Tryptic peptide analysis of protein binders in works of art by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

A proteomics approach was used for the identification of protein binders in historical paints: the proteins were digested enzymatically into peptides using trypsin before being separated and detected by high performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionisation tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-ESI-MS/MS). Mascot (Matrix Science) was used to analyse the resulting data and for protein identification. In contrast to amino acid analysis, amino acid sequences could be studied that retain much more information about the proteins. The best extraction strategy was selected based on the number of peptides that were identified in the protein content of paint replicas using different methods. The influence of pigments on the extraction method was studied and the analytical characteristics of the selected method were determined. Finally this method was applied to historical paint microsamples on the anonymous early 15th century panel painting Crucifixion with St Catherine and St Barbara (Calvary of the Tanners), the St Catherine Altarpiece by Joes Beyaert (c. 1479) and two paintings by Pieter Brueghel the Younger (1617-1628).     

Effective protein extraction protocol for proteomics studies of Jerusalem artichoke leaves

Protein extraction is a crucial step for proteomics studies. To establish an effective protein extraction protocol suitable for two‐dimensional electrophoresis (2DE) analysis in Jerusalem artichoke (Helianthus tuberosus L.), three different protein extraction methods—trichloroacetic acid/acetone, Mg/NP‐40, and phenol/ammonium acetate—were evaluated using Jerusalem artichoke leaves as source materials. Of the three methods, trichloroacetic acid/acetone yielded the best protein separation pattern and highest number of protein spots in 2DE analysis. Proteins highly abundant in leaves, such as Rubisco, are typically problematic during leaf 2DE analysis, however, and this disadvantage was evident using trichloroacetic acid/acetone. To reduce the influence of abundant proteins on the detection of low‐abundance proteins, we optimized the trichloroacetic acid/acetone method by incorporating a PEG fractionation approach. After optimization, 363 additional (36.2%) protein spots were detected on the 2DE gel. Our results suggest that trichloroacetic acid/acetone method is a better protein extraction technique than Mg/NP‐40 and phenol/ammonium acetate in Jerusalem artichoke leaf 2DE analysis, and that trichloroacetic acid/acetone method combined with PEG fractionation procedure is the most effective approach for leaf 2DE analysis of Jerusalem artichoke.     

Coupling of CE‐MS for protein and peptide analysis

The review is focused on the latest developments in the analysis of proteins and peptides by capillary electrophoresis techniques coupled to mass spectrometry. First, the methodology and instrumentation are overviewed. In this section, recent progress in capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry interfaces and capillary electrophoresis with matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization is mentioned, as well as separation tasks. The second part is devoted to applications—mainly bottom‐up and top‐down proteomics. It is obvious that capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry methods are well suited for peptide and protein analysis (proteomic research) and it is described how these techniques are complementary and not competitive with the often used liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry methods.     

Comprehensive chromatographic separations in proteomics

In such a complicated field as proteomic analysis, scientists are more and more challenged in implementing separation systems capable to provide enhanced separation power, as well as sensitivity of detection for adequate identification and, to a lesser extent, quantification of the separated compounds. To address such issues, several combinations of different separation modes have been investigated in comprehensive liquid chromatographic platforms, in which the entire sample eluted from the first dimension is subjected to a secondary chromatographic separation. The different applications exploited for comprehensive LC analysis of intact or digested proteins are the focus of this review, in which advantages and disadvantages of the different columns combinations, interfaces, and operating modes are pointed out. The combination with mass spectrometry as part of the total system is stressed, and illustrated in more detail. Theoretical concerns and practical requirements will be briefly discussed, as well.     

Online hyphenation of size-exclusion chromatography and gas-phase electrophoresis facilitates the characterization of protein aggregates

