Process analysis using ion mobility spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry, originally used to detect chemical warfare agents, explosives and illegal drugs, is now frequently applied in the field of process analytics. The method combines both high sensitivity (detection limits down to the ng to pg per liter and ppb_v/ppt_v ranges) and relatively low technical expenditure with a high-speed data acquisition. In this paper, the working principles of IMS are summarized with respect to the advantages and disadvantages of the technique. Different ionization techniques, sample introduction methods and preseparation methods are considered. Proven applications of different types of ion mobility spectrometer (IMS) used at ISAS will be discussed in detail: monitoring of gas insulated substations, contamination in water, odoration of natural gas, human breath composition and metabolites of bacteria. The example applications discussed relate to purity (gas insulated substations), ecology (contamination of water resources), plants and person safety (odoration of natural gas), food quality control (molds and bacteria) and human health (breath analysis).     

Structure-drift time relationships in ion mobility mass spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) separates ions while they travel through a buffer gas under the influence of an electrical field. The separation is affected by mass and charge but most particularly by shape (collision cross section). When coupled to MS, IMS-MS offers therefore a powerful tool for structural elucidation and isomer separation. Systematic studies aimed to compare and quantitate the effects of structural changes on drift time such as length and ramification of carbon chain, unsaturation, geometrical isomerism (cis/trans isomers for instance), cyclization and ring size are, however, scarce. Herein we used traveling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry (TWIM-MS) to systematically evaluate the relationship between structure and drift time. For that, a series of deprotonated carboxylic acids were used as model ions with a carboxylate “charge tag” for gas phase MS manipulation. Carboxylic acids showed a near linear correlation between the increase of carbon number and the increase of collision cross section (CCS). The number of double bonds changes slightly the CCS of unsaturated acids. No differences in drift time and no significant differences in CCS of cis- and trans-double bond of oleic and elaidic acids were observed. Cyclization considerably reduces the CCS. In cyclic carboxylic acids, the increase of double bonds and aromatization significantly reduces the CCS and the drift times. The use of a more polarizable drift gas, CO_2, improved in some cases the separation, as for biomarker isomers of steranoic acids. The β-isomer (cis-decaline) has smaller CCS and therefore displayed lower drift time compared to the α-isomer (trans-decaline). Structural changes revealed by calculations were correlated with trends in drift times.     

Detection of perfluorocarbons using ion mobility spectrometry

An ISAS custom-designed ion mobility spectrometer equipped with a ionization source is used for the sensitive detection of traces of perfluorocarbons (PFCs, C₅F₁₂ to C₉F₂₀) in air, a class of substances for which a growing interest for industrial and environmental applications arose within the last years. Mobility spectra of the PFCs are presented, compared and discussed with regard to the possibility of identifying these analytes; detection limits are determined to be in the upper ng l⁻¹ range. Using a specific PFC as an example, a way to prevent unwanted contributions of non-product ions, the difference mobility spectrum, is introduced and described. Advantages and possibilities of this technique are briefly discussed.     

Hydrocarbon detection using laser ion mobility spectrometry

A Laser Ion Mobility Spectrometer has been set up and trace detection experiments have been performed. We find that laser ionization almost selectively ionizes aromatic hydrocarbons. Aliphatic hydrocarbons are only laser-ionized in case these contain conjugated double bonds. As, in contrast to radioactive ion mobility spectrometry, background air constituents and air contaminants cannot be ionized, drift spectra are inherently simple and easily interpretable. We show that a laser ion mobility spectrometer can be operated in two basically different modes, either using tunable or fixed-frequency laser sources. In the tunable laser mode, aromatic hydrocarbons can be detected in the positive mode and distinguished from each other on account of their different excitation wavelengths and ion drift times. In the fixed-frequency mode, specially chosen and intentionally admitted aromatic hydrocarbons are laser ionized and the primary ionization is transferred to non-aromatic species by means of atmospheric pressure chemical ionization. In this latter mode of operation nitroglycerin and triacetone triperoxide, two non-aromatic high explosives, could be detected.     

