantiomers. They also suggest that the proposed mechanism of chiral selection can be a realistic alternative to those inherent in conventional enantioselective adsorbents.     

Spontaneous segregation on a hybrid chiral surface

Segregation of enantiomers in two-dimensional adsorbed layers is a process that is usually controlled by anisotropic directional interactions between adsorbed molecules. In this contribution, we propose a simple theoretical model in which the chiral segregation occurs even though the lateral interactions are neglected. In particular, we consider a solid surface composed of two domains with different patterns of active sites being mirror images of each other. The domains of opposite handedness represent crystal facets of a composite chiral material which are adjoined to form a heterochiral adsorbing surface. To explore equilibrium properties of the system, we use Canonical Ensemble Monte Carlo method for a square lattice. The influence of factors such as energetic properties of the surface and density of the adsorbed layer on the extent of separation is examined. The obtained results indicate that effective two-dimensional separation on the hybrid chiral surface assumed in our model can be achieved only at sufficiently low adsorbate densities. The results also suggest that the segregation on the hybrid surface would be a promising method of enantiodiscrimination for those chiral molecules which do not exhibit strong lateral interactions.     

Nanosheet-enhanced enantioselectivity in the vanadium-catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation of allylic alcohols

The use of suitable chiral ligands is an efficient means of producing highly enantioselective transition-metal catalysts. Herein, we report a facile, economic, and effective strategy for the design of chiral ligands that demonstrate enhanced enantioselectivity and catalytic efficacy. Our simple strategy employs naturally occurring or synthetic inorganic nanosheets as huge and rigid planar substituents for, but not limited to, naturally available α-amino-acid ligands; these ligands were successfully used in the vanadium-catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation of allylic alcohols. The crucial role of the inorganic nanosheets as planar substituents in improving the enantioselectivity of the reaction was clearly revealed by relating the observed enantiomeric excess with the distribution of the catalytic centers and the accessibility of the substrate molecules to the catalytic sites. DFT calculations indicated that the LDH layer improved the enantioselectivity by influencing the formation and stability of the catalytic transition states, both in terms of steric resistance and H-bonding interactions.     

Chiral nanopatterned surfaces as versatile enantiospecific adsorbents: a Monte Carlo model

This paper deals with the application of the Monte Carlo simulation method for modeling of adsorption of chiral molecules on a planar surface patterned with active binding sites. The enantiomers are assumed to be rigid chains composed of four identical segments, each occupying one binding site. The energy of interaction between a segment and a binding site is characterized by epsilon(a) and epsilon(b) depending whether the site is active or it is inert. We demonstrate that epsilon(a)>epsilon(b) imposed in our previous work [J. Chem. Phys. 126, 144709 (2007)] is not a necessary condition for the separation of enantiomers form their racemate. The obtained results suggest that the major source of enantioselectivity of the surface lies in its geometrical properties. The active adsorption sites which form the chiral pattern do not have to interact stronger with the adsorbing molecules to ensure enantioseparation. In this context, the proposed chiral surface offers more flexibility in selection of the energetic properties of the binding sites. This, in practice, means wider possibilities of manipulating chemical composition of the surface.     

Functionalization of cellulose dialysis membranes for chiral separation using beta-cyclodextrin immobilization

A membrane-based chiral separation system for the separation of racemic tryptophan solutions is developed by the covalently binding beta-cyclodextrin onto the surface of commercial cellulose membranes. The immobilization process is monitored by XPS. AFM demonstrates the evolutionary transition of membrane surface morphology before and after the CD immobilization. Due to their different complexation with immobilized CD, dialysis transport experiments show d-tryptophan preferential permeability through the immobilized CD membranes, and the enantioselectivity is 1.10. A model based on the existence of a thin chiral solution layer of amino acid at the interface between the feed solution and the membrane has been proposed. This chiral separation model has been verified using the chiral separation results of racemic amino acids and binding constants of amino acids with CD. The effect of membrane's pore size on enantioselectivity has also been investigated. The immobilized CD membrane, having MWCO 1000, exhibits the highest enantioselectivity to the racemic tryptophan solution.     