Gas-phase electrophoresis yields size distributions of polydisperse, aerosolized analytes based on electrophoretic principles. Nanometer-sized, surface-dry, single-charged particles are separated in a high laminar sheath flow of particle-free air and an orthogonal tunable electric field. Additionally, nano Electrospray Gas-Phase Electrophoretic Mobility Molecular Analyzer (nES GEMMA) data are particle-number based. Therefore, small particles can be detected next to larger ones without a bias, for example, native proteins next to their aggregates. Analyte transition from the liquid to the gas phase is a method inherent prerequisite. In this context, nonvolatile sample buffers influence results. In the worst case, the (bio-)nanoparticle signal is lost due to an increased baseline and unspecific clustering of nonvolatile components. We present a novel online hyphenation of liquid chromatography and gas-phase electrophoresis, coupling a size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) column to an advanced nES GEMMA. Via this novel approach, it is possible to (i) separate analyte multimers already present in liquid phase from aggregates formed during the nES process, (ii) differentiate liquid phase and spray-induced multimers, and (iii) to remove nonvolatile buffer components online before SEC–nES GEMMA analysis. Due to these findings, SEC–nES GEMMA has the high potential to help to understand aggregation processes in biological buffers adding the benefit of actual size determination for noncovalent assemblies formed in solution. As detection and characterization of protein aggregation in large-scale pharmaceutical production or sizing of noncovalently bound proteins are findings directly related to technologically and biologically relevant situations, we proposed the presented method to be a valuable addition to LC-MS approaches.     

A novel approach for protein identification from complex cell proteome using modified peptide mass fingerprinting algorithm

A unique peptide based search algorithm for identification of protein mixture using PMF is proposed. The proposed search algorithm utilizes binary search and heapsort programs to generate frequency chart depicting the unique peptides corresponding to all proteins in a proteome. The use of binary search program significantly reduces the time for frequency chart preparation to ～2 s for a proteome comprising ～23 000 proteins. The algorithm was applied to a three‐protein mixture identification, host cell protein (HCP) analysis, and a simulation‐generated data set. It was found that the algorithm could identify at least one unique peptide of a protein even in the presence of fourfold higher concentration of another protein. In addition, two HCPs that are known to be difficult to remove were missed by MS/MS approach and were exclusively identified using the presented algorithm. Thus, the proposed algorithm when used along with standard proteomic approaches present avenues for enhanced protein identification efficiency, particularly for applications such as HCP analysis in biopharmaceutical research, where identification of low‐abundance proteins are generally not achieved due to dynamic range limitations between the target product and HCPs.     

利用尺寸排阻色谱法研究蛋白质的变性

通过比较蛋白质变性时的色谱行为和生物物理特性，提出利用尺寸排阻色谱法研究蛋白质变性时的构象变化，根据色谱参数中保留时间，比较蛋白质变性时体积的相对变化，利用色谱峰数，确定形成变体的数目，根据峰形和峰数的变化，描述蛋白质的伸展程度，利用不同波长下峰高的变化，推断蛋白质变性芳香族基酸残基的暴露情况，利用建立的尺寸排阻色谱观察了液体和固液α－淀粉酶在低温下放置时的变性情况，讨论了变性时间和变性温度对蛋白     

Immobilized enzyme reactors in proteomics

Fast, efficient characterization of proteins is becoming one of the hottest topics in the bioanalytical community, especially for large-scale proteomic studies. As an attractive approach, protein digestion by enzymes supported on various matrices (referred to as immobilized enzyme reactors, IMERs) has recently attracted much attention.In this article, we present a critical overview of some highly efficient IMERs and related analytical systems. We give major coverage to applications of IMERs in proteomic analysis, including protein-expression profiling, characterization of proteins with post-translational modifications, and protein quantification. We also comment on promising trends for IMERs in proteomics.     

Advanced analytical tools in proteomics

Proteomics deals with the study of proteins, their structures, localizations, posttranslational modifications, functions and interactions with other proteins. The mapping of protein structure-function holds the key to a better understanding of cellular functions under both normal and disease states, which is critical for modern drug discovery. However, the study of human proteome presents scientists with a task much more daunting than the human genome project. In fact, the estimated >100,000 different proteins expressed from 30,000 to 40,000 human genes make it extremely challenging, if not impossible with existing protein analysis techniques, to map the entire cellular functions at the translational level. Consequently, there have been rapid advances in the techniques and methods capable of large-scale proteomic studies. Among them, the recently developed high-throughput screening methods have enabled scientists to analyze proteins quickly and efficiently at an organism-wide scale. Herein, we overview some of these emerging tools for high-throughput protein analysis. In particular, we focus on recent advances in the bioassay development, which has provided sensitive and selective tools for high-throughput identification and characterizations of enzymes. Finally, the recently developed bioimaging techniques to visualize and quantify proteins in living cells are also discussed.     