Fingerprinting bacterial strains using ion mobility spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is currently in widespread use for the detection and identification of narcotic and explosive compounds without prior sample clean-up or concentration steps. IMS analysis is rapid, less than a minute, and sensitive, with detection limits in the nanogram to picogram range, depending on the target analyte. Our studies indicate that this technique has potential for detection of specific components of bacterial cells and for identification and differentiation of bacterial strains and species within a minute, and with no specialized test kits or reagents required. When microgram quantities of whole bacterial cells are thermally desorbed, complex positive or negative ion patterns (plasmagrams) are obtained. These plasmagrams differ reproducibly for different strains and species and for different conditions of growth, and can be used for the classification and differentiation of specific strains and species of bacteria, including pathogens. Methods for improved ion peak detection, most notably sequential sample desorption at stepped increases in temperature (programmed temperature ramping), are described.     

Detection of infectious agents in the airways by ion mobility spectrometry of exhaled breath

Diseases of the lung, e. g. chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), interstitial lung diseases, bronchiectasis or cystic fibrosis, often lead to recurrent severe respiratory infections that cause exacerbations of the underlying disease. These acute or chronic inflammatory processes can result in a progressive destruction of the lung and in an ongoing decline in lung function. Therefore longer inpatient stays for intravenous antibiotic treatment are necessary and the quality of life in these patients is severely limited. A rapid detection of infectious agents in human lungs is often crucial, because the choice of the appropriate therapeutic regime depends at first on the identification of the infecting species. Standard methods for detection and identification are either time consuming, of low sensitivity or expensive. It is known that bacteria, and also mitosporic fungi, produce volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that can be detected in exhaled breath by ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), were a distinct detection of a specific VOC is related to a “peak”. We investigated, whether the detection and characterisation of VOCs by Multi-capillary column coupled to IMS in exhaled breath of patients whose airways are either infected or colonized by Pseudomonas aeruginosa compared to healthy non-smoker controls is capable of identifying those infectious agents. To realize a non invasive identification of pathogens, the exhaled breath of 53 persons (24 patients suffering chronic or infectious on Pseudomonas and 29 healthy controls) was investigated using an ion mobility spectrometer type BioScout. In total 224 different signals were found. Actually, 21 different signals are able to differentiate the two groups, Control and Pseudomonas, with rank sum values less than 0.2. For all 224 signals Box-and-Wisker plots were realized. The peaks with the lowest rank sum values F (0,107) and PS0 (0,112) show rather good separation of both groups. Our preliminary results demonstrate that distinct patterns of a small number of IMS-peaks are sufficient for the identification of these infectious agents. Therefore MCC-IMS seems to be a promising method for the non-invasive identification of patients which are colonized or infected with bacteria such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa.     

Analysis of a series of chlorogenic acid isomers using differential ion mobility and tandem mass spectrometry

Chlorogenic acids are among the most abundant phenolics found in the human diet. Of these, the mono-caffeoylquinic acids are the predominant phenolics found in fruits, such as apples and pears, and products derived from them. In this research, a comprehensive study of the electrospray ionization (ESI) tandem mass spectrometric (MS/MS) dissociation behavior of the three most common mono-caffeoylquinic acids, namely 5-O-caffeoylquinic acid (5-CQA), 3-O-caffeoylquinic acid (3-CQA) and 4-O-caffeoylquinic acid (4-CQA), were determined using both positive and negative ionization. All proposed structures of the observed product ions were confirmed with second-generation MS³ experiments. Similarities and differences between the dissociation pathways in the positive and negative ion modes are discussed, confirming the proposed structures and the established MS/MS fingerprints. MS/MS dissociation was primarily driven via the cleavage of the ester bond linking the quinic acid moiety to the caffeic acid moiety within tested molecules. Despite being structural isomers with the same m/z values and dissociation behaviors, the MS/MS data in the negative ion mode was able to differentiate the three isomers based on ion intensity for the major product ions, observed at m/z 191, 179 and 173. This differentiation was consistent among various MS instruments. In addition, ESI coupled with high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (ESI-FAIMS-MS) was employed for the separation of these compounds for the first time. By combining MS/MS data and differential ion mobility, a method for the separation and identification of mono-caffeoylquinic in apple/pear juice samples was developed with a run time of less than 1 min. It is envisaged that this methodology could be used to identify pure juices based on their chlorogenic acid profile (i.e., metabolomics), and could also be used to detect juice-to-juice adulteration (e.g., apple juice addition to pear juice).     