Nanosheet‐Enhanced Enantioselectivity in the Vanadium‐Catalyzed Asymmetric Epoxidation of Allylic Alcohols

The use of suitable chiral ligands is an efficient means of producing highly enantioselective transition‐metal catalysts. Herein, we report a facile, economic, and effective strategy for the design of chiral ligands that demonstrate enhanced enantioselectivity and catalytic efficacy. Our simple strategy employs naturally occurring or synthetic inorganic nanosheets as huge and rigid planar substituents for, but not limited to, naturally available α‐amino‐acid ligands; these ligands were successfully used in the vanadium‐catalyzed asymmetric epoxidation of allylic alcohols. The crucial role of the inorganic nanosheets as planar substituents in improving the enantioselectivity of the reaction was clearly revealed by relating the observed enantiomeric excess with the distribution of the catalytic centers and the accessibility of the substrate molecules to the catalytic sites. DFT calculations indicated that the LDH layer improved the enantioselectivity by influencing the formation and stability of the catalytic transition states, both in terms of steric resistance and H‐bonding interactions.     

Requirements for the formation of a chiral template

The chemisorptive enantioselectivity of propylene oxide is examined on Pd(111) surfaces templated by chiral 2-methylbutanoate and 2-aminobutanoate species. It has been found previously that chiral propylene oxide is chemisorbed enantiospecifically onto Pd(111) surfaces modified by either (R)- or (S)-2-butoxide. The enantiomeric excess (ee) varied with template coverage, reaching a maximum of approximately 31%. Templating the surface using 2-methylbutanoate, where the chiral center is identical to that in the 2-butoxide species, but is now anchored to the surface by a carboxylate rather than an alkoxide linkage, shows no enantiospecificity. The enantioselectivity is restored when the methyl group is replaced by an amine group, where a maximum ee value of approximately 27% is found. DFT calculations and infrared measurements suggest that the structures of the butyl group on the surface are similar for both 2-butoxide and 2-methylbutanoate species, implying that gross conformational changes are not responsible for differences in chemisorptive enantioselectivity. There is no clear correlation between the location of the chiral center and enantioselectivity, suggesting that differences in the template adsorption site are also not responsible for the lack of enantioselectivity. It is proposed that the 2-butyl group in 2-methylbutanoate species is less rigidly bonded to the surface than that in 2-butoxides, allowing the chiral center to rotate azimuthally. It is postulated that the role of the amino group in 2-aminobutanoate species is to anchor the chiral group to the surface to inhibit azimuthal rotation.     

Gas-chromatographic separation of enantiomers of 2-chlorobutane and 2-bromobutane on a cyanuric acid-modified Carboblack C adsorbent

The enantiomers of 2-chlorobutane and 2-bromobutane were separated by gas chromatography on a Carboblack C adsorbent modified by 10% cyanuric acid. Upon thorough mechanical stirring of a solution, cyanuric acid was shown to form chiral supramolecular structures on the surface of adsorbent particles analogously to the Kondepudi formation of chiral crystals of achiral molecules. The enantiomers of 2-bromobutane and 2-chlorobutane were found to undergo, respectively, complete and partial separation on the cyanuric acid-modified Carboblack C adsorbent. The separation of enantiomers is due to a high enantioselectivity of the modified adsorbent. The analysis of thermodynamic functions of adsorption showed that the differences in specific retention volumes of enantiomers are caused by the fact that one of enantiomers is adsorbed predominantly within the cavity of the supramolecular structure of cyanuric acid and another one is adsorbed on its surface. Separation on the proposed chiral stationary phase is characterized by the relative standard deviation of retention volumes no more than 7%.     

Catalytic Enantioselective Simultaneous Control of Axial Chirality and Central Chirality in Allenes

Chiral molecules, which may contain one or more different type(s) of stereocentres, such as central, axial, planar, and helical chiralities, etc., are indispensable in chemistry, pharmaceutical industry, and life science. Despite many advances for the preparation of chiral molecules usually with a single type of chirality have been realized, simultaneous construction of different types of chiralities is still a significant challenge. Here, we wish to report a protocol for preparation of chiral allenes with both central and axial chiralities via a catalytic asymmetric allenylation of different biologically or synthetically useful fluorinated or non‐fluorinated nucleophiles with readily available racemic allenes by using a single chiral ligand. An echoing between the central chirality and axial chirality for the enantioselectivity was observed. This strategy provides a general and practical approach to functionalized optically active allenes bearing both central and axial chiralities with an excellent enantioselectivity under mild conditions.     