Size-exclusion chromatographic protein refolding: fundamentals, modeling and operation

Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) has proven its capability to refold a variety of proteins using a range of gel filtration column materials, demonstrated in the growing body of experimental evidence. However, little effort has been allocated to the development of mechanistic models describing size-exclusion chromatographic refolding reactors (SECRR). Mechanistic models are important since they provide a link between process variables like denatured and reduced protein feed concentration (C_f,D&;R), flow rate, column length, etc., and performance indicators like refolding yield (Y_N), thereby opening the possibility for in silico design of SECRRs. A critical step, in the formulation of such models, is the selection of an adequate reaction mechanism, which provides the direct link between the separation and the refolding yield. Therefore, in this work we present a methodology using a SEC refolding reactor model, supported by a library of reaction mechanisms, to estimate a suitable reaction scheme using experimental SEC refolding data. SEC refolding data is used since it provides information about the mass distribution of monomers and aggregates after refolding, information not readily available from batch dilution refolding data alone. Additionally, this work presents (1) a systematic analysis of the reaction mechanisms considered using characteristic time analysis and Damköhler maps, revealing (a) the direct effect of a given reaction mechanism on the shape of the SEC refolding chromatogram (number of peaks and resolution) and (b) the effect that the competition between convection, refolding and aggregation is likely to have on the SEC refolding yield; (2) a comparison between the SECR reactor and the batch dilution refolding reactor based on mechanistic modeling, quantitatively showing the advantages of the former over the latter; and (3) the successful application of the modeling based strategy to study the SEC refolding data of an industrially relevant protein. In principle, the presented modeling strategy can be applied to any protein refolded using any gel filtration material, providing the proper mass balances and activity measurements are available.     

Novel liquid-chromatography columns for proteomics research

The enormous interest in proteomics research in recent years has inspired many developments in peptide chromatography. Different strategies have been developed to cope with the vast complexity of proteomics samples, trying to provide sufficient degree of separation to be able to exploit fully the potential of protein identification by mass spectrometry (MS). As reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) coupled to MS is still the method of choice for the analysis of protein digests, many efforts focus on the development of high-efficiency RP methods (e.g., monolithic columns and ultra-high-performance LC). This can also increase the speed and the sensitivity of the analysis of protein digests.As RPLC-MS alone is unlikely to provide sufficient resolution to unravel the composition of highly complex samples comprehensively, multidimensional methods will remain essential in proteome research. In this area, hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) seems to be a promising alternative to the traditional strong cation-exchange-based methods. Also, HILIC has found application in the analysis of post-translational modifications (e.g., phosphorylation and glycosylation).This review describes recent developments in LC methods for proteomics research, focusing on advances in column technology and the application of novel column materials. Illustrative examples show the possibilities of the new columns in proteomics research.     

Comparison of protein precipitation methods for various rat brain structures prior to proteomic analysis

Sample preparation is a fundamental step in proteomic methodologies. The quality of the results from a proteomic experiment is dependent on the nature of the sample and the properties of the proteins. In this study, various pre-treatment methods were compared by proteomic analysis; we analysed various rat brain structures after chloroform/methanol, acetone, TCA/acetone and TCA protein precipitation procedures. The protein content of the supernatant was also examined by 2-DE. We found that for four of the rat brain structures, precipitation with chloroform/methanol and acetone delivered the highest protein recovery for top-down proteomic analysis; however, TCA precipitation resulted in good protein separation and the highest number of protein spots in 2-DE. Moreover, TCA precipitation also gave high efficiency of protein recovery if prior sonication procedure was performed.     

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) in proteomics

In proteomics, nanoflow multidimensional chromatography is now the gold standard for the separation of complex mixtures of peptides as generated by in-solution digestion of whole-cell lysates. Ideally, the different stationary phases used in multidimensional chromatography should provide orthogonal separation characteristics. For this reason, the combination of strong cation exchange chromatography (SCX) and reversed-phase (RP) chromatography is the most widely used combination for the separation of peptides. Here, we review the potential of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) as a separation tool in the multidimensional separation of peptides in proteomics applications. Recent work has revealed that HILIC may provide an excellent alternative to SCX, possessing several advantages in the area of separation power and targeted analysis of protein post-translational modifications. Figure Artistic impression of the HILIC separation mechanism     

Bovine serum albumin as a universal suppressor of non-specific peptide binding in vials prior to nano-chromatography coupled mass-spectrometry analysis