Separation of peptides from detergents using ion mobility spectrometry

Mass spectrometry (MS) has dramatically evolved in the last two decades and has been the driving force of the spectacular expansion of proteomics during this period. However, the very poor compatibility of MS with detergents is still a technical obstacle in some studies, in particular on membrane proteins. Indeed, the high hydrophobicity of membrane proteins necessitates the use of detergents for their extraction and solubilization. Here, we address the analytical potential of high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) for separating peptides from detergents. The study was focused on peptides from the human integral membrane protein CD9. A tryptic peptide was mixed with the non-ionic detergents Triton X-100 or beta-D-dodecyl maltoside (DDM) as well as with the ionic detergents sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) or sodium deoxycholate (SDC). Although electrospray ionization (ESI) alone led to a total suppression of the peptide ion signal on mass spectra with only detection of the detergents, use of FAIMS allowed separation and clear identification of the peptide with any of the detergents studied. The detection and identification of the target compound in the presence of an excess of detergents are then feasible. FAIMS should prove especially useful in the structural and proteomic analysis of membrane proteins.     

Detection of emissions from surfaces using ion mobility spectrometry

Emissions from surfaces (from furniture, wall paintings or floor coverings for instance) significantly influence indoor air quality and therefore the wellbeing or even the health of the occupants. Together with metabolites from mold they are responsible for the well-known “sick building syndrome”. Therefore, it is in the interest of the manufacturer as well as of the occupants to have a fast and accurate method for the detection of substances relevant to this syndrome in order to be able to monitor and control product quality and indoor air quality. The use of small and easy-to-transport ion mobility spectrometers that use UV light as the ionization source enables rapid in situ detection of such substances with high selectivity and sensitivity (detection limits in the lower ppb range). If a multicapillary column is used for preseparation as well, the selectivity is increased and the unwanted influence of humidity on the spectra can be eliminated, thus enabling the use of the instruments under normal ambient conditions. Furthermore, the use of air as carrier gas avoids the need for other sources of high-purity gas. An emission cell with a homogeneous and constant air flow over the surface to be investigated was developed in order to ensure reproducible results. Investigations of emissions from wooden surfaces with and without additional contamination as well as from complex mixtures are presented. The results demonstrate that relevant emissions can be identified and quantified with high sensitivity and selectivity in under five minutes. Therefore, the method is useful for indoor air quality monitoring, especially when miniaturized instruments are applied. Figure     

Ultra-fast screening of free fatty acids in human plasma using ion mobility mass spectrometry

Free fatty acids are involved in many metabolic regulations in the human body. In this work, an ultra-fast screening method was developed for the analysis of free fatty acids using trapped ion mobility spectrometry coupled with mass spectrometry. Thirty-three free fatty acids possessing different unsaturation degrees and different carbon chain lengths were baseline separated and characterized within milliseconds. Saturated, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated free fatty acids showed different linearities between collision cross-section values and m/z. The establishment of correlations between structures and collision cross-section values provided additional qualitative information and made it possible to determine free fatty acids which were out of the standards pool but possessed the confirmed linearity. The gas-phase separation made the quantitative analysis reliable and repeatable at a much lower time cost than chromatographic methods. The sensitivity was comparable to and even better than the reported results. The method was validated and applied to profiling free fatty acids in human plasma. Saturated free fatty acids abundance in the fasting state was found to be lower than that in the postprandial state, while unsaturated species abundance was found higher. The method was fast and robust with minimum sample pretreatment, so it was promising in the high-throughput screening of free fatty acids.     