Acetylation of beta-cyclodextrin surface-functionalized cellulose dialysis membranes with enhanced chiral separation

The enhanced enantiomeric separation of racemic phenylalanine solution has been demonstrated by the membrane-based chiral resolution method using an acetylated beta-cyclodextrin-immobilized cellulose dialysis membrane. Beta-cyclodextrin (CD) was first immobilized onto the surface of commercial cellulose dialysis membranes, followed by the acetylation reaction through the treatment of the membranes with acetic anhydride to form the chiral selective acetylated beta-cyclodextrin-immobilized cellulose dialysis membrane. The acetylated CD-immobilized membrane exhibits enantioselectivity in the range of 1.26-1.33 depending on the acetylation time. The improvement in enantioselectivity after acetylation was mainly attributed to the better discrimination ability of acetylated CD and the decrease in membrane pore size. Molecular modeling simulations indicate that the acetylation of hydroxyl groups would result in a CD conformation with torus distortions and would create higher steric hindrance for penetrants. As a result, compared to the original CD, the acetylated CD may have less effective binding but better discrimination of enantiomers. The energy drop is only 3 kcal/mol between different enantiomers before and after the binding of phenylalanine with an unmodified CD. The energy drop increases to 10 kcal/mol if acetylated CD is employed as the chiral selector, showing stronger characteristics for chiral selection.     

Enantioselectivity of Photochemical Reactions within Polymer Microcapsules

Polymer microcapsule was employed as a reactionmedium to achieve enantioselectivity in photochemical reduction of phenyl cyclohexyl ketone and photoelectrocycliztion of tropolone methyl ether under the influence of various chiral inductors.In all cases,low but evident enantioselectivity was observed.The poor enantioselectivity is probably due to the facts that not all the capsules include simultaneously both the chiral inductor and the reactant molecules,and the wall of the microcapsule is not rigid enough to hold the reactant and the chiral inductor molecules in close contact.     

MALDI coupled to modified traveling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry for fast enantiomeric determination

In this work, the use of MALDI traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry‐mass spectrometry (MALDI‐TWIMS‐MS) for stereoselective structural analysis of direct cleavage and identification of 2‐substituted piperidines obtained through solid‐phase asymmetric synthesis by using heterogeneous 8‐phenylmenthyl‐based chiral auxiliary resins. A strategy for gas‐phase chiral and structural characterization of small molecular weight molecules by using MALDI‐IMS‐MS technique is discussed. Because both MALDI and IMS do not directly offer chiral resolution, an easy methodology by adding a chiral phase is described to carry out in situ online ion/molecule complexation with different chiral analytes inside the mass spectrometer. Piperidine enantiomers were resolved, and separation obtained shows dependence of surface areas. To corroborate this assumption and elucidate the separation mechanism to accomplish an analytical technique by which fast determination of the chirality of molecules may be determined for a wide range organic compound applications, it was performed DFT calculations to determine the cross‐sectional areas of proton‐bound dimer complexes. Drift times are affected by cross‐sectional areas, correlating bigger times with bigger molecular volumes during the ion mobility experiments of proton‐bound dimer complexes.     

Monte Carlo modeling of chiral adsorption on nanostructured chiral surfaces and slit pores

Adsorptive separation of chiral molecules is a powerful technique that has long been used in the chemical and pharmaceutical industries. An important challenge in this field is to design and optimize new adsorbents to provide selective discrimination of enantiomers. In this article, we introduce an off-lattice model of chiral adsorption on nanostructured surfaces and slit pores with the aim of predicting their enantioslective properties. The concept presented here involves finding the optimal chiral pattern of active sites on the pore walls that maximizes the difference between the binding energies of the enantiomers. Our initial effort focuses on chiral molecules that do not have specific interactions with the pore surface. One candidate meeting this requirement is 1,2-dimethylcyclopropane (DMCP), a chiral hydrocarbon whose interaction with a model pore surface was described using the Lennard-Jones potential. To model the adsorption of DMCP, we used the Monte Carlo simulation method. It was demonstrated that the separation of the enantiomers of DMCP is hardly obtainable because of the smoothness of the potential energy surface for molecules physisorbed in the pore. However, the simulated results allowed the identification of key factors that influence the binding of the enantiomers of DMCP to the pore walls with a special distribution of active sites. This information will be useful in future considerations of the adsorption of more complex chiral molecules.     