Non-specific binding (NSB) is a well-known problem for any application that deals with ultralow analyte quantities. The modern nano-flow chromatography coupled tandem mass-spectrometry (nanoLC-MS/MS) works with the lowest conceivable analyte concentrations. However, while the NSB problem is widely accepted and investigated for metabolomics and single-peptide medicine-related assays, its impact is not studied for complex peptide mixtures in proteomic applications. In this work peptide NSB to a common plastic autosampler vial was studied for a model mixture of 46 synthetic peptides. A significant NSB level was demonstrated for total peptide concentrations of up to 1 mg mL⁻¹. Different agents were tried for NSB suppression and compatibility with nanoLC-MS/MS analysis: a chaotropic agent, an amino acid mixture, a peptide mixture and a protein solution. The first two were inefficacious. The peptide matrix blocked NSB, however, it also led to analyte ionization suppression in nanoLC-MS/MS. The protein solution (0.1% BSA) efficiently eliminated NSB, while a trap-elute nanoHPLC configuration together with a small-pore reverse-phased sorbent effectively and quantitatively extracted the model peptides and depleted protein material from the sample. Higher protein concentration partially impeded peptide extraction. Thus, the 0.1% BSA solution might be regarded as an effective non-interfering blockader of NSB for sample resuspension and storage in an autosampler prior to LC-MS/MS analysis.     

Use of proteomics for design of a tailored host cell for highly efficient protein purification

After some initial optimization, a downstream process comprised of one or several chromatography steps removes the majority of the host proteins and achieves a reasonable degree of purification. The separation of remaining contaminant proteins from the target protein could become very difficult and costly due to their similar physicochemical properties. In this paper we describe a highly efficient strategy, based on proteomic analysis and elution chromatography, by which a protein of interest may be isolated from copurifying contaminants. Mutant strains of Escherichia coli were prepared that are deficient in three prevalent host proteins found in a strategic fraction of an elution profile of nickel immobilized affinity chromatography. Recombinant green fluorescent protein (GFPuv) served as a model protein and its elution was directed to this optimized fraction with an N-terminus hexahistidine tag (his₆), thereby easing its recovery. We demonstrate that proteomic data can facilitate the rational engineering of host cell expressing the target protein and the design of an efficient process for its purification.     

Molecular-weight distribution and structural transformation in water-soluble complexes of poly(acrylic acid) and bovine serum albumin

Interaction of polyacrylic acid (PAA) with bovine serum albumin (BSA) at different pH values and in a wide range of mixing molar ratios, γ = n_BSA/n_PAA, of components was investigated by size-exclusion high performance liquid chromatography with on-line refractive index, UV, light scattering and viscometer detectors. The results revealed the formation of stable water-soluble polymer-protein complexes at pH 5.0. For the soluble complexes thus formed, the number of the bound BSA molecules with one PAA molecule was expressed by a Langmuir-type equation as a function of the amount of excess BSA existing free in the solution. At saturation, one BSA molecule is bound to about 48 acrylic acid residues.The γ-dependencies of molecular properties and structural parameters (molecular weights, molecular-weight distribution, radius of gyration, and the Mark-Houwink equation constants) of aqueous solutions of polycomplex particles have been studied. It has been concluded from these results that the complex molecule is formed by the molecular association-dissociation processes between particles depending on protein molecules in mixtures. We assume that side-by-side association of BSA-PAA complex particles took place at γ ? 5. At γ > 5, dissociation of the aggregates occurred by the including certain protein molecules into composition and by the compactization of polycomplex particles.     

Investigation of mercury-containing proteins by enriched stable isotopic tracer and size-exclusion chromatography hyphenated to inductively coupled plasma-isotope dilution mass spectrometry