Characterizing ion mobility and collision cross section of fatty acids using electrospray ion mobility mass spectrometry

This study investigated the ion mobility (IM) and the collision cross section (CCS) of fatty acids (FAs) using electrospray IM MS. The IM analysis of 18 FA ions showed intriguing differences among the saturated FAs, monounsaturated FAs, multi‐unsaturated FAs, and cis‐isomer/trans‐isomer with respect to the aliphatic tail chains. The length of aliphatic tail chain present in the ion structures had a strong influence on the differentiation of drift, while the number of double bond showed a weaker influence. The tiny drift differences between cis‐isomer and trans‐isomer were also observed. In the CCS measurements, two internal standards were involved in the mobility calibration and accuracy estimation. It insured our empirical CCS values were of high experimental precision (±0.35% or better) and accuracy (±0.25% or better). Moreover, the mass‐to‐charge ratio (m/z) – mobility plots obtained by ion mobility spectrometry with mass spectrometry analysis of FAs – was used to investigate the structural relationship between the molecules. Each series of FAs sharing a similar structure was aligned in the linear plot. Finally, the developed procedure was applied to the determination of FAs in rat adipose tissues, and it allowed the presence of 13 FAs to be confirmed with their exact masses and CCS values. These studies reveal the direct relationship between the behaviors in IM and the molecular structures and thus may provide further validations to the FA identification process. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Kinetic study of proton-bound dimer formation using ion mobility spectrometry

A method to measure the rate constant for the formation of symmetrical proton-bound dimers at ambient pressure was proposed. The sample is continuously delivered to the drift region of an ion mobility spectrometer where it reacts with a swarm of monomer ions injected by the shutter grid. Dimer ions are formed in the drift tube and a tail appears in the ion mobility spectrum. The rate constant is derived from the mobility spectra. The proposed approach was typically examined for methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK), 2,4-dimethyl pyridine (DMP), and dimethyl methyl phosphonate (DMMP). The rate constants measured in this study were: 0.25 × 10⁻⁹, 0.86 × 10⁻¹⁰, and 0.47 × 10⁻¹⁰ cm³ s⁻¹ for MIBK, DMP and DMMP, respectively. The logarithm of the measured rate constants were found to be almost independent of reciprocal temperature within 303 to 343 K, indicating that no activation energy is involved in the formation of proton-bound dimers.     

Analysis of biogenic amines using corona discharge ion mobility spectrometry

A new method based on corona discharge ion mobility spectrometry (CD-IMS) was developed for the analysis of biogenic amines including spermidine, spermine, putrescine, and cadaverine. The ion mobility spectra of the compounds were obtained with and without n-Nonylamine used as the reagent gas. The high proton affinity of n-Nonylamine prevented ion formation from compounds with a proton affinity lower than that of n-Nonylamine and, therefore, enhanced its selectivity. It was also realized that the ion mobility spectrum of n-Nonylamine varied with its concentration. A sample injection port of a gas chromatograph was modified and used as the sample introduction system into the CD-IMS. The detection limits, dynamic ranges, and analytical parameters of the compounds with and without using the reagent gas were obtained. The detection limits and dynamic ranges of the compounds were about 2 ng and 2 orders of magnitude, respectively. The wide dynamic range of CD-IMS originates from the high current of the corona discharge. The results revealed the high capability of the CD-IMS for the analysis of biogenic amines.     

Determination of ammonia in ethylene using ion mobility spectrometry.

A simple procedure to analyze ammonia in ethylene by ion mobility spectrometry is described. The spectrometer is operated with a silane polymer membrane., 63Ni ion source, H+ (H2O)n reactant ion, and nitrogen drift and source gas. Ethylene containing parts per billion (ppb) (v/v) concentrations of ammonia is pulled across the membrane and diffuses into the spectrometer. Preconcentration or preseparation is unnecessary, because the ethylene in the spectrometer has no noticeable effect on the analytical results. Ethylene does not polymerize in the radioactive source. Ethylene's flammability is negated by the nitrogen inside the spectrometer. Response to ammonia concentrations between 200 ppb and 1.5 ppm is near linear, and a detection limit of 25 ppb is calculated.     