Recent innovations in enantiomer separation by electrochromatography utilizing modified cyclodextrins as stationary phases.

Enantiomer separation by electrochromatography employing modified cyclodextrins as stationary phases is performed in two ways. (i) Polysiloxane-linked permethylated beta-cyclodextrin (Chirasil-Dex 1) or related selectors are coated and immobilized onto the inner surface of a capillary column. Enantiomer separation is performed in the open tube and the method is referred to as open-tubular capillary electrochromatography (o-CEC). (ii) Silica-linked native beta-cyclodextrin, permethylated beta-cyclodextrin (Chira-Dex 2) or hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin are filled into a capillary column and the bed is secured by two frits. Enantiomer separation is performed in a packed column and the method is referred to as packed capillary electrochromatography (p-CEC). In a unified instrumental approach, method (i) as well as method (ii) can be operated both in the electro- and pressure-driven modes (o-CEC vs. open-tubular liquid chromatography (o-LC) and p-CEC vs. p-LC). It is demonstrated that the electro-driven variant affords higher efficiencies at comparable elution times. Employing a single open-tubular column coated with Chirasil-Dex 1, a unified enantioselective approach can be realized in which the same selectand is separated using all existing chromatographic modes for enantiomers, i.e., gas chromatography (GC), super-critical fluid chromatography (SFC), o-LC and o-CEC. As the chiral selector is utilized as a stationary phase, an additional chiral selector may be added to the mobile phase. In the resulting dual chiral recognition systems, enhancement of enantioselectivity (matched case) or compensation of enantioselectivity (mismatched case) may be observed. The overall enantioselectivity is dependent on the sense of enantioselectivity of the selectors chosen and their influence on the electrophoretic and electroosmotic migration of the enantiomers of a selectand.     

A possible mechanism for enantioselectivity in the chiral epoxidation of olefins with

The origin of enantioselectivity in the Jacobsen-Katsuki reaction has been investigated by applying density functional calculations in combination with molecular mechanics methodologies. The calculations suggest that a high enantiomeric excess is connected to three specific features: 1) a chiral diimine bridge, which induces folding of the salen ligand(H2salen = bis(salicylidene)ethylenediamine), and hence the formation of a chiral pocket; 2) bulky groups at the 3,3'-positions of the salen ligand, which cause a preferential approach from the side of the aromatic rings; and 3) pi conjugation of the olefinic double bond, which confers regioselectivity and, consequently, enantioselectivity. In combination with experimental studies, the model also provides a rationale for the decrease in ee values when one of these components is missing.     

Chemically modified chiral monolithic silica column prepared by a sol-gel process for enantiomeric separation by micro high-performance liquid chromatography

In this work a new type of chiral monolith silica column was developed for the chiral separation by micro high-performance liquid chromatography (micro-HPLC). The chiral monolith column with a continuous skeleton and a large through-pore structure was prepared inside a capillary of 100 microm I.D. by a sol-gel process, and chemically modified with chiral selectors, such as L-phenylalaninamide, L-alaninamide and L-prolinamide, on the surface of the monolithic silica column. Based on the principle of ligand exchange, these chiral monolithic columns were successfully used for the separation of dansyl amino acid enantiomers, as well as hydroxy acid enantiomers by micro-HPLC. The chromatographic conditions, the enantioselectivity and the performance of columns are discussed.     