In order to investigate trace mercury-containing proteins in maternal rat and their offspring, a method of enriched stable isotopic tracer (¹⁹⁶Hg and ¹⁹⁸Hg) combined with size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) coupled to inductively coupled plasma-isotope dilution mass spectrometry (ICP-IDMS) was developed. Prior to the analysis, ¹⁹⁶Hg- and ¹⁹⁸Hg-enriched methylmercury was administrated to the pregnant rats. Then the mercury-containing proteins in serum and brain cytosol of the dam and pup rats were separated by size-exclusion columns and the mercury was detected by ICP-MS. The ICP-MS spectrogram of the tracing samples showed significantly elevated ¹⁹⁶Hg and ¹⁹⁸Hg isotopic signals compared with the natural ones, indicating that the detection sensitivity could be increased by the tracer method. The contents of mercury in chromatographic fractions of the dam and pup rat brain cytosol were quantitatively estimated by post-column reverse ID-ICP-MS. The quantitative speciation differences of mercury in brain cytosol between the dam and pup rats were observed, indicating that such studies could be useful for toxicological estimation. Additionally, the isotopic ratio measurement of ¹⁹⁸Hg/²⁰²Hg in the tracing samples could be used to identify the artifact mercury species caused in the analytical procedure. The study demonstrates that the tracer method combined with high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-ICP-IDMS could provide reliably qualitative and quantitative information on mercury-containing proteins in organisms.     

Gas-phase dissociation pathways of a tetrameric protein complex

The gas-phase dissociation of the tetrameric complex transthyretin (TTR) has been investigated with tandem-mass spectrometry (tandem-MS) using a nanoflow-electrospray interface and a quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-TOF) mass spectrometer. The results show that highly charged monomeric product ions dissociate from the macromolecular complex to form trimeric products. Manipulating the pressure conditions within the mass spectrometer facilitates the formation of metastable ions. These were observed for the transitions from tetrameric to monomeric and trimeric product ions and additionally for losses of small molecules associated with the protein complex in the gas phase. These results are interpreted in the light of recent mechanisms for the electrospray process and provide insight into the composition and factors governing the stability of macromolecular ions in the gas phase.     

Comparative evaluation of five protocols for protein extraction from stony corals (Scleractinia) for proteomics

Corals especially the reef‐building species are very important to marine ecosystems. Proteomics has been used for researches on coral diseases, bleaching and responses to the environment change. A robust and versatile protein extraction protocol is required for coral proteomics. However, a comparative evaluation of different protein extraction protocols is still not available for proteomic analysis of stony corals. In the present study, five protocols were compared for protein extraction from stony corals. The five protocols were TRIzol, phenol‐based extraction (PBE), trichloroacetic acid (TCA)‐acetone, glass bead‐assisted extraction (GBAE) and a commercially available kit. PBE, TRIzol and the commercial kit were more robust for extracting proteins from stony corals. The protein extraction efficiency and repeatability, two dimensional electrophoresis (2‐DE) and matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI TOF MS) were employed to evaluate the protocols. The results indicated that PBE protocol had the better protein extraction efficiency than the others. Protein extraction coverage varied among the procedures. Each protocol favored for certain proteins. Therefore, it is very important for coral proteomic analysis to select a suitable protein protocol upon the experimental design. In general, PBE protocol can be the first choice for extracting proteins from stony corals.     

Interpretation of mass spectrometry data for high-throughput proteomics

Recent developments in proteomics have revealed a bottleneck in bioinformatics: high-quality interpretation of acquired MS data. The ability to generate thousands of MS spectra per day, and the demand for this, makes manual methods inadequate for analysis and underlines the need to transfer the advanced capabilities of an expert human user into sophisticated MS interpretation algorithms. The identification rate in current high-throughput proteomics studies is not only a matter of instrumentation. We present software for high-throughput PMF identification, which enables robust and confident protein identification at higher rates. This has been achieved by automated calibration, peak rejection, and use of a meta search approach which employs various PMF search engines. The automatic calibration consists of a dynamic, spectral information-dependent algorithm, which combines various known calibration methods and iteratively establishes an optimised calibration. The peak rejection algorithm filters signals that are unrelated to the analysed protein by use of automatically generated and dataset-dependent exclusion lists. In the "meta search" several known PMF search engines are triggered and their results are merged by use of a meta score. The significance of the meta score was assessed by simulation of PMF identification with 10,000 artificial spectra resembling a data situation close to the measured dataset. By means of this simulation the meta score is linked to expectation values as a statistical measure. The presented software is part of the proteome database ProteinScape which links the information derived from MS data to other relevant proteomics data. We demonstrate the performance of the presented system with MS data from 1891 PMF spectra. As a result of automatic calibration and peak rejection the identification rate increased from 6% to 44%.Abbreviations 2-DE Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis - MALDI Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation - PMF Peptide mass fingerprinting - MS Mass spectrometry - TOF Time of flight