The detection of nicotine in e-liquids using ion mobility spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is a well known field technique for the detection of various materials such as explosives and narcotics. IMS has been used for the detection and identification of nicotine, and this paper describes a simple preparation method and analysis using an Ionscan 500DT which could be used in a field environment for the detection of nicotine in e-liquids. E-liquids containing nicotine are presently a topic of much debate in many countries and their shipment across the Canadian border is prohibited. The method described here would allow border officers or any other operators of IMS instruments to use this technique to correctly determine the presence or absence of nicotine in the e-liquid; this would allow the timely importation of the e-liquids with no nicotine and restrict the laboratory analysis only to those liquids containing nicotine. The IMS method has been used on a number of samples received from manufacturers of e-liquids as well as samples seized at the border. The results of the IMS analysis correspond well with those obtained using a Gas Chromatograph – Mass Spectrometer (GC-MS) method of analysis for nicotine.     

Orthogonal extraction ion mobility spectrometry

Ion Mobility Spectrometry is a powerful tool for the study of molecular conformations, separation of mass isomers, and analysis of complex mixtures and suppression of chemical background. The factors that limit the capabilities of the technique include its relatively low resolving power and duty cycle. New principle of gas-phase ion separation, based on ion focusing under the influence of electrostatic field and stationary in time gas flow, is proposed. Both analytical calculations and a numerical simulation show that a diffusion-limited resolution of several hundred can be achieved. The new type of ion mobility analyzer is called orthogonal extraction IMS. The proposed ortho-IMS can be interfaced with commercial mass spectrometers and offers the theoretical resolution of several hundred and ion transmission close to 100%.     

Liquid phase ion mobility spectrometry

A novel analytical method, called Liquid Phase Ion Mobility Spectrometry (LiPIMS) was demonstrated, where aqueous phase analytes were ionized and introduced into non-aqueous liquids, transported by an external electric field from the point of generation to a collection electrode. Ions were produced from a unique liquid phase ionization process, called Electrodispersion Ionization. Spectra of analyte ions illustrated the potential of LiPIMS as a new separation technique. Experimental data showed that electrodispersion ionization was effective in generating nanoampere level of ion current in hexane and benzene from aqueous samples. By controlling the ionization voltage in relation to the sample flow rate, it was possible to operate the electrodispersion ionization source in both continuous and pulsed ionization modes. Unique LiPIMS spectra of aqueous samples of tetramethylammonium bromide, tetrabutylammonium bromide and bradykinin were presented and their respected liquid phase ion mobility values were determined.     

Towards metals analysis using corona discharge ionization ion mobility spectrometry

For the first time, the capability of corona discharge ionization ion mobility spectrometry (CD-IMS) in the determination of metal complex was evaluated. The extreme simplicity of dispersive liquid–liquid microextraction (DLLME) coupled to the high sensitivity of CD-IMS measurement could make this combination really useful for simple, rapid, and sensitive determination of metals in different samples. In this regard, mercury, as a model metal, was complexed with diethyldithiocarbamate (DEDTC), and then extracted into the carbon tetrachloride using DLLME. Some parameters affecting the extraction efficiency, including the type and volume of the extraction solvent, the type and volume of the disperser solvent, the concentration of the chelating agent, salt addition and, pH were exhaustively investigated. Under the optimized condition, the enrichment factor was obtained to be 142. The linear range of 0.035–10.0 μg mL⁻¹ with r² = 0.997 and the detection limit of 0.010 μg mL⁻¹ were obtained. The relative standard deviation values were calculated to be lower than 4% and 8% for intra-day and inter-day, respectively. Finally, the developed method was successfully applied for the extraction and determination of mercury in various real samples. The satisfactory results revealed the capability of the proposed method in trace analysis without tedious derivatization or hydride generation.     

Resolving interferences in negative mode ion mobility spectrometry using selective reactant ion chemistry

During the investigation of the degradation products of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) and 2,4-dichlorophenol (DCP) were found to have IMS responses which overlapped those of the TNT degradation products. It was observed that the Cl(-) reactant ion chemistry, often used for explosives analysis, was not always successful in resolving peak overlap of analytes and interferents. It is shown here that resolution of the analytes and interferences can sometimes be achieved using only air for the formation of reactant ions, at other times through the use of Br(-) as an alternative to Cl(-) for producing reactant ions, and also through the promotion of adduct stability by lowering the IMS temperature.