High-performance liquid chromatographic separation of imidazolinone herbicide enantiomers and their methyl derivatives on polysaccharide-coated chiral stationary phases

Many chiral pesticides exhibit enantioselectivity in biotransformation and ecotoxicity in the environment. A significant class of chiral pesticides is imidazolinone herbicides, of which enantioselectivity has not been well studied. Development of efficient chiral separation methods is the first step for allowing characterization of enantioselectivity in environmental processes. In this study, we attempted to resolve enantiomers of imidazolinone herbicides using reversed-phase and normal-phase high-performance liquid chromatography with polysaccharide-type chiral columns. Enantiomers of imazethapyr, imazaquin, and imazamox were separated on a Chiralcel OD-R column using 50mM phosphate buffer-acetonitrile as mobile phase. Enantiomers of imazapyr, imazapic, imazethapyr, imazamox and imazaquin were resolved on a Chiralcel OJ column using n-hexane (0.1% trifluoroacetic acid)-alcohol as mobile phase. The enantiomers of five methyl derivatives of imidazolinone herbicides were also resolved on the Chiralcel OJ column. The Deltak' values revealed a structure-enantioselectivity relationship for the separation behaviors of the enantiomers on the OJ column. The described method was successfully applied for chiral analysis of two imidazolinone herbicides (imazapyr and imazaquin) in spiked soil samples.     

Synthesis and Chiral Recognition of Novel Chiral Macrocyclic Dioxopolyamines Derived from L-Proline

Recently, much concentration has been focused on chiral macrocyclic amides that bear the dual features of macrocyclic polyamines and oligopeptides, which can act as both hydrogen bond acceptors and donors and can form complexes with cation, anion or neutral molecules, so as to have potential applications for enantiomeric recognition and enantiomeric separation. In light that the more rigid the macrocyclic molecule, the better the enantiomeric recognition, and macrocyclic receptors possessing C2 symmetry usually show higher enantioselectivity than those of C1 symmetry, we chose L-proline, which possesses a unique and rigid pyrrolidinyl group, as starting material to synthesize a new class of novel chiral macrocyclic dioxopolyamines of C2 symmetry.     

Amino Acid Ionic Liquids as Chiral Ligands in Ligand‐Exchange Chiral Separations

Recently, amino acid ionic liquids (AAILs) have attracted much research interest. In this paper, we present the first application of AAILs in chiral separation based on the chiral ligand exchange principle. By using 1‐alkyl‐3‐methylimidazolium L ‐proline (L ‐Pro) as a chiral ligand coordinated with copper(II), four pairs of underivatized amino acid enantiomers—dl ‐phenylalanine (dl ‐Phe), dl ‐histidine (dl ‐His), dl ‐tryptophane (dl ‐Trp), and dl ‐tyrosine (dl ‐Tyr)—were successfully separated in two major chiral separation techniques, HPLC and capillary electrophoresis (CE), with higher enantioselectivity than conventionally used amino acid ligands (resolution (R_s)=3.26–10.81 for HPLC; R_s=1.34–4.27 for CE). Interestingly, increasing the alkyl chain length of the AAIL cation remarkably enhanced the enantioselectivity. It was inferred that the alkylmethylimidazolium cations and L ‐Pro form ion pairs on the surface of the stationary phase or on the inner surface of the capillary. The ternary copper complexes with L ‐Pro are consequently attached to the support surface, thus inducing an ion‐exchange type of retention for the dl ‐enantiomers. Therefore, the AAIL cation plays an essential role in the separation. This work demonstrates that AAILs are good alternatives to conventional amino acid ligands for ligand‐exchange‐based chiral separation. It also reveals the tremendous application potential of this new type of task‐specific ILs.     

Relationship between enantioselectivity and solute structure on a chiral α1-acid glycoprotein column

Summary The relationship between the enantioselectivity, the retention and the solute structure for N-aminoalkylsuccinimides and 1-alkyl-2′,6′-pipecoloxylidides have been studied using α₁-acid glycoprotein as the chiral stationary phase. Both the enantioselectivity and the retention are highly affected by small changes of the solute structure in series of homologous compounds. For example, increasing the steric bulk on a basic aliphatic nitrogen improves the enantioselectivity. It was also demonstrated for the succinimides that the magnitude of the separation factor was highly affected by the distance between the basic nitrogen and the chiral center. The chiral selectivity was not lost for the succinimides despite the fact that the basic nitrogen was separated from the chiral center with seven atoms, which may be an effect of that these compounds contain more than one strong hydrogen bonding group. Substitution in the aromatic ring of the succinimides also influences both the retention and the chiral selectivity to a large extent. Electronegative substituents can increase the separation factor but introduction of an alkyl or an alkoxy group in the aromatic ring decreases the enantioselectivity for the succinimides.